Paul Sporer Baseball Chat – January 20th, 2017
Chat transcript is below:
3:05 |
: Hey everybody! Let’s talk some baseball |
3:05 |
: With Rasmus joining Dickerson in TB, is it fair to say the Rays outfield is ‘hardcore-y’? |
3:05 |
: Get out. |
3:05 |
: lol kidding, I did laugh at that |
3:07 |
: 12 team NL only 5×5. Rebuilding this year, playing for 2018/2019. Please rank: Drury, Toles,
|
3:07 |
: I think you just did. I just don’t buy Perez so I’d prefer the other 2 |
3:09 |
Josh Bell will split playing time with Jaso and Freese? : Do you think |
3:09 |
: Ya he’ll lose some time because despite being a switch hitter, he doesn’t hit lefties too well |
3:09 |
Austin Meadows is fantasy relevant in ___________ . : |
3:10 |
: NL-only leagues? It’s less about him and more about their outfield being really good (I think Cutch bounces back) |
3:10 |
: Should I trade away Hosmer & Gallo for
|
3:10 |
: I’d be OK with that, though it’d be helpful to know league context |
3:11 |
Andrew Triggs? Deep league sleeper? : What are your thoughts on |
3:12 |
: Ya I think so. Solid base skills, good GB%. Deserved better than his 4.31 ERA |
3:14 |
: Hi Paul. Really enjoying your ADP stuff but stymied by being in auction leagues. Is there a standard (if uneven) ADP-to-Auction$ conversion? I’m especially interested in only leagues, though that’s perhaps too many kettles of fish removed. Thanks! |
3:16 |
Jeff Zimmerman and he has done some work on it, but not in a particular piece. I think he’s going to do something in the near future for us, so stay tuned. : I can’t find anything immediately. Just pinged |
3:16 |
Dan Straily? How do you rank him as NL only starter over the next 2/3 years? : How much of a plus is the trade for |
3:17 |
: I don’t think his ERA is really going to improve, but rather that he’ll have a good shot at “earning” a similar ERA (in other words, his ERA/FIP will be much closer as Marlins Park should help stifle his HR issue) |
3:17 |
: Is Schwarber’s true talent avg/obp 250/350? |
3:18 |
: Projections are closer to .265/.355 but the difference is negligible between .250 and .265, so essentially yes. |
3:18 |
Taijuan Walker? I like them all but trying to get a feel for valuation…thanks! : Hi Paul – based on what you saw in 2016 can you rank for 2017: Matz, JGray, MMoore & |
3:21 |
: I like all four, too. I actually have them all within about a 12-spot clump – Gray, Matz, Walker, Moore. |
3:21 |
: Which C should I pick up for my dynasty league: Meija, Collins or Sisco? |
3:21 |
: Mejia |
3:21 |
Nate Jones better choice than Benoit or N Felix? Thinking Jones has a better shot of getting saves later in year, given Feliz and Benoit likely traded if they’re good? : Dynasty H2H – |
3:23 |
: With Robertson there, I’m just not sure Jones will thwart him. Love Jones if D-Rob is moved, but until then I think I prefer the two guys expected to close |
3:23 |
: At what point do you invest in elite non-closer relievers vs Starting Pitchers? Quintana too high? |
3:23 |
: I’d much prefer Quintana. I probably get at least 60 SPs deep before preferring stud non-closers |
3:24 |
: Any worries about Lester losing grandpa rossy? |
3:25 |
: A smidge, but I think he’ll be good still |
3:28 |
Ryon Healy’s future value? I know he’s a hot commodity right now, but if I invest in a dynasty I want him to have a moderately high ceiling : What’s |
3:29 |
: I don’t think his ceiling is massive. I’m a big fan as I’ve mentioned at every turn this offseason, but I think the ceiling is a .285/30 season which is v good, but not *elite* |
3:31 |
Freddie Freeman and estimate winning the auction at $20M or I could keep Carlos Santana for $10M. Rest of team is stacked, no holes and quality depth everywhere. They’d fill the UT slot. Is there enough difference in projections (5-year deals) to justify the cost? : Dynasty $120M budget – I have room for |
3:32 |
