2027 Relief Pitcher Rankings for Fantasy

Credit: Denis Poroy-Imagn Images

Overview

After spending a not insignificant portion of the off-season pontificating about relief pitchers, claiming the RP rankings article felt like a natural fit.

What wasn’t a natural fit, though, was how to actually rank them. Sorting simply by projected dollar value, while not necessarily a bad approach, doesn’t materially add anything that you, the reader, could not do yourself. Likewise, vibing out a list is probably not the way to go either – relievers are often obscure in real life and fantasy; if an elite reliever toils on a bad team, does he really make a sound? I think the answer is yes, but as with a lonely tree falling in the woods, it can be difficult to hear.

In search of a systematic way to order these arms, I settled on the following method. After filtering for relievers either projected to be better than -$5 or garner double-digit saves, I built models similar to those in my previous tome to predict whether or not a reliever would reach “elite” or “good” based on a cluster of prior-season statistics. These models turned out to be pretty good, so I used them, along with their projected dollar value and projected saves total to create z-scores for each. I then took the average of these four z-scores and sorted top-to-bottom to differentiate my general tiers below. I then sorted these tiers based on various logics which I’ll describe below. As a note, I don’t report the probabilities because I don’t want them to mislead or distract readers from the broader rankings. As in my earlier analysis, I trust the rank ordering results more strongly than I trust the probabilities themselves.

I like this ranking methodology because while each metric does contain a lot of overlapping information, they each speak to something a bit different about what we value in relievers. My elite probabilities help grasp their ceiling and my “good” probabilities help find their floor. Meanwhile, using projected saves helps provide clarity about their role and using dollar value generally factors in their non-saves stats. As the offseason rolls on, projections update, and bullpen hierarchies become clearer, names might shift within or between these tiers, but the overall logic underlying the ranks will remain the same.

Changelog

  • 11/25/2026 – First Update

Ranking Methodology

  • ADP is based on 30-day rolling NFBC Online Championship Leagues.
  • $ Values are based on a standard 5×5 12-team league using the FanGraphs Depth Charts and these Auction Calculator settings. They default to a player’s most valuable position, so if the first base list includes a catcher, it will show that player’s value at catcher.
  • ADP and $ Values are updated as of the last update date on this post.
  • 5-game eligibility was used for these lists to cast the widest net.

FullCompact

Dudes

The best of the best.
Dudes
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
1 Mason Miller SDP RP – 16 $24
2 Cade Smith CLE RP – 27 $19

What really do I need to say here? Mason Miller has been baseball’s top reliever on a skills basis for three years running, and just tallied the fifth-best relief WAR this century. My models rate him as the likeliest reliever to return an elite season, and the least likely to fall off a cliff. I will note that the draft price is steep: this is basically the highest cost of a reliever ever. The projected dollar value is roughly aligned with a mid-second round pick, so if you can stomach the risk, the price isn’t crazy on a value basis. That said, this isn’t the best pre-season projection for a reliever ever; that title belongs to Craig Kimbrel amidst his mid-2010s run of dominance. So, caveat emptor.

Quietly lurking in Miller’s shadow is another large, dominant reliever who would be receiving his laurels as fantasy’s top bullpen arm if not for his tier-mate’s historic production. Cade Smith arrived in Cleveland in 2024 as an essentially finished product, dominating right away and putting up 2.5+ WAR seasons like clockwork. In fantasy value, he’s actually been neck and neck with Miller over this stretch – Miller’s 2026 edge was narrower than you might assume – and Smith actually outperformed him in 2025 due to Miller’s midseason trade to the Padres temporarily cutting off his path to saves. They were likewise only a few dollars different in 2024. If not for Miller, Smith’s ADP would also be challenging for the highest of a reliever in recent memory. If I were in a bizarre parallel universe where someone was forcing me to draft one of these two relievers, I would probably choose Smith because of his draft price, but these are obviously the two best relievers in fantasy heading into 2027.

One Step Down

The best of the rest.
One Step Down
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
3 Jhoan Duran PHI RP – 38 $17
4 Louis Varland TOR RP – 39 $14
5 Josh Hader HOU RP – 41 $10
6 Aroldis Chapman BOS RP – 60 $11

This tier is sorted first by age groups, and second by my model’s rating of their likelihood to fall below the standard of a good reliever. Jhoan Duran comes out on top. It’s hard to find material blemishes in his game; he’s leveraged triple-digit heat to be one of baseball’s top relievers in both real life and fantasy for five years running. He’s coming off of the best season, skill-wise, of his career, and is still in the middle of his peak. The only wart I can really come up with isn’t even really a wart: he hasn’t been injured. It’s crazy that we live in a world where five consecutive healthy seasons might make one uneasy about a pitcher’s health prospects, but that is nonetheless the one in which we reside. The longer a pitcher goes without breaking, the more conspicuous he becomes. Don’t let that shy you away from acquiring Duran, though: he doesn’t figure to be any more vulnerable than any other arm on this list.

