Hitters Who Underperformed Their Projected Value Within the Top-200 Picks

Sep 14, 2026; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Mandatory Credit: John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

We’re following up on an earlier article about hitters who are outperforming their projected value this season. But there’s also the other side of that coin: 19 hitters among the top 200 picks who are underperforming their projected value by at least $20. Unsurprisingly, the hitters drafted within the top 50 picks who were injured or struggled have been the biggest busts.

The visual below shows hitters who have lost $20 or more this season.

Hitters Who Underperformed Their Projected Value Within the Top-200 Picks
Name ADP Earned Dollars Projected Dollars Dollars Earned – Projected Diff
Aaron Judge 1.85 -$2.39 $43.52 $20.56 -$45.91
Addison Barger 193.09 -$27.58 -$2.82 -$15.20 -$24.76
Agustín Ramírez 86.85 -$6.43 $14.17 $3.87 -$20.59
Brent Rooker 42.11 -$15.53 $24.10 $4.28 -$39.62
Brenton Doyle 166.25 -$16.66 $9.17 -$3.75 -$25.83
Cal Raleigh 18.73 $5.97 $30.74 $18.36 -$24.77
Francisco Lindor 25.35 -$1.40 $21.29 $9.95 -$22.69
José Ramírez 6.28 $8.30 $30.69 $19.50 -$22.39
Juan Soto 4.65 $10.29 $39.10 $24.69 -$28.82
Julio Rodríguez 9.49 $11.99 $32.69 $22.34 -$20.70
Kyle Tucker 13.13 $4.87 $29.32 $17.09 -$24.45
Luis Robert Jr. 105.64 -$13.68 $9.11 -$2.29 -$22.79
Maikel Garcia 63.15 -$9.45 $14.40 $2.48 -$23.86
Noelvi Marte 147.71 -$18.88 $3.32 -$7.78 -$22.19
Roman Anthony 50.75 -$20.36 $14.48 -$2.94 -$34.84
Ronald Acuña Jr. 5.26 $5.32 $31.76 $18.54 -$26.45
Shohei Ohtani 1.27 $26.11 $47.84 $36.97 -$21.74
Trevor Story 111.33 -$16.88 $11.47 -$2.70 -$28.35
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. 18.05 $3.51 $29.45 $16.48 -$25.94

Some of these hitters suffered injuries, such as Aaron Judge, Cal Raleigh, and Brent Rooker. Meanwhile, other hitters have seen skills and luck factors fall off, impacting their fantasy production. Can they bounce back next season? Or should we avoid them?

Agustín Ramírez, C, Marlins

Liam Hicks stole the show for the Marlins, with Ramírez struggling at the plate. That led to Ramírez being sent down in early May for three months before returning to the majors. Ramírez has teased us with a 75.7 mph bat speed, yet the 2.7% barrel rate per plate appearance fell from 8% in 2025. Though Ramírez stole 16 bases in 2025, despite below-average speed and athleticism. However, Ramírez’s 18% stolen base opportunity rate fell to 9% this season, so the opportunities disappeared.

With Hicks gone, Ramírez has been platooning with Joe Mack, limiting his volume and upside. Though there’s power and speed within Ramírez’s fantasy profile, playing time could be problematic. Keep tabs on the Marlins transactions at the catcher position.

José Ramírez, 3B, Guardians

In mid-June, Ramírez missed around one month after a hamate bone surgery on his left hand. Though Ramírez has stolen 33 bases, 11 home runs isn’t what fantasy managers expected after doing 30/40 in the previous two seasons. Ramírez has a 3% barrel rate per plate appearance, over two points below his career average and his lowest season-long rate since 2016.

Thankfully, Ramírez continues to run, with a 30% stolen base opportunity rate, nearly identical to the past two seasons. Meanwhile, Ramírez is converting his chances into steals 89% of the time this season. Unfortunately, without the power, Ramírez’s earned value plummets, as he turns 34 heading into the 2027 season. If there’s a significant discount in Ramírez’s price of (maybe 2+ rounds off his former first-round price), we’ll want to target him to bounce back in 2027.