: It’s a pretty sharp AVG difference, but I’m not sure it’s worth 2x. If you have AVG coverage elsewhere on the team, I’d just go with Santana |
3:32 |
: How many of these players can/should I offer to land Trout? Correa, Springer, Polanco, Stanton, Freeman, Hosmer, Villar, Bird and Sano.. |
3:33 |
: Love Trout, but I wouldn’t want to decimate my team. My guess is that someone trading would want Correa to start and go from there. I have no idea what would get accepted, but if you really want Trout, you could offer Correa, Stanton, and Hosmer. |
3:33 |
: Is Tanaka the most forgotten-about Top 20 starter in baseball? |
3:34 |
: He’s a bit underrated right now and has been since news of his UCL tear came out. It’s a partial tear, though, and I think many have it in their mind that he WILL get TJ sooner or later and we can’t know that. I think some fail to realize that many pitchers have some kind of partial tear, but that can be 5% or 55%, we just don’t know. I still love Tanaka. |
3:37 |
: Should I be selling Jackie Bradley right now? Asked another way, is his value at it’s apex right now? |
3:38 |
: It’s probably in the upper reaches, ya. I’m a JBJ honk, but I recognize that plateauing is his best bet as opposed to getting markedly better at this point. V good real life player, but just a solid fantasy player |
3:43 |
: General Question: Is there a specific percentage of auction dollars you like to have on draft day after keepers? It’s looking like I will have spent 68% of my total auction dollars on keepers. |
3:44 |
: No, I don’t think there’s a general rule. It really depends on league setup and your individal team |
3:44 |
: I feel like Marcus STROMAN is in for a big year. What are your thoughts Pete? |
3:44 |
: WTF is Pete? |
3:45 |
: Rate the following on most saves expected in ’17: |
3:45 |
: Ottavino, Neris, Kelley, or J Johnson. How would you rank for ’17? |
3:45 |
: Ottavino, Johnson, Kelley, and Neris (I think Benoit closes) |
3:45 |
: What are your thoughts on xStats done by your colleagues? Pretttty interesting. |
3:46 |
Giancarlo Stanton is like the toxic ex girlfriend you can’t stop talking to : Great stuff to read. Always like learning and I’m glad they’re smart enough to do that stuff since I’m all good for is lame jokes about |
3:46 |
Matt Strahm? Gives the Royals a long term 1B/DH and the Angels clear up salary and get a starter : Could a deal be worked around CJ Cron for |
3:47 |
: Think the Royals might be working to extend Hosmer. They’re gonna keep someone(s) from their group of guys coming up for contract after this yr. They’ve dealt Davis and Dyson, could maybe deal another, but I think Hosmer and Moose or maybe Hos and Alcides get deals |
3:48 |
: Cliff, I like Stroman. I think he’s good for a mid-3.00s ERA with a good WHIP. Strikeout rate likely to be about average, though he did spike in 2H of ’16 |
3:48 |
: Paul, Who are some guys who might be a bit undervalued because they’re old and boring? |
3:51 |
: Pretty much all of em, but a few specifically: VMart, Beltran, Rajai. Miggy at the high end, even though he’s no worse than a 2nd rounder. |
3:52 |
Luis Valbuena get if he indeed signs with the angels? Will it depend on potential trades? : How much playing time will |
3:54 |
: I’d say about 450 PA slotting in vR regularly |
3:54 |
: Am I overly optimistic if I think peak Albies can hit 12-15HR and steal 35-40 bases? |
3:55 |
: Power feels high, but agree w/SBs. more of a high AVG/high SB guy |
3:55 |
: Where would you rank fulmer this year? Adp is 35 behind Reyes which I think is absurd. |
3:58 |
Alex Reyes. I’ve got Fulmer 31st right now : Ya I don’t really see how he’s behind |
3:58 |
: Eno and I discussed him yesterday and we think his ERA will in fact regress, but that his Ks could surge to offset it |
3:58 |
: trade my Correa away for Goldy & Villar? |
3:58 |
: Yessir, 100% |
4:03 |
