Adbert Alzolay emerged from the Cubs’s closer committee as the clear choice by the end of the season, ultimately converting 22 saves. The converted starter appears to be in the bullpen for good, but Craig Counsell is never one to shy away from using relievers unconventionally, which could lead to setup men earning more saves.
Alex Lange started the season looking like he could be the Tigers’s All-Star representative, but lost his footing as the season wore on, posting a 5.06 ERA from June 1 through the end of the season. Most troubling was his 34 walks in 42.2 innings in that time. His stuff is undeniably closer-worthy, but he’ll need to find the zone more often to stick.
José Leclerc had a bizarre season, pitching well the whole way through but only earning four saves, with Bruce Bochy calling an audible for Will Smith to be his closer after Leclerc had some walk-heavy, inefficient outings. But by the playoffs, Leclerc was the clear closer, earning another four saves along the way. The David Robertson addition makes Leclerc’s position hold on the closing job a lot looser, but we’ll keep him in this spot for now as we await clarity.
Hunter Harvey finally made it through a mostly healthy season in 2023, setting a new career high with 57 appearances after making it into just 64 in the four years prior. He also earned ten saves, and will be jockeying for position with Kyle Finnegan.
Kyle Finnegan is a spot below Harvey only because his stuff just isn’t as good as Harvey’s, so even if it’s roughly a coin flip as to who closes right now, my guess is that Harvey runs away with the job.
Carlos Estévez was looking like one of the better deals of the offseason in the first half, when he was selected to his first career All-Star game after posting a 1.80 ERA in the first half. But much like the Angels, his performance withered in the second half, with a 6.59 ERA (plus six more unearned runs). His job is in flux after the Robert Stephenson signing, who will both make more than Estévez and had an opposite second half. Estévez could get knocked down quite a bit on this list if Stephenson wins the job outright out of camp.
Hard-throwing Mason Miller will be converted to the bullpen in 2023, and has the leg up on the closer job entering the season. That said, I’m concerned about how he’ll be utilized. Will he be able to work back-to-back days? How many saves will he realistically earn?
The Marlins gave up a notable prospect to get David Robertson at the trade deadline, but it didn’t work out, with a 5.06 ERA in 22 games for Miami, ultimately losing his job to Tanner Scott and undoing a lot of good he had done with the Mets. Still, he was throwing harder than ever, and the Rangers rewarded his stuff with an $11.5M contract. Right now, it’s unclear who’ll get the closing reps between Robertson and Leclerc, and they could both make big moves up or down this list depending on who wins out.
Justin Lawrence was one of the more mercurial relievers of the 2023 season, with a 5.40 ERA at home, 1.62 ERA on the road, 2.76 ERA in the first half, 5.22 ERA in the second half, and almost perfectly alternating good and bad months throughout the year. Of those who apepar to have closing jobs at least somewhat locked in at this stage of the offseason, Lawrence is lowest because of his inexperience, lack of success at Coors, and the continued presence of Daniel Bard on the roster.
Robert Suarez never got things going in the first year of his five year, $46 million contract, missing a large chunk of the season and ultimately making it into only 26 games. He was still tough to hit, allowing just 15 hits in 27.2 innings, but his strikeout and homer rates both went in the wrong direction. Still, he’s likeliest to enter the season as the Padres closer, with Yuki Matsui providing competition.