Who is Being Dropped and Why

With FAAB-ageddon over, it’s time to see who were the most dropped players in the 38 NFBC Main Event leagues.



  • Teoscar Hernandez (22): I was using him as a spot starter on a couple of my teams hoping he’d get hot. It was nice to have the Blue Jays to make the decision to move on for me.
  • Jeimer Candelario (20): Another borderline talent coming into the season who was sent down.

Note: In “The Process”, we wrote: “Any major leaguer with an OPS below .635 looks to be below average and could be replaceable.” Candelario was at .573 and Hernandez was at .562. The current low OPS list (min 100 PA) is littered with hitters who have been demoted (Justin Bour and Mallex Smith) or “injured” (Travis Shaw and Ender Inciarte). Any player under a .635 OPS and especially a .600 OPS could be at risk for losing their job.


  • Francisco Cervelli (17): He’s not hitting (.505) and losing playing time to Elias Diaz (.537 OPS). It’s a pillow fight between these two.
  • Aledmys Diaz (16): He could have been placed under the Injury heading since a hamstring issue may bench him some this week. And Jose Altuve may be back at the week’s end killing all of Diaz’s current fantasy value.
  • Nick Kingham (15): He was demoted mid-week to the bullpen but now he may be starting on Wednesday.
  • Brandon Kintzler (14): This Saves grab didn’t pan out.
  • Derek Holland (14): Moved to the bullpen after struggling (7.36 ERA).
  • Ryan O’Hearn (13): While his .648 OPS is above the demotion line, he’s useless to fantasy owners.
  • Erik Swanson (13): Nine runs in three innings in his last start. He can’t even be streamed at this point.
  • Eric Thames (12): He’s played in 18 games this month and started in only nine of them. The results (.189/.434/.270) are Joey Votto-ish.
  • Austin Hedges (11): There are even a baseline catcher hitting thresholds and a .531 OPS doesn’t cut it.
  • John Means (11): One start this week at Colorado. A reasonable drop but might be a cheap add later if he gets pounded.
  • Julio Urias (11): Administrative leave for domestic battery.
  • Junior Guerra (11):’He’s got a couple of Saves but Josh Hader looks to be the closer.
  • Lou Trivino (11): Some owners were slow at dropping Trivino after picking him up when Blake Treinen had an injury scare.
  • Emilio Pagan (10): Not the official closer but might get 10 Saves with elite counting stats (13.5 K/9, 0.68 WHP, and 0.61 ERA).
  • Ian Kennedy (10): Another potential closer in which some owners were tired of holding on to.
  • Jackie Bradley Jr. (10): A .421 OPS
  • Jeremy Hellickson (10): Owners who took the Hellickson two-step were rewarded with a 4 K’s, 2.13 WHIP, and 9.00 ERA. Congrats.
  • Trevor Cahill (10): I was looking to add Cahill when possible this past FAAB period. While I’m not keen on his matchup this week (home versus Minnesota), he has a nice two-step at Oakland and at Seattle next week.

Here are the players dropped in five or more leagues.

Players Dropped in the NFBC Main Event
Name Drops (38 leagues)
Jonathan Loaisiga 32
Miguel Andujar 29
Teoscar Hernandez 22
Jeimer Candelario 20
Anibal Sanchez 18
David Robertson 18
Francisco Cervelli 17
Jed Lowrie 17
Aledmys Diaz 16
Nick Margevicius 16
Nick Kingham 15
Brandon Kintzler 14
Delino DeShields 14
Derek Holland 14
Garrett Hampson 14
A.J. Minter 13
Erik Swanson 13
Ryan O’Hearn 13
Eric Thames 12
Austin Hedges 11
John Means 11
Julio Urias 11
Junior Guerra 11
Kelvin Gutierrez 11
Lou Trivino 11
Emilio Pagan 10
Ian Kennedy 10
Jackie Bradley Jr. 10
Jeremy Hellickson 10
Trevor Cahill 10
Brad Keller 9
Chris Martin 9
Christin Stewart 9
David Bote 9
Freddy Peralta 9
Manuel Margot 9
Renato Nunez 9
Reyes Moronta 9
Seranthony Dominguez 9
Stephen Vogt 9
Carlos Gonzalez 8
Harold Ramirez 8
Homer Bailey 8
Justin Bour 8
Mike Fiers 8
Ryan Brasier 8
Starlin Castro 8
Anthony Swarzak 7
Charlie Tilson 7
Hernan Perez 7
Ivan Nova 7
J.P. Crawford 7
Jakob Junis 7
John Gant 7
Ryan Cordell 7
Tim Beckham 7
Tony Wolters 7
Wilmer Font 7
Archie Bradley 6
Brian Anderson 6
Chris Iannetta 6
Cody Allen 6
Cole Tucker 6
Ender Inciarte 6
Jefry Rodriguez 6
Jon Duplantier 6
Mac Williamson 6
Merrill Kelly 6
Mitch Garver 6
Orlando Arcia 6
Rowdy Tellez 6
Ty France 6
Tyler Beede 6
Vince Velasquez 6
Aaron Sanchez 5
Albert Pujols 5
Andrew Miller 5
Austin Barnes 5
Blake Swihart 5
Brett Anderson 5
Chad Pinder 5
Chris Davis 5
Dereck Rodriguez 5
Drew Pomeranz 5
Grayson Greiner 5
Jason Heyward 5
Jeff Samardzija 5
Jeremy Jeffress 5
Johan Camargo 5
John Hicks 5
Josh Harrison 5
Jung Ho Kang 5
Luis Rengifo 5
Mike Zunino 5
Nick Anderson 5
Trent Thornton 5
Willy Adames 5
Yonder Alonso 5

Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won three FSWA Awards including on for his MASH series. In his first two seasons in Tout Wars, he's won the H2H league and mixed auction league. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.

newest oldest most voted

“Pillow fight” LOL that’s perfect