My models actually like Louis Varland to repeat his elite season a bit more than they like Duran’s. So if you’re chasing upside, maybe Varland is the play. The pros: he’s quite good, throws gas, and led the first three tiers of these rankings in innings last year. The cons: he hasn’t been this good for all that long. This is why I’ve got him ranked below his former Twin Cities teammate, who debuted the same year but has consistently pitched much better. I would go out on a limb to say that historical precedent does matter less for relievers than it might any other position, where a new pitch or mechanical tweak can just suddenly turn you into a completely different pitcher. That said, Varland had an ERA beginning with a seven as recently as 2024, and the remnant of a guy who gave up a home run on one-fifth of his fly balls lingers. But remember when I mentioned that Miller just had one of the best relief seasons this century? There’s one other 2026 arm who shows up on the first page of that leaderboard, and it’s Varland.

One of the takeaways that surprised me most during my reliever research binge earlier in the offseason is just how long Josh Hader has been basically this good. Since his debut in 2017, he’s accrued at least $10 of fantasy value in eight of his 10 seasons. He is starting show some cracks – 2026 featured the lowest innings total of his career, the lowest strikeout rate of his career, and an ERA that was nearly a full run lower than his FIP. But consider: that FIP was still 1.94, his velocity returned to typical 95 mph-plus form by the end of the season, and he didn’t have any arm trouble after returning from the injured list in early June. He has about as locked of a role as anyone on this entire list and rates by my models as the likeliest to maintain his level floor and ceiling production within this tier. I like him less than Duran and Varland because of the warts I mentioned, but I think a reasonable mind could easily rate him at the top of this group.

The argument for Aroldis Chapman is similar, if a bit more chaotic around the edges. He’s been one of fantasy’s best relief arms for the part of two decades at this point, and doesn’t have any major warning flags from last year. But: he’s getting a bit long in the tooth and the precedent for hard throwing pitchers – let alone relievers – at his age is thin. He spent the early part of this decade truly in the wilderness before rediscovering, apparently, that you can evidently Just Throw Strikes. His projections are notch below the top two names in the tier below him, but my models think he’s a much more likely bet to maintain his level of production in 2027. On a skills basis in 2026, he was in the same ballpark, if not better, than those players as well. So while I think you could make a reasonable argument he belongs more in the third tier than the second, ultimately I look at his recent skills, performance, role, and track record and see a markedly higher floor. Feels crazy to say that about a 38-year-old pitcher – I suppose that’s why he’s at the bottom of this tier – but I think it’s true nonetheless.

Two Steps Down

Still elite, but not without uncertainty.
Two Steps Down
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
7 David Bednar FA RP – 51 $11
8 Andrés Muñoz SEA RP – 58 $16
9 Mason Montgomery PIT RP – 44 $14
10 Jacob Latz TEX RP – 79 $7
11 Bryan Baker TBR RP – 53 $8

This tier is also broken into two mini groups: established, multi-year closers with warts and guys who’ve done it for one year or less. Within these groups, I’ve sorted by their respective probabilities to return another elite season, according to my model. In the first group, David Bednar has rebounded well after his disaster 2024, but his velocity and strikeout numbers did take a hit in 2026. That said, he was still quite excellent and figures to have stable role in the Yankees’ bullpen. Andrés Muñoz, meanwhile, threw as hard and struck out as many hitters as ever but ran into a significant home run problem. Everything else under the hood looks basically fine, and I’d be willing to make a bet that he figures it out enough to return top-eight value.

Mason Montgomery is easily the most tantalizing of the closer newbies. After a torrid stretch run that probably won leagues for a fair share of fantasy managers, he has a tremendous amount of helium going into 2027. I’d pump the breaks just a touch – he was much more “normal elite” than “bonkers elite” for most of last year, but it’s easy to see why he has so much hype. The other pair, while certainly not slouches themselves, are a tick below Montgomery in my estimation if not their fastball velocity. I think, other than Bednar, Jacob Latz probably has the firmest hold on any closer job out of this tier; it’s questionable whether Texas has another bullpen arm that they could call above average, let alone good. But he seemed to have benefited from BABIP luck (.182) that might be unlikely to hold. My views on Bryan Baker have already graced the digital pages of RotoGraphs. I am not enthusiastic about a pitcher who ran an ERA a full run and a half ahead of his estimators while also striking out the fewest batters among this group. The Rays also aren’t the type of team married to sticking with one firm closer; his 41 saves for in 2026 are an outlier for Tampa since the days of Alex Colomé. I do think, for now, he’s a better bet than anyone below him on this list to both a.) be a good pitcher and b.) accrue ~25 or more saves but by my eyes he’s clearly the worst of the best.

