Deep Mixed Wire: Trevor Bauer, Corey Dickerson

When I’m determining what I’m going to spend on players during my leagues’ FAAB runs, I think about the long term. We all do, right? In my experience, however, most fantasy players tend to base their bids on the here and now: The players on hot streaks fetch the most dollars. The exceptions include recently named closers and promoted prospects of great esteem, among others, but you get the idea.

I’ll talk more about FAAB strategy in future columns, I’m sure, but I wanted to plant the seed: Bid according to what kind of returns you figure to receive from the player for the rest of the season, regardless of recent performance. A player’s latest feats can factor in a little, sure, especially if characteristics of them indicate skills growth. In the latter instance, though, you’re already wisely influenced by possible long-term gains.

One of the two players I list here Jason Collette and I discussed in Sunday’s podcast, so I’m a little ashamed that I’m dropping his name in this column. But only a little, because both of these cats:

1)      are interesting players, at worst, for mixed leaguers;

2)      provide examples that will help me to discuss aspects of FAAB strategy.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed.
We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member.
1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other.
2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off.
3. Dark mode and Classic mode!
4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them.
5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects.
6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.)
7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only.
8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO.
9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members.
10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features!
We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it.

SP Trevor Bauer, Cleveland Indians

Ownership: ESPN 0.5% | Yahoo! 6% | CBS 30%

He’s arguably the Tribe’s top pitching prospect. When this season is finished, the argument may look quite silly in retrospect. As many know, Bauer was one of the game’s top-rated talents just a couple of years ago, but control problems and makeup concerns, among other things, dropped his stock considerably. “Control problems” is putting it mildly, really, at least when it comes to his limited major league exposure.

The organization has invested a lot of time and effort in Bauer’s development. This past winter saw the right-hander consolidate the mechanical changes that Cleveland has tried to instill and his natural delivery. The spring training results were no good, but his first four regular season starts have been eye-opening. He’s fanned 21 and walked only six in 18 2/3 innings (three starts), yielding only 13 hits and two runs, for Triple-A Columbus. He made a spot start for the Indians on April 9, and in it he allowed four hits, two runs (one earned) and two walks, with eight K’s, in six frames against the San Diego Padres.

Bauer, 23, is a pitcher of remarkable intellect, particularly when it comes to his craft. The April struggles of both Carlos Carrasco and Danny Salazar have already forced the club to answer questions about their places in the rotation. If either of their stumbles last into May, then it can’t be long before Cleveland makes a change.

Bauer’s potential return is immense. His past failings and his roster status should keep his price down, but I wouldn’t wait. I scooped him up in Tout Wars (15-team mixed league) and had to pay $4 ($100 budget with a Vickrey bidding system) only because one other person bid on him (for $3, naturally). This is a 12-team mixed league stash, too, in my book.

OF Corey Dickerson, Colorado Rockies

Ownership: ESPN 0.7% | Yahoo! 4% | CBS 13%

We must have interest any time a position player in Colorado gains playing time. We don’t have to like or want the player, but we have to investigate. Of course, most fantasy owners are familiar enough with Dickerson because he was one of 37 outfielders in competition for the team’s starting spot in center field this past spring training.

Dickerson, 25 in a month, is the same intriguing hitter who for some warranted a late-round flier in mixed leagues this past March. He can hit for a quality average, belt 15 or so homers and swipe roughly the same number of bases if he plays a full season. In his first start after Michael Cuddyer’s placement on the disabled list for a strained hamstring, on Monday, Dickerson went yard for one of his three hits and thieved a base.

We know that Dickerson’s foray into fantasy relevance is in all likelihood going to be short-lived. He’ll probably platoon with Brandon Barnes in right until Cuddyer returns. It appears that Charlie Blackmon has sold his soul in exchange for Ted Williams’ powers, so the job is his for the foreseeable future.

But Dickerson is the kind of minimum-bid add in a mixed league about which you can feel good, as opposed to the one of several bucks it may have taken to land David Murphy. Similar type of production, probably similar shelf lives. Come on, we’ve seen the Tribe’s right-fiend platooner have good stretches for a month or six weeks. Is there reason to expect more?

Besides, Cuddyer could have a setback. Carlos Gonzalez is never that far from a DL stint. Justin Morneau is healthy, but are we certain that’ll last? Can we be sure that Blackmon’s success will? There are multiple ways that Dickerson may maintain significance, and you would have saved some dough in the process if any of them comes about.

We know you play in all sorts of leagues. So to help you fine-tune the analysis you’d like to read, we’ve added three tags to the categories on the right: Roto, Head to Head, and Daily Fantasy Update. Use these to get the information that is most relevant to your leagues!





Nicholas Minnix oversaw baseball content for six years at KFFL, where he held the loose title of Managing Editor for seven and a half before he joined FanGraphs. He played in both Tout Wars and LABR from 2010 through 2014. Follow him on Twitter @NicholasMinnix.

42 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Ben Suissa
12 years ago

how can do different websites vary so much in ownership%? 30 percent for CBS but less than 1% for espn? explain

Phil McCracken
12 years ago

ESPN both for fantasy and sports in general is geared towards mouthbreathers.

Table
12 years ago

ESPN probably has the best NBA coverage

buddyglass
12 years ago
Reply to  Ben Suissa

I’ve noticed that ESPN ownership rates for starting pitchers seem to be way lower than what I’d expect. I play in a 12-team mixed league at ESPN and we always end up drafting way more starters than the ownership rates would project. Plenty of sub-5% SPs end up being drafted whereas 20%+ hitters aren’t taken.

