Top 5 Prospects for 2015: San Francisco Giants

This 30-part series will look at the projected Top 5 freshman contributors for each big league club for the year ahead. The rankings take into consideration a mixture of ceiling, readiness and potential playing time allocation, which is to say some players with lower ceilings may be ranked ahead of others with higher ceilings because they project to have a greater impact in the coming season.

In a Nutshell: The Giants’ freshman class of 2015 doesn’t have a lot of depth but it has a strong hitting prospect, a number of capable arms and even a guy that can make things happen with his feet — when he manages to get on base. All in all it should be decent but unspectacular.

The Top 5 Freshman for 2015

1. Andrew Susac, C: Veteran backstop Buster Posey has been seeing increased playing time at first base to try and shield him from injury. Susac could be the guy that finally pushes the former MVP to first permanently. The rookie backstop is a competent defender and has enough hitting skill to become an above-average hitter for a catcher. Because he’s lost some development time to injuries in the past, it will be understandable if the Giants want Susac to open the year back in Triple-A. But if back-up Henry Sanchez struggles again with the bat, it may be too tempting for the front office to give the freshman a shot on this perennial-playoff team.

2. Kyle Crick, RHP: A top pick from the 2011 draft, Crick has moved swiftly through the minors thanks to his immense talent — and despite the injuries that have prevented him from pitching over 100 innings more than once (just 2012). The biggest issue facing this hard-throwing Texan is the lack of consistent control, as witnessed by his 61 walks in just 90.1 innings last year. Some view him as a future reliever but the Giants likely see him as a potential rotation fill-in for injured veteran arms during the 2015 season. If he can improve his control and polish his repertoire, he has No. 2 starter potential.

3. Gary Brown, OF: The recent addition of veteran Japanese outfielder Nori Aoki is a boon for the Giants but not great news for Brown. On the plus side, perhaps the rookie can keep an eye on the veteran and start to learn a better approach for utilizing his plus speed (i.e. trimming the long swing and hitting the ball on the ground more consistently). Brown has 30+ steal potential but he also has just enough pop in his bat to mess with his head. Now 26, this former first rounder needs to start making the adjustments before he becomes the dreaded Quad-A player.

4. Steven Okert, RHP: A 2012 fourth round pick, the Giants organization was excited with Okert’s potential after witnessing his hard-throwing ways in his pro debut. He really came into his own in 2014 while pitching at both High-A and Double-A, and struck out a combined 92 batters in 68.1 innings. He may open 2015 back in Double-A, where he appeared in 24 games in ’14, but he likely won’t be long for the league and could be in the Majors by mid-year. Look for Okert to quickly challenge for high leverage innings if his command/control hold up.

5. Ty Blach, LHP: Selected one round after Overt in 2012, Blach spent all of 2014 in Double-A and could challenge Crick for the first promotion to fill a void in the starting rotation. A strong-bodied lefty, he doesn’t possess “wow” stuff but he mixes his pitches, changes speeds and throws strikes. He might help in fantasy due to his durability and consistency but he’s not going to rack up the strikeouts.





Marc Hulet has been writing at FanGraphs since 2008. His work focuses on prospects and fantasy. Follow him on Twitter @marchulet.

14 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
gribo
11 years ago

Susac – extremely overrated. Mark it down. Everyone is upgrading his hit tool based on his SSS call-up. Reality is a low avg guy with moderate power – if he can stick.

Bill
11 years ago
Reply to  gribo

He’s not a top prospect sure, but he did well in A ball in 2012 and well in AA in 2013. PCL stats shouldn’t count for 2014, but he has decent plate discipline which should allow him to hit .240 to .250 as a floor with upside and 12-15HRs with upside, and an OBP at .310 to .315 as a floor. With above average defense that’s 1.5 to 2.0 WAR right there so…I’d take him.

Snarf Jabroni
11 years ago
Reply to  gribo

gribo – it has been marked down.

Everyone is “upgrading his hit tool”, because he got off the bench cold without regular playing time, and proved he could hit MLB pitching, with POWER, including off some of the best ala Trevor Rosenthal in the NLCS.

Certainly a small sample size, but he never looked overmatched, showed great plate discipline, and hit both Price and Kershaw (twice, 2 2B) off the wall in only 95 AB with a 125 OPS+.

***
11 years ago
Reply to  Snarf Jabroni

Aaron-Cibia type player?

