With drafts going and projections being released it is time to look at what they say about each other. This week I am going to look at what Steamer says about who is undervalued and overvalued at their current ADP. I took the FanGraphs Auction Calculator Values for Steamer and compared them to the current NFBC ADP to see which names jumped out at me within the top 100 projected hitters.

Francisco Lindor Steamer Projection: PAs 666 24 HR, 81 R, 86 RBI, 13 SBs, .250/.322/.430

Lindor finally looked like the vintage version of himself in 2022, putting up a top 10 fantasy season so I am a little surprised he made this list. There isn’t a ton in the profile that says he is going to take a step back as long as he is healthy and after playing 161 games in 2022, there isn’t much reason to believe he won’t be again. He could definitely regress a bit in the batting average department as he had an xAVG of .254, but batting average is fluky and I am not overthinking that too much. I think he is a pretty safe bet as a third round pick and if he drops in a draft, I’ll be snagging him most times.

Ozzie Albies Steamer Projection: 570 PAs, 20 HR, 69 R, 73 RBI, 13 SBs, .259/.312/.455

Albies has the largest gap between his ADP and Auction value of any hitter in the top 100. This one is all about health. Albies only played in 64 games which was the second time in three seasons in which he missed a larger portion of the season. When healthy, Albies is a five category stud, but last year he was a massive bust for those of us taking him in the first or second round. I don’t want to dismiss the other concerns for Albies however. Albies was struggling before his initial injury, hitting .244/.289/.405 with eight home runs and three stolen bases and was dropping in the lineup. Lineup spot will be very important to his value as he loses a lot of value if he is not hitting in the top half. I tend to believe he will be hitting in the top five and should be healthy heading into 2023, so I am willing to take a gamble on a player I was willing to take as a first round pick last year that I can get in the fourth round like I did in my first draft of the year.

Trevor Story Steamer Projection: PAs 642, 23 HR, 77 R 82 RBI, 17 SBs, .238/.311/.425

Story is coming off of a disaster season in his first year in Boston where he played just 94 games and struggled massively when healthy. I can chalk up a lot to learning to hit outside of Coors, learning a new position, and injury. That being said, I think some of his ADP is still based on his name value which was boosted by his former home park. There are some concerns with the underlying skills. He had his highest strikeout rate, hostess o-swing, and lowest contact rate since 2017. He did still hit the ball with authority and was fantastic on the bases, not getting caught once. I think he is one of the hardest players to project due to his first season out of Coors being so injury riddled, but the stretch of 202 plate appearances between June 1 and ending his season on September 11 where he hit seven home runs and stole seven bases with a .254 average feels about right and when you project that over the 575 plate appearances that FanGraphs Depth Charts gives him, you get a 20/20 season with a .254 average and that would put him right around where steamer has him which confirms for me that he is probably being over-drafted.

Gunnar Henderson Steamer Projection: PAs 619, 22 HR, 76 R, 78 RBI, 10 SBs, .254/.344/.443

Man, I want to love Henderson for this year, but I am afraid of the hype. He is already going in the top 100 and I just am having a hard time believing he is worth that. On the plus side, he should have an everyday role right off the bat and there is a ton of talent in the bat. On the negative side, Henderson had a two degree launch angle in the Majors and that led to a 60% ground ball rate and a 24.4% flyball percentage which was even worse than his high ground ball and low flyball rates we saw him post in AAA. He was also oddly passive at the plate, sporting a 41% swing percentage which led to a 18.6% called strike rate and below average z-contact rate. The power is there but he will have a hard time tapping into it right away unless there is a change in the approach and swing path. I think he is a fade for me this season especially as the price inevitably climbs due to his youth and upside.

Adolis Garcia Steamer Projection: PAs 648, 27 HR, 74 R, 86 RBI, 17 SBs, .233/.283/.427

Adolis was everyone’s favorite fade last year to the point that he became a huge bargain on draft day. However, I am still fading the underlying skills. He had the third worst zone contact rate, ninth worst o-swing, and fourth worst swinging strike rate of any qualified hitter in baseball last year. There is a ton of power and speed and his defense will keep him on the field through cold stretches, so even when the awful plate skills catch up with him, he can still have value especially if you have strong batting average players offsetting what could be a huge anchor. Right now, I can’t pay the price, but as more and more people write and talk about the bad underlying numbers, he could end up being another good value once again.

Tyler O’Neill Steamer Projection: PAs 559, 26 HR, 68 R. 75 RBI, 14 SBs, .243/.315/.447

This is an interesting one for me. At first glance O’Neill’s line doesn’t look that bad. He made some really good changes to his approach and underlying skills. He became more patient and selective which led to a career best zone contact, walk rate and strikeout rate. I think a lot of it comes down to how many games he plays. Steamer projects 134 a year after he played only 96 due to injury and two years after playing 138. He is projected to be healthy this season and his defense should keep him on the field when healthy, but there are rumors he could be dealt to a different team. Where he ends up will determine a lot of his value. Staying in St. Louis is a bit of a double edged sword. It is a fantastic lineup which is good and bad as he has no chance at being one of the top four hitters, but you want players in good lineups. The Cardinals also have multiple prospects knocking on the door of the Majors and while they aren’t naturally outfielders, it seems likely that Jordan Walker will move to the outfield and Masyn Winn could push Tommy Edman to the outfield. If O’Neill gets traded, he likely bats higher in the lineup and is in a better park, but that could raise his price. Right now, I am not overly scared of the current price because of how bad the outfield position is, but his price is important to keep watching.

