Starting Pitcher Chart – April 24th, 2024

Stephen Brashear-USA TODAY Sports

Daily SP Chart archive

I got on that yardwork grind today after a good bout of rain the last week or so and frankly, it took me out a bit so I’m crashing!  I’ve got my chat at 1pm CT tomorrow, though, so feel free to come out and ask any questions you might have and I’ll have a proper commentary bit in this space tomorrow night.

Starter Notes April 24, 2024
1 Joe Ryan MIN v CHW x x x 22 3.57 1.06 29% 30th Could the White Sox somehow get negative runs here?
2 Freddy Peralta MIL at PIT x x x 23 1.90 0.76 32% 23rd
3 Jordan Montgomery ARI at STL x x x 6 1.50 0.67 14% 24th Snell’s struggles feel worse when juxtaposed against Monty looking amazing in his debut even though the 2 are wholly unrelated
4 Reynaldo López ATL v MIA x x x 18 0.50 0.94 18% 25th ReyLo isn’t as good as these shiny ratios obviously, but he doesn’t need to be to remain a viable option in most formats
5 Bryce Miller SEA at TEX x x x 24 1.85 0.82 18% 6th Tinyyyy sample but love the 460 pt. vL OPS improvement down to just .457 thanks in part to his new splitty
6 Clarke Schmidt NYY v OAK x x x 20 3.15 1.55 17% 29th
7 Nick Lodolo CIN v PHI x x x 12 0.75 0.75 33% 6th Not as auto-start as Greene given the lower price point, but similar vibes where you’re in for the ride even in the tough home starts
8 Garrett Crochet CHW at MIN x x x 25 5.61 1.01 27% 27th B2B duds though CIN/PHI are solid lineups… needs to rebound here or we really tighten up our usage thresholds
9 Blake Snell SFG v NYM x x x 11 11.57 1.97 12% 7th I’m staying the course as he works through the kinks
10 Jack Flaherty DET at TBR x x x 24 4.44 1.11 25% 22nd Brilliant skills (25% K-BB) have been undercut by a 1.5 HR9 and 66% LOB rate, I’m hanging on!
11 Tyler Alexander TBR v DET x x 20 4.79 1.35 11% 26th Streamable everywhere w/this matchup but hasn’t risen to all formats must-start status yet thus just 2-x’s
12 Spencer Turnbull PHI at CIN x x 22 1.23 0.77 18% 17th Pitching v well and I’m on board… just saying you don’t have to start him in Cincy
13 Sean Manaea NYM at SFG x x 19 4.12 1.37 13% 16th Revenge game!!
14 Jon Gray TEX v SEA x x 20 3.15 1.40 17% 18th Has a 1.10 ERA & WHIP, 23 Ks, and just 2 ER (5 total R) in 16.3 IP since his rough season debut v. CHC
15 Dean Kremer BAL at LAA x 22 4.91 1.14 13% 24th Hasn’t been able to carryover the ST spike in swinging strike rate w/a paltry 8% mark so far, but has been solid 3 of 4 starts thus far
16 Jameson Taillon CHC v HOU x 5 1.80 0.60 22% 8th I’ll reiterate that HOU’s struggles aren’t the lineup so we’re just not throwing everyone v. them; pickup Jamo for the at NYM/v. MIL 2-step next wk, though
17 Alec Marsh KCR v TOR x 22 3.22 1.03 12% 16th Can he thwart a non-Orioles club? 8.7 IP/1 ER in 2 starts v. BAL; 9.7 IP/7 ER v. CHW & NYM
18 Tyler Anderson LAA v BAL x 25 1.42 0.95 5% 9th Ugly 5% K-BB might scare you… counterpoint: 13% SwStr says the 14% K rate will rise and give more credence to those sparkly ratios so he’s firmly on the mid- and deep-lg radar
19 Yariel Rodriguez TOR at KCR x 7 2.35 1.30 31% 9th Could be his last start befor shifting to the pen, buuuttt that could fuel some W potential if he’s getting 2-4 IP in the middle of games!
20 Landon Knack LAD at WSN x 5 3.60 1.00 16% 5th Not averse to chasing a cheap W, just know that it’s not risk-free w/WSN hitting well vR early on
21 Kyle Gibson STL v ARI x 25 5.04 1.20 4% 19th Standard issue risky stream for deeper leagues, but maybe scoop & stash for at DET next wk
22 Joe Boyle OAK at NYY 18 7.23 1.71 7% 10th His Game Scores (50 avg; >55 great; <40 terrible) perfectly encapsulate his volatility range: 12, 66, 57, 33
23 Josh Fleming PIT v MIL 9 1.93 1.18 8% 21st Solid arm who might develop some viability if he sticks in the rotation, but pretty risky in a random 1-off
24 Jake Irvin WSN v LAD 23 3.13 1.00 16% 3rd I know Swervin’ Jake Irvin cooked LAD last time out but I just can’t run it back… could be down for that at MIA/v. TOR next wk, though!
25 Cooper Criswell BOS at CLE 6 4.26 1.58 7% 13th
26 Spencer Arrighetti HOU at CHC 7 11.57 2.29 8% 12th
27 Carlos Carrasco CLE v BOS 18 3.44 1.53 5% 14th
28 Matt Waldron SDP at COL 19 4.74 1.53 13% 21st I’m barely interested in trusting a knuckler in ideal settings, let alone Coors Field… even against this rough COL lineup
29 Kyle Tyler MIA at ATL #N/A #N/A #N/A #N/A 1st
30 Ty Blach COL v SDP #N/A #N/A #N/A #N/A 13th
Recommendations for Roto 5×5 Leagues

