Late-Season Hitter Earned Valued Versus Pre-Season Projected Value

In 12-team leagues, 37 hitters earned $20 or more on the Player Rater. Of those 37 hitters, 24 were drafted within the top 100 picks. Meanwhile, four hitters went undrafted or were past pick 400: Jake Bauers, Jake McCarthy, Jordan Walker, and Liam Hicks. We want to hit on these breakout hitters in the draft or acquire them during the season. These are the waiver pickups that turn into regular starters on our fantasy squads.
The 37 hitters who earned $20 or more are seen below.
| Name | ADP | Earned Value | Projected Value | Earned – Projected Diff |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jordan Walker | 511.72 | $33.49 | -$4.02 | $37.51 |
| Liam Hicks | 748.54 | $25.46 | -$9.15 | $34.60 |
| Jake Bauers | N/A | $20.14 | -$13.29 | $33.44 |
| Jake McCarthy | 506.76 | $23.73 | -$7.21 | $30.94 |
| Pete Crow-Armstrong | 32.94 | $48.06 | $21.20 | $26.87 |
| Sal Stewart | 161.87 | $30.85 | $4.29 | $26.56 |
| Miguel Vargas | 303.09 | $25.55 | $1.82 | $23.73 |
| Dillon Dingler | 254.62 | $24.16 | $1.00 | $23.16 |
| Otto Lopez | 229.16 | $26.53 | $5.24 | $21.29 |
| CJ Abrams | 65 | $32.29 | $13.70 | $18.59 |
| Iván Herrera | 178.43 | $24.07 | $7.28 | $16.79 |
| Luis García Jr. | 261.85 | $22.62 | $6.07 | $16.55 |
| Ben Rice | 53.19 | $36.56 | $20.18 | $16.39 |
| Alec Burleson | 175.19 | $25.39 | $10.21 | $15.17 |
| Yordan Alvarez | 33.39 | $35.88 | $20.82 | $15.05 |
| Gabriel Moreno | 181.22 | $22.36 | $7.91 | $14.45 |
| Drake Baldwin | 78.63 | $27.63 | $16.67 | $10.97 |
| Yandy Díaz | 138.64 | $23.87 | $13.62 | $10.25 |
| Hunter Goodman | 67.36 | $31.36 | $21.61 | $9.75 |
| James Wood | 37.79 | $28.21 | $18.79 | $9.42 |
| Randy Arozarena | 89.38 | $24.13 | $14.84 | $9.28 |
| Matt Olson | 48.01 | $23.73 | $16.69 | $7.03 |
| Michael Harris II | 99.07 | $20.42 | $13.91 | $6.51 |
| Brice Turang | 48.18 | $21.76 | $15.49 | $6.27 |
| Rafael Devers | 61.62 | $23.69 | $17.59 | $6.09 |
| Pete Alonso | 24.44 | $27.95 | $22.25 | $5.70 |
| Junior Caminero | 16.48 | $31.21 | $26.43 | $4.78 |
| Jackson Merrill | 70.79 | $20.40 | $16.75 | $3.65 |
| Kyle Schwarber | 24.69 | $26.16 | $23.41 | $2.76 |
| Elly De La Cruz | 8.45 | $28.80 | $26.22 | $2.58 |
| Bryce Harper | 47.9 | $22.50 | $20.06 | $2.44 |
| William Contreras | 56.56 | $23.92 | $22.07 | $1.85 |
| Zach Neto | 32.3 | $21.34 | $20.20 | $1.14 |
| Fernando Tatis Jr. | 14.01 | $27.94 | $29.51 | -$1.57 |
| Jackson Chourio | 19.38 | $22.38 | $24.70 | -$2.33 |
| Bobby Witt Jr. | 3.1 | $25.63 | $38.29 | -$12.66 |
| Shohei Ohtani | 1.27 | $26.11 | $47.84 | -$21.74 |
While some players earned $20 in value despite falling short of projections, today we’re focusing on the hitters whose actual value was at least $20 more than their projected value. Typically, these breakout players have a mixture of skill, luck, and playing in their favor. Should we believe these players are legitimate as we look toward 2027?
Dillon Dingler, C, Tigers
12-Team Projected Value: $1.00 (254.6 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $24.16
Dingler has set career highs across the board with 27 home runs and over 150 runs plus RBI this season. He has doubled his home run total from 2025, though the BABIP regressed (.273), causing his batting average to dip to .244. Dingler has strong plate discipline, with a 79.7% contact rate and a 9.8% swinging-strike rate. Pairing that with an above-average 6.8% barrel rate per plate appearance is an optimal combination. Furthermore, Dingler ranks in the 90th percentile across defensive advanced metrics, keeping him in the lineup, even if the bat struggles.
Though Dingler cooled off since July 1, with 8 home runs and a .217 batting average, his season-long numbers and skills suggest he is a legitimate, high-end catcher for 2027.