Question Marks

Universally rosterable, but not without role or consistency questions.
Question Marks
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
12 Raisel Iglesias FA RP – 97 -$3
13 Adrian Morejon FA RP – 246 $7
14 Tanner Scott LAD RP – 200 $6
15 Trevor Megill MIL RP – 71 $8
16 Aaron Ashby MIL RP – 319 $5
17 Devin Williams NYM RP – 117 $8
18 Emilio Pagán DET RP – 127 $3
19 Riley O’Brien STL RP – 116 $5
20 Jeff Hoffman MIN RP – 166 $5
21 Edwin Díaz LAD RP – 78 $7
22 Hogan Harris ATH RP – 368 $1
23 Robert Suarez ATL RP – 134 $5
24 Randy Rodríguez SFG RP – 227 $5
25 Justin Martinez ARI RP – 137 $9
26 Daniel Palencia CHC RP – 230 $4
27 Ben Joyce LAA RP – 217 $4

This tier comprises the remaining pitchers who rate above zero in my average z-score metric, and are sorted by their probability metrics. Here, we’ve got a mix of the last semi-stable options, arms with relatively clear roles to start the year but lingering performance questions, and players with elite “everything else” but foggier paths to saves. The first name on the list, Raisel Iglesias, is similar in spirit to the Bednar/Muñoz mini-tier above. He has a long track record of good performance in a closing role, but will be 37 and has lost a tick and a half of velocity since 2024. He also, according to my models, is just a hair less likely to register an elite season than any of the tier above. Combined, it’s enough for me to feel comfortable bumping him down.

After that, we have the three best projected non-saves relievers in Adrian Morejon, Tanner Scott, and Aaron Ashby. Morejon is currently a free agent; if he ends up on a team planning to install him as closer, I imagine he may rise into the third tier. Scott, my models think, is a much better bet than teammate and tier-mate Edwin Díaz to be worth your virtual money. Any injury or shaky performance from his bullpen neighbor will likewise catapult him at least one rank higher. Ashby is a weird case – his role is unique enough that I think his penchant for vulturing wins is somewhat sustainable, and therefore might be worth consideration as a volume play after the best relievers are off the board. Sandwiched in between these guys is Trevor Megill, who’s the last capital-C closer on this list about whom I’d feel solid enough from a skills and role perspective to treat as a true RP1. As a note, if Grant Taylor and Didier Fuentes were projected for non-saves relief roles, this is where they’d be. With saves projections, I imagine they would do well enough to bump Latz and Baker out of the tier above and into a new one with Iglesias and maybe Megill.

The next six all have a starker balance of pros versus cons and a much more tenuous hold (see what I did there) on their respective closer jobs. Between 2020 and 2024, Devin Williams threw 222 innings of 1.70 ERA ball, but has suffered under the bright lights of the Big Apple in the past two seasons. Emilio Pagán is more cromulent than good. Riley O’Brien probably has the least competition in this tier, but also the least compelling raw stuff. Jeff Hoffman will start the season in the closer role, strike out oodles of hitters, but is liable to contract gopheritis at any point and tumble down the bullpen by June. Meanwhile, attention garnered by Edwin Díaz’s contract with the Dodgers and a few truly dominant turns have papered over a career that is actually pretty spotty; he’s never had two consecutive seasons with an ERA that starts with the same number. He’s going into his age-33 season following a year of health woes, and my models think he’s much closer to Hogan Harris than he is Megill or Iglesias, so proceed with caution. Speaking of Harris, he has a lot of things in his favor: he added two ticks to his fastball in 2026, took hold of the closer job in Sacramento, struck out more than 11 batters per nine, but a ghastly walk rate and resultant WHIP (1.45 in 2026, 1.41 career) will hold him back from serious fantasy relevance.

The last group of five is a cadre of players with saves projections for 2027 that pitched fewer than 100 innings combined 2026. They’re a clear notch above the next tier down on a talent basis, but you don’t want any of them as your primary option for saves. To my eye, these are more speculative plays and could easily move out of this tier if their team signs a more established free agent (like Iglesias or Morejon) that they intend to install as closer, or if they don’t make it through spring training healthy.

Saves Goobers

Abandon hope, all ye who enter here.
Saves Goobers
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
28 Ryan Helsley BAL RP – 316 $2
29 Félix Bautista BAL RP – 143 $1
30 Ryan Zeferjahn CHC RP – 327 $1
31 Juan Morillo ARI RP – 519 $0
32 Steven Cruz KCR RP – 364 $0
33 Bryan Hudson CHW RP – -$1
34 Calvin Faucher MIA RP – 624 $0
35 Tejay Antone CIN RP – 589 -$1
36 Erik Tolman WSN RP – 545 -$2
37 Yoendrys Gómez MIN RP – 488 -$4
38 Lucas Erceg KCR RP – 522 -$4
39 Juan Mejia COL RP – 750 -$7

Among negative z-score rated players, these are the guys currently projected for double digit saves and are sorted roughly by projected dollar value. If you must trawl these depths, your best bets will be the guys projected to hurt you the least elsewhere, which is what the projected dollar value tells us. There are a few ghosts of elite pitchers past but all come with serious volume or skill risk and will be volatile based on role projections. Generally, this is a tier of watchlist guys more so than anyone who needs to be drafted with priority.

