2026 Ottoneu Arbitration Allocation Results – Team Distribution

After finishing up yesterday’s article, I realized I had more questions to ask and more data to dig into. So we are back for day two.

Today, we are going to dig into team questions: what is the distribution of dollars received by teams? Does that distribution vary by standings spot? And lastly, we’ll dig into the question of whether managers allocate primarily to teams or primarily to players.

To start, while the average team received $25 in allocations (a simple mathematical fact when every team has $25 to distribute the distributions are a zero-sum game), the median received is $26. That isn’t a massive difference, but it does mean that more teams were hit with an above-average amount of arbitration, pushing the median up, while a smaller number of teams were hit with very few dollars. This is easier to see in graphical form:

As you can see, the bulk of that graph lives between $23 and $32. There were teams (4.3% of our sample) that received the max $33 from their competition, while 82 teams (4.4%) received $15 or less. Only two teams received the minimum $11, and only 16 received $13 or less.

Now, there is a caveat here, in that I limited the data to 12-team leagues where all teams completed their allocations. But at least in this sample, the message here is that basically every team – all but two! – have at least one player on whom  it is worth allocating an extra buck or two.

There is another interesting pattern when you compare allocations vs. final 2026 standings. Teams that finished first received $30.66 on average. No other standings place was over $30. Team’s that finished 12th received $19.32 on average and only one other standings place (11th) was under $20. Every single spot in the standings received less than the spot above it.

This plot shows that – you can see the mean (the red diamond) going down position by position. This graph, though, also shows the range of allocation totals for each spot, and there are two things that standout to me:

  • The range increases as we move down the standings. The higher a team finished in 2026, the more it receives in arbitration, on average, and the more concentrated it is. There are very few outliers at the top – every team in every league is hitting the first (and second, and third, for that matter) place team with a lot of arbitration.
  • While the mean goes down as you move down the standings, the increased range means that some “bad” (last place) teams still got hit with $30+ in arbitration. To very poorly steal from and paraphrase Leo Tolstoy, all teams near the top of the standings are alike (in that they deserve to get a lot of arbitration); each team near the bottom ended up there in its own way (and therefore might just be bad or might be on the rebound with interesting talent to target in arbitration despite the standings).

Getting specific, the correlation between place in the standings and dollars received in arbitration is -.696. That is a rather highly negative correlation (negative because as standings spot goes “up” from 1 to 2 to 3 and on to 12, dollars allocated go down from over $30 to under $20). It implies that where a team finished in the 2026 standings explains nearly 50% (ok, 48.4%) of how much money is allocated to that team.

Now, it is important to note that this does not mean first place teams are allocated to because they are first place teams. Correlation does not imply causation. It could be that being a first place team means you are more likely to have good, undervalued players and having good, undervalued drives allocations. But there is a very clear, very strong relationship between where you finished in 2026 and how hard arbitration hit you.

That isn’t the only explanatory factor though. By using pre-arbitration rosters and the projections in Justin Vibber’s latest Surplus Calculator, I attached a salary and a projected 2027 dollar value to each player. This let me look at the impact of total team surplus and total team value on how much money is allocated to a team.

As noted above, the R2 for standings on dollars allocated to a team is .484. Creating a model that incorporates both value and surplus (how much is a team worth based on the values in Surplus Calculator and how much more is the team worth than it costs?) increases the R2 to .565. That doesn’t move the needle as much as standings alone, but it isn’t a small change.

We can get another small boost in the explanatory power of the model by adding in a “top-20 surplus” count – how many players on a given roster are top-20 surplus assets in that league. That increases the R2 to .619 and if we add a variable looking at the interaction between top-20 surplus count and standings, the R2 increases to .633, another small gain.

The interaction variable,  factor helps to explain something we saw earlier: the much wider range of arbitration outcomes for teams that finished lower in the standings. For teams that did well in 2026, having particularly high-surplus players on the roster didn’t matter much. For each top-20 surplus player a first place team has on their roster, they could expect to get about $0.48 in additional arbitration.

But for teams lower in the standings, having elite surplus assets matters a lot. Each top-20 surplus player on a last place team adds about $1.89 to the team’s arbitration total. And remember, that is separate from the effect of having high value and high surplus across the roster.

The interesting finding here, though, is that team success is the bigger factor in how much a team receives. We can see that in the R2 above, but you can also see it if you compare high-performing teams with limited high-surplus targets to low-perforing teams with multiple high-value targets.

Allocations by Standings vs. Top-20 Surplus Contracts
Top-20 Surplus Assets First Place Team Fifth Place Team Last Place Team
1 $29.20 $25.90 $19.40
2 $30.80 $27.50 $21.50
3 $31.00 $28.20 $22.00
4 $31.90 $27.40 $27.80
5+ $32.00 $31.10 $25.00

There is no number of top-20 surplus players a last place team can have to drive average arbitration as high as a first place team, even if that first place team lacks obvious targets. It’s nearly impossible to even drive it as high as a  fifth place team – those bottom two cells in the “last place” column account for seven teams, total, across 154 leagues. This pattern holds all the way up to 9th place teams. A 9th place team with 5+ top-20 surplus assets received $26.0 on average, still less than a 3rd place team with one such asset ($28.0) and barely more than a 4th place or 5th place team with one such asset ($25.8 and $25.9, respectively).