Kris Bryant Steamer Projection: 568 PAs, 20 HR, 78 R, 69 RBI, 5 SB, .269//.348/.458

Bryant is coming off of a lost season in his first with the Rockies in which he only played 42 games. He was great in the games he played, hitting .306/.376/.475 with five home runs, though 26 of his 42 games were in Coors. One of the main issues is that he has struggled to stay healthy. Bryant has lost major parts of three of the last five seasons and has not played in 150 games since 2017. I think Bryant has been overrated for a few years now, but the fact he is in Coors now will continue that trend. I am fading him at the current price and do not expect his price to drop moving forward.

With drafts going and projections being released it is time to look at what they say about each other. This week I am going to look at what Steamer says about who is undervalued and overvalued at their current ADP. I took the Fangraphs Auction Calculator Values for Steamer and compared them to the current NFBC ADP to see which names jumped out at me within the top 100 projected hitters. Read the rest of this entry »

In 2022 the average number of plate appearances among big leaguers was 121. A plate appearance marks any time a player walks up and digs into the batter box. Each spit, every toe twist, and all of the glove-tightening times in the box accumulate together into plate appearances. Let’s start with the easy one. Who had the most? Marcus Semien. He had 724. In fact, he had exactly 724 last season as well. That’s roughly 4.5 plate appearances per game.

That’s absurd.

He played in 161 games in 2022 and he wasn’t even the player who played in the most games this year. That would be 162 games and, actually, two players did it; Dansby Swanson and Matt Olson. Teammates! The Ironman Cal Ripken, Jr. averaged 4.3 plate appearances (12,883) per game (3,001) for his career. What Semien, Swanson, and Olson did this year is special. It should be an award in itself. If it is already and I don’t know it, don’t blast me. But I’m pretty sure people would just say, “Oh, an award just for showing up?” and I would argue that showing up is rare these days.

Here’s a histogram of 2022’s every plate appearance:

Read the rest of this entry »

What was the best possible fantasy combination of infielders (1B, 2B, SS, 3B) this season? That is an easy question to answer if you use the year-to-date settings on the auction calculator and you simply look at the best player at each position. It would look like this:

1B: Paul Goldschmidt, $33.7

2B: Jose Altuve, $25.2

SS: Trea Turner, $32.5

3B: José Ramírez, $31.2

But, if you were in a 12-team roto snake draft and were able to get both José Ramírez and Trea Turner, you likely played in a league full of clowns. J-Ram’s average draft position (NFBC) was 3.2 while Turner’s was 1.2. It’s unlikely any fantasy teams had both of those top players. So, what was the best possible infield within reasonable ADP? Here’s how I tried to answer this question.

Read the rest of this entry »

To qualify for this totally made-up award, a player must have been projected to earn positive value in the stolen base category (mSB) on our Auction Calculator (default settings, steamer projections) and negative value in every other category. They then needed to earn positive value in at least three of the four non-SB categories (mR, mHR, mRBI, mAVG).

Finalists: Bobby Witt Jr., Daulton Varsho, Dansby Swanson

—

Finalist #1: Bobby Witt Jr., Projected negative: mAVG, mHR, mRBI, mR. Earned positive: mHR, mRBI, mR, mSB

Surely there will be plenty written about Bobby Witt Jr.’s rookie season in fantasy realms this offseason. His preseason projections were likely low due to the uncertainty of his playing time/call-up situation. It was clear that he was going to be good. But, would you have guessed he’d finish as the fifth-best third-baseman by auction value earned? It was clear that he was going to steal bases, and in the end, that’s what drove his value. If you look at any one of his 15-game rolling charts not involving base running, it would tell you a story of a 22-year-old rookie who has a lot of potential but may not have lit the world on fire in his first year. It happens.

Witt outperformed all of his roto-category projections except for his batting average. He was projected to hit .257 and he hit .254. Not bad, steamer projections. Compared to his 2021 AAA stats, his line-drive rate was down and his ground ball rate was up. He also put out fewer fly-balls for home runs than he did in AAA. However, he still showed that he has the 22-year-old ability to absolutely smoke the ball with his 92nd Statcast percentile maxEV. But, he had a difficult time with major league four-seamers, putting up a -7 Statcast run value and a 23rd worst (among qualified hitters) -2.6 pitch-info p-val on wFA. However, Witt accumulated 632 plate appearances in his rookie season (second behind Steven Kwan) and that experience must be worth a few extra dollars going into 2023.

