The Future (at Catcher) Is Here

Credit: Joe Camporeale-Imagn Images

The catcher position has been a pretty stable one in fantasy and is pretty deep right now, without perhaps a superstar name. Not only is the current health of the position in a good place, but there is also an influx of young talent that will be looking to break through in 2027.

Catcher is not usually known for being the position where young studs are eagerly waiting in the wings, but rather the position of stable, wily veterans.

Perhaps times are changing?

Naturally, though, given the responsibility that comes with the position, there is trepidation handing things over to prospects and breakthrough candidates. When a catching prospect has the upside with the bat to make an impact, teams may look to get them at-bats while also utilizing the experience a seasoned veteran . Last season, the Royals showed a good blueprint of this with how they introduced Carter Jensen while also continuing to maximize Salvador Perez in the twilight of his career.

For 2027, there seems to be a number of candidates to be the next breakthrough prospect, and they have huge potential upside in fantasy if they can stick at the position or hold enough offensive value that they are able to get reps at infield positions or DH.

Using the early ADP from NFBC, we can already see how these young catchers are being valued and the ceiling-floor range that comes with each of them. This is something subject to a lot of change as the season (hopefully) approaches; this could shift a lot as we learn about the potential role for 2027.

The Next Generation of Catchers
Player Team ADP Min Max Spread % Drafts
Ethan Salas SD 213.9 181 256 75 100%
Leo Bernal STL 154.1 111 235 124 100%
Rafael Flores Jr. PIT 269.8 211 346 135 100%
Eduardo Valencia DET 325.2 263 416 153 97%
Rainiel Rodriguez STL 384.8 231 406 175 84%
Agustín Ramírez MIA 309.7 172 415 243 94%

Inspired by my colleague Jack Dorfman’s piece, this table highlights the current range of ADP for each player and where they are being selected after 32 drafts. With young catchers in particular, this can be especially helpful to gauge what the thought is on their ceiling and floor. It is sorted by the gap between the minimum and maximum ADP. So now we have a bit of a deeper look into this group and can see what they can offer in 2027.

Ethan Salas, San Diego Padres

Ethan Salas, one of the top prospects in baseball, positioned himself well to be the primary catcher for the Padres in 2027, following the opportunity given to him at the back end of the year. Catcher has been a bit of a hole for San Diego for a while now, but given the trust they showed Salas at the end of 2026, he looks primed to fill that vacancy. The disciplined approach that made Salas a top prospect has shown up in his brief time in the majors. Already demonstrating great bat-to-ball skills inside the zone with a 91.8% Z-Contact and just 8.7% SwStr%, Salas has a high floor.

This is reflected in the smallest gap between the minimum and maximum ADP. He should have steady playing time, and he has a great approach with a good hit tool. So despite the smallest sample of the group, he looks to be the safest, if perhaps not the most exciting, option.

A shadow does hang over Salas: in 2027, he is probably a platoon bat. Luis Campusano proved himself to be more than handy and is likely to eat into Salas’s playing time, especially if he starts slow, and particularly against southpaws. There is also not a lot of power upside with Salas compared to some of the other names here, as he has well below league-average bat speed. Despite the lack of power and Campusano breathing down his neck, Salas will have the highest floor going into 2027 given his defensive upside and prospect pedigree.

Leo Bernal, St. Louis Cardinals

I spoke about my high outlook for Bernal in my piece on young hitters with bat speed, and he would be my pick of this group at this stage. Bernal seems to have the best blend of power, hit tool, and avenue to playing time, as he seemingly solidified himself as the everyday catcher at the back end of last season. While he has a similar floor to Salas in my view, his ceiling is higher, at least for 2027. This is reflected in the ADP: his minimum and maximum ADP are already lower than Salas’s and the lowest in the group, but more varied. Salas’s spread of 75 starting at 181 means he might be a know-what-you’re-getting value play, whereas Bernal has some more risk involved given his higher ADP cost.

Similar to Salas, he does have competition for playing time. But it is also very much his job to lose, and with Ivan Herrera being shifted to DH, I would be shocked if he is not the starting catcher in 2027. Given his bat speed and other bat tracking data, it is no surprise his ceiling is higher than someone like Salas. While the sample size is small, we can still get a good idea of what we can expect from his 2026 campaign. Across his 102 PA, Bernal hit 5 HR with a .189 ISO and .474 SLG, a rate of 29 HR per 600 PA. While that is too much to expect from a first full season, I think we can expect a decent power output, thanks to his 10% overall barrel rate and 55.7% hard-hit rate, which sit above MLB averages. I anticipate seeing Bernal on a lot of teams come 2027 Opening Day.

Rafael Flores Jr., Pittsburgh Pirates

From the projected lineups we have today at the end of November, Rafael Flores Jr. is the last of this group in line to be behind the plate on Opening Day. Like Bernal, he was also able to get a decent enough look at major league pitching with 163 plate appearances in 2026. Across that span, he fared well, slashing .264/.331/.527 with 11 HR, 25 RBI, and a 130 wRC+.

