Early ADP Observations: Third Basemen
- Credit: Jay Biggerstaff-Imagn Images
With the 2026 season behind us, it’s never too early to begin preparing for the new fantasy baseball season. Steamer released its initial projections for 2027; Jason R.R. Martinez’s FanGraphs Depth Charts (FGDC) followed with its projections, and NFBC released 2027 ADP based on completed drafts. I’m particularly fond of FGDC because Jason integrates playing time projections with Steamer, and eventually ZiPS when those are released. Through Tuesday, November 17, 33 drafts have been completed, including 12-team NFBC 50s, 15-team Gladiators, and 15-team Draft Champions (DCs), which is a 50-round draft-and-hold roto contest.
This series will review early ADP data in paid roto leagues, by position. The goal is two-fold: to identify draft trends within positions relating to the entire player pool and to highlight specific players who might be over- or under-valued by the early draft market. Thirteen of the 33 completed drafts are Draft Champions, and that is the ADP referenced in this series.
Last draft season, third base was arguably the shallowest fantasy position, along with second base. There were only 11 third basemen in the top 200 ADP and many of them were massive busts, including Austin Riley (ADP 57), Maikel Garcia (62), Eugenio Suárez (114), Matt Chapman (175), and Noelvi Marte (176). Per our Player Rater, several of the highest-earning third basemen were drafted late or not at all — Nolan Arenado, Kazuma Okamato, Max Muncy and Isaac Paredes all finished among the top 10 at the position. Two among the top 10 were rookies who earned 3B eligibility in-season: Sal Stewart (3B3) and Kevin McGonigle (3B5). Jazz Chisholm Jr. lost his eligibility and is now a second basemen only. Similar to last season when there were six third basemen in the top 60 followed by a huge tier drop-off, this season there are five and then a big tier drop-off. It’s been quite the fall from grace for the position, last rising to prominence in 2023, when nearly 20% of the top 75 hitters had third base eligibility. The hot corner isn’t so hot anymore. If we’re not specifically targeting an early bat there, we’ll have to perform our due diligence on the middle- and late-round alternatives.
Below are the top 12 third basemen ranked by ADP through 13 NFBC DC drafts:
| ADP RANK | PLAYER | POSITION | TEAM | ADP |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Junior Caminero | 3B | TB | 6.9 |
| – | tier break | – | – | – |
| 2 | José Ramírez | 3B | CLE | 18.9 |
| 3 | Sal Stewart | 3B, 1B | CIN | 23.8 |
| 4 | Miguel Vargas | 1B, 3B | CWS | 29.3 |
| – | tier break | – | – | – |
| 5 | Kevin McGonigle | 3B, SS | DET | 44.5 |
| – | tier break | – | – | – |
| 6 | Zack Gelof | 3B, OF | ATH | 106.9 |
| 7 | Manny Machado | 3B | SD | 113.8 |
| 8 | Alex Bregman | 3B | CHC | 116.5 |
| – | tier break | – | – | – |
| 9 | Kazuma Okamoto | 3B | TOR | 149.9 |
| 10 | Bryson Stott | 3B, 2B | PHI | 155.5 |
| 11 | Maikel Garcia | 3B | KC | 162.5 |
| 12 | Bo Bichette | 3B, SS | NYM | 164.9 |
A Tier of His Own
Junior Caminero isn’t just the highest projected third baseman, he is currently the top-ranked player on both FGDC and Steamer, per the Auction Calculator using NFBC settings:
| Player | $ (FGDC) | Player | $ (Steamer) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Junior Caminero | $62.2 | _ | Junior Caminero | $63.8 |
| Bobby Witt Jr. | $60.4 | _ | Pete Crow-Armstrong | $58.3 |
| Pete Crow-Armstrong | $55.0 | _ | Shohei Ohtani | $57.2 |
| Juan Soto | $53.7 | _ | James Wood | $56.9 |
| Elly De La Cruz | $51.6 | _ | Bobby Witt Jr. | $55.2 |
The 23-year-old slugger is the only player to hit 40 HR and 100 RBI in each of the last two seasons. In 2026, Caminero boasted the league’s best average bat speed (79 mph) and ranked among the top 11% of qualified hitters in average exit velocity (92.7 mph), hard-hit rate (49.6%), barrel rate (13.1%), slugging percentage (.530), expected slugging percentage (.500), and isolated power (.259). He raised his walk rate considerably — from 6.3% in 2025 to 11.3% in 2026 — and has maintained a sub-20% strikeout rate over his first two full seasons in the Majors. Despite the support of early projection models, Caminero is not a top-five consensus fantasy pick because he doesn’t contribute positively in stolen bases like Crow-Armstrong, Ohtani, Witt Jr., De La Cruz, and Fernando Tatis Jr. do. Managers starting with Caminero should feel confident about their power/average category base, but need to set plans in advance to attack the stolen base category.