Jake Bauers, 1B/OF, Brewers
12-Team Projected Value: $-13.29 (Undrafted)
12-Team Earned Value: $20.14
Andrew Vaughn started the season injured, and Bauers benefited. Bauers went from a deep-league streamer to a reliable option in most formats. He has set career bests in home runs, runs, RBI, and batting average. Bauers logged the most plate appearances in his career. His patient approach, with a 21.3% chase rate and a 40% swing rate, play to his advantage.
That approach has driven his 16.4% walk rate (a career high), which has led to a career-best .394 OBP. Bauers has been providing value in OBP, batting average, and points leagues. Though his barrel rates have been similar to recent seasons, he is swinging the bat harder over the past two years. Bauers averages a high-end 76.5 mph bat speed with a 7.8% barrel rate per plate appearance, two points above his career average.

Previously, Bauers was deployed as a strong-side platoon option. He averages a 92 wRC+ and .305 wOBA against left-handed pitchers in his career, compared to a 103 wRC+ and .318 wOBA against right-handed pitchers. Surprisingly, Bauers has been performing significantly better against lefties this season, with a 156 wRC+ and .401 wOBA. That’s nearly identical to his performance against right-handed pitchers: 144 wRC+ and a .382 wOBA.
Bauers changed his batting stance, using a narrower stance (18.7 inches), over 10 inches closer than his career norm. Furthermore, Bauers had a 28-degree open stance this season, 17 degrees different than his career average (11 degrees open). Theoretically, using a more open stance might help Bauers track pitches better from left-handed pitchers.
Bauers has the tools to generate fantasy value, but he lacked volume until this year.
Jake McCarthy, OF, Rockies
12-Team Projected Value: $-7.21 (506.7 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $23.73
McCarthy has been the Rockies leadoff hitter since late May after being platooned in the bottom third of their lineup earlier in the year. With the Diamondbacks, McCarthy stole over 20 bases in three seasons, and he has continued to run this year, setting a new career high in steals. After a down season in stolen base opportunity rate (16%) last season, McCarthy’s percentage jumped to 28% this year. However, it’s McCarthy’s 15 home runs that have been mot surprising, after he hit 14 from 2023 to 2025.
McCarthy has a career-best 71.4 mph bat speed with a mediocre 4.2% barrel rate per plate appearance. He has been pulling the ball into the air 17.1% of the time, over four points higher than his career average. While those are optimistic numbers for McCarthy, he has been fortunate with an 11.5% HR/FB rate after being under 8% in the previous three seasons. However, the most notable component is McCarthy’s pulled-air rate because 12 of his 15 home runs have been on pulled balls.
McCarthy has shown strong defensive metrics in all three outfield positions. After a breakout season, the Rockies or another team might give him a longer-term contract. Just be aware that 15 or so home runs is a near-peak outcome, assuming he continues pulling the ball into the air. If McCarthy’s draft price isn’t too pricey, a projection between 2024 and 2026 would be my expectation.
Jordan Walker, OF, Cardinals
12-Team Projected Value: $-4.02 (511.7 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $23.73
Walker went to Driveline this offseason to work on his bat path and swing to unlock those juicy tools. He has been using a narrower stance (22.5 inches), seven inches closer than his career average. Meanwhile, Walker’s stance is more neutral, just one degree open after being 17 degrees open in 2025 and 42+ in previous seasons.
Walker’s bat speed remained elite (79.2 mph) with a career-best pulled air rate (16.4%) this season. We could argue that Walker could surpass 30+ home runs in following seasons with those high-end power tools. Batting average will be a concern with Walker, given his 70.9% contact rate and a 15.2% swinging-strike rate, though he crushes the ball when he makes contact.
Walker has also been running more often. That’s evident in Walker’s 16% stolen-base opportunity rate, while converting 79% of the chances. He possesses the athleticism and size of an NFL linebacker, with 30/20 being realistic outcomes in the coming years. Some drafters may be taking Walker in the first round in 2027.
Liam Hicks, 1B/C, Rays
12-Team Projected Value: $-9.15 (748.5 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $25.46
Hicks was regularly in the top third of the Marlins lineup, whether as designated hitter, first base, or catcher. Since his move to the Rays, Hicks has been deployed as a strong-side platoon. Hicks hit 14 home runs and 12 barrels with the Marlins, showing his efficiency as he pulls the ball into the air 20.2% of the time. Though Hicks doesn’t barrel the ball often, with a 3.1% barrel rate per plate appearance, he makes contact 89.4% of the time, which provides a high floor.
Hicks should have dual-eligibility at first base and catcher, making him a target in two catcher leagues next season. While Hicks is pushing toward 20 home runs, that’s not the expectation moving forward. Based on Hicks’s power metrics, hitting 10-12 home runs is more likely with the batting average carrying his fantasy value.
