Chad Young’s Ten Bold Predictions for 2013
We’ve started bold prediction week for 2013, and it sounds like the readers really want BOLD predictions. Of course there is always a trade-off – don’t go bold enough, and you are just stating what we already know; go too bold and you will likely be wrong and your predictions will have no fantasy value.
But the fans want bold and I like to please the fans, so I am going to go big here. Does that mean I will likely fall short of the four predictions I made last year that were either right or at least close to right? Probably. But I’m swinging for the fences anyway.
1) Ike Davis will be top five in baseball in HR. Last year I said Ike would finish top five in the NL and sure enough he tied for fifth. But when you add in the AL, his 32 bombs sat tied for 14th. But he’s healthy, he’ll avoid that slow start, and he’ll crack the overall top five this year.
2) Justin Masterson will look more like an ace than a guy ROOGY.. In 2011, Masterson posted a 3.28 FIP and a nearly matching 3.21 ERA. In 2012, the wheels fell off. His K% barely budged, but the walks increased, the HR increased, and his long-standing troubles with lefties ballooned the ERA to nearly 5.00 with a FIP north of 4.00. Will he suddenly challenge a fellow Justin for the title of best pitcher in the AL Central (or AL period)? No, but the owners who buy low on him will be pleasantly surprised when the walk rate comes back down, the ball stays in the yard, and Masterson becomes the go-to guy the Indians need.
3) Dustin Ackley goes 20-15. I originally planned to predict him at 15-15, which seemed bold enough for a guy who has never reached either benchmark before. But a few years ago, Ackley seemed destined for perennial 15-15 seasons, so why not take a bigger stand? With the fences coming in at Safeco and Ackley healthy going into the season, I think the 20 HR is pretty straight-forward. And if he reaches base enough, he could get to 15 SB for the first time, too.
4) The most valuable SP in a deep Braves rotation will be Mike Minor. Tim Hudson is the nominal ace, Julio Teheran has all the spring buzz, Kris Medlen is coming off a stellar second half, but Minor will best them all (and Paul Maholm and half a season of Brandon Beachy).
5) Josh Hamilton doesn’t get past HR #25. Thrice in his career Hamilton has crossed 130 games played and all three times he has also crossed the 30 HR threshold. But he is 32, has had injury issues, is moving to a tougher park…I don’t think he’ll even crack 25 HR if he plays most of the season, and there is always the chance he won’t play most of the season.
6) Chris Tillman will be a top-20 AL SP. His velocity faded last year, his ERA was far healthier than his peripherals would suggest it should have been, and he had some elbow soreness that shut him down in September. Those are all good reasons why I am seeing his draft stock stay down and that I hear people tell me he will regress mightily. But if those things are related – if his elbow was impacting his velocity which hurt his peripherals – there is also good reason to think that he could break out. His velocity is up according to reports from Spring Training, and so I am buying Tillman.
7) Cory Luebke will be this year’s Kris Medlen. At mockdraftcentral.com, Luebke’s average draft position is 372, which for a 12 team league means he is the 31st guy on your roster – meaning he not only isn’t drafted but probably isn’t on your watch list. But, like Medlen, despite being all but overlooked in drafts, Luebke will take the NL by storm and post a big time second half.
8) David Freese continues his climb and hits 25 HR this year. I was prepared to make this claim about Mike Moustakas, but Eno Sarris backed Moose in his predictions, so I picked another 3B. Freese has hit 20 HR last year, after hitting 10 and four in 2011 and 2010. He was also 5th in HR and FB distance last year, according to baseballheatmaps.com, meaning the power is legit. The question for Freese is can he get more loft on the ball. His FB% has been around 26% for his career, and that is not enough to support 25 HR. But I think we’ll see him get under a few more this year.
9) Paul Konerko and Adam Dunn will combine for fewer than 55 HR. I am invested in these two in my leagues, so I hope I am wrong, but despite hitting 67 between them last year (and being closer to 70 most years since 2000) I think the two aging sluggers see a pretty precipitous drop in 2013.
10) Kenley Jansen does not get double digit saves. Everyone seems ready to predict that Jansen (who is pretty clearly the best reliever in the Dodgers pen) will take over for Brandon League before long, but I am not buying it. I think it is highly unlikely that Jansen will pitch his way INTO the closer role unless League pitches his way out of that role, and I think that League can be perfectly acceptable in ninth, and can climb up over 25 saves in 2013. If League is a serviceable closer and Jansen is lights out getting big outs when big outs are needed, regardless of inning, the Dodgers will have no cause to make a change, and I predict they won’t. I am sure Jansen will vulture a few saves here and there when League isn’t available, but he isn’t a closer and I don’t think he will become one.
