2013 AL Starting Pitcher Tier Rankings: June Update

Rankings update week! Since there was the obligatory confusion in the AL OF rankings update, let me remind you — American League. As in not National League. Though, I do have to admit it is amusing to read which random player is asked about not appearing in the rankings, as it’s never the top guy in the other league. Lots of movement this time as the important rates stabilize and become significant.

You’re the Best

Justin Verlander

For the first time in a while, Verlander’s ERA is significantly above his SIERA. For the past two years, the reverse has been true, as he has managed to post sub-3.00 ERAs with skills suggesting more of a 3.00-3.25 range. We first notice a greatly inflated .359 BABIP. While we might be quick to blame the porous Tigers infield defense, we should look no further than Verlander’s batted ball distribution. He has allowed an uncharacteristic 25% line drive rate, which suggests that high BABIP isn’t all poor fortune.

That said, line drive rate itself is flukey in small samples, so even if the BABIP has been somewhat deserved so far, it will obviously come down. I would be much more concerned about the fastball velocity decline, which has not improved as the season has progressed, if Verlander wasn’t inducing a high SwStk% as always or posting the same Contact% or striking out batters at the highest rate of his career. He’ll be fine.

Second Best

Felix Hernandez
Yu Darvish
C.C. Sabathia
James Shields
Max Scherzer
David Price

Felix Hernandez is yet another top tier starter who has seen his velocity decline but is actually striking out the highest rate of batters of his career. Amazing. Sabathia’s velocity is slowly creeping back up and his peripherals remain as strong as always. Scherzer finally moves up a tier as it looks like only bad fortune would prevent him from earning this type of value. Of course, he’s actually already experiencing bad fortune when comparing his SIERA (2.61) to his ERA (3.42). I dropped David Price to the bottom of this tier as the triceps injury and velocity decline scare me. But he should be back shortly and might prove that the concerns are overblown.

Strong Enough

Chris Sale
Jered Weaver
Anibal Sanchez
R.A. Dickey
Doug Fister
Jon Lester
Alex Cobb
Matt Moore
Hiroki Kuroda
Clay Buchholz

Jered Weaver rejoins the rankings, but with a lack of velocity and his strikeout rate and resulting performance in question, cannot move any higher at the moment. Anibal Sanchez jumps a tier as his amazing strikeout rate surge continues. His fastball velocity is up slightly, but that’s really the only thing that looks different, so I wonder how he has managed to generate so many swinging strikes. He might be even higher if there was a good explanation or he had some sort of track record for this. Dickey finally drops a tier and he may continue to alternate good starts and bad. Makes it difficult to make start/bench decisions and his opponent might not matter. Either the knuckleball is working and baffling batters or it’s not. Since his velocity is down on the pitch, it’s silly to assume it will suddenly return, which is the likely explanation behind his decreased strikeout rate.

According to my expected strikeout rate metric, Alex Cobb has been a bit lucky striking out batters so far. Still, he jumps a tier given his combination of skills, including a sky high ground ball rate. I expect both the walk rate to drop and the strikeout rate to decline though. Well, I’ve been right so far about Matt Moore. Unfortunately he’s experiencing luck regression and I’m becoming more concerned that the velocity loss is going to hurt him. For pitchers like Verlander and Felix who have excellent control, they could get away with a decline in velocity. Moore’s command struggles likely means fewer opponent swings outside the zone. He drops near to the bottom of the tier.

Clay Buchholz finally jumps a tier, but only to the bottom of this one. He’s doing it with basically a league leading called strike rate. Is that sustainable? Maybe, maybe not. I’d much prefer to believe in a pitcher who’s inducing more swinging strikes like Anibal. Nothing in his statistical profile suggests he’s really any different of a pitcher than in previous seasons.

