Mike Aviles Meets Value Catapult

In December, the Boston Red Sox traded Jed Lowrie to the Houston Astros, which presumably increased the value of Jed Lowrie, but also cemented Marco Scutaro as the team’s shortstop for 2012. Draft sheets were dutifully updated.

Rather inexplicably, the Red Sox recently traded said cemented shortstop to the Colorado Rockies which left a few scratching their heads and scouring Twitter to see if there was another hand to be played. After all, that left the Red Sox without a real natural shortstop and according to The Fielding Bible, shortstops are important.

Enter Mike Aviles.

The immediate speculation was some kind of platoon between Aviles and Nick Punto, which might leave a lot to be desired in Boston, but it presents a tantalizing opportunity to pounce from a fantasy baseball angle. Looking objectively at the two, they are the yin and the yang of utility infielders. Where Punto is clearly superior defensively, he produces with the bat like it’s one of those foot long souvenir splinters. Aviles has always hit pretty well — and sometimes very well — but isn’t known for his defensive abilities, although he has held his own at the six in the past. Based on that crude cursory glance, I’d have to put my money on Aviles getting the majority of starts at shortstop until he proves his glove totally incapable.

Should Aviles be named the “starter” — and for fantasy purposes, that probably means to be on the field no fewer than five times a week — you should take notice.

Aviles will be 31 when the 2012 season starts and yet he’s never played in more than 110 games — some of that due to team decisions and some of that due to injury. He’s known for swinging at everything but making a lot of contact, and he possesses decent pop. He’s reached double digit home runs just once as a major leaguer, but again, that was playing about two-thirds of a full season.

The tempting part is the promise of regular playing time. Last season, in just 286 at-bats, Avlies managed seven home runs and 14 stolen bases, actually experiencing miserable batted-ball luck in Kansas City somewhat balanced out by some good fortune upon arrival in Boston, where he hit .317/.340/.436 in a little over 100 plate appearances.

Then there’s the allure of ballpark fit. Aviles is happiest when he’s pulling the ball, and it just so happens that Fenway is happy to deliver a lot of doubles to right handed pull hitters due to something about a big wall in left. Aviles is a career .368/.366/.638 pull hitter, hitting nearly 90% of his home runs to left field, and it wouldn’t take too much of an imagination to see him bouncing balls off the monster routinely in 2012.

A shortstop with the potential to hit for average and provide double digit home runs and stolen bases is pretty valuable. If he can find 500 plate appearances in 2012, Mike Aviles could be a pretty attractive — and sneaky — pick in your looming fantasy draft.

Keep an eye on the shortstop situation in Boston. While they almost certainly are kicking the tires on a flashier option at shortstop, the current budget might not allow for it, which might open the door for Aviles to become a regular option once again.

We hoped you liked reading Mike Aviles Meets Value Catapult by Michael Barr!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

Michael was born in Massachusetts and grew up in the Seattle area but had nothing to do with the Heathcliff Slocumb trade although Boston fans are welcome to thank him. You can find him on twitter at @michaelcbarr.

newest oldest most voted

Shhhhhh!!!! I wish you had made up an article about how the Sox really want to focus on Defense, like in 2010, and will be looking at Punto to play often. Then we could have had Aviles to ourselves.

Good bit on Aviles’s pull numbers. He will be at the bottom of the lineup when he does play, hitting behind a guy named Crawford. RBIs may abound for Aviles if Crawford gets back in the lineup sooner rather than later and has a better season than last.