The chart includes their 2024 stats (this changed over from last year’s stats on April 22nd), their opponent’s wOBA versus the pitcher’s handedness from this year so far (this is changed as of April 11th), my general start/sit recommendation for 10-team, 12-team, and 15-team (or more) leagues, and then a note about them (notes will be more statistical-based once we get some sample to work with). Obviously, there are league sizes beyond those three so it’s essentially a shallow, medium, deep. If a pitcher only has an “x” in 15-team, it doesn’t mean there’s no potential use in 10s and 12s, but it’s basically a riskier stream for those spots.

These are general recommendations, and your league situation will carry more weight whether you are protecting ratios or chasing counting numbers. This is for standard 5×5 roto leagues. The thresholds for H2H starts are generally lower, especially in points leagues so I thought there would be more value focusing on roto.


Paul is the Editor of Rotographs and Content Director for OOTP Perfect Team. Follow Paul on Twitter @sporer and on Twitch at sporer.

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
1 month ago

Paul you are tempting the baseball gods with that Ryan blurb. I have Ryan in an important league and hoping to not be collateral damage from your hubris!

Montgomery has had good results so far but a .167 BABIP/100% LOB/14% K rate point to him being who he always has been — perfectly adequate.

Last edited 1 month ago by Gregg
1 month ago
Reply to  Paul Sporer

Yeah, the White Sox got five runs off the Twins yesterday. It’s a much-needed reminder that anyone can beat anyone in this league. Three off Pablo Lopez, who was first-ranked. Taking Fedde produced better value!

Baseball, man. There’s nothing that makes less sense sometimes.

Last edited 1 month ago by EonADS
1 month ago
Reply to  Paul Sporer

Yep. Just serves as a cautionary tale, and a reminder that process sometimes needs adjustments. It’s not so different from actually playing baseball, at least mentally.

1 month ago
Reply to  Paul Sporer

Not so much sitting him as having him at the top of the slate. He might have had the easiest matchup, but he wasn’t the safest option imo. Webb, Houck, and Gilbert all are superior pitchers overall, and Lopez has been lesser this season as hitters have started to punish his poor fastball location. He’s always had an issue with that, but his breaking pitches and changeup have made up the difference. Not so much this year, but he’s also always underperformed his advanced metrics. At this point, it’s too much of a pattern to ignore.

Fedde, I faded for similar reasons as you did, but I think both of us underrated him and will continue to if he isn’t moved up slightly. He arguably had the second-easiest matchup, and the adjustments from Korea were there. There’s a bit of recency bias there, but you do have to factor in current performance, it’s just a lesser consideration than underlying talent.

Last edited 1 month ago by EonADS
1 month ago
Reply to  Paul Sporer

Fair, that makes more sense. I disagree with some of the reasoning, but given that we’re different people, that’s bound to happen. Thanks for explaining things 🙂

I’m more of a DFS guy, so that also probably played into things a little as well. I basically have to overrate recency compared to more long-term formats.

Last edited 1 month ago by EonADS