Seeing is Believing

Derek Holland
Tommy Milone
Josh Johnson
Hisashi Iwakuma
Ryan Dempster
Jeremy Hellickson
C.J. Wilson

Derek Holland jumps a tier as he is inducing swinging strikes at a career high rate, which has finally translated into a strong strikeout rate. For a lefty with plus fastball velocity, it was always a wonder why his strikeout rates have been rather pedestrian. The increased slider usage has led to the additional swings and misses as he is both throwing the pitch more and frequently and getting an even higher SwStk% on it than ever before. Iwakuma also jumps a tier. Despite posting an almost identical pitch mix, his SwStk% has risen and he’s throwing significantly more first pitch strikes, which has pushed his walk rate into elite territory.

Josh Johnson returned from the DL on Tuesday and got good results, but his fastball velocity was down a bit. His league, home park and injury history prevents me from moving him any higher. I provided a more detailed analysis of Hellickson a couple of weeks ago, but it’s funny how he’s posting better skills than in past years, but now it’s his luck that’s the problem. I still have absolutely no idea what to make of him, so he’ll remain here, perhaps for the rest of eternity.

I’m Not Okay (I Promise)

Justin Masterson
John Lackey
Roberto Hernandez
Scott Kazmir
Jason Hammel
Alexi Ogando
Phil Hughes
Felix Doubront
Ervin Santana

Justin Masterson is one of the biggest winners in this rankings update jumping a tier to the top of the previous one. His strikeout rate is going to decline, if you believe my expected strikeout rate formula of course (and you should!), but it should still remain above previous seasons. And with that extreme ground ball tendency, only poor infield defense would prevent a sub-4.00 ERA. He’s basically Alex Cobb with worse control and a lesser ability to contain lefties. John Lackey, though, is actually the biggest winner, leaping over the tier below him and moving up two tiers overall. Despite a similar pitch mix that he has always shown, his skills are at vintage Lackey level. He has even discovered a newfound ability to induce the ground ball.

Yes, I bravely moved Roberto Hernandez up to the top of the tier. He has posted strong skills all season long, but has been continually bitten by the home run ball, which has also hurt his LOB%. Although he has sometimes had trouble keeping fly balls in the park in the past, a 22% HR/FB rate is ridiculous. His previous career high was near 14%, and his career rate, which includes this year, is just about 12%. Be patient.

Scott Kazmir finally makes his debut on this here rankings list. It’s still pretty amazing that after all these years, his skills and velocity are essentially back to vintage levels. Better BABIP luck will result in value in even 12-team mixed leagues.

Jason Hammel drops a tier — his strikeout and walk rates improved dramatically in May, but naturally he endured significantly worse fortune and his ERA, which ended April at 3.79, was a whopping 6.44 in May. Just ERA regression at play. Ground balls are gone though and his velocity remains down from last year, so the hope for a strong follow-up should probably be given up at this point.

Man it’s tough being an extreme fly ball pitcher at Yankees Stadium. But Phil Hughes’ SIERA is nearly identical to where it was last year. He’s going to have the occasional blowup, as we have obviously witnessed, but he has strong control and good enough strikeout ability to maintain some value. Ervin Santana jumps a tier, but barely. My expected strikeout rate formula suggests he’s been one of the luckiest starters and actually deserves a strikeout percentage closer to 18%. Also, that walk rate simply isn’t sustainable. The Royals offense has been horrid as well, which those paltry three wins attest to, despite a 3.03 ERA.

Livin’ on the Edge

David Phelps
Jarrod Parker
Corey Kluber
Dan Straily
Kevin Gausman
Bartolo Colon
Jose Quintana
Andy Pettitte
A.J. Griffin
Nick Tepesch

David Phelps and Dan Straily join the rankings and both have shown some pretty good skills so far, but an inability to strand runners has hurt both of their ERAs. There’s no guarantee that Phelps remains in the rotation all season or that he’ll even have the stamina to do so. And when Brett Anderson returns, there’s no guarantee Straily remains in the rotation.