Miguel Vargas, 1B/3B, White Sox
12-Team Projected Value: $1.82 (303.1 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $25.55
This is what a breakout season looks like. Vargas has shown massive upticks in power skills, with his 73.9 mph bat speed and a 9% barrel rate per plate appearance. Furthermore, Vargas has been pulling the ball into the air more often (27.9%), up from 23% in the previous two seasons. With that new approach and power uptick, Vargas nearly doubled his home run total from 2025.
Vargas has been running more often (12%) and converting 90% of his chances, leading to a career-high in steals. Though Vargas totaled 13 steals before 2026, he has the athleticism to steal double-digit bases if he keeps running more often. The median projection is 25/15 for Vargas’s home runs and stolen bases next season, with the skills to support the breakout campaign.
Since Vargas hits plenty of balls into the air, batting average could be a risky category, as we’ve seen in the past. But his contact quality will continue to lead to HR and should limit some of the average risk. He should be a target next season, even with the elevated price.
Otto Lopez, 2B/SS, Marlins
12-Team Projected Value: $5.24 (229.2 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $26.53
Lopez’s 30 steals and .307 batting average have been boosting his fantasy value. In previous seasons, Lopez has given us power and speed, though steals carried his value more than power. Lopez has average power, with a 4.9% barrel rate per plate appearance. After Lopez’s 14% stolen base opportunity rate in 2025, it bounced back to 21% this season. The lower stolen base output in 2025 could be explained by Lopez’s sprained ankle injury and poor conversion rate (71%).
The two main concerns for Lopez are that he needs volume to compile fantasy value and potential batting average regression thanks to a .337 BABIP, his highest over the past three seasons. That said, Lopez can contribute in five categories, as he hits toward the top third of the Marlins lineup. If we regress Lopez’s batting average, he might be more like a $15 player than a $25+ player.
Pete Crow-Armstrong, OF, Cubs
12-Team Projected Value: $21.20 (32.9 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $48.06
The 2027 1.01 in fantasy drafts replicated and surpassed his 2025 breakout season. Crow-Armstrong is the frontrunner in NL MVP, and is shwoing 40/40 potential. After never having an OBP above .300, Crow-Armstrong is walking significantly more this season. That’s partly because Crow-Armstrong is being more patient, swinging (49.6%) and chasing (33.8%) less often.
For context, Crow-Armstrong has a career swing rate of 55.2% with a 37.8% chase rate. The more patient approach coincides with fewer whiffs, as Crow-Armstrong lowered his swinging-strike rate to a career-low of 12.1%. That gives Crow-Armstrong a higher floor and ceiling. Furthermore, Crow-Armstrong’s bat speed spiked to 75 mph, nearly 2 mph harder than his career average. He pulls the ball even more, with a 34% pulled air rate while consistently barreling the ball (8.1%).
Many drafters were worried about the batting average risks with Crow-Armstrong, especially with his historically aggressive plate approach. But as those skills are changing this season, we’re banking on it sticking around, given the wide gap of over $10 earned between PCA and the second-best hitter this season.
Sal Stewart, 1B/3B, Reds
12-Team Projected Value: $4.29 (161.87 ADP)
12-Team Earned Value: $30.85
Stewart exceeded expectations, as many projection systems had him at 18-20 home runs and single-digit steals. He has 55 barrels with an 8.5% barrel rate per plate appearance. Though Stewart doesn’t have high-end bat speed (72.1 mph), his all-field power comes from consistently hitting the launch-angle sweet spot (35.4%), ranking in the 63rd percentile.
Stewart has a 12% stolen-base opportunity rate with below-average speed (29th percentile). We discussed how Stewart fares in stolen bases relative to his speed during an in-season rookie check-in. Among qualified hitters, Stewart is tied for 61st in the Weighted Stolen Base metric (0.0) and 124th in the Statcast baserunning above-average metrics out of 136 players. Once we get past the top 50 in Weighted Stolen Bases (wSB) with a Speed Score (Spd) under 4.0, most players have below-average speed. Stewart was in the top 50 in wSB, but he fell out. Inside the top 50 in wSB, the hitters with a Speed Score below 4.5 are Freddie Freeman, Michael Harris II, Ezequiel Tovar, Marcus Semien, Mike Trout, and Josh Naylor.
Stewart is still young, so 12-15 stolen bases could be a regular part of his fantasy profile. He’ll need to be efficient to reach those marks. Speaking of Freeman, Stewart could be a discounted version of him. He won’t have the elite batting average of .300 or higher, though we’ll take .260 to .270 for next season.
Corbin writes for RotoGraphs, focusing on deep dives into baseball advanced metrics. He won two Fantasy Sports Writers Association awards in 2022 and 2023. Corbin also contributes to Yahoo Fantasy. You can find him on X @corbin_young21