A long-time fantasy baseball veteran and one of the creators of ottoneu, Chad Young's is the Managing Editor for RotoGraphs, and can be heard on the Keep or Kut Podcast. You can follow him on Bluesky @chadyoung.bsky.social.
“get passed” ? or “get past”
“League pitches he was out of that role” or “League pitches his way out of that role”?
‘Implied, Lisa… or implode?’
“Fewer” than 55 HR
Fixed, along with the two above. Embarrassing issues for a guy with a journalism degree. Thanks for the copy editing!
Last time Brandon League was a closer, he pitched his way out of the role.
Eveerything else is a great example of actually predicting somthing bold but plausibale none the less.
True, and living in Seattle I was fortunate enough to see him pitch quite a bit last year before the trade, and he was a mess. For some reason, no body was swinging and missing against him. But he corrected that in LA, which is either a fluke or a result of some change in his mechanics. The Dodgers said they wanted to fix his mechanics when they acquired him. That doesn’t mean that is what happened, but it means it might be what happened – and the guy did save 37 in 2011.
Mine: Wilin Rosario will hit 35 home runs.
Not a bad one.
Cory Luebke? Really? Coming back from Tommy John surgery? He will be lucky to make it back for the start of the 2nd half. I will chalk your bold prediction up to a crack addiction.
I do tend to agree with this comment, given the control issues that seem to come with TJS comebacks. I love Luebke … for 2014 … but I’m not confident he’ll kill it during this season.
I think the only thing that makes this bold is the 2013 part of it – I am also high on him for next year, and far more confident in him in 2014 and beyond, but I don’t think I would raise many eyebrows with that. I have him in a number of leagues, in large part to have him stashed for the future, but also because I think there is real value this year.
Top 20 SP for Tillman is beyond bold. What reason is there to have such optimism for him? Even when his velocity was higher he wasn’t posting rates that suggested he had front end potential.
I recently joined a league where I have 40 roster spots to fill, and everyone else has already drafted so I’m left with the scraps.
I picked up Nova, Evoladi, Pettitte, Maholm, Mcallister, E. Santana, Doubront and Tillman is still there for the taking and I have 5 roster spots free and over $250 in cap space…and I’ll still pass.
To be fair, I said Top 20 AL, not top 20 overall, and that is a pretty big difference. On Rotographs consensus rankings, that puts him in the Hellickson/C.J. Wilson area. And while that is still a bold prediction, I think it is totally plausible.
For what it’s worth, in your situation, picking up Maholm over Tillman doesn’t make much sense to me. We know exactly what Maholm is, and he’s a decent but unimpressive pitcher who is going to give a MLB team solid innings and an fantasy team mediocre innings. Tillman still has potential to be much more. They are 95th (Maholm) and 103rd (Tillman) in the consensus rankings, but the variability on Tillman is much higher. Assuming you are not going to be winning in 2013 with your situation, a $1 Tillman who could be a servicable fantasy pitcher for you in the future is a great value – way more useful than Maholm.
I see the point you are making, and it’s a good one. There’s no reason to pick guaranteed mediocrity over upside if your playing for next year. I completely agree with that point. But I don’t see the upside to Tillman. I see more potential that Maholm has a good april and I could sell high on that.
Bold!
Mine: Cespedes goes 40-30.
I’d like to join the fray. Nice predictions, by the way. So far I think you have the best balance of balls and feasibility, Chad.
Mike Leake finishes top 12 among NL starting pitchers and Rick Porcello finishes top 3 among AL starting pitchers while receiving votes for AL Cy Young.
How does Masterson get there? He’s only got two pitches and neither of them can get out lefties. If the word isn’t out yet, at some point you’d think folks will start wondering why the Rays completely dominate him, and realize how much of genius Maddon is.
Mine:
Jon Lester reaches 200 Ks.
Alex Gordon has 70 XBHs.
BJ Upton beats Justin Upton in more 5×5 categories (specifically Rs, HRs and SBs).
Err, typo, *80 not 70
“he isn’t a closer and I don’t think he will become one.”
He only lost his closer role because he had heart issues down the stretch. He was one of the dominant closeres in baseball last year and emerged as that the year before.He will be closer by June.
To be clear, I don’t use the term closer as some sort of overall statement on a pitcher’s ability or mentality or anything. It is just a simply factual statement that he is not, by role, a closer.
As for why he lost the role and his chances to become dominant in the role – yeah, I agree, long-term, Jansen will be a dominant closer. But there has to be a reason for the Dodgers to move him, and the fact is that if League is effective, their bullpen will be just as strong (maybe stronger) with their best RP in a relief ace role and their second best in the closer role. Switching them won’t do much good. Unless League suffers, I think it will be awfully hard for Jansen to surpass him.
All in all, these predictions have been pretty good. And I have no idea where tillman ranks in al starters…