—

Finalist #2: Daulton Varsho, Projected negative: mAVG, mHR, mRBI, mR. Earned positive: mHR, mRBI, mR, mSB

One thing to keep in mind is Varsho’s increased projected value due to his eligibility at catcher. The positional scarcity earns him a higher value. But, Varsho was a catcher-eligible player who was expected to run and he did not disappoint, stealing a career-high (MLB) 16 bases. He also put together a close-to-full season with 592 plate appearances in 151 games. He was a workhorse this season and everything but his batting average (.234) showed it.

However, these roto-value gains don’t seem to be accompanied by much underlying Statcast data:

He did catch 31 games in 2022, so depending on your league rules, he may or may not be eligible again at the catcher position in 2023. Regardless, no matter which way you look at it, 27 home runs and 16 stolen bases at the catcher position in 2022 play nicely on any fantasy team under any league parameters. For a player who has only had roughly one and a half seasons at the major league level, I’m looking forward to seeing his 2023 projections.

—

…and the award goes to…

Finalist #3: Dansby Swanson, Projected negative: mAVG, mHR, mRBI, mR. Earned positive: mHR, mRBI, mR, mSB, mAVG

As Swanson heads into free agency this offseason, his 2022 totals indicate that he intended to make a statement.  In 2022 he put up the most plate appearances of his career, scored the most runs, hit the most RBI, and stole the most bases. He also put up his lowest BB%, which didn’t help those rostering him in OBP leagues. His K% has been on an upward trend in the past three seasons, but so have his home run totals, FB% and SwStr%.

Is he selling out for power? Maybe. But he also outperformed his batting average projection (steamer) of .245 by over 20 points (.277) and the 2022 major league average was .243.

Don’t call him a rabbit, but he did run, stealing a career-high 18 bags. However, he’s not being given this award because he stole bases, he’s being given this prestigious award because he did everything else.

Congratulations to Dansby Swanson on an amazing season and to any fantasy managers that rostered him. Next week, I’ll begin my dishing out these highly coveted awards to pitchers.

Be sure to check out Lucas Kelly’s Beginning Guide to the Calculator

After going over what several members of our team would like in a draft prep spreadsheet, we made one that takes the output from our auction calculator and creates position rankings.

Important: We tried to include all the necessary information into the Google Sheet, but it won’t be ideal for everyone. You are encouraged to customize it to your tastes as it’d be too hard to take all individual requests to set up the perfect one for everyone. Read the rest of this entry »

The following is a look at some of the advanced features of the auction calculator. Adding keepers, how to change the value of relievers, and inputing points leagues are discussed. Lucas Kelly went over the basics of the calculator in this article.

Keepers

The Keeper function is one of the best features of the auction calculator. Since it was added, I’ve used it every year for my home keeper league and will again this year. While it takes a bit of time to set up, it’s well worth the effort. Read the rest of this entry »

I’ll admit that the first time I looked at the auction calculator I was overwhelmed and confused. What do all those numbers mean? How come some of them have parentheses around them? What’s an aPOS? I use a snake draft in my league, not an auction. Why do I need dollar values? Well my friend, if you have asked yourself those questions I hope to answer some of them in this post and prove to you that our auction calculator is a very valuable tool whether you play in a 10-team ESPN home league or you’re an NFBC regular.

Read the rest of this entry »

One of the greatest fantasy tutorials I’ve ever received came in Jeff Zimmerman and Tanner Bell’s, The Process. In the book, there is a breakdown of two very important valuation systems; standing gains points and z-scores. Our auction calculator, for example, is built around z-scores. For a further dive into both, I highly suggest purchasing a copy of the book. In general, z-scores help us understand how good player A is compared to the rest of the draftable player pool and it can be used as a great jumping-off point for your rankings. I use the word “rankings” because they are not projections and that’s the beauty in z-scores. You are not trying to outsmart projections. Instead, you are using a projection system of your choice to create your rankings. In this post, I’ll be creating z-scores for shortstops in 2022 using Steamer projections.

Read the rest of this entry »

I recently took over an Ottoneu team for the upcoming 2022 season. If you are unfamiliar with Ottoneu, it’s keeper league where you get to make trades from mid-November to January 31st. Any players left on your roster after that you keep, using the auction draft to fill in the missing pieces. Taking over someone else’s team kind of feels like moving into an empty office. There are a few cobwebs in the corner, the previous owner left a really cool pen in the desk drawer and there’s a very stinky sandwich in the staff refrigerator that you somehow feel like is your new responsibility.

The fun part is taking stock of what you have and trying to decide what you want to keep (cool pen) and what you want to cut (stinky sandwich). In this series of posts, I’ll write about the decisions I have to make, how I go about analyzing the data before making my decision, and then what decision I plan to make. You too could be doing this kind of thing, all you have to do is take over someone’s abandoned team and search through the desk drawers when you move in.

Read the rest of this entry »