Charting the 2026 Rookie Pitching Class: Part 1

This crop of rookies has now had some time to get adjusted to the big leagues, and this piece will look to check in on how they have measured up so far through the season. Less of a prediction of things to come, but more so of how much we can rely on them at this stage of their young careers. But of course, this is fantasy. So there will be a natural eye on what could be… are some guys getting the rough end of the stick, and are some getting away with it a little?
Corbin Young recently wrote a fantastic check-in piece that went into depth on some rookie pitchers, Nolan McLean, Parker Messick, and Bubba Chandler. While this won’t go into as much of the nitty-gritty, it is a more macro exercise analysing how they stack up against each other as a whole.
I wanted to establish a composite rating that accounted for metrics that provided a balanced view of their profile as a pitcher, balanced against their xERA. These metrics were then weighted to favor those I felt were more important and those I want to see in a pitcher. This will be split into two pieces: this one sets up the methodology, so to speak, and the reasoning behind the metrics used for the ranking. The next piece will dive into more of the nuances and any interesting cases the data throws up.