Snarf Jabroni
11 years ago
Reply to  Snarf Jabroni

Arencibia? LOL, puh-leeze.

J.P. is a below-average defensive catcher with a .255 career OBP.

Susac is a consistent .350 OBP player at every level he’s ever played, and throws out 35-40% of runners.

Mike
11 years ago

lol Henry Sanchez.

Anyways, I think they are legitimately concerned about Hector as a C with the amount of hits he’s taken to his head. I’d be very surprised if Susac isn’t on the MLB roster opening day.

crawdads
11 years ago

Re: Susac — Just ignore Brandon Belt? I don’t think so. Posey doesn’t move permanently to first as long as Belt is on the team.

Re: Brown — he is AAAA. Look at the numbers. Calling him the Giants’ #3 overall is crazy. It really calls into question this whole article.

Will HannonMember since 2017
11 years ago
Reply to  crawdads

This is for fantasy prospects for 2015 only… so with SB’s, Brown is pretty reasonable on this list.

crawdads
11 years ago
Reply to  Will Hannon

Two things about Brown:

1) You can’t steal first base.
2) You can’t hit or even have an at bat if you’re not in the lineup.

With Aoki, Pence, Pagan and a few bench guys ahead of him it’s doubtful Brown gets much of a look at all going forward. He’s already old for AAA and didn’t do anything remarkable there over the last two years.

Gary Brown seems like a nice kid. I hope the best for him. Would love for the Giants to have a “30+ steals” guy. Sadly, though, I just don’t see it.

robbyrobdu
11 years ago
Reply to  crawdads

Yes this is purely for getting a shot this year…some teams, like the Giants, don’t have many holes so it’s harder the speculate on where the need may arise and who exactly fills it…it’s not always the top prospect or even a prospect at all…it’s often a journeyman/AAAA type guy…and even with that said the prospect pool is by all accounts quite bad in the field.

Brown was highly drafted and has some tools, and teams are not likely to just give up on players like that…baseball more than any other sport has shown us that players have a tendency to really “step up to the plate” (punny? LoL) when given a chance in the show…and sometimes eventual superstars fall flat on their face in their first taste…remember these guys are working on things all the time…and I don’t know about you but I don’t need to be AMAZING at something after 2-3 years or else I give up…it’s a process, and not everyone takes the same curve.

I hope that very objective take gives you something to Ponder…I am all for questioning and doubting rankings…I was adamant that Arenado was better than Castellanos and there was no reason based on pedigree and numbers one was getting all the love, for example and posted it everywhere…
I am also an ardent Josh Reddick supporter, as “prospect guys” never thought he had huge upside and ignored year after year of “overperforming” until the BoSox called him up and he continued his solid play…at some point the production has to matter…but not always, because some guys still have refining of their tools…but the potential underneath is very shiny….

Ok, now I’m done.

Thanks for the article!! 🙂

DrBGiantsfan
11 years ago

Don’t sleep on Tyler Beede rocketing through the system to beat Crick to the major leagues. Beede has comparable FB to Crick with much more advanced secondary stuff. Beede may have some mild-moderate command issues, but they pale in comparison to Crick’s.

glib
11 years ago

Push Posey to first? Poor Brandon Belt really is not loved. More so sine there is a substantial hole at 3b…

carmot
11 years ago

And… Cody Hall remains “The Invisible Man.” Huh. Seems like he is about due for some credit, he’s performed very well.

Meanwhile, Crick and Brown? They are considered candidates for playing time in 2015, huh? Crick and his 6 BB/9. Brown seems to have fallen out of favor with the Giants. If one is going to include Susac, why not also include Matt Duffy? Mention Ty Blach, but not Clayton Blackburn?

3B doesn’t offer a lot of depth. Arias, or guys that don’t have much experience there. So, maybe Duvall actually has a fairer chance than Brown for a call-up? But, IMO, that still isn’t saying much.

Everybody can continue to speculate about Posey moving from catching. But it seems (to me) like the Giants’ Brain Trust have been explicitly clear, that ain’t happening anytime soon. It sure would be great to see Belt get in a full & productive MLB season.

pirates hurdles
11 years ago

I don-t think anyone sees Crick as a #2 SP anymore. The walk rates north of 5 have sunk that boat. I would think that A.Mejia would have a shot if he comes back off suspension with a quick start.