Trevor Cahill & Ryan Rua: Deep League Wire
Baseball in 2015 has finally begun! Well, the version that actually counts has. So it’s time to dig deep and uncover those hidden gems that could lead you to victory. As usual, the deep league wire will include names owned in 10% and less of CBS leagues and usually be players whose value is confined to deep mixed or mono leagues, unless otherwise noted.
Trevor Cahill | SP ATL | CBS 10% Owned
The Diamondbacks entered spring training with about 67 starting pitchers battling it out for just five rotation spots. They also had Tommy John surgery returnees to look forward to later on in the year in the form of both Patrick Corbin and Bronson Arroyo. So it wasn’t too surprising that the D-Backs chose to reduce some of that serious depth by trading away Cahill last week. After a fortunate BABIP-fueled breakout season back in 2010 with the Athletics, Cahill has oscillated around league average levels, before bottoming out with a 5.61 ERA last year in Arizona.
But if we look past the surface stats, we find that his overall peripherals package remained similar to where it has always been. He was done in by absolutely atrocious defense this time around, which also deflated his LOB%. But his strikeout rate actually jumped to a career high, likely boosted by his relief appearances. Both his changeup and curve ball were fantastic at inducing swinging strikes. The move to Atlanta should benefit Cahill, as he gets out of a difficult environment for pitchers to a much more pitcher friendly park. He’s obviously not going to get much run support, but his ratios should improve significantly.
Of course, he has apparently changed his mechanics which Eno has already discussed. So we cannot necessarily rely on his historical skill metrics to get a good idea of what to expect from him. But he’s got the extreme ground ball profile and shown the ability to punch out hitters at around a league average clip. So the seeds are there and perhaps the new mechanics could help him improve the last piece of the puzzle — his control.
Ryan Rua | OF TEX | 7%
The Rangers entered spring training with literally five candidates for the starting left field job. Rua was the lucky man to win out, though fantasy owners don’t seem so enthused. Last year, our own prospect guru Kiley McDaniel rated him as just the 21st best prospect in the Rangers system and considered him having “corner utility/platoon” upside. His power is his best tool, though outside his monstrous 2013 performance at Single-A where he posted a .308 ISO, he hasn’t exceeed a .192 mark at any other level.
The projections suggest that a full-season would yield about 15 homers, which is nothing special for an outfielder. But he does pair that with a touch of speed. He swiped 14 bases in 2013 and seven last year, which isn’t anything exciting to be sure. But it means that perhaps he could steal 5-10 bases over a full season. If his ultimate upside over a full season is 15 homers and 10 steals, that’s pretty darn valuable in a deep league.
Unfortunately, he doesn’t have the greatest of job security. Jake Smolinski is no standout, but he remains on the roster as a bench bat, while former prospect Michael Choice toils away in the minors. If Rua stumbles, either of those two could conceivably take over. But that’s why Rua is strictly a deep leaguer at this point.
Mike Podhorzer is the founder of ProjectingX IQ, an advanced fantasy baseball analytics platform that transforms projection data and in-season performance signals into actionable intelligence. He is the 2015 Fantasy Sports Writers Association Baseball Writer of the Year and three-time Tout Wars champion. He is the author of the eBook Projecting X 2.0: How to Forecast Baseball Player Performance, which teaches you how to project players yourself. Follow Mike on X@MikePodhorzer and contact him via email.
Travis Snider or Ryan Rua? Or is that just a toss up?
Haiku answer:
T. Snider for sure
I think he hits twenty out
Much better hitter
Snider for sure
How does Rua compare to Kiermaier? I see better speed and a more locked spot, less power?
Better speed and position for Kiermaier but less power. More power better hitting for Rua.
Kiermaier will sit against lefties so I think that makes me lean toward Rua. At least in he short term for as long as he has a staring job.
Rua also qualifies at 3b which is more useful
Cahill’s 2014 was not really as bad as advertised. Yeah, he had a 5.61 ERA but with a 3.89 FIP, 3.83 xFIP, and 3.96 SIERA, all three of which were the second best of his career. His .350 BABIP and 62.6 strand rate seem to be the main culprits for his bad year, since they far exceeded his .285 and 71.8 career numbers. Also, his K/9 as a starter would have been a career high regardless of relief appearances, at 8.07. I think he could have a real bounceback year in ATL in front of what should be very good infield and outfield defenses in a good pitcher’s park. He’s already been snapped up in my league unfortunately.