The Rest

Choose your own metaphor: long-shot, dart throw, lotto ticket, etc.
The Rest
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
40 Spencer Miles TOR RP – 336 $3
41 Bradgley Rodriguez SDP RP – 506 $2
42 Abner Uribe MIL RP – 233 $2
43 Brent Headrick NYY RP – 623 $1
44 Edgardo Henriquez LAD RP – 569 $0
45 Chad Patrick MIL RP – 546 -$2
46 Garrett Whitlock BOS RP – 398 $0
47 Jack Dreyer LAD RP – -$2
48 Alex Vesia FA RP – 634 -$3
49 Bryan Abreu FA RP – 357 -$2
50 Erik Sabrowski CLE RP – 669 -$1
51 Dylan Lee ATL RP – 671 $1
52 Gregory Soto FA RP – 527 -$2
53 Kevin Kelly TBR RP – 679 -$2
54 Brandyn Garcia ARI RP – 411 $2
55 Tyler Wells TBR RP – 486 $1
56 Yohan Ramírez PIT RP – 725 -$1
57 Dylan Dodd ATL RP – -$3
58 Rico Garcia BAL RP – 460 -$3
59 Luke Weaver PIT RP – 481 -$1
60 Pete Fairbanks FA RP – 566 -$3
61 Samy Natera Jr. LAA RP – 481 -$2
62 Tyler Holton DET RP – 726 -$3
63 Seranthony Domínguez SEA RP – 704 -$2
64 Jeremiah Estrada SDP RP – 588 -$1
65 Erik Miller BOS RP – 696 -$3
66 Jonathan Bowlan PHI RP – 627 -$1
67 Ronny Henriquez MIA RP – 313 $0
68 Luis Gastelum STL RP – 647 -$2
69 Sean Newcomb FA RP – 717 $0
70 Andrew Morris MIN RP – 645 -$1
71 Will Dion WSN RP – 607 -$3
72 Nate Lavender NYM RP – 724 $1
73 Drew Sommers DET RP – 465 $1
74 Evan Phillips ATL RP – 408 $1
75 Camilo Doval SFG RP – 718 -$2
76 Michael Petersen MIA RP – 511 -$1
77 Gabe Speier SEA RP – $1
78 Kevin Ginkel FA RP – 718 -$2
79 Garrett Cleavinger TBR RP – -$3
80 Jonathan Loáisiga FA RP – -$2
81 Eduard Bazardo SEA RP – -$3
82 Trent Harris SFG RP – 512 -$2
83 Jordan Hicks CHW RP – 629 $1
84 José A. Ferrer SEA RP – $2
85 Matt Brash SEA RP – 696 $1
86 Anthony Bender MIA RP – 693 -$3
87 A.J. Puk FA RP – $0
88 Graham Ashcraft CIN RP – 717 -$3
89 Justin Slaten BOS RP – -$3
90 Cam Booser TBR RP – -$3
91 Reed Garrett NYM RP – -$2
92 José Alvarado FA RP – -$3
93 Dedniel Núñez NYM RP – 651 $0
94 Shelby Miller CHC RP – 738 -$3
95 Will Vest DET RP – 688 -$1
96 Robert Garcia TEX RP – 740 -$3
97 Tyron Guerrero BOS RP – 743 -$1
98 Hunter Harvey FA RP – -$4
99 Ray Kerr ATL RP – 750 -$4

If the tier above is watchlist guys, then these are your deepest cuts. I’ve sorted them by my models’ likelihoods to break out because I think that’s what you want most from this group of players. The first 17 (through Yohan Ramírez) all rate as more likely to register a good or elite season than any of the players in the Goober tier, and I would actually prioritize rostering the first five coming out of drafts.

