Buy Low on Alex Gordon and Chase Headley
I’m just as guilty as anyone of feeling fed up with players, despite their pedigree. Today, I’ve got a little quick-hitter to try and provide some perspective on two well known players who are really scuffling right now. Both players could be nice little buy-low candidates, although players with name recognition always cost a little more it seems. But sometimes you have to roll the dice when you need lightning in a bottle in order to get back into contention, and that’s what these two have the potential to provide.
Over his first 40 games, Alex Gordon hit .343/.367/.535 with six home runs, 29 RBI, and 29 runs scored. He was well on his way to replicating that fantastic 2011 season and was starting to look like an excellent value pick for many of you out of the gate. But the cold reality of batted ball luck seemed to snatch him right out of cloud nine and the rest of the season has produced a .202/.313/.229 slash line. Yes, a .229 slugging percentage, that’s no typo. Over his last 128 plate appearances, Alex Gordon has three doubles, zero home runs and seven RBI.
Indeed, over his last 30 games, Gordon has had a 38 wRC+. Yeah, that’s run production which is more than 60% below league average, or there abouts. Was it just the bouncing ball? In those glorious first 40, his BABIP was .411. In the latter pile of garbage, it was .253. The wheels have come off for Gordon, and the big question is if he’s gonna find the mudders again or if we’re stuck with the training wheels from here on out. If I’m a vulture, I might be interested in this data:
| BB% | K% | BABIP | LD% | GB% | FB% | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| April | 4.6% | 22.9% | 0.395 | 20.3% | 49.4% | 30.4% |
| May | 8.1% | 17.9% | 0.398 | 24.2% | 42.9% | 33.0% |
| June | 10.5% | 18.4% | 0.192 | 30.8% | 38.5% | 30.8% |
So over the last three months, Gordon has seen his walk rate climb pretty dramatically, his strikeout rate remain fairly stable (and below career averages). His line drive rate has steadily climbed and his BABIP is simply in the toilet in June. The near .400 BABIP over the first two months wasn’t likely to be sustained, but given his hit trajectory, walk rate, and strikeout rate, I’d be betting that Gordon will pull out of his funk sometime soon. I’d be buying.
In the first half of 2012, Chase Headley hit .267/.368/.413 with 8 home runs. And then you probably remember the 23 home runs he hit from that point on, running up a .308/.386/.592 slash line.
His first half of 2013 is just barely north of putrid – .222/.327/.348 with six home runs and he’s hardly even running with just four swipes. Maybe another second half explosion is lurking?
Headley owns a career .334 BABIP over more than 3,000 plate appearances — so we should feel fairly comfortable with that figure as a baseline. Right now, his BABIP sits at .276 while his expected BABIP based on his hit trajectory is fully .331 — much more in line with his career. He’s suffered through a .188 BABIP over the past month while batting a truly awful .156/.252/.229. His hit trajectory on the season, however, is right in line with his career rates:
| LD% | GB% | FB% | HR/FB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2013 | 21.00% | 45.70% | 33.30% | 11.10% |
| Career | 19.60% | 45.40% | 35.00% | 10.30% |
There are a few warning flags. His contact rate is down about three percent to 72% and his swinging strike rate is at a career high 12.5%. He is, however, seeing just 39% of pitches in the strike zone, which is about 7% lower than the league average. So it’s clear pitchers are being much more careful with Headley than they have been in the past. It’s simply incumbent upon Headley to adjust and be more selective if this is indeed how pitchers are going to deal with him for the rest of the season.
Lastly, in 2012, Headley’s average distance on fly balls and home runs was 301 feet. So far this season, it’s just 276 feet. That’s one of the bigger differences I’ve seen when making such a comparison, so I don’t know if it reflects some kind of injury or dumb luck — but it’s worth pointing out that in 2011, his average distance was 284 feet, lending a little fuel to the outlier argument we’ve heard before about his 2012 power outburst.
At his current clip, Headley projects to finish the season with a .220 batting average, 13 home runs, 51 RBI, and eight steals. I’m not sure there are many people who would put money on that, but if you can convince an opposing manager to give him up on the cheap, you might have a great third base solution with plenty of upside for the second half.
Michael was born in Massachusetts and grew up in the Seattle area but had nothing to do with the Heathcliff Slocumb trade although Boston fans are welcome to thank him. You can find him on twitter at @michaelcbarr.


Drafted both. Benched Gordon for Craig once he earned LF eligibility, and currently have Headley sitting behind Rendon. Would be real happy if Headley, in particular, got his act together
Would you consider my Billy Butler for his Alex Gordon? or is that giving too much?
probably too much. But Butler hasn’t really done much of anything besides draw walks so far.
I’m in a dynasty league and will have a logjam at 1st next season, as Agone will lose OF eligibility and Napoli will lose C eligibility (most likely), so I’m trying to stay ahead of that potential mess.
might be more inclined to see what I could get for Napoli.
What level OF or SP you think Napoli could bring?
I’d look for someone who is in win-now mode and gun for #3 OF type (if you use 5 OF) or #3 SP type.
Would you drop Todd Frazier for Headley? I already have Sandoval, Carpenter and Pedro Alvarez with 3B eligibility.
toughie. I probably would, but you’d have to weigh whatever else you have in the OF. Carpenter is probably most valuable as a 2B. But picking up Headley might give you the opportunity to move Alvarez while he’s hot.
I’d rather move Alvarez and replace him with Headley. Frazier is pretty nice, probably better than Headley IMO.
What about Billy Butler as a buy low?
Coincidentally just offered Headley for Gordon last night. Waiting to hear back.