Cornerstones + Rookie Stud
This mini-tier of second and third-round studs consists of veteran José Ramírez and two dual-eligible corner infielders who were discussed in the First Basemen article. Stewart and Vargas are both reasonably priced, though I’ll be apprehensive of Stewart in the ADP 20-30 range if De La Cruz is dealt before the season. Vargas has a wide pick range in Draft Champions, going as high as 18th overall and a max pick of 41. Ramírez’s results were considerably impacted by a left hamate bone fracture in mid-June that kept him out of the lineup for nearly six weeks. In the 314 plate appearances before the injury, Ramírez sported a .179 ISO with 10 home runs; after the injury, the ISO was down to .073 and he hit just two homers in 230 PA. We shouldn’t count on another 30-HR season from a fully-healed JRam, but it’s certainly possible, and the 22-25 HR range from early models is more than reasonable.
Ramírez was among the stolen base leaders before the injury, swiping 24 on 26 attempts in 72 games, right behind Witt (26) and Nasim Nuñez (24). He ran slightly less after the All-Star break (13-of-15 in 52 games), but was on-pace for 50-plus, which would have topped his career high of 44 from 2025. Ramírez has always been a top fantasy producer despite mediocre career power metrics (88.8 EV, 6.6% BRL, 36.5% HH) and though many predicted power regression before last year, we didn’t end up with a proper 2026 data set because of the wrist injury. I’m comfortable with JRam as a second-rounder and would be ecstatic to start a 15-team draft with a SP1 (Jacob Misiorowski, Tarik Skubal, Cam Schlittler) + Ramírez combo.
Kevin McGonigle had an excellent season, posting a roto stat line of 97-18-72-12-.278 and earning the AL Rookie of the Year award on 28-of-30 first-place votes. One notable negative was his base-stealing: just one swipe on four attempts in 63 post-All-Star break contests after successfully swiping all 11 attempts before the break. Also, he was a slightly worse hitter against lefties (88 wRC+, 0.55 BB/K, .093 ISO) than against righties (146, 1.22, .177). His batting eye and plate discipline was quite impressive for a prospect who had never taken a single at-bat in Triple-A. McGonigle drew 95 walks (13.4%) against 100 strikeouts (14.1%). That 0.95 walks-to-strikeouts ratio ranked fifth behind plate maestros Luis Arraez (1.39), Steven Kwan (1.15), Geraldo Perdomo (1.12) and Juan Soto (1.01). It will be interesting to see how other models will project him. He is very likely to provide a stable floor (85-15-65-10-.265), but offensive context is important. RosterResource currently projects Hao-Yu Lee and Colt Keith as the 2-3 hitters on Opening Day. That’s several months away and there’s much on tap for the Tigers’ front office to provide sufficient lineup depth around McGonigle and the other parts of the core, namely Riley Greene, Dillon Dingler, and rising star, Max Clark.
Veterans & Various Category Targets
Let’s group these next two tiers together. There’s Zack Gelof, Manny Machado, and Alex Bregman in the 100-120 ADP range, and the quartet of Kazuma Okamoto, Bryson Stott, Maikel Garcia, and Bo Bichette in the ninth and 10th round of 15-teamers (12th and 13th round of 12-teamers).
| Player | PA | R | HR | RBI | SB | AVG | $ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Zack Gelof | 435 | 76 | 22 | 55 | 16 | 0.256 | $10.5 |
| Manny Machado | 677 | 82 | 30 | 91 | 5 | 0.217 | $11.9 |
| Alex Bregman | 702 | 92 | 28 | 93 | 3 | 0.265 | $20.1 |
It’s unwise to simply prorate stats, but it sure is fun to imagine what Gelof’s 5×5 line and final dollar value would look like compared to Machado’s and Bregman’s if Gelof had similar plate appearances. The 76 runs in 435 PA is a staggering rate and the 22 dingers are impressive. Perhaps he would have batted closer to his .236 xBA. Then again, he did a lot of his damage without key members of “the band” for long stretches (Brent Rooker, Shea Langeliers, Nick Kurtz, Tyler Soderstrom). He was also quite versatile, earning starts at (mostly) third base, second base, all three outfield positions, and as a DH. Gelof also started at least seven games in every lineup slot, and after his purported negligent stadium maintenance injury, he was primarily in the 2-5 spots. He flashed 200+ ISOs against both lefties and righties and remarkably kept his strikeout rate under 25 percent. Gelof is clearly the upside pick of this trio, especially with the speed, home park boost, and the assumption that key members of the offense will be healthy for the start of the season.