Byron Buxton ($13), Chris Archer ($27), Zach Britton ($23) and Andrew Miller ($18). Standard Roto. : I can only keep 3 AL only auction: Hosmer ($26), JD Martinez ($26), |
4:04 |
: Martinez, Britton, and Buxton |
4:04 |
: What are your thoughts about Beltre heading into 2017? Great season last year, but how long can it last? |
4:08 |
: Hall of Famers often have smoother declines, but I understand the worries at age-38 because at that age it can just go instantly instead of a steady decline. For Beltre specifically, I still trust him |
4:09 |
: in a 10×9 category, 12-team H2H “keep forever” keeper league with the following categories: R H HR RBI SB BB K TB AVG OPS and IP k/9 k/bb QS W ERA WHIP HRagainst….which player would you prefer: Hamels, Trumbo or KDavis. Would you trade Hamels straight-up for either of them? |
4:10 |
: I’m not a huge Trumbo guy so I’d probably take Davis for him, but each is probably a fair deal |
4:10 |
: Rate the following NL pitchers on potential to bounce back: Strasburg, Harvey, DeGrom, Grienke, Cole. |
4:11 |
: Strasburg, Greinke, deGrom, Cole, and Harvey. I’m really playing wait-and-see with Harvey. Thoracic Outlet Surgery doesn’t have a great track record, but it’s relatively new, too, so I’ll have a close eye on Harvey in spring |
4:11 |
Jose Quintana vs. Matt Moore – worth the premium or worth the wait? : |
4:12 |
: Not sure Q is better enough to offset 4-5 rounds, I’d wait for Moore |
4:12 |
: Who has the better year in an OBP league – Cutch or Piscotty? OPS league? |
4:12 |
: Cutch in both |
4:12 |
: To piggyback on Hannah’s question- is there an auction price to draft round converter for those of us not in auction leagues? |
4:12 |
: Look for Jeff’s work in the near future on that |
4:13 |
Robbie Ray being a potential fantasy sleeper this year? Pitching at Chase doesn’t help but high strikeout guy anyway : Do you see |
4:16 |
: I’ve come around a little on him, but still don’t believe he was just unlucky. Was actually just discussing it – @heathcummingssr Park and GB%
|
4:16 |
Jacoby Ellsbury done yet? : Is |
4:16 |
: Not entirely, but I’m still taking you as a late flier in deep leagues, Aaron |
4:17 |
: Who do you like and dislike in the Astros’ rotation? |
4:17 |
: Keuchel came to my birthday, McHugh never responds to my texts, McCullers uses me to hang with Charlotte, Fiers and I had a falling out, and I don’t really know Morton yet |
4:18 |
: McCullers is my fave, upside is still huge. Keuchel is a solid mid-to-high 3.00s guy, McHugh and Fiers are AL-only fodder, and Morton is an intriguing gamble. Injury cut him short in PHI, but he was showing something with his new velo. I’ll throw a buck at him in a few lgs for sure |
4:19 |
: why has there been no talk about Tetsuto Yamada being posted, great numbers in Japan |
4:19 |
: I don’t know him 🙁 |
4:19 |
: Google Paul Sporer DUI. You’re basically a criminal now Nice work Pete |
4:19 |
: LOL, you jerks |
4:19 |
: i gotta delete that tweet now before ppl take it seriously |
4:20 |
: Any chance JDM gets traded this year if the Tigers fall behind? |
4:20 |
: yes, definitely possibly |
4:20 |
: possible* |
4:20 |
Max Kepler: Like, Love, or Dislike this year? : |
4:20 |
: Like |
4:20 |
: Is their much difference in production between rizzo and miggy? |
4:21 |
: Can Kepler make the leap into a top 40 OF this year or next three? |
4:21 |
: Ya he certainly could |
4:21 |
Carlos Martinez or Chris Archer in a dynasty? Is it close? : |
4:21 |
: Archer, but yes it’s close |
4:21 |
Kevin Kiermaier’s playing time with the Rasmus and Smith additions? : Hey Paul. We love you in Tennessee…or I do, at least. Anyways, should I worry about |
4:21 |
: Thanks!! No, you shouldn’t. His defense guarantees his spot. Bat is emerging, too. I like KK |
4:22 |
: First year player draft (diamond mind), which Cardinal: S.Oh or A.Diaz? |
4:22 |
: I’m a big Oh fan |
4:22 |