Corey Kluber also joins the rankings and it’s safe to say that Mr. Carson Cistulli has some kind of fascination with the man. Since May 21, he has included Kluber’s name in the title of his daily notes a total of five times. That means a whopping 31% of his posts since then have discussed the Indians starter. Woah. I like Kluber and wrote about him last week. It’s hard to believe his underlying skills are sustainable, but he’s clearly pitching much better than his results would have you believe.

You may not have noticed, but since the disastrous month of April, Jarrod Parker’s skills have rebounded back to normal levels. Of course, normal levels aren’t all that exciting to me and he has remained at this ranking since the preseason. Kevin Gausman makes his rankings debut and really, he could be a lot higher or a lot lower by the end of the season. So far, his skills have been uninspiring. Despite being armed with a fastball that would rate first in average velocity among all starters, his SwStk% is very disappointing. He’s not in the greatest situation to succeed given his home park and division, but it’s hard not to be intrigued by his Double-A success and the quality of his stuff.

As expected, Jose Quintana’s skills have declined a bit in May, but not enough to make him completely worthless. Nick Tepesh’s extremely ground ball ways make him a poor man’s Cobb. He should remain a surprisingly decent pitcher, but a below average strikeout rate caps his fantasy value.

The Great Disappointment

Ubaldo Jimenez
Rick Porcello
Jason Vargas
Bud Norris
Tommy Hanson
Mark Buehrle
Zach McAllister
Wade Davis
Chris Tillman
Scott Diamond

I moved Ubaldo Jimenez to the top of this tier, but that’s all I could muster. His May skills surge is intriguing, but one month isn’t enough for me to declare that he’s back, or anywhere close to it. Still, he certainly offers more upside than most of the dreck in this tier. Rick Porcello also gets a half-hearted endorsement on the heels of a strong May. He still has to deal with that terrible infield defense though and it’s still up for debate where his true talent strikeout ability currently stands.

I identified Bud Norris as a potential strikeout rate surger a couple of days ago, which is something his owners are praying for given his weak other skills. Unfortunately, his ERA is headed upward whether his strikeout rate rebounds or not and he’s just not in a good situation to earn any fantasy value. Zach McAllister sports a SIERA mark more than a full run above his actual ERA. He also doesn’t own a strong strikeout rate so once that regression takes place, he won’t provide any value whatsoever.

Hurt

Jake Peavy
Brandon Morrow
Matt Harrison
J.A. Happ
Wei-Yin Chen
Brett Anderson
Brett Myers





Mike Podhorzer is the founder of ProjectingX IQ, an advanced fantasy baseball analytics platform that transforms projection data and in-season performance signals into actionable intelligence. He is the 2015 Fantasy Sports Writers Association Baseball Writer of the Year and three-time Tout Wars champion. He is the author of the eBook Projecting X 2.0: How to Forecast Baseball Player Performance, which teaches you how to project players yourself. Follow Mike on X@MikePodhorzer and contact him via email.

85 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Yah-seal Pweeg
13 years ago

Porcello’s May peripherals would suggest he is not quite a disappointment

ryan
13 years ago

Justin grimm living on the edge and hector santiago is back…any thoughts?

NJ
13 years ago

What about Bartolo Colon?

Pudieron89
13 years ago

Where is bartolo? He belongs at least in tier 5, possibly even 4. Some very strong starts as of late and he’ll always help out with K/BB.

wjylaw
13 years ago

Stopped reading once I saw the ridiculous Iwakuma ranking.

Jordan
13 years ago
Reply to  wjylaw

Agreed. Not really a “ridiculous” ranking but i think he deserves to be at least one tier higher. If not more.

Scottttttt
13 years ago

I have both Hisashi Iwakuma & C.J. Wilson. They’re not in the same tier. They’re not where NEAR in the same tier.

Mark
13 years ago
Reply to  Scottttttt

I normally don’t care what so called expert rankinngs are but it seems a little bizarre how low Iwakuma is ranked. He basically has done this since he became a starter in July of last year. That’s a full season of amazing stats. All of the peripherals seem to confirm this.

