AL SP Musings: Harrison, Tillman and McCarthy
With only a week of baseball in the books, it is time for small sample size analysis! Here are some thoughts on various AL starting pitchers.
The former Braves prospect opened eyes after his sterling performance against the powerhouse Red Sox offense this past Sunday. He was immediately added in my shallow 12-team mixed league, so I have to assume he was picked up in many others as well. In fact, his ownership percentage in CBS leagues skyrocketed from 10% to 40% since the first scoring period began. Two encouraging signs suggest that this could be his breakout year : His average fastball velocity jumped last season and not only was that level sustained during his first start, it actually increased another 0.3 miles per hour. Second, his SwStr% was an impressive 11.1%, a mark that would have ranked fifth among all Major League starters last season, to give you some perspective. He has always shown pretty good control and induced ground balls at an above league average level, so might as well give Harrison a shot if he is still available in your league.
Tillman is another former top prospect, but one who was thought of highly a little more recently than Harrison. His first start got him picked up in my league, but I am not getting too excited. His average fastball velocity dipped just below 90.0 miles per hour, while his SwStr% was a lowly 5.9%. Along with just okay control and a fly ball tilt, I do not see what all the fuss is about. He is nothing more than a gamble in AL-Only leagues, just as he was coming into drafts.
After somewhat hyping up the supposed new look McCarthy several weeks ago, he started his first game on Tuesday and the results were mixed. The good news was that his control was outstanding, and his GB% was at a career best of nearly 47%, the first time it crept above 39.0%. On the downside, he struck out only two and generated a SwStk% of just 3.4%. Unfortunately, Pitch Type and Velocity data have not been posted yet at the time of this writing, but I am very interested in seeing what his fastball averaged. Back in 2006, McCarthy’s fastball averaged almost 91.0 miles per hour, but that figure dropped to just under 89.0 miles per hour last season. If he is truly healthier than he has been in years, I would hope and expect that his velocity has improved. Either way, he remains an intriguing and cheap AL-Only find.
Mike Podhorzer is the founder of ProjectingX IQ, an advanced fantasy baseball analytics platform that transforms projection data and in-season performance signals into actionable intelligence. He is the 2015 Fantasy Sports Writers Association Baseball Writer of the Year and three-time Tout Wars champion. He is the author of the eBook Projecting X 2.0: How to Forecast Baseball Player Performance, which teaches you how to project players yourself. Follow Mike on X@MikePodhorzer and contact him via email.


Harrison’s swinging strike% is 11 this year, not last year. Last year it was 7.5. Bleh.
I said it was this year as a reason to be optimistic.
Are we really talking about one-game swinging strike and velocity samples?
Haha, when that’s all we have this season to go on, yes! And velocity and SwStk% rates are much less flukey than many metrics. A pitcher is unlikely to luck into lots of swinging strikes against, nor could he luck into throwing 95.0 miles per hour unless the gun is totally wrong.
Touching 97.6mph is huge and the five swinging strikes on the heater are impressive, but are you serious?
When you’re dealing with such a tiny sample size, it’s misleading to quantify it as a percentage and compare it against previous years. Just use the raw data, it’ll speak for itself and people can interpret it however they’d like. Furthermore, the fact that you’re even trying to defend this bullshit is a walking the same line between funny and pathetic that Charlie Sheen’s teetering on.
The differences between the min/max SwStr% teams last year was something like 5 or 6% for hoot’s sake.
Let. The. Data. Speak. For. Itself.
“Harrison almost touched 98mph and recorded 9 swinging strikes, five of which came on the heater. If you’re the gambling type, roll the dice and hope for a mixed metaphor”
Exhale: Anyways, McCarthy probably should’ve only been credited with 2 ER rather than 4. In a post game official scorer’s call, a sure-fire error was turned into a hit and McCarthy got stuck with 2 extra ER if that makes any difference at all.
Tomorrow, we’ll talk about statistical significance, confidence intervals and Charlie Sheen’s take on the Boston Red Sox.
Maybe take another one of those deep exhalations there, champ.
(supposed to be a reply to Kris)
I had a cigarette instead and I’ve calmed down. I just couldn’t believe the argument that since SwStr% becomes statistically significant quicker, it is therefore significant immediately.
Kris, I don’t recall typing that anymore. Could you point me to where I said this?
“Second, his SwStr% was an impressive 11.1%, a mark that would have ranked fifth among all Major League starters last season, to give you some perspective”
What do you take from that sentence because it comes across a lot differently when it’s phrased as “He got 9 swinging strikes.”
Anyways, I eagerly await the follow-up piece that praises Josh Tomlin’s 12.1% Swinging Strike Rate against those very same Red Sox in their next game. A number that would’ve put him second only to Francisco Liriano last year to give you some perspective.
Anyways, the comment, “A pitcher is unlikely to luck into lots of swinging strikes against, nor could he luck into throwing 95.0 miles per hour unless the gun is totally wrong,” was the nail in the coffin.
I think Harrison’s super-awesome-amazing, but the difference between last year’s statistics and this year’s is like one or two swinging strikes.
Tillman is having trouble commanding his fastball. that’s why his swinging strike rate is so low, why he’s not lasting deep into games, why he’s giving up so many walks, etc. he’s always been a flyball pitcher so when his fastball command is off, he tends to nibble (because otherwise he’ll give up a lot of home runs).
“the fuss” is that his breaking stuff was filthy in his first start, and today it wasn’t too bad either (the main difference is that the Tigers’ lineup is a lot stronger than the Rays’). just needs to figure out that fastball…