Sunday Night Waiver Wire & FAAB Chat

7:31
Jeff Zimmerman: Welcome

7:31
Jeff Zimmerman: Here are the winning bids in the three Tout Wars 15-team leagues.

7:32
Jeff Zimmerman:

7:32
Jon: Would you drop Crochet for Springs? Springs looked great today and Crochet is likely to get shut down

7:32
Jeff Zimmerman: Yes

7:33
Daprez: Thank you for doing these chats! I’m in a 6×6 roto with Betts, Casas and Edman returning. Could you rank these guys in order of droppability? Toglia, Mayo, C. Doval, Lux, J. Dominguez & India. Or do I release Edman?

7:33
Jeff Zimmerman: Drop in this order: Mayo, Doval, Edman

7:34
Stan: Do you expect any good IP from Musgrove or Boyd ROS?

7:34
Jeff Zimmerman: Musgrove yes, not so much with Boyd

7:34
Gerry: Who do you like for ROS?  Manaea, Arighetti or Festa?

7:35
Jeff Zimmerman: It would come down to matchups. Pretty close

7:36
Maris9: Who are a couple of top September call ups?

7:37
Jeff Zimmerman: I have no idea what teams will do and most call-ups won’t be worth it. Just play it week to week.

7:37
KCBBq: In order who would you rather have as a keeper in a 12 team AL only 5×5 H2H keeper league at $2 or less: Jon Gray, Romano, Dingler, Dezenzo? Have a few FAAB left and don’t think I can get Caminero for $7 or less.

7:37
Jeff Zimmerman: Dezenzo, Romano, Gray, Dingler

7:37
Scott: Do you think Birdsong is streamable in 12-team mixed league after 3 poor performances?

7:38
Jeff Zimmerman: I still am, I don’t have many choices in my leagues.

7:38
JT: Firmly in 1st place for a majority of 10T h2h redraft season, will clinch # 1 tonight, was just offered Alvarez for Alonso and Corbin Carrol, should I take it ? I have Casas and Harris on IL but also part of me is attached to Corbin since i brought low on him and he seems to finally be contributing, another part of equation is that Judge is our main player.

7:38
Jeff Zimmerman: I’d hold onto the pair

7:39
Liquid SWRds: How much to bid on SWR vs Spaghetti and Ryne Sandberg-Nelson? Same question in roto and points if it matter.  – The GZA

7:39
Jeff Zimmerman: At this point, it should take 1% to 2% of the initial budget to roster them

7:39
Andrew: Who’s the best rookie for SF to hold for dynasty – Ramos, Fitzgerald or Birdsong?

7:39
Jeff Zimmerman: Ramos for me

7:40
tumtum: Dezenzo’s strikeouts in AAA and so far in Houston are much lower than we’ve seen in the minors prior to the injury. I expect regression against him, but have you seen or heard whether there is legitimate improvement that supports the results?

7:40
Jeff Zimmerman: No known improvements besides being healthy

7:40
Ron: Do you expect E Rodriguez (ARZ) to be effective the rest of this season?

7:40
Jeff Zimmerman: From what I’ve seen so far, not really

7:40
Tony Yayo: Erceg or Walker?

7:41
Jeff Zimmerman: Walker because the managers has appointed him the closer’s role

7:41
joe: cutting Grayson in redraft?

7:41
Jeff Zimmerman: yes

7:41
Butter Rum: 10 team standard 5×5 NL only roto – please rank J. Bride, M. Canha, A McCutchen to start this week – all hitting categories are in close races.

7:42
Jeff Zimmerman: These are garbage pieces for the week. Bride but it’s only 5 games.

7:42
New closers: R. Walker over Ari J Martinez?

7:42
Jeff Zimmerman: Yes

7:42
John: Has Ryne Nelson figured something out?  Seems to be different pitcher last few starts

7:43
Jeff Zimmerman: Seems like he’s been better for a while, but he’s pulling a Lance Lynn with his fastball being his only effective pitch.

7:44
B’ryce Hammer Destroyer of Baseballs: Tatis Jr isn’t makin it back before September… Cut in a redraft? My playoffs (2 weeks) start that first week of September

7:45
Jeff Zimmerman: I’d hold him until right before the playoffs start then cut. If he’s back, he could win the playoff round himself

7:45
Lloyd Banks: Get froggy and leap from Will Smith to Joey Bart or Austin Wells?

7:45
Jeff Zimmerman: No, that’s a horrible idea

7:45
Frank: Hope the move went well.

7:46
Jeff Zimmerman: Thanks. I didn’t know two beds could be arranged so many different ways.

7:46
Yankee E: Arrighetti at least worth a stream against the White Sox this week after 25 Ks in his last two starts?

