More Help Needed: 2013 & 2014 Closer Roles
On Wednesday, I asked for help to verify historic preseason closer situations and how those roless held up. Today, I will task your memory and ask for help with two more seasons. After getting these two seasons straightened out, I’ll call it quits on the collection process and begin the analysis next week.
Please look over your favorite team and make sure the information is correct. Additionally, look over the situation with question marks as the information I gathered was vague. Finally, here is the meanings of each column.
- One guy – The team announced the closer at the start of spring training.
- Another guy – Someone besides the initially announced closer got the job.
- Competition – The team didn’t announce a set closer and had several players vying for the job.
- Replacement coming – The team’s expected closer was hurt or suspended but was expected to take the job over later.
- Replaced returned – Expected closer returned to the role after being out.
- EOS – End of season
- Traded away – The team traded away the closer
- Traded for – The team trade for a new closer
- Poor performance – The pitcher performed so bad they lost their role.
- Injury – Lost role because of injury
- Suspension – Closer lost role because of suspension
Team | Going into Spring Training | Going into season | (Eventual)Top Guy | Steamer ERA | Last Until | Reason if Replaced |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Angels | One guy | One guy | Ernesto Frieri | 2.70 | April 27th | Poor performance |
Astros | Competition | Competition | Chad Qualls | 4.03 | EOS | none |
Athletics | One guy | One guy | Jim Johnson | 3.40 | April 10th | Poor performance |
Blue Jays | Competition | One guy | Sergio Santos | 3.06 | May 4th | Poor performance |
Braves | One guy | One guy | Craig Kimbrel | 1.79 | EOS | none |
Brewers | Competition | One guy | Francisco Rodriguez | 3.57 | EOS | none |
Cardinals | One guy | One guy | Trevor Rosenthal | 2.55 | EOS | none |
Cubs | One guy | One guy | Jose Veras | 3.47 | April 12th | Poor performance |
D-backs | Competition | One guy | Addison Reed | 3.06 | EOS | none |
Dodgers | One guy | One guy | Kenley Jansen | 2.16 | EOS | none |
Giants | One guy | One guy | Sergio Romo | 3.04 | June 29th | Poor performance |
Indians | One guy | One guy | John Axford | 3.64 | May 9th | Poor performance |
Mariners | One guy | One guy | Fernando Rodney | 3.08 | EOS | none |
Marlins | One guy | One guy | Steve Cishek | 3.32 | EOS | none |
Mets | Competition | One guy(?) | Jose Valverde | 4.18 | April 20th | Poor performance |
Nationals | One guy | One guy | Rafael Soriano | 3.74 | Sept 7th | Poor performance |
Orioles | Competition | One guy | Tommy Hunter | 3.60 | May 20th | Injury |
Padres | One guy | One guy | Huston Street | 3.51 | July 19th | Traded away |
Phillies | One shit bag | Same shit bag | Shit bag | 3.15 | Sept 16th | Suspension |
Pirates | One guy | One guy | Jason Grilli | 2.40 | April 27th | Injury |
Rangers | Competition | One guy | Joakim Soria | 3.61 | July 23rd | Trade away |
Rays | One guy | One guy | Grant Balfour | 3.12 | June 9th | Poor performance |
Red Sox | One guy | One guy | Koji Uehara | 2.17 | Sept 6th | Poor performance |
Reds | One guy | Replacement coming | J.J. Hoover | 3.39 | April 8th | Poor performance |
Rockies | Competition | Competition | LaTroy Hawkins | 3.66 | EOS | none |
Royals | One guy | One guy | Greg Holland | 2.39 | EOS | none |
Tigers | One guy | One guy | Joe Nathan | 3.03 | EOS | none |
Twins | One guy | One guy | Glen Perkins | 2.75 | Septh 16th | Injury |
White Sox | Competition(?) | One guy | Matt Lindstrom | 4.02 | May 20th | Injury |
Yankees | One guy | One guy | David Robertson | 3.05 | April 8th | Injury |
Team | Going into Spring Training | Going into season | (Eventual)Top Guy | Steamer ERA | Last Until | Reason if Replaced |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Angels | Competition | Replacement coming? (Madson) | Ernesto Frieri | 3.06 | July 18th | Poor performance |
Astros | One guy | One guy | Jose Veras | 3.88 | July 29th | Traded away |
Athletics | One guy | One guy | Grant Balfour | 3.46 | EOS | none |
Blue Jays | One guy | One guy (Replacement coming?) | Casey Janssen | 3.28 | EOS | none |
Braves | One guy | One guy | Craig Kimbrel | 1.84 | EOS | none |
Brewers | One guy | One guy | Jim Henderson | 3.67 | May 25th | Injury |
Cardinals | Competition | One guy | Edward Mujica | 3.41 | Sept 21st | Poor performance |
Cubs | One guy | One guy | Carlos Marmol | 3.55 | April 6th | Poor performance |
D-backs | One guy | One guy | J.J. Putz | 2.98 | May 8th | Injury |
Dodgers | One guy | One guy | Brandon League | 3.33 | June 11th | Poor performance |
Giants | One guy | One guy | Sergio Romo | 2.74 | EOS | none |
Indians | One guy | One guy | Chris Perez | 3.68 | May 25th | Injury |
Mariners | Competition? | One guy | Tom Wilhelmsen | 3.48 | June 14th | Poor performance |
Marlins | One guy | One guy | Steve Cishek | 3.47 | EOS | none |
Mets | One guy | One guy | Bobby Parnell | 3.18 | July 31st | Injury |
Nationals | One guy | One guy | Rafael Soriano | 3.15 | EOS | none |
Orioles | One guy | One guy | Jim Johnson | 3.54 | EOS | none |
Padres | One guy? | One guy? | Huston Street | 2.91 | June 1st | Injury |
Phillies | Shit bag | Same shit bag | Shit bag | 2.58 | EOS | none |
Pirates | One guy | One guy | Jason Grilli | 2.75 | July 22nd | Injury |
Rangers | One guy | One guy | Joe Nathan | 2.98 | EOS | none |
Rays | One guy | One guy | Fernando Rodney | 3.20 | EOS | none |
Red Sox | One guy | One guy | Joel Hanrahan | 3.50 | April 14th | Injury |
Reds | Competition | One guy | Aroldis Chapman | 2.35 | EOS | none |
Rockies | Competition? | One guy | Rafael Betancourt | 3.37 | June 1st | Injury |
Royals | One guy | One guy | Greg Holland | 3.08 | EOS | none |
Tigers | Competition | Replacement coming | Joaquin Benoit | 3.11 | April 23rf | Replacement Returned |
Twins | One guy | One guy | Glen Perkins | 3.09 | EOS | none |
White Sox | One guy | One guy | Addison Reed | 3.46 | EOS | none |
Yankees | One guy | One guy | Mariano Rivera | 3.15 | EOS | none |
Thanks again and with the data checked, the analysis can begin.
Thanks to Jared Cross for the historic Steamer projections and RotoWire for the player updates.
Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won four FSWA Awards including on for his Mining the News series. He's won Tout Wars three times, LABR twice, and got his first NFBC Main Event win in 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.
2014:

it amazing how many of those long-shot candidates were closers last year or projected closers for this year.
Is this from Rotoballer.com or somewhere else?
From rotoballer.com, on Opening Day.