The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Harper
This is the classic tale of good versus evil. Is the man in question truly the good natured doctor or the dreaded monster? There are clues along the way that must be examined but, no matter what the evidence suggests, it will be up to the man himself to prove who he really is. It is rare that the audience is rooting for the monster, but that in fact is the case.
In 2015, Bryce Harper was a monster. He hit .330/.460/.649 with a .319 ISO. His wRC+ was 197, which was 25 points higher than the next best hitter in Major League Baseball in 2015 and ranked 40 all-time, tied with Ross Barnes of the 1876 Chicago White Stockings. This does not even mention his traditional fantasy statistics.
| Season | Name | Team | G | PA | HR | R | RBI | SB |
| 2015 | Bryce Harper | Nationals | 153 | 654 | 42 | 118 | 99 | 6 |
Mr. Harper posted career highs in a multitude of areas:
| Season(s) | Team | BABIP | HR/FB | BB% | BB/K | FB% | Pull% | Hard% |
| 2012-2014 | Nationals | 0.319 | 16.60% | 10.40% | 0.49 | 33.50% | 35.90% | 31.90% |
| 2015 | Nationals | 0.369 | 27.30% | 19.00% | 0.95 | 39.30% | 45.40% | 40.90% |
Harper’s approach at the plate in 2015 was more patient. He swung 6.3% less in 2015 than in his previous season, including a drastic improvement in swinging at pitches outside of the strike zone. This new approach helped contribute to the huge jump in BB/K and BB%. While he has never shown this type of patience in the Major or Minor Leagues, it is not out of the question that it is legitimately due to his age and his growing control of the strike zone.
Harper’s new approach led him to pull the ball more to increase his power output. It jumped a full 9% in 2015. While this is great for his power numbers, if he continues to pull, the league will adjust accordingly. When they do, you could see a sharp decline in his BABIP. The growth in his pull percentage could also be partially responsible for the simultaneous growth in his hard contact. Harper has always maintained that he prefers to hit to all fields, especially left-center. If he reverts back to being less of a pull hitter, it would undoubtedly affect his power numbers.
His 27.3% HR/FB rate was an extreme jump from his career rate of 16.6% prior to last season. Only Nelson Cruz and Chris Davis had higher rates. His FB% jumped drastically as well, raising 6% from his prior career numbers. While Harper is a better pure hitter than Cruz and Davis, he had never shown their kind of fly ball tendency or power potential. While he could sustain some of the jump in HR/FB due to a large increase in HR + FB distance in 2015, it is unlikely that he will be able to maintain such a high percentage without some fluctuation in average.
There is also the fact that while his BB%, K%, pull percentage, and hard contact stayed steady in the second half of the season, we did see his groundball and fly ball percentages fall back in line with his career averages and an over 3% drop in his HR/FB rate during that period.
So, will Bryce Harper be the monster that he was in 2015, or will he revert back to being Dr. Jekyll?
If you believe that last year was completely legitimate or buy into the Zips projection comps of Ted Williams, then he would be the monster. It appears that the fantasy community at large completely agrees with that. He is universally being considered a top three pick in redraft leagues this season, and many industry experts have decided that he deserves to be number one.
I am much more skeptical, however. Despite the fact that I buy some of what we saw, the massive jumps in so many areas is a little too good to be true for me. I am more of a believer in his second half numbers, which would say that his HR/FB% will come down 3-4% and his average will regress into the .300 -.310 range. And while I am not ready to put the injury-prone tag on him, the fact that 2015 was his first year with at least 600 plate appearances in the Majors is a tad bit troublesome.
I have backed off of some of the comments about my distaste for the fantasy industry’s immense love for Harper, but I still feel like too many people believe that 2015 is the start of an epic beginning to greatness or some sort of new baseline for him. People are ignoring the real possibility that there is some level of imminent regression coming.
In redraft leagues, I will not be taking Harper in my top three, but I understand more why others will. There is some inherent risk in Mr. Harper, and in spite of my trepidation, I won’t forget that in the classic tale, the monster wins.
Justin is the co-host on The Sleeper and The Bust Podcast and writes for Rotographs covering the Roto Riteup as well as other periodic articles. In addition to his work at Rotographs, Justin is the lead fantasy writer/analyst and co-owner for FriendswithFantasyBenefits.com, and the owner of The Great Fantasy Baseball Invitational. He is also a certified addiction treatment counselor. Follow Justin on Twitter @JustinMasonFWFB.


Just curious, what is your top three if no Harper?
Probably Trout, Donaldson, Goldie in some order.
Just guessing.
Currently I have Goldy, Trout, and Donaldson, but I have toyed with a lot of guys in my top 6 including Machado, Altuve and Harper.
No Arenado? Younger version of Donaldson, almost as good, plus Coors factor.
Arenado is in the discussion for a lot of people. I am less convinced that his numbers away from Coors are sustainable. Still think he is a top 15-20 guy but I’m more bearish than the industry for sure.
I disagree with his injury history. He gets hurt because he played at 110% all the time. Last year he learned to reign it in a bit. It’s not like his body is fragile. If you leave him out of your top three, you’re basically forfeiting the league. Harper’s talent is Troutian, and there’s zero reason not to take him one or two.