Ottoneu Points 2027RP Tiered Rankings
Tier Rank Player Notes
Dudes 1 Mason Miller What really do I need to say here? Mason Miller has been baseball’s top reliever on a skills basis for three years running, and just tallied the fifth-best relief WAR this century. My models rate him as the likeliest reliever to return an elite season, and the least likely to fall off a cliff. I will note that the draft price is steep: this is basically the highest cost of a reliever ever. The projected dollar value is roughly aligned with a mid-second round pick, so if you can stomach the risk, the price isn’t crazy on a value basis. That said, this isn’t the best pre-season projection for a reliever ever; that title belongs to Craig Kimbrel amidst his mid-2010s run of dominance. So, caveat emptor.
Dudes 2 Cade Smith Quietly lurking in Miller’s shadow is another large, dominant reliever who would be receiving his laurels as fantasy’s top bullpen arm if not for his tier-mate’s historic production. Cade Smith arrived in Cleveland in 2024 as an essentially finished product, dominating right away and putting up 2.5+ WAR seasons like clockwork. In fantasy value, he’s actually been neck and neck with Miller over this stretch – Miller’s 2026 edge was narrower than you might assume – and Smith actually outperformed him in 2025 due to Miller’s midseason trade to the Padres temporarily cutting off his path to saves. They were likewise only a few dollars different in 2024. If not for Miller, Smith’s ADP would also be challenging for the highest of a reliever in recent memory. If I were in a bizarre parallel universe where someone was forcing me to draft one of these two relievers, I would probably choose Smith because of his draft price, but these are obviously the two best relievers in fantasy heading into 2027.
One Step Down 3 Jhoan Duran This tier is sorted first by age groups, and second by my model’s rating of their likelihood to fall below the standard of a good reliever. Jhoan Duran comes out on top. It’s hard to find material blemishes in his game; he’s leveraged triple-digit heat to be one of baseball’s top relievers in both real life and fantasy for five years running. He’s coming off of the best season, skill-wise, of his career, and is still in the middle of his peak. The only wart I can really come up with isn’t even really a wart: he hasn’t been injured. It’s crazy that we live in a world where five consecutive healthy seasons might make one uneasy about a pitcher’s health prospects, but that is nonetheless the one in which we reside. The longer a pitcher goes without breaking, the more conspicuous he becomes. Don’t let that shy you away from acquiring Duran, though: he doesn’t figure to be any more vulnerable than any other arm on this list.
One Step Down 4 Louis Varland My models actually like Louis Varland to repeat his elite season a bit more than they like Duran’s. So if you’re chasing upside, maybe Varland is the play. The pros: he’s quite good, throws gas, and led the first three tiers of these rankings in innings last year. The cons: he hasn’t been this good for all that long. This is why I’ve got him ranked below his former Twin Cities teammate, who debuted the same year but has consistently pitched much better. I would go out on a limb to say that historical precedent does matter less for relievers than it might any other position, where a new pitch or mechanical tweak can just suddenly turn you into a completely different pitcher. That said, Varland had an ERA beginning with a seven as recently as 2024, and the remnant of a guy who gave up a home run on one-fifth of his fly balls lingers. But remember when I mentioned that Miller just had one of the best relief seasons this century? There’s one other 2026 arm who shows up on the first page of that leaderboard, and it’s Varland.
One Step Down 5 Josh Hader One of the takeaways that surprised me most during my reliever research binge earlier in the offseason is just how long Josh Hader has been basically this good. Since his debut in 2017, he’s accrued at least $10 of fantasy value in eight of his 10 seasons. He is starting show some cracks – 2026 featured the lowest innings total of his career, the lowest strikeout rate of his career, and an ERA that was nearly a full run lower than his FIP. But consider: that FIP was still 1.94, his velocity returned to typical 95 mph-plus form by the end of the season, and he didn’t have any arm trouble after returning from the injured list in early June. He has about as locked of a role as anyone on this entire list and rates by my models as the likeliest to maintain his level floor and ceiling production within this tier. I like him less than Duran and Varland because of the warts I mentioned, but I think a reasonable mind could easily rate him at the top of this group.