Mister
13 years ago
Reply to  Mark

Why isn’t the walk rate sustainable? I thought that generally walk rate was a repeatable skill. Iwakuma has been pretty strong in F-Strike% (65.7%) and Zone% (48.6%), but admittedly not phenomenal. His real strength is that he gets batters to swing at his pitches outside the zone at an extremely high rate (O-Swing of 36.5%, highest in the AL). Is that not a sustainable skill?

I get the innings concern. However, I’m less concerned about a Japanese veteran tiring after 180 innings or so than I am a rookie. Also, from a pitch count perspective Iwakuma might be in a better spot, because he has been so efficient and kept getting pulled early in the beginning of the season due to blister troubles. I never understood why managers look at IP instead of pitches thrown when they’re worried about tiring their pitchers near the end of the season.

Mister
13 years ago
Reply to  Mark

Well, I was mostly thinking of his 4% BB%, not his 1.3 BB/9. His BB/9 should increase even if his BB% stays the same due to BABIP regression. As the BABIP increases, he’ll be allowing more hits, which means getting fewer outs in between his walks, which means more walks on a per inning basis.
For what it’s worth, which is admittedly not a lot, Iwakuma did have 3 seasons in Japan with BB/9s between 1.4 and 1.6. Yes, I’m cherry-picking, as his other seasons saw BB/9s between 2 and 2.8.
I think this is basically a philosophical disagreement. I ran into this same type of disagreement about Mike Trout before the season. I thought it was silly that people were projecting him to hit .280 after he hit .326 in almost a full season in 2012. I agreed with the naysayers that his BABIP would regress, I just didn’t think it would regress by 60 points. Basically, the naysayers said “NOBODY is that good,” and I said, “The only evidence we have shows this particular player being that good.”

Yes, when you see someone putting up video game numbers, it’s prudent to expect him to regress, I get that. However, it seems to me that there’s almost a fallacy of over-predicting regression that comes into play when dealing with these outlying strong performances in limited but not completely insignificant sample sizes. It’s almost like some people punish a player’s projection for his success, based on his success being so good that it’s “unsustainable.”

I certainly could be wrong. I certainly don’t project player performance as a full-time job. Perhaps since you do this regularly, you frequently see players put up 4% BB% for 88 innings and have observed that they regress much more heavily than I realize. I don’t mean to be disrespectful; I’m just trying to understand the philosophy behind these projections.

Mister
13 years ago
Reply to  Mark

Listened to the podcast. Just bought your book too! I understand your perspective on how unproven Iwakuma is. I think I’d still rather have him than many guys in the 3rd tier because of his upside. Having drafted him in an AL only keeper league for $3 this year though, I’ll be holding on to him and hoping he really is as good as what he’s shown so far this year. I’ve tested the trade market in my league, trying to sell high, and it does seem like most people are still pretty skeptical.

KCExile
13 years ago
Reply to  Mark

It’s my understanding that the 32 downside part of his career thing is more of a bell curve for hitters and less understood/consistently predictable for pitchers. Can you speak to this?

Dan GreerMember since 2018
13 years ago

For the first time in a while, Verlander’s ERA is significantly above his ERA. For the past two years, the reverse has been true…

Oof.

MDLMember since 2021
13 years ago
Reply to  Dan Greer

Looks like the second one should be FIP.

Ross
13 years ago

what about AJ Griffen not even a write up on him. He is a superstar

Jeff
13 years ago

Seriously, who would not trade CC or Shields for Scherzer at this point? How can a site with a quantitative focus put Sabathia ahead of Scherzer?

lastguyoffthebench
13 years ago

What kind of trade value could you get for Iwakuma? In a standard league would Ortiz for Iwakuma be a fair trade?

pudieron89
13 years ago

no

lastguyoffthebench
13 years ago
Reply to  pudieron89

so who would you rather have, Ortiz or Iwakuma? I was able to trade Iwakuma and get Shields.

rustydudeMember since 2021
13 years ago

Maybe if you have an owner in your league who likes to chase shiny new objects. Iwakuma hasn’t even been a starter continuously across 365 days. Best to just hold onto him until his value builds, with time.