One note on this – the R2 for projected roster value (how much are the players on the roster worth, regardless of surplus) was .211, while the R2 for roster surplus was .172. Teams were hit harder in arbitration for overall value than they were for surplus value.

There is a lot there, so let me try to summarize:

  • Nearly half of how much money a team receives in arbitration can be explained by where they finished in the standings.
  • Total team surplus and total team value also have a real impact and having one or more particularly high surplus players also drives up arbitration, but not enough to make up for the standings effect.
  • Teams that finish in the top got hammered in arbitration, almost regardless of their roster makeup. Going from one top-20 surplus asset to four would increase a first place team from $29.2 in arbitration to $31.9. The same generally holds for 2nd place ($28.7-$30.9) and 3rd place ($28.0-$30.5).
  • Teams that finish near the bottom, however, saw wide ranges in allocations, largely dependent on whether they had elite assets worth allocating to.

I also wondered about how allocations were impacted by the final standings spot of the team making the allocation. It turns out – maybe not surprisingly – that there isn’t a ton to see here. But there isn’t nothing.

Teams in the top half of the standings allocated slightly more money to other top teams than teams in the bottom of the standings did. First place teams allocated

Comparison of Allocations by Standings
Final 2026 Standings Rank From 1st Place From 2nd Place From 11th Place From 12th Place
1 N/A $2.84 $2.73 $2.70
2 $2.77 N/A $2.57 $2.53
3 $2.72 $2.75 $2.59 $2.51
4 $2.57 $2.60 $2.47 $2.37
5 $2.41 $2.52 $2.33 $2.27
6 $2.42 $2.30 $2.25 $2.20
7 $2.25 $2.25 $2.20 $2.16
8 $2.19 $2.08 $2.16 $2.11
9 $2.08 $2.01 $1.96 $2.18
10 $2.07 $2.10 $1.92 $2.10
11 $1.72 $1.91 N/A $1.86
12 $1.77 $1.63 $1.79 N/A

I reviewed this table for all 144 combinations of allocating and receiving team, but simplified it here to show the pattern. You can see here that second place teams allocated $2.84 to the team that beat them, while the bottom two teams allocated just $2.73 and $2.70 to the league winners. First place teams allocated $2.77 to their biggest competition; cellar dwellers allocated just $2.57 and $2.53 to second place.

Higher ranked teams are also ever-so-slightly more likely to hand out a $3 allocation to a team or a $1 allocation to a team, than lower ranked teams. The difference is very small. First place teams handed out $1 allocations 22.6% of the time, compared to 19.3% for last place teams; $2 allocations 27.5% of the time, compared to 34.2% of the time for last place teams; and $3 allocations 49.9% of the time, compared to 46.5% of the time for last place teams.

Lastly, higher ranked teams spread allocations across more players. Those $3 allocations they give out so readily are being given to more teams but not to more players. When first place teams gave an opponent a $3 allocation, they concentrated that on a single player just 33.5% of the time; last place teams did it 41.7% of the time. This is another small effect, but it contributes to another difference between top and bottom teams: top teams spread the wealth more.

Spread of Allocations by Standings
Rank Players Allocated To
1 18.17
2 18.88
3 18.42
4 18.35
5 18.63
6 17.93
7 17.75
8 17.92
9 17.94
10 17.87
11 17.49
12 17.18

The top five teams all spread their allocations, on average, across more than 18 player; the bottom seven across less than 18 players. Again, the effect is not huge but it does exist.

All of these effects, added up, do paint a picture of what higher ranked teams do:

  • They spread allocations across more players
  • They hit more teams, but fewer players, with full $3 allocations
  • They give more money to other top teams

What this means is in the eye of the beholder. If you believe the teams that finished higher in the standings are likely to be more effective, more seasoned managers who are generally better at playing the game, there is some evidence here that those three things are “smart” things to do. But it is equally fair to say that teams at the top are more focused on the here-and-now (they just won or got close to it and want to win again or get over the top next year) and are acting in accordance with that.

Putting that all together, we have some interesting findings, I think.

  1. Teams that succeed get hit hard in arbitration. Shocking.
  2. Having a lot of team value and having particularly high surplus players will also attract more arbitration dollars your way. But not as much as success will.
  3. The most successful teams based on 2026 standings put more arbitration on other successful teams and spread that arbitration across more players, on average.

There are other interesting analyses to consider, but those will have to wait for another day.

 

 

 





A long-time fantasy baseball veteran and one of the creators of ottoneu, Chad Young's is the Managing Editor for RotoGraphs, and can be heard on the Keep or Kut Podcast. You can follow him on Bluesky @chadyoung.bsky.social.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted