The Wobble that Derailed My Mock

Charlie Saponara of got a bunch of experts together for a mock draft last night. Yours truly may not have acquitted himself as well as he’d hoped. He blames the fact that his eyes are permanently crossed after editing 1083 player caps for the Second Opinion this weekend, but no-one wants to hear his excuses — especially now that he’s talking about himself in third person. The. Worst.

What had happened was: a little wobble, one botched pick, and you end up looking at a few spots on your roster with the stank eye. One wobble can bring the train down — and in this case Martin Prado might have been the one-man wobble, or maybe not. Maybe it started earlier.

Since I had the turn, let’s just assess the draft by every two picks.

1.12 Hanley Ramirez
2.1 Dustin Pedroia

Could have done this turn in my sleep, and I actually recommend it as a draft slot. This is a middle infield with a ton of upside in a year where shortstop looks like it might be really terrible. No problems here.

3.12 Dan Haren
4.1 Jay Bruce

Picking a pitcher this early is never easy, but it felt like the draft was pushing elite pitching early — Haren was only the ninth pitcher picked, and in that context I have no problem with taking him there. Once I saw that one of my favorite ‘late aces,’ David Price, was already gone, I sorta panicked. That was the first wobble — I would have been fine with Yovani Gallardo, Zack Greinke or Jon Lester as my first pitcher, and if Haren had been in the draft pool, I likely would have gotten one of them in round five. Bruce? It’s a five-outfield league and he should hit 30. Wanted power and an outfielder and he seems fine here.

But that pitcher pick really came back to bite me.

5.12 Eric Hosmer
6.1 Buster Posey

I have no complaints about these picks. Once Paul Konerko was gone, I realized that I needed a first baseman pretty badly, and “Hunter Pence at first base” was still out there — even if he doesn’t add a ton of power via an improved fly ball rate in 2012, he’ll be fine. And in a two-catcher league, getting a stud at the position in the sixth round seems just about right — especially 11 picks after Brian McCann.

So no real problems with the pick. That doesn’t mean I wasn’t already cursing my screen. I was hoping to pick Brett Lawrie with my fourth round pick, but when I picked the pitcher, I was stuck with only one position player pick, and the outfield seemed like more of a need. Then, in the next two rounds, Lawrie, Aramis Ramirez, and Pablo Sandoval all went, and I was angry.

Two lessons here. 1) Just because everyone else is picking pitching early, you don’t have to. 2) If you like a player, don’t worry about ADP too hard, take him. If you think Lawrie has the floor a .280 20/20 third baseman — and I do — then he’s a fine fourth-round pick. If you think pitching early is suspect because pitchers hit the DL more often and for longer than hitters, and there are only two pitching ‘positions,’ — and I do — then it’s fine to wait to pick the 12th-best ace. Just get one of the better number twos.

7.12 Jason Heyward
8.1 Dan Hudson

Fine place for two guys that could bounce back into star status. Hudson should strike more guys out this year based on his swinging strike rate, and Heyward just needs to be healthy for a year worthy of a second outfielder in a five-outfielder league. Heyward went between Drew Stubbs and Jayson Werth, and Hudson went between Matt Cain and Josh Beckett. Just right.

The wobble is still there, though: I thought, with Alex Rodriguez and Kevin Youkilis still on the table — and both looking old — that one would make it back to this pick. When they didn’t, the fear began to grip me. I had a ‘problem position’ suddenly.

9.12 Logan Morrison
10.1 Jonathan Papelbon

Looking back, I’m just happy I didn’t start panicking earlier. Well, the run on outfielders in round nine (Brett Gardner, Cameron Maybin, Ichiro Suzuki, and Lance Berkman) sorta made me nervous, but I like Logan Morrison this year. .280 and 25 shouldn’t be too difficult for him. And Papelbon’s strikeout rate makes him an elite closer that can help pad my strikeout category — that’s fine for double digit rounds.

Still no third baseman.

11.12 Tommy Hanson
12.1 Martin Prado

After taking a shot at an ace in the SP3 spot — a shot that most of the draft room was okay with — the panic finally got to me. Even though both Prado and David Freese were on the draft board, and most people had third basemen, I picked Prado, thinking he could play in the outfield if I got another third baseman later. This decision cost me more than any other decision in the draft.

13.12 Lucas Duda
14.1 Chris Carpenter

Yeah I love Lucas Duda, been touting him since mid-season last year, and think he can easily manage LoMo-like numbers for cheaper. And Chris Carpenter is a fine ace-lite with an SP3 cost.