Jeff
13 years ago

Seriously,

Sabathia – 3.66 FIP, 8.09 K/9, 1.24 WHIP
Shields – 3.26 FIP, 8.16 K/9,1.05 WHIP
Scherzer – 2.45 FIP, 10.73 K/9, .89 WHIP

WTF? Scherzer has been a bit lucky on babip and Sabathia unlucky, but really, what’s the rationale here?

Steve
13 years ago
Reply to  Jeff

I have to agree with Jeff. Sabathia’s been gracefully declining, and Scherzer arguably hasn’t peaked yet. At this point, I think he’s legit enough to be a top-5 AL pitcher. Once his strand rate normalizes, his ERA should be microscopic. I’d rather have him going forward than Sabathia or Shields.

Clifford
13 years ago
Reply to  Jeff

just speculation, but its likely Scherzer’s .253 BABIP combined with an unsustainable 0.71 HR/9 rate, and a decline in fastball velocity? just a guess though. I would trade CC or Shields for Scherzer 10 seconds ago.

Steve
13 years ago
Reply to  Clifford

The BABIP is a little low, yes, but it comes with an above-average LD%. Plus, his problem in the past had been a high BABIP, so this is showing that perhaps his true talent is something like a league-average BABIP, which would be beneficial. The main factor in his ERA right now is his terrible strand rate, which hasn’t been a problem in the past and will likely normalize. His velocity is down from last season, but it’s been increasing so far this season, and right now it’s right at his career average, so it doesn’t seem like an issue.

Mister
13 years ago

I’m baffled by the Iwakuma ranking. He belongs at least in the 3rd tier, if not 2nd. He’s top 10 in the AL in FIP, xFIP, and SIERA, and 3rd in BB%. That ultra-low BB% will continue to translate to an outstanding WHIP for him. There is not a single pitcher in the 3rd tier for whom I would trade Iwakuma. In the 2nd tier, I would not trade Iwakuma for either Sabathia or Price.

And why is Bartolo Colon ignored? He’s another WHIP stud.

Bebop
13 years ago
Reply to  Mister

You wouldn’t trade Iwakuma for David Price? You are patently nuts.

Pat G
13 years ago

Is that a My Chemical Romance reference in there? throwin it back to HS for sure

Clifford
13 years ago

Jarrod Parker is simply too low IMO. I realize that he had an awful start to the season, but he’s been really good as of late. In his last 5 starts, he’s 3-1 with a 2.41 ERA, 0.89 WHIP, 26/10 K/BB, and .208 BAA. Honestly, if someone offered you Scott Kazmir, Fausto, Duobront, Hughes, Hammel, or Hellickson for Parker, would you even consider it for a second? Id take him over everyone in Tier 4 except Iwakuma(whose ranking is laughably low).

Jay
13 years ago

Cliff Lee?

Jay
13 years ago

Sorry. AL only. My mistake. Good List and commentary.

mike
13 years ago

where does mike minor fall on this list

mike
13 years ago
Reply to  mike

sorry my mistake AL only

JV
13 years ago

Where’s Bumgarner?

JV
13 years ago
Reply to  JV

Haha, AL only… like everyone else said

MDLMember since 2021
13 years ago

Clayton Kershaw??!?!?!?!?!

MDLMember since 2021
13 years ago
Reply to  MDL

My fault, my fault… AL only

James
13 years ago

I stopped reading as soon as I got to the end of the article.

Ridiculous.

Trevor
13 years ago

Where is Michael Morse?

Oh, it’s a starting pitching ranking.

My bad.

Mike
13 years ago

Am I just missing Cliff Lee? I don’t see him on search either.

Mike
13 years ago

My bad, as soon as I posted that I realized it’s AL only…..I will work on reading.

Gob Bluth
13 years ago

Sabathia in the same tier as Darvish and Felix seems crazy to me.

I’d even rank Darvish over Verlander right now.