Julio Rodríguez, OF, Mariners

Rodríguez projects to finish this season with one of his worst seasons from a fantasy standpoint. On a positive note, Rodríguez hit the 20/20 mark for the 5th straight season. However, Rodríguez’s runs, RBI, and batting average could be all be career worsts.

Rodríguez has improved his contact rate (74.6%) and swinging-strike rate (13.1%) by 1 percentage point this season. Interestingly, Rodríguez posted a career-low 6.2% barrel rate, 1 point below his career norm. That said, it’s been a mixed bag with an 18.1% pulled air rate, but a career-worst 13.2% HR/FB this season.

Those mental errors by Rodríguez stick in our minds, which could coincide with a slightly lower draft cost in 2027.

Kyle Tucker, OF, Dodgers

Tucker has been fulfilling the strategy of avoiding players who join new teams. That’s evident in Tucker’s lowest home run total since 2020 and the lowest batting average since his rookie season (.141 BA) in 72 plate appearances. Tucker’s 4.5% barrel rate per plate appearance is the lowest since 2018. Furthermore, Tucker’s 20.3% pulled air rate dipped from over 22% over the past four seasons.

Tucker could have been pressing with the Dodgers. That’s somewhat evident with his chase rate (23.8%) and swing rate (48.3%) both being 3-5 points higher than recent seasons. Meanwhile, Tucker’s 8.3% HR/FB is more than 5 points below his career average, suggesting poor luck in home runs. Besides 2024, Tucker’s fantasy profile involved 20/20 with a quality batting average, which hasn’t been the case this season.

Tucker’s strong plate discipline should age well. His power could bounce back in 2027.

Brenton Doyle, OF, Rockies

Unfortunately, Doyle suffered an oblique strain in May that cost him two months. Doyle’s fantasy value took another hit when he was traded out of Coors Field to the White Sox. Unfortunately, Doyle landed in a weak-side platoon role with the White Sox, as Tristan Peters holds down center field.

Doyle has a better bat speed (72.3 mph), yet his 3.7% barrel rate per plate appearance fell from 7% or higher in the previous two seasons. With Doyle’s 90th percentile Speed Score, he should be an asset for power and speed over a larger sample. In the small sample of 62 plate appearances with the White Sox, Doyle’s 31.7% pulled rate and 42.5% flyball rate shifted in opposite directions from the career norms.

Doyle’s 2027 draft price should fall significantly, given the poor production and limited playing time.

Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 3B, Blue Jays

Somehow Guerrero has single-digit home runs in the middle of September while totaling 582 plate appearances, after five straight seasons of 20+ home runs. He has a near-elite bat speed (76.3 mph), yet his 5.5% barrel rate per plate appearance is a career low. Guerrero’s launch angle has been an issue, though his home run luck shifted against him, with a 5.9% HR/FB rate. For context, Guerrero had a 16.2% HR/FB in his career.

Guerrero continues to hit the ball hard, with a 102.8 mph EV50 (No. 24), which accounts for the hardest 50% of a player’s batted balls. That is two mph lower than 2025 (104.8 mph EV50, No. 8) and 2024 (105.7 mph EV50, No. 6). We might be able to blame Guerrero’s poor production on a right elbow injury in May, back tightness in June, a hamstring injury in late July into early August, and a concussion in mid-August.





Corbin writes for RotoGraphs, focusing on deep dives into baseball advanced metrics. He won two Fantasy Sports Writers Association awards in 2022 and 2023. Corbin also contributes to Yahoo Fantasy. You can find him on X @corbin_young21

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
ChapelHeel66Member since 2018
1 month ago

Yes Raleigh had injuries but he also was horrendous for a significant number of PAs even when healthy. Many were forced to drop him by the end of July, which makes him more than a mere underperformer with ADP 18. In keeper leagues he was an unmitigated disaster.

Last edited 1 month ago by ChapelHeel66