Archive for Closers

A Forensic Inquiry: How Much Should You Spend For Pitchers?

A few years ago, a guy named Jabari Blash streaked across the Fantasy Baseball firmament like a doomed comet. He had tremendous raw power, but was a three-true-outcomes guy with a vengeance, and most of those outcomes were strikeouts. His plate discipline, his glove, and his baserunning skills were such that he had to hit a lot of home runs to keep a major league job, and when he didn’t, first the Padres and then the Angels kicked him to the curb. We ourselves didn’t expect Blash to succeed, but we nonetheless took him in various deep drafts out of our sentimental recollection of a story we heard in our youths.

The tale goes like this: A young man’s fantastically wealthy grandfather dies. He leaves his entire estate to charity. To the young man, he leaves only some words of wisdom and advice. The key to success and happiness, says Grandpa, can be stated in a single word: BLASH. But to find out what the word means, the young man must do as the grandfather did in his own youth and seek out a certain guru who lives as a hermit at the top of a remote Tibetan mountain.  After much travail, distress, danger, and expense, the young man scales the mountain and finds the guru. “Guru,” he says. “I have come from far across the sea to acquire the wisdom that you alone possess. What is the meaning of BLASH?” And the guru says, “Buy Low And Sell High.” Read the rest of this entry »


Beat the Shift Podcast – Catcher Episode w/ Vlad Sedler

The Catcher episode of the Beat the Shift Podcast – a baseball podcast for fantasy baseball players.

Guest: Vlad Sedler

Projections

  • VDP Projections
  • ATC Projections

Strategy Section

  • Risk
    • How to price players with risk
    • Is there a limit to the amount of risk you can assemble on one fantay roster?
  • Closers
    • The arguments for and against drafting a super elite closer in the 2nd round
  • Catchers
    • General assesment of the catcher player pool
    • General strategy for drafting catchers in 2023

Injury Guru’s Trivia of the Week

ATC Undervalued Players

Read the rest of this entry »


Beat the Shift Podcast – End of Season Wrap-Up Episode w/ Ian Kahn

The End of Season Wrap-Up Episode of the Beat the Shift Podcast – a baseball podcast for fantasy baseball players.

Guest: Ian Kahn

Most memorable moment of the season

Fantasy MVPs

  • Drafted Hitters
  • Undrafted Hitters
  • Drafted Starting Pitchers
  • Undrafted Starting Pitchers
  • Relief Pitchers

Strategy Section

  • Which is more important – the draft, or in-season play?
  • Should we be avoiding risk more in drafts, particularly in the early rounds?
  • Lessons learned in 2022
    • What was the optimal closer strategy in 2022? Will it change in 2023?
    • What were some waiver wire strategy lessons learned from 2022?
    • Was the market premium for speed justified in 2022?
    • Were catchers worth taking early in drafts? Will they be worth taking early in 2023?
    • Was starting pitching worth buying early in drafts in 2022? Where should we look to purchase pitching in 2023?
  • Who are some potential “Spencer Strider” type candidtates for 2023?

Read the rest of this entry »


2022 Closer Trends

I included a few thoughts on the following tables, but it’s basically a data dump to be used for 2023 prep. I went through and hopefully determined, with the help of my Twitter followers, the initial 2022 closers and if they kept their job. Some information could still be off so let me know in the comments what needs to be corrected.

First off, here are this season’s initial closers. I included if they kept their job and if they lost it, why. Additionally, I tracked their team’s total Saves.

Initial 2022 Closers
Team Eventual First Top Closer NFBC ME ADP Going into season Last Until Reason if Replaced Saves Team Saves % of Team Saves
Angels Raisel Iglesias 36 One Guy 8/2/2022 Trade 16 38 42%
Astros Ryan Pressly 55 One Guy 4/15/2022 Injury 33 53 62%
Athletics Lou Trivino 202 Competition 4/18/2022 Injury 10 34 29%
Blue Jays Jordan Romano 62 One Guy EOS None 36 46 78%
Braves Kenley Jansen 57 One Guy EOS None 41 55 75%
Brewers Josh Hader 22 One Guy 8/1/2022 Trade 29 52 56%
Cardinals Giovanny Gallegos 92 Competition 7/15/2022 Poor Performance 14 37 38%
Cubs David Robertson 353 Competition 8/2/2022 Trade 14 44 32%
Diamondbacks Mark Melancon 127 Competition 8/5/2022 Poor Performance 18 33 55%
Dodgers Craig Kimbrel 123 One Guy 9/23/2022 Poor Performance 22 43 51%
Giants Jake McGee 174 Competition 5/11/2022 Injury 3 39 8%
Guardians Emmanuel Clase 42 One Guy EOS None 42 51 82%
Mariners Paul Sewald 264 Competition EOS None 20 40 50%
Marlins Anthony Bender 248 One Guy 5/25/2022 Injury 6 41 15%
Mets Edwin Diaz 46 One Guy EOS None 32 41 78%
Nationals Tanner Rainey 313 Competition 7/13/2022 Injury 12 28 43%
Orioles Jorge López 434 Competition 8/2/2022 Trade 19 46 41%
Padres Taylor Rogers 95 One Guy 8/29/2022 Poor Performance 28 48 58%
Phillies Corey Knebel 93 One Guy 8/14/2022 Injury 12 42 29%
Pirates David Bednar 176 Committee 7/25/2022 Injury 19 33 58%
Rangers Joe Barlow 224 One Guy 7/13/2022 Injury 13 37 35%
Rays Andrew Kittredge 136 Committee 5/16/2022 Injury 5 44 11%
Red Sox Matt Barnes 156 Competition 6/1/2022 Injury 8 39 21%
Reds Tony Santillan 450 Competition 6/17/2022 Injury 4 31 13%
Rockies Daniel Bard 419 One Guy EOS None 34 43 79%
Royals Scott Barlow 115 One Guy EOS None 24 33 73%
Tigers Gregory Soto 138 One Guy EOS None 30 38 79%
Twins Emilio Pagan 427 Competition 7/1 Poor Performance 9 28 32%
White Sox Liam Hendriks 25 One Guy EOS None 37 48 77%
Yankees Aroldis Chapman 65 One Guy 5/22/2022 Injury 9 47 19%

No major takeaways from this table except … the Twins had just 28 Saves.