Lee
13 years ago

Miguel Gonzalez and Ivan Nova: see any potential value from either of these guys for the rest of the season? I know Nova got bumped from the rotation and down to AAA, but I imagine he returns to the rotation eventually.

Tage
13 years ago

Unreal. Iwakuma gets little respect in the mainstream media. I would have thought that a site devoted to analyzing pitchers would not group him with Hellickson (5.6 ERA), Wilson (4 ERA / 1.4 WHIP), etc. He was a stud for 16 games last year and elite this year. That’s all we have to go off of so why is there so much disrespect?

all of god's children
13 years ago
Reply to  Tage

Re: ‘disrespect’

I don’t think that word means what you think it means. It does not automatically get invoked if someone happens to differ with you on something as trivial and subjective as a pitcher ranking.

Cordially,
Planet Earth

atoms
13 years ago

What’s wrong with the word “disrespect”? I think it’s totally fair to make the argument that the author’s ranking does not give Iwakuma full respect for his abilities.

ed
13 years ago

Josh Johnson returned from the DL on Tuesday and got good results, but his fastball velocity was down a bit. His league, home park and injury history prevents me from moving him any higher.

For what it’s worth, the Blue Jays have had the same basic park factor as the Marlins and Royals for a little while now.

ed
13 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Well, unless the homers inflate the actual number of runs scored, then they aren’t really an issue, right? ER count the same no matter how they’re scored.

I suppose if Johnson were more prone to giving up home runs than average you might be somewhat concerned, but that doesn’t appear to be the case. Johnson hasn’t been prone to giving up lots of HR over his career.

ed
13 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Also, Rogers has been at 101, 101, 100, and 100 for 2008-2011. That’s pretty much neutral. By that standard, the Marlins play in a hitter’s park.

ed
13 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Even with a likely higher HR/FB rate, Johnson’s also shown some groudball-y tendencies as well, although he’s been a bit up and down there.

It’s always interesting to revisit park factors every so often. Apparently the Phillies’ park has actually played pretty neutral over the last few years. I would not have guessed!

BStu185
13 years ago

I wish RG would just do mixed league rankings, not only because they’d actually be useful, but also to eliminate the “Durrr, where is [insert player from other league?” comments.

Brian
13 years ago

This is a pretty suspect ranking from top-to-bottom, sorry.

Sabathia is way way too high. You have to know that. Darvish probably belongs in the top tier with Verlander, at the very least above Sabathia. Same goes for Scherzer.

Shields is nice but to be in Tier 2 ahead of guys like Anibal Sanchez and Chris Sale? I don’t think so. Jered Weaver is nice too, but just back from injury and with his peripherals dropping off last year it’s a risky rank.

Finally, the rest of the commenters are right that the Iwakuma ranking is insane. He’s sandwiched between Josh Johnson (injury prone, just returning, awful this year) and Ryan Dempster of the 3 wins and 4.39 ERA. C’mon man.

James
13 years ago
Reply to  Brian

Why are people citing small sample sizes, wins, and ERA on fangraphs?

Brian
13 years ago
Reply to  James

None of these guys are my fantasy players. I just don’t have time to write a thesis.

Its comments like yours that really alienate non-sabermetrically minded people.

I cited wins and ERA to show that Dempster hasn’t been a great fantasy asset this year … these are shorthand in addition to the fact that I know his FIP, K/9, SwStk% similarly should place him far beneath Iwakuma.

You don’t have better knowledge than me. Why don’t you take on the facts rather than the fact that the presentation doesn’t meet your snobby saber-standards? There is no SIERA in fantasy.

Brian
13 years ago
Reply to  James

Fine. But wins are a fantasy stat, and Dempster is projected to only win 6 more for the rest of the season, with a 4.66 ERA and 4.31 FIP. What are you proving by telling me that something counted in the past is in the past?

Is it your position that wins don’t reflect at all on a pitcher’s performance? Conversations like this are making me start to hate the saber community that I once loved. Any knucklehead can bash wins and say there are better stats, but wins still exist and can be indicative of plenty.