110%? That would partially explain Werth’s season, assuming Bryce borrowed the extra 10% from him.
I disagree with the premise that passing on him is basically forfeiting your league. The idea that you cant win a league if you miss in the first round is an antiquated idea. I am not saying that it is even wrong to take Harper that early but there should be more of a discussion about it than there is in the fantasy industry.
What a bunch of BS – turn his weakness into an inhuman positive trait…
I dont follow, Vince.
Well only three people get to draft in the top 3. And there probably aren’t any three team leagues around. So it may not be quite as dire as you portray.
“If you leave him out of your top three, you’re basically forfeiting the league.”
Well at least you’re not prone to hyperbole…
Great point about the league adjusting to Harper. And I get the injury concern. But…
Is anyone buying Harper for more than .300-.310? Wouldn’t a 3-4% reduction in HR/FB% still amount to 35+ homers?
And wouldn’t those numbers still be incredible? If you buy his second half numbers, you’re buying a wRC+ of 182, which would still be better than Trout by 10 points.
But even if your concerns constitute pessimism toward Harper, you’ve got a top 3 player.
They would be still great, but it would depend on a number of things on whether it is top three value. Does he steal as much as last season or less? If his HR/FB ratio decline, does his FB% also? I’m also not saying don’t draft him. I am starting a conversation about why he is an unquestioned top 2-3 player.
So projecting 5 SB instead of 6 is going to alter your valuation significantly? If anything, he has SB upside, since they have a new manager:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/nationals-journal/wp/2015/12/16/under-dusty-baker-nationals-have-need-for-speed/
I sort of get where Justin’s coming from. I still think Harper is top 3, but his BABIP from last year (.369) is not fully sustainable, and I don’t think the ISO is either (.319).
The question then becomes how many of the walks were because pitchers were so afraid of the power? And does that change?
I’m not a huge believer in the “fragile” idea with most players (Tulo excepted). I think health is mostly a crapshoot.
I think the Steamer projection of .301/.412/.564 is about right, with maybe a slightly lower OBP and slugging. Even a .300/.390/.540 would put him at the top of the conversation for top 3, wouldn’t it?
He is definitely in the conversation. It depends a lot on format (ie Avg vs obp or what your roster position format is), if you think that he is going to steal or not, and what you think his runs/rbi totals will be like. This is more about starting that conversation because it appears that he has been appointed top 3 status without discussion of any sort of regression.
I think one has to consider the weak division he is in. Last year he feasted on the Braves, Phillies and marlins who accounted for 1/2 his HR. He was still good against better teams, just a bit less great. Lets see if he can repeat and avoid injuries which hampered him his first 3 years. I don’t like the guy for some reason, more of a Trout man I guess, but he is a talent
So say you have the 3rd pick. Trout is picked 1st and goldy 2nd. If you take donaldson, you can still have a great outfielder in the 2nd round who could provide stolen bases. Otherwise, if you take harper, by the time you draft again, the top 4 3B are gone as are the top 4 1B and you may end up reaching for speed later due to the recent decline in quality 25 plus steal players. Is harper that much better than donaldson to justify the difference in positional availabilty? The corners, especially 3B, are rather top heavy.
Also that Kershaw guy
“Just starting a discussion” or “He’s definitely in the conversation” seems like a cop out. You directly say you won’t draft him in the top 3. I assume you’re not just writing clickbait, so… don’t soft pedal it in your defense.
I think you’re underestimating people when you say “he’s been annointed top 3 status without discussion of any sort of regression”. Without regression, he’s the CLEAR #1 overall player without debate, but that’s not currently how he’s being evaluated. Most people see last year, build in regression, and still come out with a top-3 season.
His prospect status & age are also items that you haven’t mentioned. This isn’t Brady Anderson hitting 50 bombs – Harper is the best prospect in 20 years/30 years/forever? He was expected to be amazing, has played for 4 full seasons, and STILL hasn’t entered his physical peak. I side with the industry on this one.
Was he really a better prospect than ARod or Griffey Jr.?
Maybe I wasn’t responding as clearly as I meant to. Do I think Harper belongs in the discussion for the 3rd pick? Yes. Do I believe he belongs in the discussion for the 1st? No, I do not. If he repeats last season, then he is the top player, but predicting that and not building in regression or injury risk to me is foolish. I’m not going to beat up anyone if they take him first (as I did on my podcast last October), but at the same time predicting Harper to repeat those numbers is way too optimistic. It was an historic season. If it becomes his new baseline, than we are looking at a talent like we haven’t seen in decades (not including juiced Barry.) I’m not betting on that being the case.
If you want to talk about buying and selling, compare your projection to Steamer’s projection: .301/.412/.564 with 7 SB in 620 PA. It sounds like you’re inline with the projected performance, which makes the point of this article a bit… mysterious.
I appreciate the contrary view. But it almost seems like you’re being contrary for the sake of it. Injuries? Well, he learned to stop running into walls. Regression? He’s 23. Most his age are at AA. So, while I won’t completely blast you for the academic exercise, your arguments just don’t hold water.
I am definitely not being contrary for the sake of it. Regression in his number should be expected. The question is how far?
People seem pretty wrought up about all this! Don’t worry, March is coming. Interesting take, Justin. Thanks.