I would bet that Headley’s broken thumb tip is the main cause of his struggles thus far … it hurts just thinking about a broken thumb tip! But I agree with you Micheal, Headley is a fantastic buy-low opportunity, especially for those looking for OBP and cheap power/steals.
I was going to say that not mentioning that Headley started off the season on the DL with a broken thumb was a very significant omission in this article . Good catch Gus .I have Headley on a couple of my teams and I am hoping that the further away he gets from the thumb injury,the better he will hit ,which seems reasonable to me ,unless he has gotten himself into bad habits by favoring the thumb .
Rereading the article it appears that Michael Barr is completely unaware that Headley had a broken thumb ,when he speculates that “maybe some injury” might be responsible for the shorter average distance of Headley’s fly ball this year .
It has been more than two months now. Blame his thumb if you like, but it’s kind of ridiculous for me to bother mentioning it at this point.
Are FanGraphs writers usually unaware of major injuries to Top 100 fantasy players?
I think the safest bet, dirck, would be to assume the writer puts no stock in the early season thumb injury rather than to assume writer ignorance/negligence. This is FanGraphs, not some guy who does this as a hobby.
So, as a Headley owner, I’ve been rebuking all the crappy buy-low offers I’ve been seeing. What’s a fair value SP/OF/MI expectation given my unwillingness to accept this level of performance as indicative of what he’s capable of doing the rest of the year. I don’t need to move him, as I’ve dealt with his struggles and managed to stay in 2nd-4th place range all year.
If you’re an owner and still a believer, then I think you just sit on him. Even easier to do if you’re in the top third of the league.
Gordon or Jennings the rest of the way?
That’s tough for me. Wish Jennings was running more. A lot more. I think this one is about balance. Where do you have more need – HR, R, RBI, SB. Because it’s Jennings in SB and R and it’s Gordon on HR and RBI.
Great article. Would you offer McLouth for Gordon? I’m doing pretty well in steals and am expecting a mclouth regression at any point now.
McLouth probably doesn’t get it done. You might have to sweeten that offer.
In a keeper with OPS, would you trade Hamilton for him? I can’t stand Hamilton any longer.
if you can’t stand him anymore, Gordon would be a pretty decent return. Probably better than sitting Hamilton until (if) the switch flips.
Him is Gordon, btw
On an unscientific and observational note, Headley has looked really bad swinging through the fastball when he finally works the count in his favor. Late and missing by more than a few inches. A friend who has some baseball experience has mentioned that he’s pulling his head.
That’s mostly what he’s doing. I’m a little lazy right now so I don’t have the data on me for where pitchers are really pitching him, but I watch a bunch of Padres games and he’s stroking the outside pitches okay. His fundamentals seem fine out there. But inside and low stuff vs righties….Wow. He has been horrendous. His swing is crooked, his head can’t stay still, and he’s inches above the ball. Inside changeups and inside breaking balls, he can’t read them worth a lick.
I own Headley and Gordon, just trying to wait this one out. I don’t watch the Royals often so I have no clue what Gordon’s issue is (I think he just got pinch hit for David Lough somehow), but with Headley, it seems like a timing thing.
Funny, I own Gordon and now I’m trying to pick up Headley while he’s still cheap. Hopefully when Gyorko comes back Forsythe can slide over to 3B and Headley can take a few days off to relax and work on his swing.
One of the guys actually DROPPED Gordon for some reason I can’t fathom in the middle of this (For Milone of all people!)
Fortunately, I snapped him up instantly. Feels good. Still can’t comprehend why he dropped him, especially since the dude who did is 1st in the league right now (just barely in front of me)…
Would CJ Wilson and Melky Cabrera get the job done?
Yuck
The owner accepted my offer.
How about A-Ram for Headley? Who would you guys rather have?
A-Ram
Should I trade Jered Weaver for Gordon??
Do it
Is there a place us common folk can look up batted ball distance and well hit percentage? I see those stats cited often, but I don’t know where they pull them from
I second this request.
I got mine from Zimm’s baseballheatmaps.com
Another owner in my 16 team dynasty said he wants Sandoval and he will put together an offer of Headley + for him. He hasn’t sent the offer yet, but when he soes, what would be suitable as a throw in to accompany Headley? Or should I not deal Sandoval. Note: It’s a H2H 7×7 category with K’s and OPS as the xtra cats for hitters, so seeing as Sandoval doesn’t strikeout very much makes him a little more valuable.
Update: he offered me Headley and Beachy for Sandoval and another player who will probably be Frieri. Frieri’s my only closer and I’m punting saves anyway, (this is also holds league and I’m good w/setup men) and I could use a good young SP. So if you could give me some guidance on this I would be appreciative. It’s not that I dislike Sandoval, he’s just frustrating with missing games every damn season.
On Headley, I’m curious why his higher than usual Swinging Strike% is a problem when his O-Swing% of 26.8% is right in line with his career mark of 26.7%. Is it problematic if he’s swinging more often when he’s not going outside the zone to do so???
Seems to me like Headley is being more aggressive, but more aggressive INSIDE the strike zone, which is supported by his 2013 #P/PA of 3.92 (compared to his career mark of 4.03) and his O-Swing%.
I really don’t know how to reconcile his higher swing rate and aggressiveness inside the zone with the fact that he’s seeing a significantly lower than league average percentage of pitches inside the zone.
I don’t know how much power Headley will produce this year, but I the batting average and OBP should improve quite a bit. I thought bringing in the Petco fences would help offset a large chunk of any impending power regression in 2013, but so far that just hasn’t been the case.