The Yankees Infield: Big Names, Not Much Game

It’s time for our Depth Chart Discussions to begin. In an effort to suss out every team, we’ve divided them into four parts (infield, outfield, bullpen, and rotation) and will begin breaking them down for you over the next few weeks. You can find them gathered here.

I wrote about the New York Yankees starting rotation last week and — seeing as I’ve already spent plenty of quality time with their depth chart — I decided to tackle their infield as well. (I will not be including a separate designated-hitter portion of this piece; I think that position will be a revolving door of several guys who I’ll already be covering positionally.)

CATCHER

Brian McCann
JR Murphy

I’ll get this out of the way right now: I’m not expecting any Yankee infielders to be valuable mixed-league fantasy assets. The only exception is behind the dish, as Brian McCann suffered through one of the worst offensive seasons of his career in 2014, yet still managed to finish the year as the No. 9 fantasy catcher.

McCann is possibly the most predictable power hitter in the history of baseball. Since 2006, the 31-year-old backstop has averaged 21.6 homers per year — never dipping below 18 dingers, and never exceeding 24. Last year, his value was held down by his .232 batting average, partially due to seeing an ever-increasing number of right-field shifts. Additionally, McCann saw his walk rate drop to a career-low 5.9%, and his resulting on-base percentage was just .286 — a far cry from his career .343 mark.

Whether he can overcome the shifts or not, it’s pretty much unthinkable in my opinion that McCann will put up another .286 OBP season in 2015. Steamer has him projected for .251/.317/.445, and I really like that projection. I’d be comfortable putting him in the No. 6-8 range for fantasy catchers — somewhere mixed in with guys like Yadier Molina and Matt Wieters in that middle tier of mixed-league backstops.

If McCann gets hurt, JR Murphy could be a look in AL-only leagues. Murphy doesn’t really excel in any one area, but he’s a decent hitter with some pop. Austin Romine may be the more likely choice to start the year on the 25-man roster, seeing as he’s out of options, but the Yanks have had Romine in their system for eight full years, and I highly doubt he’ll ever see significant major-league playing time. Gary Sanchez is still hanging around too, but his prospect status has faded considerably, and he’s unlikely to stick behind the plate.

FIRST BASE

Mark Teixeira
Garrett Jones

Is there anyone still out there who views Mark Teixeira as a viable mixed-league fantasy first-base option? Okay, good. If he stays healthy, he’ll likely hit 20+ home runs. Still, first base is so deep in fantasy that Teixeira is unlikely to provide much for fantasy owners in his age-35 season — especially with the erosion of his ability to consistently make solid contact.

To be perfectly honest, I’m not sure I’m all that much more confident in Teixeira’s abilities than I am in his new teammate, Garrett Jones. Jones will see some time at first, DH and in the outfield, and he could make for a nice platoon option for those of you in AL-only leagues. Kind of like Teixeira, just with a less-clear path to regular playing time.

SECOND BASE

Stephen Drew
Rob Refsnyder

In all likelihood, Stephen Drew will be the Yankees’ starting second baseman on Opening Day. He will be completely irrelevant. However, I’d be shocked if Rob Refsnyder doesn’t snag the job from him sooner rather than later.

Drew is made of glass, will be 32 years old by Opening Day, and hit .162/.237/.299 last year — including a downright hilarious .150/.219/.271 line in his 46 games with the Yanks. Drew is a considerably more reliable defender than Refsnyder — and the latter isn’t on the 40-man — so he’ll probably be the starter for a couple months.

Refsnyder’s ceiling is likely that of a second-division regular, as he possesses a solid hit tool with enough pop to avoid being just an empty batting average. Entering his age-24 season, Refsnyder has solid plate discipline and a little bit of speed — low double-digit homers and steals in a full major-league season wouldn’t be surprising.

Keep an eye on the Yanks over the next several weeks. If they find a way to work Refsnyder onto the 40-man, he could be worth a long look in AL-only leagues.

SHORTSTOP

Didi Gregorius
Brendan Ryan

Didi Gregorius will get the lion’s share of playing time at shortstop, where he is a whiz with the glove. However, through 191 major-league games, his weighted offense is 16% below league-average, with a paltry .243/.313/.366 slash line. He doesn’t steal bases, and he has just 13 homers in his 724 plate appearances. He’s on the fringe of viable shortstop options in AL-only leagues.

Brendan Ryan? No.

THIRD BASE

Chase Headley
Alex Rodriguez

I think we all know by now that Chase Headley’s 31-homer season in 2012 was about as flukey as flukes get. After all, he hit exactly one-third of his career homers that year, in just 17.7% of his career plate appearances. In the two years since, he’s managed just 26 homers combined.

After being traded to the Bronx last year, the 30-year-old hit a healthy .262/.371/.398, but the big question remains: Can he hit for enough power to be fantasy-relevant in mixed leagues? 36 of his 50 hits as a Yankee were singles, and third base is looking like a very deep position this year.

Furthermore, the specter of Alex Rodriguez looms. I don’t expect A-Rod to get much playing time at third base — and neither do our projections — but with Headley already looking like a borderline option, the mere presence of A-Rod could very likely Ralph Nader him out of fantasy relevance.

We hoped you liked reading The Yankees Infield: Big Names, Not Much Game by Scott Strandberg!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs




Scott Strandberg started writing for Rotographs in 2013. He works in small business consultation, and he also writes A&E columns for The Norman Transcript newspaper. Scott lives in Seattle, WA.

newest oldest most voted
troy
Guest
troy

Maybe ARod can play short again? They say he has lost a lot of weight. Think of the range, think of the range.

TreeFrog
Guest
TreeFrog

If the Yankees were smart, they would try this – Stick him at short and in a matter of a game or two he’d blow out a knee, then they don’t have to worry about him again.

pft
Guest
pft

Arod’s never had knee problems. At worst he blows out a hamstring. No salary relief there. Frankly, its doubtful they managed to obtain insurance on him that does not exclude pre-existing conditions since most coverage must be renewed every 3-5 years

Quite Serious
Guest
Quite Serious

I very seriously had this same thought. Let’s say the Yankees season goes down the tubes by the midway point of the season. They’re at 33-48 and Tanaka is knocked out, whatever.

Why in hell would the Yankees NOT ride A-Rod as hard as possible? Put him at SS every inning of every day until he blows out a knee or something. Yeah, it’s not the most ethical way to do things, but is there anything specifically against MLB rules here?

In fact, at that point, they should be batting him leadoff and sending him off on steals and hit and runs constantly, too.

Give him as much time on the field and bases and at the plate a possible. A big injury could save the Yanks $10-$20 million easy, or more.

I’m not suggesting this, mind you. Just musing out loud and wondering…

Cool Lester Smooth
Guest
Cool Lester Smooth

Think of Didi’s range, and realize that there’s no way in hell they’re putting a 39/40 year old out there?

murph3699
Member
murph3699

Makes sense but then again this is the organization who decided to let the 2nd best SS play the position since 2004.

Dan Greer
Member
Member
Dan Greer

You mean no way in hell they do it a 3rd consecutive year?