What Should We Make of Tim Lincecum
The 2013 season was a mixed bag for Tim Lincecum. Nothing epitomized his season more than his starts on July 13th and 22nd. The first was a no hitter against the Padres while the second was a 3.2 inning, eight run shelling against the Reds. All season long, he mixed great and poor outings with no rhyme or reason. The Giants were nice enough to reward him handsomely with a two-year, $35 million contract before he could reach free agency, but should fantasy owners be similarly generous?
According to Zach Sanders’ valuation, Lincecum was a replacement level fantasy hurler in 2013, at least for owners in traditional 5×5 leagues. He was worth negative 60 cents which ranked him as the 83rd best pitcher, smack dab between Rick Porcello and Alexi Ogando.
Lincecum’s 4.37 ERA was one of several drawbacks to his season, but for those fantasy owners who play in FIP-based points leagues, he was much better. He posted over 4.3 points per inning in Ottoneu’s FanGraphs Points format, which is above average for a starting pitcher. In that format, he was the 44th best pitcher by raw points total with a comparable season to Jose Quintana or Ubaldo Jimenez. It seems to me that format matters more when evaluating Lincecum than it does for most other pitchers.
Despite seeing his average fastball velocity decline over the years – from 94 mph in 2008 to 90 mph the past two seasons – Lincecum still generates the same frequency of whiffs as he did in his heyday. He’s been able to maintain that overall whiff rate by scaling up the usage of his slider. It’s also worth noting that his fastball whiff rate has only declined about half a percent.
Lincecum has been remarkably durable throughout his career despite every scout in the world predicting his inevitable doom. He’s started at least 32 games in every full season of his career. His innings pitched totals have declined below 200 in the past two seasons, but that’s due to performance rather than durability. He’s thrown roughly 16 pitches per inning in most seasons, a rate that held up in 2013. So he’s not working harder to get his outs, he’s just being pulled earlier. That corroborates the theory that his reduced workload is purely performance based.
Throwing more sliders increases his injury risk. He uses the pitch a little over one-fifth of the time, a trend that began just three seasons ago. Jeff Zimmerman, who handles our disabled list projections and recently published his 2014 list, has found that heavy slider usage correlates with injuries. However, Jeff sets the threshold for ‘slider risk’ at 30 percent, a rate which Lincecum has never reached. When asked, Jeff explained that “the 30% slider value pushed the DL% chance significantly above the 40% league average DL chance.” For what it’s worth, Lincecum has a fairly low chance to hit the disabled list in 2014 at 32 percent (yes, 32 percent is a relatively low risk for a starting pitcher).
His change-up is also a go to pitch for him. As you can see from his pitch usage chart (below), he loves to use the pitch when ahead of left-handed batters. He also uses it frequently against right-handed batters. Brooks Baseball classifies the pitch as a split, although Lincecum considers it a change-up.
Most of his trouble these past two seasons can be attributed to allowing more home runs. Hitters pounded his change-up in 2012, but last season they feasted on his fastball. 10 of the 21 home runs he allowed were on fastballs, yet he’s only allowed 33 home runs on fastballs throughout his entire career. It’s not fair to compare his fastball in 2008 to 2013, but we can probably expect fewer home runs next season. His xFIP was 3.56 last season. If Lincecum can perform to that predictor, then he’ll be useful in nearly all leagues.
When and where to target Lincecum next season is a bit nuanced. Clearly, owners in FIP-based leagues can be more aggressive. His high ERA’s may even artificially reduce his cost, although I would expect owners in FIP-based leagues to be particularly savvy about misleading statistics. Owners in traditional leagues may want to be more restrained. As a best case scenario, Lincecum could pitch to his xFIP and post a 3.60 ERA, win about 12 games, and post a league average WHIP. That’s pretty similar to what Gio Gonzalez did this past season and he was worth $9.
If Lincecum has another season with home run problems, then he’s much more likely to post a $0 to $5 season. Lincecum’s average auction cost was $7 last season according to Fantasy Pros and I expect a similar cost of acquisition next spring. Lincecum’s best skill seems to be his durability. You can’t count on Lincecum to help you in any category besides strikeouts, but he could give you 200 innings of decent baseball. Winning pitching rate stats always requires luck. Lincecum might be a decent investment if you’re looking to catch lightning in a bottle.
You can follow me on twitter @BaseballATeam



Lincecum has drastically underperformed his FIP two straight seasons in a row. That will likely continue. The problem is his K/9 and BB/9 rates with men on base have plummeted. He is still good with men on base, but from the stretch he is a below average pitcher.