And the next table just shows that some recent trends have stabilized.

Year Trends on Initial Closers
Year Saves by Initial Closer Team Saves % Saves by Initial Closer Total EOS EOS % Same Incumbent as the previous year Same Incumbent %
2013 927 1266 73.2% 15 50%
2014 746 1264 59.0% 11 37% 16 53%
2015 737 1292 57.0% 11 37% 14 47%
2016 797 1276 62.5% 11 37% 16 53%
2017 668 1179 56.7% 10 33% 13 43%
2018 759 1244 61.0% 5 17% 12 40%
2019 573 1180 48.6% 7 23% 9 30%
2020 202 422 47.9% 11 37% 8 27%
2021 592 1200 49.3% 9 30% 6 20%
2022 599 1232 48.6% 9 30% 6 20%
Avg 660 1156 57.1% 9.9 33% 11.1 37%

The total number of Saves is constant and few closers hold the job for a full season, let alone from season to season.

And finally, the numbers of pitchers reaching certain Save totals.

Year Trends on Initial Closers
Year Players Getting Saves Players Getting > 4 Saves Players Getting > 9 Saves Non Incumbent > 9 Saves
2013 130 42 37 10
2014 134 49 39 15
2015 145 47 37 15
2016 148 53 42 15
2017 162 52 40 15
2018 165 59 43 14
2019 199 64 38 16
2020 131
2021 198 70 41 18
2022 222 64 35 12
Avg 163.4 55.6 39.1 14.8

Twenty-four more pitchers got a Save compared to last season. With the Saves getting spread out, only 35 pitchers (the lowest number recorded) accumulated 10 or more Saves. Just 18 guys had 20 or more Saves. If several fantasy teams are grinding for Saves, this is the reason why. This low number is also the reason fantasy managers will continue to spend up on closers.


Beat the Shift Podcast – Trade Deadline Roundup Episode w/ Steve Gardner

The Trade Deadline Episode of the Beat the Shift Podcast – a baseball podcast for fantasy baseball players.

Guest: Steve Gardner

MLB Trade Deadline

Read the rest of this entry »


Beat the Shift Podcast – FAAB Episode w/ Scott Jenstad

The FAAB Episode of the Beat the Shift Podcast – a baseball podcast for fantasy baseball players.

Guest: Scott Jenstad

Strategy Section

  • FAAB / Waiver Wire
    • How has the waiver wire changed over the past few seasons?
      • Is it more important or less important?
    • When to enter FAAB during the week.
    • Looking at “your” team.
    • How playing with a partner helps with waiver wire pickups.
    • What to look for when picking up players?
    • What to look for when dropping players?
    • How much FAAB should you have left over at the All-Star break?
    • Does prior league bidding affect your FAAB bids?
    • Does current team FAAB amounts affect your FAAB bids?

Read the rest of this entry »


The Sleeper and the Bust Episode: 1038 – 2 Start Pitchers and Closer Chaos

4/10/22

The latest episode of “The Sleeper and the Bust” is live. Support the show by subscribing to our Patreon!!

Follow us on Twitter

Read the rest of this entry »


Paul Sporer’s 2022 Reliever Rankings and Closer Chart Vol. 2

John E. Sokolowski-USA TODAY Sports

The end of the lockout hasn’t cleared things up quite as much as we were hoping, especially with Kimbrel still not traded and unlikely to be by Opening Day at this point.

I’ve got the Closer Chart for you with my Next-In-Line and Darkhorse candidates so you can see every bullpen at a glance and then there is a straight ranking of the relievers after that where you can see that I favor some of the Medium stability closers over some of the High stability guys. It is admittedly hard to be super confident in a reliever ranking after the 10-15 just because who you already have will then dictate where you go later in terms of handcuffing or dipping into other bullpens with lottery tickets, etc… so don’t be too locked into the exact order of the ranking sheet.

Read the rest of this entry »


Beat the Shift Podcast – Relief Pitcher Episode w/ Greg Jewett & Eric Samulski

The Relief Pitcher Episode of the Beat the Shift Podcast – a baseball podcast for fantasy baseball players.

Guests: Greg Jewett & Eric Samulski

Strategy Section

  • General 2022 closer landscape & draft strategy
  • FAAB capital vs. Draft captial for closers – which is more efficient?
  • Holds / Saves+Holds leagues
  • Closer Handcuffs for 2022
    • Giants
    • Padres
  • Reuven’s Closer Questions
    • Should you choose closers that are on good teams?
    • Pick closers based on skill?
    • Avoid closers who could be traded?
    • Avoid closer by committee situations?
    • Avoid certain teams all together with lousy players?

Read the rest of this entry »


Justin Mason Relief Pitcher Ranks: 3/11/22

As we head into primetime drafting season, I will be rereleasing my positional ranks. Here are my current ranks for relief pitchers for 2022, my third of the offseason. I will post updates as things change with signings, injuries, or news in Major League Baseball. On the Sleeper and the Bust Patreon, you can see the rankings updated live.

You can review my ranks for other positions here: https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/category/rankings/

Read the rest of this entry »