Ottoneu Trade Deadline: All Questions Answered
The Ottoneu Trade Deadline is today! If you’ve followed along recently, we have covered the trade deadline (or trading in general) in some detail.
Ottoneu 101: Roster Organizer – Using the roster organizer as you start to plan for next season.
OttoGraphs Episode 16: VetoGate 2016 – Podcast on acceptable behavior of vetoing trades.
Ottoneu 101: Approaching the Trade Deadline – Primer on the Ottoneu Trade Deadline, and how to approach it as you consider buying/selling.
Ottoneu 101: Production, Salary, Surplus, Value – Definitions and applications of how trades can be viewed when trying to weight surplus and current production.
Today we want to try something a little bit different. We are encouraging everyone to leave their Ottoneu trade questions in the comments and we will help to answer them as best we can. Trey, Tom, and Justin will be stopping in throughout the day as well. As a reminder – each of us focuses on Ottoneu and it’s various formats. We are happy to help out to the best of our abilities with other league types, but recognize that is not our strong suit. The deadline ends at 11:59:59 ET. So get those trade offers out and work towards finishing those deals as soon as possible. Today is not the time to be nickle and dime your league mates in hopes of extracting every ounce of value you can. Time is short.
Joe works at a consulting firm in Pittsburgh. When he isn't working or studying for actuarial exams, he focuses on baseball. He also writes @thepointofpgh. Follow him on twitter @Ottoneutrades


Who would you rather have: $20 JUpton or $20 Wil Myers?
Myers
I would also prefer Myers
Myers
I have a very strong infield going into next year. Would you trade your 2$ Story for a 10$ Pollock.
I would probably take Story. Then trade him for someone I liked more than Pollock in the offseason.
Story will suck up arbitration, which is useful. Protects your other players.
I prefer Story to Pollock there
Prefer Story here.
Tillman, Matz or McCullers? Pick one (or more) to drop.
Tillman, and only Tillman
Are either, both or neither $23 Lester or $11 Gausman keepers in FGpts?
Lester definitely is. I’ll defer on Gausman
I agree with Joe, Lester is a keeper for sure. I think Gausman has more upside and will be better in 2017, but I think $11 is probably too much to pay right now. It’s reasonably close though, so I would definitely hold him until the offseason.
Keep both. I’m giving Gausman one more year to break out.
If this year was a loss but you were looking to compete next year would you trade a $21 Hamels for a $1 Dominic Smith?
I think you should be able to get something much better than Dominic Smith in return for Hamels. I definitely endorse moving Hamels though, if not now then in the offseason.
Save Hamels for the off season. There’s still plenty of time to buy D. Smith, but he’s unlikely to be a huge contributor, especially if competing for next season. I’d target someone else.
I have been offered $28 Carpenter $10 Severino for $8 Teheran $12 Brantley $3 Margot and $1 Senzel. I don’t like the deal but needed to make sure I’m not missing something. Thanks.
I would Cut Severion, Teheran, Brantley… I would maybe cut Margot. I would keep Senzel, I would keep Carpenter. So Carpenter side.
Thanks Joe.
$5 Giolito or $3 Nola? 5×5. Would cut $5 Stephenson if I traded Nola.
You should cut Stephenson at $7 (next year) even if playing in a Reds-only league. Go with Nola here.
Thanks. Plan to cut Stephenson; was just giving context. The Nola injury has me concerned since he needs PRP.
$15 Pedoria for $1 Roark and $5 Herrera/$9 Wheeler? Hoping to compete next year…
Assuming this is FGPTS and Kelvin Herrera, I think I’d stick with Pedroia
Baez at $9 for $37 Scherzer? I could use some SP and am in a dogfight for first. Same question but if I also had to include Reyes at $3?
I’d want Scherzer and would deal Baez before Reyes
Thanks–already did the deal but had to give up both.
Agree with Joe. If you can get Scherzer for Baez alone, take it and run