Brian
13 years ago
Reply to  James

Thats a much better argument.

But Dempster’s walks are up and his velocity is down, and he’s pitching for the Red Sox now which is not a favorable place to be a pitcher.

His FIP is 4.56 and his xFIP is 3.84. Even if you use SIERA as you do it’s 3.77.

The original point is that he should be nowhere near Iwakuma, who has a 1.94 ERA, 3.23 FIP, 3.23 xFIP and pitches in a huge home park.

TheTinDoor
13 years ago

Glad to see Verlander still #1. You don’t even have to get into BABIP, SIERA, or SwStk%. All you need to know about his disappointing rate stats is his line from 5/16 at Texas.
2.2 IP, 8 ER, 8 baserunners – worst start of the past few seasons, at least.

If you toss out that start, he’s got a 2.81 ERA and his WHIP drops by .06. K-Rate is still elite (10.7 K/9).

Of course you can’t do that with his existing stats. That start happened. But for a predictive measure, unless you saw something in that start that you expect to be repeated, I think the rest of his season looks right in line with his historical numbers.

Darrell Berger
13 years ago

As a fan who watches most Tigers games I can give you my scouting report, or biased opinion, whichever. I think Verlander’s arm is just 30 years old after throwing lots of pitches for several years. He’s going through the transition that many aces do: he has lost a bit of arm speed and must adjust. We have seen very little of the excellent curve he broke out at the end of 2011 and enabled him to be the best pitcher in baseball the following year. He may for the next few years not be the best, but perhaps say, one of the top ten. Scherzer is really the best pitcher on the staff right now. Sanchez’ K rate has risen because of great use of the changeup and general mixing of pitches. Porcello’s last two starts may be teasers, or they may be signs that he is becoming what Tigers always thought he would. He still does not know how to regroup, rattles too easily. That’s why once he gives up a hit or two, he tends to give up 5 runs rather than one or two. If he pitched with the meanness of Fister he would be a much improved pitcher.

Brian
13 years ago
Reply to  Darrell Berger

Darrell — so Sanchez passes the eye-test for you? I can look at the stats and say he’s been great, but I haven’t had the opportunity to watch him pitch.

Any fall off since his 19-K performance? That was a lot of pitches.

Paul
13 years ago

I need to pick a stop starter with Peavy on the DL. Which out of these Ogando, Wood, Lincecum (on waivers), Griffin, Cingrani, Parker (waivers), Cashner. 6X5 H2H.

Name
13 years ago

Mike Pelfrey?

AngMohClay
13 years ago

Roberto Hernandez should not be a tier above Bartolo Colon. I also think Yu should be in the first tier. With a premium offense, and him having shown the ability to throw many pitches, his win chances are elite. He’ll lead the MLB in strikeouts this year, and one only need to watch him pitch (or just look at that amazing GIF) to know that his insane 34.8 K% is sustainable (or at least something in that ridiculous territory). His ERA is backed up by all of the peripheral based metrics (FIP,xFIP, SIERRA). I’m not sure if I would trade Verlander for him straight up, but he’s the only pitcher that would make you really think deeply about that.

Nick
13 years ago

Would you rather have Roberto Hernandez or Kazmir?

Nick
13 years ago

You really aren’t more concerned about Dickey? Take away his 2 starts against the Giants, and things are real ugly. Even with them, his K/9,BB/9 and lost velocity would have me much more concerned than what your rankings suggest.

Nick
13 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Ok fair enough but like I said even with those 2 his numbers and peripherals are bad. I guess the Giants are particularly noteworthy because they are in the NL. Honestly, when he only struck out 2 Braves (who are striking out at a 24% clip) that’s when I lost hope.

day
13 years ago

to me, scherzer is number one as of right now…and for the allstar vote, shouldn’t that be all that matters? he just went up to 9-0 and has over 100 strike outs. he has been fun to watch this season, even more so than the end of last year.