7:46
Jeff Zimmerman: For sure

7:46
Gerry: Would yesterday and todays results move Arrighetti above Festa on your list or is Festa still the choice?

7:48
Jeff Zimmerman: They could be 1 and 2. Spaghetti will have more K’s and BB’s while Festa, fewer. Go with team needs.

7:48
Curtis Jackson: OC – How much FAAB do you try to leave yourself for September?

7:48
Jeff Zimmerman: $20 a week, especially in leagues that count.

7:50
B’ryce Hammer Destroyer of Baseballs: What’s your read on Kershaw at this point? Is he just getting pitch count up and should be good? Or is this the end?

7:50
Jeff Zimmerman: There doesn’t seem to be much there, I’ve ignored him

7:50
JG: Waldron is at Colorado this week.  Start / Sit ?

7:50
Jeff Zimmerman: Hold and sit. I’m not that brave

7:51
Favio: Drop George Springer or Butler for Mookie activation?

7:51
Jeff Zimmerman: Butler for me

7:51
Maris9: Just a hot streak for Alex Call?

7:51
Jeff Zimmerman: Probably but he’s playing and that means something in deeper leagues

7:52
Dusty Wagner: What am I missing on Pham? Starting against RHP still but being seen as a platoon guy?

7:52
Jeff Zimmerman: He’s infuriating. I’m hoping to drop in all my leagues.

7:53
Jay: Would you drop Isaac Paredes for Jake Burger?

7:53
Jeff Zimmerman: Yes

7:53
Luis Roberts jr: What is wrong with me and am I droppable in a 10 man points league?

7:53
Jeff Zimmerman: Who are the other options

7:53
Dawn: A. Benintendi or Z. Dezenzo in AL only roto?

7:53
Jeff Zimmerman: Dezenzo for now

7:54
Skippy: Is Nestor Cortes below the Middle reliever line now?

7:55
Jeff Zimmerman: I don’t have him as low as others. Might a drop in shallower leagues but the option in deeper leagues might not be there

7:56
Jeff Zimmerman: One guy I am dropping his Carlie Morton. I had not noticed how bad he’s been

7:56
JG: Everyone is “down” on expectations on Walker Buehler. But the Dodgers need him.  Start him this week ?

7:57
Jeff Zimmerman: No for me. I had him available in a couple of leagues and didn’t bid on him.

7:57
tumtum: Kjerstad has concussion-lingering symptoms, do you think the Orioles will bring him back or send him down to AAA

7:57
Jeff Zimmerman: Like five more times, he’s getting the Olivares treatment.

7:57
Jim: Mahle or E-Rod ROS?

7:57
Jeff Zimmerman: Mahle

7:58
Joe: You ranked Robles over McCarthy in your W20 waiver column. Yet McCarthy has a HUGE edge in Zips RoS projections…thoughts?

7:58
Jeff Zimmerman: Robles has made some changes that I believe Zips hasn’t taken into account

7:59
Degrom: Is Degrom worth picking up at this point

7:59
Jeff Zimmerman: Most likely not unless you have deep bench

8:00
Jeff Zimmerman: Dominguez and Cruz

8:00
Craig B: are any of the Red Sox pitchers worth keeping at the moment? Bench and wait?

8:01
Jeff Zimmerman: I thought their hype was too much and I haven’t kept up with their struggles. I’d hold unless there is a major velo loss (>2 mph)

8:02
Jeff Zimmerman: Joyce and Bautista

8:03
nfbcOC12: Ok to drop Eovaldi in 12s? Been inconsistent and now has a side injury.

8:03
Jeff Zimmerman: Sure, if there is a better replacement

8:03
$51 for Jordan Montgomery?: This has to be someone who lost a bet, right?

8:04
Jeff Zimmerman: Possibly. Most likely, they had too much money left and wanted to blow some

8:04
Jon: Hamilton make your bats list if available? Red Sox w/ 7 at home and seems like all righties

8:05
Jeff Zimmerman: I feel he’s an automatic choice

8:05
Jerry Koosman: 12 team pts league: Arrighetti or Ryne Nelson?

8:05
Jeff Zimmerman: Spaghetti

8:06
RTFBC: How do you like the OBP / S+H with overall format now that you tried it out?

8:07
Jeff Zimmerman: Better if someone and their $11 would get out of first place.

8:08
Jeff Zimmerman: I love not having Friday lineups. Extends the number of leagues I can handle.

8:08
Andy: have Chapman at 3b, drop Jung for Woo? Need pitching help

8:09
Jeff Zimmerman: Chapman has been decent. Hold over Jung but if you need pitching, drop for Woo

8:09
Playoff Stashers: Not much to play for before OBP H2H playoffs. Rank the stashes for 2-3 weeks time: Caminero, Buehler, Albies, Musgrove, S Marte.