I don’t know how I failed to comment directly about his FIP. I guess I’m tired of talking about it 🙂
Here is link on FIP underperformers – http://hiddenvigorish.com/2013/12/the-anatomy-of-fip-underperformers/
Solid article Marcus, but I believe you failed to eliminate a possible explanation with Lincecum. While Nolasco has shown this problem with men on base his entire career, Lincecum has fallen into it recently. That could mean that he has taken to approaching hitters differently with men on base rather than simply being worse out of the stretch. The increase in walk rate does support your theory.
I don’t have the database (or querying skill) to test whether he approached hitters differently with men on base, and I’m not saying that’s what I believe to be the case. It’s just a possible explanation that hasn’t been ruled out.
Thanks Brad. This is just an opinion with nothing to base it on really, but I think Lincecum can’t get away with his drop in velocity as much out of the stretch. He still has the deception in his windup to cover for the 2 or 3 mph loss off his fastball.
So I took a look at some additional splits and what it smells like to me is that the drop in strikeout rate is much more “real” than the increase in walk rate.
His walk rates were as follows last season:
No one on: 3.31 BB/9
runners on: 3.65
scoring pos: 4.70
That basically says that his walk rate was lower with runners on first than with the bases empty. If I calc’d it right (it’s 5:30 AM so I might have botched it 🙂 ), he had a 3.12 BB/9 with runners on first base.
When I say smells, I mean no rigorous analysis was done, I just looked at the numbers.
If you watch most of his games, like I do, you would see that he indeed loses command when he goes into the stretch. The typical pattern is he will sail along for 2-3 innings not allowing anything, then a runner gets on base. Boom! He just loses it, wild high, walking guys, giving up strings of hits. That is the discrepancy in his ERA vs FIP right there. He gives up his walks and hits in bunches.
I’m just gonna keep drafting him ’cause he’s Timmy. No rational relationship with Tim Lincecum for me.
A hat.
A boat.
A pterodactyl.
Broach.
There’s a sale at Penneys!
Timmy has had his ups and downs physically. After 2010, he decided he needed to be stronger, so he bulked up by gorging on In-N-Out double-doubles, french fries and milkshakes. By late in the season, he looked puffy and doughy. For 2011, he decided he needed to be thinner and healthier so he cut out the In-N-Out and swam for his workouts. by mid-season, he was rail thin and this uniform was hanging off of him. Finally last year, he got serious about a rational athletic diet and workout regimen. For what it’s worth, he appeared to get stronger as the season progressed even though he still had his ups and downs in games. Reports are that he is enthusiastically continuing that regimen this offseason. I don’t know how that will translate into results, but I am looking forward to watching a strong Timmy all season.
The way the splits are divided up is a bit deceiving. From the blowup game following his no-hitter, Timmy allowed 33 ER in 77.2 IP over the remainder of the season for an ERA of 3.80. That one blowup game raised his second half split by .74. He also had back-to-back games where he allowed 6 runs and 5 runs. Take out those two games plus his post no-no blowup, he had an ERA of 3.00 in his other 10 second half starts.
I think there is a better than even chance we will see a Timmy with an ERA in the mid 3’s in 2014.
But every pitcher is better when you arbitrarily toss a quarter of his start. (The no-hitter was an outlier, too, so you should probably eject that one, right?) The total package includes bad days, so you gotta look at the total package.
It is not arbitrary. There is a big difference between a pitcher who gets shelled in 3 out of 13 starts but is great the other 10, as opposed to one who gives up 4 runs every start. Personally, I’d much rather have the guy who gets shelled once in awhile. It does not matter whether you lose by 1 run or by 6, you still lost. I’d rather have the better chance of winning the other 10.
In addition, I believe that the fact Timmy as so good in most of his games bodes well for 2014 assuming he continues his strength, conditioning and diet program.
Also, the no-hitter was an outlier in hits/baserunners allowed, but I was not counting WHIP. It was not an outlier in terms of ER allowed.
Also, I did not count either the no-no or the post-no-no blow-up game in the 3.80 second half ERA post blow-up.
I thought your comment about Lincecum’s value being format dependent was particularly insightful. He’s nearly unusable in H2H leagues because he’s a huge risk to shit the bed on any given outing.
On a personal note, I’m glad to see him back with the Giants. Now I can keep wearing my “Let Timmy Smoke” shirt to the park.