But I missed out on Jason Kipnis. That one hurt. At 12.7, in a draft with an MI slot, Kipnis might have been the steal of the draft. We’ve been writing about how Kipnis is a better investment for the price than Dustin Ackley, and I’ve been drinking the kool-aid. One of stupid Freese or Prado would have dropped to me here, and I would take Jason Kipnis and Martin Prado over Chris Carpenter and Martin Prado. Yup, this one made me angry.

15.12 Jordan Walden
16.1 Chris Sale

Love my pitching. Hate my third baseman.

17.12 Zack Cozart
18.1 Colby Rasmus

Cozart is a decent Kipnis-lite, but he’s older, was considered less of a prospect, and just doesn’t have the same upside. Love my outfield. Still hate my third baseman.

19.12 Ryan Roberts
20.1 Chris Perez

So I needed a backup MI and a backup third baseman — all because I didn’t pick Brett Lawrie earlier in the draft. So I picked Ryan Roberts here, which is fine, but the dude is 31 already and could easily disappear again like he did all those years before last year. What if I was happier about my situations around the infield? I might have taken a catcher, or a better utility bat (Justin Morneau?).

(As for Chris Perez, yes, I know, but my favorite late-draft sleepers like Addison Reed and Kenley Jansen were already taken by all the pros in this room. Say what you will about Perez — and I’ll join in — but he’s still the incumbent closer. If this draft had a bench, I would have drafted Vinnie Pestano and felt good about my three closer situations, as I think Pestano is the clear number two.)

21.12 Clay Buchholz
22.1 Nolan Reimold

No problems with the actual players here — but, combined with my picks in the 19th and 20th, I still didn’t have my second catcher… and I only liked one catcher left on the board.

23.1 Ryan Hanigan

Crap. Jonathan Lucroy went at 22.2 and with it went my decent number two. Since Devin Mesoraco is a rookie on a Dusty Baker team, Hanigan might surprise this year. And really, you don’t want to pick a second catcher too early or anything. But Lucroy and Carlos Lee might have been better than Reimold and Hanigan, if a little lite on upside.

So, I learned some things, and the team is decent, but has those obvious flaws:

C Buster Posey (6.1)
C Ryan Hanigan (23.12)
1B Eric Hosmer (5.12)
2B Dustin Pedroia (2.1)
3B Martin Prado (12.1)
SS Hanley Ramirez (1.12)
MI Zack Cozart (17.12)
CI Ryan Roberts (19.12)
OF Jay Bruce (4.1)
OF Jason Heyward (7.12)
OF Logan Morrison (9.12)
OF Lucas Duda (13.12)
OF Colby Rasmus (18.1)
Util Nolan Reimold (22.1)

P Dan Haren (3.12)
P Dan Hudson (8.1)
P Jonathan Papelbon (10.1)
P Tommy Hanson (11.12)
P Chris Carpenter (14.1)
P Jordan Walden (15.12)
P Chris Sale (16.1)
P Chris Perez (20.1)
P Clay Buchholz (21.12)

With a phone full of pictures of pitchers' fingers, strange beers, and his two toddler sons, Eno Sarris can be found at the ballpark or a brewery most days. Read him here, writing about the A's or Giants at The Athletic, or about beer at October. Follow him on Twitter @enosarris if you can handle the sandwiches and inanity.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
10 years ago

I wouldn’t beat yourself up over 3B. 3B blows and it’s going to suck for a lot of people, so you just have to make it up somewhere else. It surprises me though that Hosmer is going that early. Rasmus in the 18th round could provide some real value. It makes me sad that Panda is going 4:1. He’s worth it, but I keep holding out hope it’ll be like last year when I got him in the 11th round or something.

10 years ago
Reply to  Oliver

Sandoval went 4:12… it’s a Snake. But yeah, still high.

Charlie Saponara
10 years ago
Reply to  Sean

What I was thinking: I had the wheel pick with R4 P12 and R5 P1. Panda has an ADP around 70 and given the run on 3Bs I didn’t think he’d get back to me at pick 72 (I’m certain he wouldn’t have). Gotta get the players you want when picking from the wheel.

Brad Johnsonmember
10 years ago
Reply to  Sean

Call me crazy, but I’d be taking Sandoval way earlier than pick 70. 4:12 isn’t even a reach in my eyes.