8:10
Jeff Zimmerman: I have no idea that far ahead, so I’d go with the guys returning first. Get Musgrove and Buehler, see how they throw, and you can then decent to keep or move on.

8:10
Benny: Do you believe in the last few weeks of Andrew Benintendi? Reborn or a case of even the sun shines on a…

8:10
Jeff Zimmerman: Nothing knew

8:10
Tim: Are we seeing anything in Nootbaar these days? He just seems increasingly meh

8:11
Jeff Zimmerman: I think he’s unrosterable because of the lack of playing time.

8:11
Jay: H2H playoffs are the last 3 weeks of the season. Rank these starters for the playoffs. Grayson Rodríguez, Jacob DeGrom and Jared Jones.

8:12
Jeff Zimmerman: Jones in the only choice, again get the guy returning first

8:12
Catcher: What are your thoughts on Adrian Del Castillo?  Do you think he will get regular playing time the rest of the year and continue to produce?

8:13
Jeff Zimmerman: I dug in and asked around about him when called up. The review is great hitter (for a catcher) but needs a ton of work behind the plate.

8:13
Benny: Nick Sogard, Romy Gonzalez, Ramon Urias, or Stefanic for a desperate MI?

8:13
Jeff Zimmerman: Stefanic and Urias are decent right now.

8:13
John: Better DH option rest of the way, Neto or Chapman?  Thanks.

8:13
Jeff Zimmerman: Neto

8:14
Maxxed out: Scherzer going to Texas for further evaluation.  Time to drop everywhere I would assume?

8:14
Jeff Zimmerman: I’m holding in the one league I have him for news, but I can understand letting him so

8:14
Jim: I have Dominguez stashed at end of roster (one of joys of having a huge lead in 10t h2h) L Robert Jr just got waived, worth the shot and drop dominguez or is this a lost season for Robert

8:14
Jeff Zimmerman: Add Robert

8:14
Christina: I have both Spencer’s in dynasty. do I change my team name to SchwellAghetti?

8:15
Acadia: Soler or Josh Bell?

8:15
Jeff Zimmerman: For me, it would be a position of need question.

8:15
James: Ok to drop Ryan instead of holding on IL correct ?

8:15
Jeff Zimmerman: I’m dropping

8:16
HappyFunBall: My IR is clearing out lately and I’ve only got room to hold one of Cobb, DL Hall, or Kershaw at the bottom of my roster.  It’s a QS league with an innings limit so SPs that won’t go 6 are hard to use.  I’m thinking Cobb’s the one most likely to be startable. Yes?

8:16
Jeff Zimmerman: I might lean Kershaw, but I don’t like any of them

8:16
Kevin: Head to head points league rest of season. Martin Perez or Cody Bradford?

8:16
Jeff Zimmerman: Perez

8:17
Dave: Are Sewald, Doval, and Kimbrel all drops in 15s

8:18
Jeff Zimmerman: Depends if you can replace all three. The order I’d drop them in is Doval, Kimbrel, Sewald.

8:18
Msfan: Neto or Bichette ROS? OBP points league.

8:18
Jeff Zimmerman: Neto and it’s not even close

8:19
Andrew: Is it too early to close up shop in a 15 team NFBC league? Top 3 in both ERA and WHIP, and can pick up 2 or 3 points. Despite being top 5 in IP, I am bottom 4 in Ws and Ks, and still losing ground. With 7 point lead, can I start leaning on RPs to drive the ERA and WHIP lower to secure those points? This would only leave Runs, HRs, and SBs, as the only places to gain points (and only a few points at that), if another team goes on a late run. Guys like Kremer, T. Myers, and Heaney, would be the ones to go for guys like Buto and Cade Smith.

8:19
Jeff Zimmerman: You are probably at the point you need to pick a lane

8:20
Jeff Zimmerman: I find it easier to go the RP route because some managers are going to suck up and stream ever SP out there

8:22
Andy: Is Trevor Story worth a stash?

8:22
Jeff Zimmerman: No

8:22
Whit: Start this week vs susceptible SB opponents?

8:23
Jeff Zimmerman: I added him last week. Nice bench option to cover all but SS, 1B and C

8:23
Benny: My league’s FAAB runs in 10 minutes and still tinkering. When do you lock in your bids and step away from the keyboard?

8:25
Jeff Zimmerman: I rarely tinker with my bids, especially at this point in the season. I have little FAAB left and need some for later and can only drop bids down. Once I’m done with this chat, I have 30 minutes to look for duplicate drops and out of place bids.

8:26
Jeff Zimmerman: That’s it for this week, see everyone next week.





Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won four FSWA Awards including on for his Mining the News series. He's won Tout Wars three times, LABR twice, and got his first NFBC Main Event win in 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bogart46Member since 2025
8 months ago

Who are top September call ups? Gimme two.