Tyson Ross? Just read today he’s going to be out until May / June. AL only league, should I even bother trying to spend $ on, or let someone else have him? : What are your thoughts on |
4:22 |
: I wouldn’t bother. Let someone else deal with the headache this year and monitor him for ’18 |
4:22 |
: What are the odds Trevor may is minnesotas closer this year? |
4:22 |
: 36% |
4:23 |
: Good afternoon Paul. Hope you are well. I play in an AL only league, OBP is a category. Would you keep (same price of $2) vogelbach or berrios? |
4:23 |
: Doin pretty well, thanks! I’d keep Berrios. Awful yr in 16, but I’m not giving up |
4:23 |
Kelvin Herrera can become a top 5 closer? : Think |
4:23 |
: Yes, I do and I’ve been drafting him as such since the Davis deal |
4:23 |
: Love the podcast. 20tm H2H Dynasty (holds lg) – trade Ottavino and Ramos for Betances? |
4:24 |
: Thank you! Even w/the holds I don’t think I’d do that. I really like Ottavino. And Ramos is pretty good, too. Dellin rules, but he’s not SO much better to trade two strong RPs for him |
4:24 |
: hey paul, can you rank smyly, tai walker and nola for next year? |
4:24 |
: Nola, Walker, Smyly |
4:24 |
: First impressions on ADP: which positions are you waiting on? Which positions do you want in early on? (hitters and pitchers) |
4:25 |
http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/early-adp-thoughts-outfield-part-1/ : Waiting on 2B for sure. Think there’s some depth to 3B, too. Would like a cornerstone 1B. I’m doing a series on the early ADP – |
4:25 |
: Type faster my guy!! |
4:26 |
: Seriously? |
4:26 |
Cody Allen get more saves than Miller? : Will |
4:26 |
: I think so, yes |
4:26 |
: Better keeper, slightly-below-market Lester or minimum Fulmer? |
4:26 |
: Min Fulmer |
4:26 |
Robbie Ray question), is he a possible Top 25 SP in standard scoring leagues? : Also (in regards to earlier |
4:26 |
: It would take quite a leap for that |
4:26 |
: Solarte has long been one of my favorite bottom of the draft guys bc of his positional eligibility. He’s now only eligible at 3B for this season (had 1 and 2b last year), do you forsee him getting time at other positions this year? Any other utility types to target? |
4:27 |
: I love GOATlarte, too, but it does suck that he’s 1 position now. I could definitely see him bouncing around the IF and acquiring some in-season elig. |
4:28 |
: Please rank Duffy, Fulmer, Smyly, Porcello |
4:28 |
: Duffy, Porcello, Fulmer, Smyly |
4:28 |
: Are these players worth the following in 12 team with OBP, mixed league: Yelich ($21), Cabrera ($44), Lester ($10) |
4:29 |
: Yelich is a little cheaper than market, Cabrera is market cost, and Lester is much cheaper |
4:29 |
: How do you feel about Ray if we add K/9 as a category? |
4:29 |
: It helps, but I’m still not gaga over him |
4:29 |
: whoa, real high on Walker are we? |
4:29 |
: are we? |
4:29 |
: I guess I am higher. I’ve got him 45, market is 61st |
4:30 |
: is jd martinez (assuming health) a lock for .280 and 35 bombs? |
4:30 |
: Ya I feel good about that |
4:30 |
: So do you think Pollock can accomplish 15HR/30steals? |
4:30 |
: Definitely |
4:30 |
: Quick one, Kiermaier or Broxton? |
4:30 |
: Kiermaier |
4:30 |
James Paxton: dislike, like, or love this year? : |
4:30 |
: Love |
4:30 |
: Considering picking up MLB The Show next year just to get me through January. Oof, this has been rough |
4:31 |
: They’ve been pumping out new cards all winter. It really does help me get through it, tbh. I haven’t been able to really play at all this week, but I should have time tonight |
4:31 |
: Re: bounceback pitchers – is there a higher ceiling than Harvey? |
4:31 |
: He still has a v high ceiling if the TOS healing is quick |
4:31 |
: It’s just such an unknown, espec. bc so many who have had TOS were older |
4:32 |
: I’m seeing mccullers being drafted as top 50 sp. if he reduces walks and stays healthy, is top 15 possible? |