One Step Down 6 Aroldis Chapman The argument for Aroldis Chapman is similar, if a bit more chaotic around the edges. He’s been one of fantasy’s best relief arms for the part of two decades at this point, and doesn’t have any major warning flags from last year. But: he’s getting a bit long in the tooth and the precedent for hard throwing pitchers – let alone relievers – at his age is thin. He spent the early part of this decade truly in the wilderness before rediscovering, apparently, that you can evidently Just Throw Strikes. His projections are notch below the top two names in the tier below him, but my models think he’s a much more likely bet to maintain his level of production in 2027. On a skills basis in 2026, he was in the same ballpark, if not better, than those players as well. So while I think you could make a reasonable argument he belongs more in the third tier than the second, ultimately I look at his recent skills, performance, role, and track record and see a markedly higher floor. Feels crazy to say that about a 38-year-old pitcher – I suppose that’s why he’s at the bottom of this tier – but I think it’s true nonetheless.
Two Steps Down 7 David Bednar This tier is also broken into two mini groups: established, multi-year closers with warts and guys who’ve done it for one year or less. Within these groups, I’ve sorted by their respective probabilities to return another elite season, according to my model. In the first group, David Bednar has rebounded well after his disaster 2024, but his velocity and strikeout numbers did take a hit in 2026. That said, he was still quite excellent and figures to have stable role in the Yankees’ bullpen. Andrés Muñoz, meanwhile, threw as hard and struck out as many hitters as ever but ran into a significant home run problem. Everything else under the hood looks basically fine, and I’d be willing to make a bet that he figures it out enough to return top-eight value.
Two Steps Down 8 Andrés Muñoz
Two Steps Down 9 Mason Montgomery Mason Montgomery is easily the most tantalizing of the closer newbies. After a torrid stretch run that probably won leagues for a fair share of fantasy managers, he has a tremendous amount of helium going into 2027. I’d pump the breaks just a touch – he was much more “normal elite” than “bonkers elite” for most of last year, but it’s easy to see why he has so much hype. The other pair, while certainly not slouches themselves, are a tick below Montgomery in my estimation if not their fastball velocity. I think, other than Bednar, Jacob Latz probably has the firmest hold on any closer job out of this tier; it’s questionable whether Texas has another bullpen arm that they could call above average, let alone good. But he seemed to have benefited from BABIP luck (.182) that might be unlikely to hold. My views on Bryan Baker have already graced the digital pages of RotoGraphs. I am not enthusiastic about a pitcher who ran an ERA a full run and a half ahead of his estimators while also striking out the fewest batters among this group. The Rays also aren’t the type of team married to sticking with one firm closer; his 41 saves for in 2026 are an outlier for Tampa since the days of Alex Colomé. I do think, for now, he’s a better bet than anyone below him on this list to both a.) be a good pitcher and b.) accrue ~25 or more saves but by my eyes he’s clearly the worst of the best.
Two Steps Down 10 Jacob Latz
Two Steps Down 11 Bryan Baker
Question Marks 12 Raisel Iglesias This tier comprises the remaining pitchers who rate above zero in my average z-score metric, and are sorted by their probability metrics. Here, we’ve got a mix of the last semi-stable options, arms with relatively clear roles to start the year but lingering performance questions, and players with elite “everything else” but foggier paths to saves. The first name on the list, Raisel Iglesias, is similar in spirit to the Bednar/Muñoz mini-tier above. He has a long track record of good performance in a closing role, but will be 37 and has lost a tick and a half of velocity since 2024. He also, according to my models, is just a hair less likely to register an elite season than any of the tier above. Combined, it’s enough for me to feel comfortable bumping him down.
Question Marks 13 Adrian Morejon After that, we have the three best projected non-saves relievers in Adrian Morejon, Tanner Scott, and Aaron Ashby. Morejon is currently a free agent; if he ends up on a team planning to install him as closer, I imagine he may rise into the third tier. Scott, my models think, is a much better bet than teammate and tier-mate Edwin Díaz to be worth your virtual money. Any injury or shaky performance from his bullpen neighbor will likewise catapult him at least one rank higher. Ashby is a weird case – his role is unique enough that I think his penchant for vulturing wins is somewhat sustainable, and therefore might be worth consideration as a volume play after the best relievers are off the board. Sandwiched in between these guys is Trevor Megill, who’s the last capital-C closer on this list about whom I’d feel solid enough from a skills and role perspective to treat as a true RP1. As a note, if Grant Taylor and Didier Fuentes were projected for non-saves relief roles, this is where they’d be. With saves projections, I imagine they would do well enough to bump Latz and Baker out of the tier above and into a new one with Iglesias and maybe Megill.
Question Marks 14 Tanner Scott