Again, like with Bernal, it would be unrealistic to expect that to repeat in 2027, but he’s proven his ability to make an impact in the Pirates’ lineup and has a strong outlook for 2027.

Steamer is currently projecting 10 home runs, .242/.314, and a 96 wRC+ across 302 PA. While it will be his job to lose, Pittsburgh has a few young catching prospects looking for playing time: Henry Davis and Endy Rodriguez.

Flores’s batted ball profile leans pull and hard contact. His 49.5% pull rate and 46.6% hard-hit rate both top the group of six. But currently, he hits too many ground balls with a 44.7% ground ball rate. While it would be fair to point out that from a small sample, batted-ball data can be very noisy, this is something that he has continued from his time in Triple-A in 2026, where his 47.8% ground-ball rate and 1.62 GB/FB ratio ran even higher than his MLB marks. However, he has always hit the ball hard. So if he can start elevating the ball, the bat speed, the pull numbers, and power are all there.

Eduardo Valencia, Detroit Tigers

Eduardo Valencia ended the season like a freight train. In 59 September PAs, Valencia hit .385/.448/.635 with 7 doubles, 2 HR, and a 1.083 OPS, leading him to finish the season with 182 wRC+. Again, a small sample across 138 PA for the season, but he was really able to demonstrate his power potential in an offense looking for some life. He overperformed his expected data, but his xwOBA was still an impressive .372, and he crushed off-speed pitching with a .479 xwOBA on those pitches. Again, a small sample, and major league pitching will be quick to adjust next year, but it at least proves his ability at this level. Despite being a prospect, Valencia is 26 years old, so 2027 will be the time for him to begin to really assert himself in this lineup.

But despite the power potential, his biggest obstacle will be the logjam in front of him. He is behind arguably the best defensive catcher in baseball, and his integration at DH came when Kerry Carpenter was moved to the IL. So his fantasy value will hinge on how the Tigers juggle their roster to get him at-bats. But for a team that will have playoff aspirations, they could use the firepower of Valencia’s bat to help lengthen a lineup that doesn’t offer a ton outside of Kevin McGonigle, Carpenter, and Riley Greene.

There is also reason to be concerned with his 38.5% O-Swing% and a 4% walk rate. If the power dries up, there won’t be much to fall back on, and he could be the kind of streaky asset to pick up for the month or two while hot. So the big question is whether he can be more than a bench bat to be of serious fantasy consideration.

Rainiel Rodriguez, St. Louis Cardinals

The biggest wildcard of the group for 2027, Rainiel Rodriguez is just 19, is the second Cardinals’ catcher on this list, and request a real leap of faith if you are drafting him at 231, his minimum ADP. The uncertainty is reflected in the NFBC rostered rate, which is the lowest of this group at 84%, but still pretty significant considering his lack of experience.

Rodriguez is the top prospect in the Cardinals’ pretty stacked farm system, according to MLB Pipeline prospect rankings, ahead of Leo Bernal. Rodriguez could see the Cardinals accelerate his pathway to the major league roster, giving him infield reps, as the bat looks like it can already play. As this image from TJStats shows, even in Double-A, he looks like he has already outgrown that level and has a good shot to feature on the major league roster at some point in 2027, even if he may start in Triple-A.

His draftability and how high you are willing to take him will likely depend on your format, but certainly in deeper, dynasty, and two-catcher formats, he could even end up being drafted higher than 231 come draft season.

Agustín Ramírez, Miami Marlins

Given his outlook at this time last year, seeing Ramírez with the widest ADP spread, ranging to 415, is a pretty stunning turn of events. He will have a lot to prove in 2027. His above-75 mph bat speed and 58% Fast-Swing% are all well and good, but mean little if he is not able to make contact. And this is where Ramírez has struggled; these promising bat-tracking numbers are paired with a worrying 84% Z-Contact rate and an O-Contact% of 53%. Even when he makes contact, a 15.0% BlastCon% and 26.3% SqUpCon% show low contact quality on swings relative to the bat speed. He will also have a very capable Joe Mack ahead of him in the pecking order, so at-bats may be limited.

He has shown the ability to take his walks, but with an ISO of .119, there is just not enough power at this moment to warrant a fantasy roster spot. When he went back to the minors, he did not even light it up there with a middling .322 wOBA. So drafting Ramírez will be a gamble on bat speed and exit velocity, and right now that isn’t enough for me, especially for a top-200 draft pick.





Jack Martin is a contributor for RotoGraphs and previously covered the Seattle Mariners for Last Word On Sports. Follow him on Twitter @_jackmrtn.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
votto eroticaMember since 2019
4 hours ago

Is an 84% z-con for Ramirez bad? That sounds about average for an mlb hitter. If I’m not mistaken it was scraping 80%, and he lost seven or eight points in z-con from last year.

I’d point to cratering barrel and hard hit rates as even greater areas of concern, though it’s not clear what happened there as his swing decisions don’t look dramatically different on the surface (i.e. chase rate and zone swings about the same).

I’m definitely hanging on to Valencia over him, as much because Ramirez probably isn’t a catcher as anything. If he can’t hit a FB or elevate the ball he’s not going to make it at another position.