I suspect it *may* be because some ESPN league options require you to carry middle relievers, or some high-ish number of relief pitchers. That would cause the ownership rates of “fringe” SPs to be low. My league has no such requirement; you get 9 pitcher slots and 3 bench slots and you can put whatever kind of pitcher into them you want. So most teams tend to carry zero middle relievers, 2-4 closers and the rest of their slots (plus the bench slots) are filled up with starters.

buddyglass
12 years ago
Reply to  buddyglass

@Nicholas: Yeah, the league I’m in doesn’t use default settings. We have no whole-season GS cap. Instead, we have an 80 IP weekly cap. To me, this makes non-closer RPs more or less worthless. Even a fringe SP, e.g. Nate Eovaldi, Drew Hutchinson, Jon Niese, etc., is more valuable than the best non-closer RP.

RCMember since 2016
12 years ago

“But Blackmon is the kind of minimum-bid add in a mixed league about which you can feel good, as opposed to the one of several bucks it may have taken to land David Murphy.”

Did you mean to say Dickerson instead of Blackmon here?

Cameron Dunlop
12 years ago

Just so you catch the mistake…Bauer never pitched for Triple-A Indianapolis, as they are the Major League Pirates Triple-A affiliate. He pitched for Triple-A Columbus, the clippers

Adam
12 years ago

I started Dickerson over Mike Olt in the utility spot in my 20-team mixed league last night. Dickerson didn’t play. Olt hit a three-run homer 🙁

How to know when he’ll actually play?

Andrew
12 years ago
Reply to  Adam

fantasyalarm.com

They have a daily MLB lineups page. Also follow on twitter, very helpful to fantasy players!

Satoshi Nakamoto
12 years ago
Reply to  Andrew

Wow! Awesome. Now I don’t have to set my phone to buzz 15 minutes before each set of games start.

Adam
12 years ago

Thank you, both Andrew and Nicholas, for these resources

centerfield ballhawk
12 years ago
Reply to  Adam

Bumgarner was on the mound last night. Dickerson bats left handed. Watch and see what happens on Friday when Dickerson faces Robbie Erlin. It might be a straight platoon in right field until Cuddyer returns from the DL>

Andrew
12 years ago

Nick, how sustainable to you feel Bauer’s control/command is? I heard he had stopped moving around on the rubber and focused on one spot. His velocity is back, has 3 plus pitches and if is attacking the zone, 10 team mixed relevant correct? Can you rank Bauer, Eovaldi and Wily Peralta for ROS?

Thanks!

Satoshi Nakamoto
12 years ago

I grabbed Dickerson the moment I saw Cuddyear landed on the DL.
Cargo has knee tendinitis and has been scuffling for about 5 games.
Morneau is one smack to the head away from being forced into retirement due to concussion issues. The dude has enough money he’s not gonna risk his well being.

*** And look at the Rockies schedule for May and June! So many juicy matchups versus bad pitching staffs, at great hitters parks both away and of course in Coors field.

Any and all Rockies hitters are gonna explode. Buy now while you can.

Kaline's Ghost
12 years ago

Is Bauer the better stash than Gausman at this point?

chrisMember since 2026
12 years ago

Any chance in the future we could see Ottoneu ownership % as well?

pj
12 years ago

Been adding both in my leagues over past couple weeks. Really think Bauer will come up next week and Dickerson should be productive when he plays.

stuck in a slump
12 years ago

Ok, so I have Dickerson on my team, but I put him on the NA list when he was optioned. Now I can’t figure out who to drop to get him back in my lineup. I’m thinking Withrow, but he’s been so good for my rate stats and K’s. Otherwise I’d have to drop Almonte. Is it worth it to drop one of them? No one seems interested in Almonte or Dickerson as part of a trade.

Emcee Peepants
12 years ago

Agreed, I like Almonte as well and owned him for a little while, but his 34.4% K rate(!), .270 wOBA, and 68 wRC+ do not make him worth owning right now. I would pick up Dickerson if I could, he should be able to beat those numbers if even in a limited number of ABs.

Bob the Dog
12 years ago

I took the late-round flier ion Dickerson n my 14-team mixed – then when he was sent down I replaced him with Almonte. Now he’s back, I’ve dropped Almonte and picked him back up.

I’m a bit concerned about the platoon, but Almonte has really cooled off and his average was starting to kill me. And Cargo’s injury worries should help firm up more playing time for Dicko.

stuck in a slump
12 years ago
Reply to  Bob the Dog

Thanks for the advice you guys. Perhaps I should also mention that this is a near dynasty level keeper league. So even if Almonte is flailing now, do you think that he could prove worthwhile to hang on to?

Mario Mendoza
12 years ago

Is the humidor broken or something? It looks like the old rule of drafting all COL hitters is back in full force.

pj
12 years ago
Reply to  Mario Mendoza

Look at the game today. 5 HRs.

Satoshi Nakamoto
12 years ago

Dickerson getting benched vs Lefties.
Oh well it sounded like a good idea to grab him.
Waiver fodder…

mike
12 years ago

what do you think we can realistically expect from Polanco when he gets the call? he’s absolutely destroying AAA pitching at the moment albeit in a very small sample size. Is he worth a stash now?

Ralph
11 years ago

Would love to hear authors opinion now!

Ralph
11 years ago

Dickerson

Ralph
11 years ago

Thanks! I would like to see that k rate drop a lefties too.