Question Marks 15 Trevor Megill
Question Marks 16 Aaron Ashby
Question Marks 17 Devin Williams The next six all have a starker balance of pros versus cons and a much more tenuous hold (see what I did there) on their respective closer jobs. Between 2020 and 2024, Devin Williams threw 222 innings of 1.70 ERA ball, but has suffered under the bright lights of the Big Apple in the past two seasons. Emilio Pagán is more cromulent than good. Riley O’Brien probably has the least competition in this tier, but also the least compelling raw stuff. Jeff Hoffman will start the season in the closer role, strike out oodles of hitters, but is liable to contract gopheritis at any point and tumble down the bullpen by June. Meanwhile, attention garnered by Edwin Díaz’s contract with the Dodgers and a few truly dominant turns have papered over a career that is actually pretty spotty; he’s never had two consecutive seasons with an ERA that starts with the same number. He’s going into his age-33 season following a year of health woes, and my models think he’s much closer to Hogan Harris than he is Megill or Iglesias, so proceed with caution. Speaking of Harris, he has a lot of things in his favor: he added two ticks to his fastball in 2026, took hold of the closer job in Sacramento, struck out more than 11 batters per nine, but a ghastly walk rate and resultant WHIP (1.45 in 2026, 1.41 career) will hold him back from serious fantasy relevance.
Question Marks 18 Emilio Pagán
Question Marks 19 Riley O’Brien
Question Marks 20 Jeff Hoffman
Question Marks 21 Edwin Díaz
Question Marks 22 Hogan Harris
Question Marks 23 Robert Suarez The last group of five is a cadre of players with saves projections for 2027 that pitched fewer than 100 innings combined 2026. They’re a clear notch above the next tier down on a talent basis, but you don’t want any of them as your primary option for saves. To my eye, these are more speculative plays and could easily move out of this tier if their team signs a more established free agent (like Iglesias or Morejon) that they intend to install as closer, or if they don’t make it through spring training healthy.
Question Marks 24 Randy Rodríguez
Question Marks 25 Justin Martinez
Question Marks 26 Daniel Palencia
Question Marks 27 Ben Joyce
Saves Goobers 28 Ryan Helsley Among negative z-score rated players, these are the guys currently projected for double digit saves and are sorted roughly by projected dollar value. If you must trawl these depths, your best bets will be the guys projected to hurt you the least elsewhere, which is what the projected dollar value tells us. There are a few ghosts of elite pitchers past but all come with serious volume or skill risk and will be volatile based on role projections. Generally, this is a tier of watchlist guys more so than anyone who needs to be drafted with priority.
Saves Goobers 29 Félix Bautista
Saves Goobers 30 Ryan Zeferjahn
Saves Goobers 31 Juan Morillo
Saves Goobers 32 Steven Cruz
Saves Goobers 33 Bryan Hudson
Saves Goobers 34 Calvin Faucher
Saves Goobers 35 Tejay Antone
Saves Goobers 36 Erik Tolman
Saves Goobers 37 Yoendrys Gómez
Saves Goobers 38 Lucas Erceg
Saves Goobers 39 Juan Mejia
The Rest 40 Spencer Miles If the tier above is watchlist guys, then these are your deepest cuts. I’ve sorted them by my models’ likelihoods to break out because I think that’s what you want most from this group of players. The first 17 (through Yohan Ramírez) all rate as more likely to register a good or elite season than any of the players in the Goober tier, and I would actually prioritize rostering the first five coming out of drafts.
The Rest 41 Bradgley Rodriguez
The Rest 42 Abner Uribe
The Rest 43 Brent Headrick
The Rest 44 Edgardo Henriquez
The Rest 45 Chad Patrick
The Rest 46 Garrett Whitlock
The Rest 47 Jack Dreyer
The Rest 48 Alex Vesia
The Rest 49 Bryan Abreu
The Rest 50 Erik Sabrowski
The Rest 51 Dylan Lee
The Rest 52 Gregory Soto
The Rest 53 Kevin Kelly
The Rest 54 Brandyn Garcia
The Rest 55 Tyler Wells
The Rest 56 Yohan Ramírez
The Rest 57 Dylan Dodd
The Rest 58 Rico Garcia
The Rest 59 Luke Weaver
The Rest 60 Pete Fairbanks
The Rest 61 Samy Natera Jr.
The Rest 62 Tyler Holton
The Rest 63 Seranthony Domínguez
The Rest 64 Jeremiah Estrada
The Rest 65 Erik Miller
The Rest 66 Jonathan Bowlan
The Rest 67 Ronny Henriquez
The Rest 68 Luis Gastelum
The Rest 69 Sean Newcomb
The Rest 70 Andrew Morris
The Rest 71 Will Dion
The Rest 72 Nate Lavender
The Rest 73 Drew Sommers
The Rest 74 Evan Phillips
The Rest 75 Camilo Doval
The Rest 76 Michael Petersen
The Rest 77 Gabe Speier
The Rest 78 Kevin Ginkel
The Rest 79 Garrett Cleavinger
The Rest 80 Jonathan Loáisiga
The Rest 81 Eduard Bazardo
The Rest 82 Trent Harris
The Rest 83 Jordan Hicks
The Rest 84 José A. Ferrer
The Rest 85 Matt Brash
The Rest 86 Anthony Bender
The Rest 87 A.J. Puk
The Rest 88 Graham Ashcraft
The Rest 89 Justin Slaten
The Rest 90 Cam Booser
The Rest 91 Reed Garrett
The Rest 92 José Alvarado
The Rest 93 Dedniel Núñez
The Rest 94 Shelby Miller
The Rest 95 Will Vest
The Rest 96 Robert Garcia
The Rest 97 Tyron Guerrero
The Rest 98 Hunter Harvey
The Rest 99 Ray Kerr