Bregman is one of those perennially boring selections who is rarely drafted too far ahead of his ADP. Managers who drafted him for his productive first season in the National League were pleasantly rewarded; especially in context of the sea of busts at the position. He was among the plate appearance leaders, maintained his typically strong plate discipline (10.8% BB, 14.5% K) and pull-happy tendencies (49.2%), which resulted in a massive variance between his .464 SLG and and .391 xSLG. Bregman was particularly awesome after the All-Star break, slashing .303/.384/.626 with 19 homers in 238 plate appearances.
Machado drafters didn’t drop him, but boy were they tempted to. Those first three months was a brutal stretch as he annihilated folks in batting average, mustering a paltry .189 in 344 PA through the end of June. His R-HR-RBI (40-16-46) were on normal Manny pace and his underlying metrics didn’t sound off major alarms. He kept it going in the second half (42-14-45 in 333 PA) and batted .247. The end result was .217 (.243 xBA) and Steamer projects a .249 average in 2027. I’ll take the over.
Light on power after your first 10 picks and still need a third baseman? Okamoto may be your guy. He might even improve on last season’s .232 average, but not by a lot unless he finds a way to curb the Ks like he did early in his playing career, in Japan. The Blue Jays may sign someone like Seiya Suzuki to help bolster the offense.
Stott is the quintessential “I need to boost my bags” guy in this range. His production is fairly consistent year-to-year — a 70-12-70-.250 guy who can steal 25-35 bags.
Bichette joins Bryan Reynolds as the spokesmen for the B Boring Club. Hey, there’s value in high floor/low ceiling veterans who can provide their projectable counting categories, especially if it comes with a batting average in the range of his career .288 mark. He should be even more comfortable in his second season in The Big Apple, but it’s impossible to know if Bichette will be more a .250 guy than .300 guy. Steamer math ironically splits that difference, projecting .276.
[Editor’s note: The Maikel Garcia trade news broke immediately after this was published; look for an update to this analysis later today] Maikel Garcia’s ADP dropped by more than double last year’s price. He stands out as a undervalued target at this price and I am hopeful that the next-level breakout some of us expected from him last season, comes to fruition in 2027. His price will quickly rise once drafters realize that the early draft market his mispriced him.
The Targets
- Draft Junior Caminero if you draw the 6th or 7th and have stolen base acquisition plan ready before the draft.
- Have zero trepidation about taking José Ramírez around or even before his ADP. He’s not done yet.
- Gamble on the possibility that Zack Gelof has another level of production that can reasonably be attained.
- Don’t look the gift horse in its mouth if Manny Machado or Alex Bregman are still hanging on the draft board, one round past his ADP. Draft them.
- Draft Maikel Garcia before his market price escalates.
There are many intriguing third basemen in the 160-360 ADP range, and I plan to tackle them another time, possibly in the new year. There are many interesting names of note and I look forward to taking that roto deep dive to help uncover the gems and the landmines.
Vlad writes for RotoGraphs and is the head of fantasy baseball content at FTN Fantasy. He is a Tout Wars Expert League champ, member of the CDM Fantasy Sports Hall of Fame and has been nominated for FSWA writing awards six times. Vlad has been playing fantasy baseball since 1995, winning 42 NFBC leagues since 2012 and ranking in the top percentile in NFBC’s Online Championship contest (33% win rate, 52% cash rate; 64 leagues). Much to the chagrin of his colleagues and most baseball aficionados, Vlad is a lifelong Dodgers fan who claims his first gut call at age 9 was Kirk Gibson’s 1988 World Series home run. You can follow him on X and BlueSky @RotoGut.


As much as I would have liked to see if Nolan Arenado might have found his way back onto a 3B list, he probably is still a bit of a hard sell over some of the younger guys in the last tier. Getting him as a backup to pair with those last tier guys might not be a bad idea, though, just in case.
I hope the McConigle write up was tongue-in-cheek bc this is the difference between 2026 Jake Bauers and 2026 Cam Smith:
This is an outstanding summary of the 3rd base landscape heading into 2027. Beautifully written, Vlad!
Garcia’s picture already outdated.