4:33 |
: There’s huge breakout potential, but he NEEEEDS to stay healthy. Something like a top 15 breakout is like a 5% outcome, but I’ll be investing in the upside |
4:33 |
: Re: Astros rotation…Do you see a young guy making an sizeable impact, i.e. Martes or Devenski? |
4:33 |
: Martes, Devenski, and Paulino will be waiting in the wings if injury or under performance strikes |
4:33 |
: Devenski is a sneak tip solid investment in deeper leagues |
4:33 |
James Paxton as an ace, both in real and fantasy and would you keep at $13 in $260 auction with maybe 10 good pitchers not owned and available : Do you believe in |
4:34 |
: Def keeping at $13. For me an ace is more established, so he’s not there yet, but he can be a strong #2 this year if he stays upright |
4:34 |
: Keeper draft for years but want to try something else. Where would you go for your first auction draft? |
4:34 |
: Can you start a home league? Live auctions are life! |
4:34 |
: Expectations for Stanton this season? |
4:34 |
: Disappointment. |
4:35 |
: 35/.260 |
4:35 |
: Hello friend! |
4:35 |
: Hi |
4:35 |
: Over / under 180 innings for McCullers this year? |
4:35 |
: Under |
4:35 |
: With homers up so much last season, Hosmer’s 25 HR was pretty average right? Do you believe in Hosmer in a dynasty lgs? Is the skill set better than 2016 performance? |
4:36 |
: Ya 25 wasn’t special. He’s alright, but if he’s not hitting for high AVG, then his meh HR totals just don’t do much for me |
4:36 |
Dansby Swanson in my 16 TM deep keeper? : what should my trade value be for my own |
4:36 |
: Relatively high |
4:36 |
: Sporer, when looking at Astros rotation, no info on Musgrove or Paulino. Where do you think they slot in? |
4:37 |
: Ooh Musgrove, forgot to mention him earlier. The Astros staff isn’t star-studded, but there is depth. If some of these backend guys don’t work out or get hurt, they have viable replacements. I like Musgrove |
4:37 |
: Please rank for dynasty: Taillon, Fulmer, Gray, Manaea |
4:37 |
: Fulmer, Gray, Manaea, Taillon |
4:37 |
: young SP…rank: J.Gray, A.Nola, J.Paxton, R.Ray |
4:37 |
: Paxton, Gray, Nola, Ray |
4:37 |
: OBP into consideration, who would you target for 2B: segura or odor? |
4:38 |
: if OBP matters, I gotta go Segura. Odor’s HR advantage means less if HRs remain high like ’16 |
4:38 |
: What odds do you give Gallo getting 300 ABs this year? |
4:38 |
: 30% |
4:38 |
Brad Miller, Andrew Miller and Nate Jones or Hanley, Profar and Ian Kennedy? : Which side do you like in AL only roto, |
4:38 |
: Hanley side, but it’s a good deal for both, IMO |
4:39 |
|
4:39 |
: That red pops! |
4:39 |
: I like it, Just announced? Wonder if MLB 17 will be able to get em in |
4:39 |
: Over under for correa: 25 HR , 100 RBI, 90 R , 15 SB and .850 slash line. |
4:39 |
: Can’t really do multiple categories for an over/under |
4:39 |
: Bc you have to answer em all individually |
4:41 |
: I’d say that’s a reasonable projection and there is a solid chance for more that’s why he’s a bona fide late-first, early-second rounder |
4:41 |
Maikel Franco ever get to 30 HRs annually? : Does |
4:41 |
: I can definitely see it. He’s very early in his career, be patient |
4:41 |
: Surprised Taillon last…are you down on him? |
4:42 |
: No, it’s a tough group, though |
4:42 |
: Think he can put up some 200-IP seasons of his ’16 numbers, but I don’t see him getting markedly better |
4:42 |
Tommy Joseph this year? Is he platoon bound? : What do you expect out of |
4:43 |
: He’ll get some off days vR, but more or less a full timer |
4:43 |
: I know you shouldn’t turn dollars into quarters, but I could use the depth in a dynasty. Yu for Hanley and Teheran? |
4:43 |
: I’m in on that, especially with your stated purpose |
4:43 |
: Couple more, y’all |
4:45 |
: If Robles tears up AA in 2017, do you think he can play in September? |
4:45 |