Full Rankings Without Tiers

No tiers. Just the rankings.
Full Rankings Without Tiers
Rank Name Team Pos Change ADP $
1 Mason Miller SDP RP – 16 $24
2 Cade Smith CLE RP – 27 $19
3 Jhoan Duran PHI RP – 38 $17
4 Louis Varland TOR RP – 39 $14
5 Josh Hader HOU RP – 41 $10
6 Aroldis Chapman BOS RP – 60 $11
7 David Bednar FA RP – 51 $11
8 Andrés Muñoz SEA RP – 58 $16
9 Mason Montgomery PIT RP – 44 $14
10 Jacob Latz TEX RP – 79 $7
11 Bryan Baker TBR RP – 53 $8
12 Raisel Iglesias FA RP – 97 -$3
13 Adrian Morejon FA RP – 246 $7
14 Tanner Scott LAD RP – 200 $6
15 Trevor Megill MIL RP – 71 $8
16 Aaron Ashby MIL RP – 319 $5
17 Devin Williams NYM RP – 117 $8
18 Emilio Pagán DET RP – 127 $3
19 Riley O’Brien STL RP – 116 $5
20 Jeff Hoffman MIN RP – 166 $5
21 Edwin Díaz LAD RP – 78 $7
22 Hogan Harris ATH RP – 368 $1
23 Robert Suarez ATL RP – 134 $5
24 Randy Rodríguez SFG RP – 227 $5
25 Justin Martinez ARI RP – 137 $9
26 Daniel Palencia CHC RP – 230 $4
27 Ben Joyce LAA RP – 217 $4
28 Ryan Helsley BAL RP – 316 $2
29 Félix Bautista BAL RP – 143 $1
30 Ryan Zeferjahn CHC RP – 327 $1
31 Juan Morillo ARI RP – 519 $0
32 Steven Cruz KCR RP – 364 $0
33 Bryan Hudson CHW RP – -$1
34 Calvin Faucher MIA RP – 624 $0
35 Tejay Antone CIN RP – 589 -$1
36 Erik Tolman WSN RP – 545 -$2
37 Yoendrys Gómez MIN RP – 488 -$4
38 Lucas Erceg KCR RP – 522 -$4
39 Juan Mejia COL RP – 750 -$7
40 Spencer Miles TOR RP – 336 $3
41 Bradgley Rodriguez SDP RP – 506 $2
42 Abner Uribe MIL RP – 233 $2
43 Brent Headrick NYY RP – 623 $1
44 Edgardo Henriquez LAD RP – 569 $0
45 Chad Patrick MIL RP – 546 -$2
46 Garrett Whitlock BOS RP – 398 $0
47 Jack Dreyer LAD RP – -$2
48 Alex Vesia FA RP – 634 -$3
49 Bryan Abreu FA RP – 357 -$2
50 Erik Sabrowski CLE RP – 669 -$1
51 Dylan Lee ATL RP – 671 $1
52 Gregory Soto FA RP – 527 -$2
53 Kevin Kelly TBR RP – 679 -$2
54 Brandyn Garcia ARI RP – 411 $2
55 Tyler Wells TBR RP – 486 $1
56 Yohan Ramírez PIT RP – 725 -$1
57 Dylan Dodd ATL RP – -$3
58 Rico Garcia BAL RP – 460 -$3
59 Luke Weaver PIT RP – 481 -$1
60 Pete Fairbanks FA RP – 566 -$3
61 Samy Natera Jr. LAA RP – 481 -$2
62 Tyler Holton DET RP – 726 -$3
63 Seranthony Domínguez SEA RP – 704 -$2
64 Jeremiah Estrada SDP RP – 588 -$1
65 Erik Miller BOS RP – 696 -$3
66 Jonathan Bowlan PHI RP – 627 -$1
67 Ronny Henriquez MIA RP – 313 $0
68 Luis Gastelum STL RP – 647 -$2
69 Sean Newcomb FA RP – 717 $0
70 Andrew Morris MIN RP – 645 -$1
71 Will Dion WSN RP – 607 -$3
72 Nate Lavender NYM RP – 724 $1
73 Drew Sommers DET RP – 465 $1
74 Evan Phillips ATL RP – 408 $1
75 Camilo Doval SFG RP – 718 -$2
76 Michael Petersen MIA RP – 511 -$1
77 Gabe Speier SEA RP – $1
78 Kevin Ginkel FA RP – 718 -$2
79 Garrett Cleavinger TBR RP – -$3
80 Jonathan Loáisiga FA RP – -$2
81 Eduard Bazardo SEA RP – -$3
82 Trent Harris SFG RP – 512 -$2
83 Jordan Hicks CHW RP – 629 $1
84 José A. Ferrer SEA RP – $2
85 Matt Brash SEA RP – 696 $1
86 Anthony Bender MIA RP – 693 -$3
87 A.J. Puk FA RP – $0
88 Graham Ashcraft CIN RP – 717 -$3
89 Justin Slaten BOS RP – -$3
90 Cam Booser TBR RP – -$3
91 Reed Garrett NYM RP – -$2
92 José Alvarado FA RP – -$3
93 Dedniel Núñez NYM RP – 651 $0
94 Shelby Miller CHC RP – 738 -$3
95 Will Vest DET RP – 688 -$1
96 Robert Garcia TEX RP – 740 -$3
97 Tyron Guerrero BOS RP – 743 -$1
98 Hunter Harvey FA RP – -$4
99 Ray Kerr ATL RP – 750 -$4





Jonathan is a contributor for RotoGraphs. He is a Tigers fan living in Philadelphia with his wife and dog and requests that you leave your best pizza topping combinations in the comments.

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
murraygd13Member since 2019
1 hour ago

Should Hagen Smith be added to the RP rankings? Sounds like the plan is for him to be in the White Sox bullpen in 2027.