Rounds 6-10 of My #2EarlyMock Draft

I posted my first five rounds yesterday and you can check those out here. I was going to post my first nine rounds, but I was minutes away from my 10th pick so I decided to break it up into two 5s.

Round 6, Pick 62: Marcell Ozuna | OF, STL (ADP: 69… nice)

While I was ahead of the ADP on Ozuna, this still felt like a bargain to me. He labored through much of the first half as his shoulder was clearly bothering him, but he’s looked like his 2017 self in the second half with a .303/.353/.527 line and 12 homers in 218 PA. He hit just 10 HR in 377 first half PA and had just a .645 OPS through May. A healthy Ozuna is a top 50 pick.

Round 7, Pick 83: Aaron Hicks | OF, NYY (ADP: 83… I’m the only one to take him so far)

I guess I could’ve waited on Hicks as I’m the only one in all eight leagues to take him and at least 6 of the 8 leagues are 100 picks deep. I know he’s hitting a meager .244, but he’s one of just 21 players to go 20+ HR/10+ SB this year with 24 and 11. And that’s in just 129 games. Of course, health has been a career-long issue so I don’t want to lean too heavily on the fact that he didn’t play a full season and expect 150+ games in ’19. If he does get that lucky health season, though, a 30/15 in coming.

Round 8, Pick 86: Scooter Gennett | 2B, CIN (ADP: 79.8)

Gennett completely backed up his 2017 breakout with an excellent follow up: .315/.365/.495 with 22 HR, 88 RBI, and 84 R. The Reds offense was once again formidable even with Joey Votto’s power outage. Even if there’s a little dip in the power, I like that he’s hit .307 in the last two years.

Round 9, Pick 107: Matt Olson | 1B, OAK (ADP: 93.3)

I definitely like the Gennett pick on its own, but it’s even more useful in the context of sandwiching a pair of sub-.250 hitters around him in Hicks and Olson. Obviously, more was expected of Olson after he popped 24 HRs in just 59 games last year, but if his 41% HR/FB rate from last year was the absolute high end, I think his 16% this year is pretty close to the low end of what these skills should deliver.

His batted ball profile didn’t change nearly enough to foster a 25-point drop in HR/FB rate so I think there was some bad luck there. His pull percentage did dip eight points, but his flyball rate was essentially neutral (-3 pts to 43%) and he’s hit the ball harder (+7 to 47%). First base just isn’t super-deep, either. I was really surprised looking at the pool as this pick was coming up and felt I had to go with Olson’s 30+ HR upside here.

Round 10, Pick 110: Luis Castillo | SP, CIN (ADP: 97)

Hey, looks who’s back!!!! Dr. Tanner mentioned to me that he was surprised to see me take Castillo after hearing me say on the podcast that I wouldn’t make the same mistake in 2019, but I was meaning that I wouldn’t make the same mistake with a Castillo type… in other words, overdrafting a small sample god who wasn’t a finished product (maybe Jack Flaherty next year… although his 143 IP are quite a bit more than Castillo’s 89 from last year). Castillo was an obvious disappointment this year, carrying a 5.85 ERA through June, but he’s rallied in the second half with a 2.93 ERA and 1.05 WHIP with a 20% K-BB rate in 74 innings of work. Home runs remain his biggest issue, but he’s improved from 1.9 HR/9 in the first three months to 1.2 since July 1st.

While I was undoubtedly all in on Castillo this year, the one reservation I had was that the Luis Severino comp that many were fond of simply overlooked the sophomore campaign of Sevvy and just hoped/expected that Castillo would jump to the 2017 version. In the end, I overlooked it, too, citing his age and developed changeup as reasons he could skip the trajectory of Sevvy that included the bumpy second season. Castillo is still a budding stud as far as I’m concerned and I’ll be happy to dive back in for 2019, especially at a lower price.

The team through 10:


1B: Olson (9)

2B: Gennett (8)

3B: Machado (2)

SS: Bogaerts (3)

CI: Rendon (5)


OF: Harper (1)

OF: Ozuna (6)

OF: Hicks (7)



P: Cole (4)

P: Castillo (10)


Whattya think? Here’s the #2EarlyMock ADP board again, who has been over- and under-drafted in your estimation?

We hoped you liked reading Rounds 6-10 of My #2EarlyMock Draft by Paul Sporer!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

Paul is the Editor of Rotographs and contributes to ESPN's Daily Notes. Follow Paul on Twitter @sporer and on Twitch at sporer.

newest oldest most voted

The big question mark with Hicks is playing time, no?
On a team with Judge, Stanton, Clint Frazier, and potentially bidding on Harper, where is he supposed to play?


Hicks has a 123 WRC+ and is a good defender. Clint Frazier’s upside is probably Aaron Hicks right now. Seems like a safe job for Hicks if he’s healthy.