: It’s possible because anyone is a call away once in AA these days, but I don’t see it happening |
4:45 |
Hunter Renfroe eventually be the Padres all-time HR leader? : Will |
4:45 |
: Sure |
4:46 |
: (I have no idea) |
4:46 |
: But he does have exquisite power |
4:46 |
: Thanks for answering all my questions, I greatly appreciate it. Just can’t wait for baseball. |
4:46 |
: No problem! |
4:46 |
Tyler Skaggs pitch this year? And is he a nice deep league option? : How many innings does |
4:46 |
: 165, yes |
4:47 |
: Gun to your head. Keeper, leaves out Bregman, Beni, or Dahl? |
4:47 |
: Ooh damn |
4:47 |
: I think it’s Beni |
4:47 |
: Who you like more: Joc or Grichuk? |
4:47 |
: Joc |
4:48 |
Byron Buxton or Keon Broxton? Who do you like better for 2017 : |
4:48 |
: Still betting on Byron’s upside |
4:48 |
: Keeper……deeeeeeeeeep, Soler or Gurriel? |
4:48 |
: Soler’s PT seems more stable |
4:48 |
: Broxton and Dahl too much to give up for Villar? |
4:49 |
: It’s steep, but Broxton is flawed enough that he could end up being a virtual non-factor so then it’s Dahl for Villar |
4:49 |
: OK y’all, I gotta get goin’! Thanks for coming out. Tons of activity in these last couple chats. Next week I should have more time for a bigger one |
4:52 |
: thanks, Paul |
Strongly disagree with Segura over Odor in any format unless steals are worth double. They have the same OBP projection. Segura’s power was complete fluke and he’s moving to tougher balpark. Inflated BABIP. I mean steamer wOBA/wRC+is .339/108 Odor to .307/94 for Segura that’s a big gap that’s factoring in OBP. Unless those 10-15 steals are worth more than 15 HRs and 80 points of SLG in your format, you’d be crazy to lean Segura.
Segura’s power wasn’t a complete fluke, though it was park-influenced. How was the BABIP inflated? High contact, groundball hitter with speed… that’s the recipe for BABIP.
Segura had 19 more SBs last year, had 20+ every season, and Odor is a terrible base stealer so I’m not sure why it’d only be 10-15. I don’t see any real reason to project Odor for double digits. Meanwhile, Zimmerman had HR and SB valued equally going into last year, so his SB advantage can offset the HR deficit. Given the boon in HRs and continued scarcity of SB, they might even be worth more these days.
SLG wasn’t said to be a category in the league.
Bottom line is they’re close, IMO, but I trust Segura to hold some of his OBP gains in ’16 more than I trust Odor to randomly start walking
Ignoring the disagreement on the fluke power part, Segura had the highest FB% rate of his career last year and at the same time the highest BABIP by 30 pts. He’s always been fast and a ground ball guy. I call that inflated.
Re the SB difference – just going by the steamer projections which are on the low end of the 10-15 range (also don’t think Segura will be on base nearly as much as I’ve established).
It’s not just slug though – it’s 28 projected RBI because of that slug.
I don’t see it as close, but agree to disagree. It’s what makes fantasy fun.
You completely fail to mention the other issues Segura was dealing with while accruing those stats. I’d love to see your performance when dealing with the death of your son. Then have people call your performance a fluke when you no longer are playing with that heavy burden on your shoulders.
Could he regress? Sure, but to sit there and act like the stats you hold is gospel is laughable.
You’d love to see that? Little harsh. I can’t imagine that grief and would understand if it affected his performance, but I’m just analyzing what I can.
I agree that to take Segura is questionable but it is very close. I am in a 5X5 roto where TB take the place of HR and OBP takes the place of AVG and the two are extremely close according to my projections (which have not been adjusted for Park changes). Odor by a nose, maybe two noses once Safeco is factored in.