MASH Report 8/22/16
Let’s get to the injury updates/analysis….
Jung Ho Kang is on the 15-day DL with a left shoulder injury. No official word as to what he hurt, but the way he landed on it gives me some pause. Hopefully it is minor, and he did run off the field afterwards. These impact injuries could be anything in such a complex joint as the shoulder, from a collarbone fracture to a ligament sprain to a labral tear. Yes, non-pitchers can tear their labrum too. Tough timing because he was starting to hit the ball well.
Matt Cain is back on the DL, this time for “low back strain.” Conspiracy theory folks, get your tin-foil hat on, because this has the feeling of a sneaky roster move. Regardless of true injury or not, it doesn’t appear to be serious and he should be fine. I only bring this up as a reminder that, when looking at a team’s injury statistics, roster moves sometimes account for trips to the DL. I can recall many times (yes, minor leagues, but still) players being sent to the DL for phantom injuries, just to clear a spot.
No real update on Matt Holliday yet, other than the surgery was a success. I assume they are also going to try and accelerate the healing with a bone growth stimulator.
Seth Maness was scheduled for Tommy John surgery but, once the surgeon got inside of his elbow, it was decided to not reconstruct the ligament (which is what TJS is—making a new ligament) but to just repair his existing one. This could cut his recovery time in half, meaning he probably won’t miss the entire 2017 season, and possibly is back early 2017. You don’t see this decision very often, switching from a planned TJS to a repair.
Trevor Rosenthal’s throwing program is delayed as he still is dealing with his shoulder. Interesting note that there “may also be a forearm issue” and that his altered throwing program delay “was done with the idea that the PRP injection Rosenthal received could use the time to take root, flush out the inflammation, and heal the shoulder.” I don’t quite agree with the “flush out the inflammation” part but it’s semantics really. Bottom line? He might not make it back for the season.
Those of you counting on a quick Jose Bautista return, you’re in luck. Maybe end of this week.
Back to the DL again for Geovany Soto. Remember he had a right meniscal surgery in May, came back but then his left knee hurt (compensating for right knee recovery) and now the right one is flared up again. In his words, it was “angry.” We all know the toil catchers put on their knees, and the fact that fluid continues to build up here has to be frustrating for everyone. Plus, before the knee flared up again, he also was dealing with a bruised thumb. I bet he’s done.
John Lackey has a tired shoulder/headed to the DL, and I think this is nothing more than time to rest for one of the Cubs’ stalwarts. 18 quality starts, playoff experience, and a clubhouse leader are all reasons the Cubs want to make sure they have him for their playoff run.
Zach Wheeler had his elbow examined by that-famous-sports-surgeon-we-have-all-heard-of, and while his surgically (TJS) reconstructed elbow is still intact, now he has a flexor muscle strain, effectively ending his season.
Here’s a fun one….Billy Butler is out due to injuries received from a brawl with teammate Danny Valencia. Definitely sounds like a concussion.
Yunel Escobar and Nick Franklin are both on the relatively-new 7-day DL (started in 2011). These guys aren’t major fantasy impact guys, but I bring it up just to highlight MLB’s concussion-only DL. As a society we are learning so much about concussions and what they are/how to treat them. The main thing is that the brain (concussions are a brain injury) needs time to heal, both from physical and mental activities. That’s precisely what this DL gives them….sometimes 15 days is not needed and it can restrict roster situations.
Giancarlo Stanton MAY not be done for 2016, according to Marlins brass. If you feel the need to stash him, go on ahead wit yo bad self.
BJ has been a licensed AT (athletic trainer) since before the last MLB strike (do the math). He spends his days working for a major medical device/brace company and his nights...well, this. Follow him on the Twittaz @bjmaack
John Lackey and “clubhouse leader”, in the same paragraph without a ‘not’ somewhere in between. Not a transformation of Yunellian proportions, but still pretty impressive.
Well-played sir. No, I get your point and agree that I probably didn’t sue the right phrase here. I will say, however, that right/wrong/indifferent, he is a gamer and competitor and that is what I was trying to convey.
Strasburg on DL with “right forearm soreness.” Uh-oh.
Hate that I missed this one before I posted. Yeah, if you match his recent performance with this news, you have to assume it’s not just “soreness”—the Nationals are probably fearing the worst. I will relay info/analysis as soon as I can.
Thanks for the note.
Everything I’ve seen has said elbow, not forearm soreness. Obviously it could be a ruse but they are still saying he could pitch now if he wanted to.
Excellent reminder of how it’s important to pay attention to the whole story. Initial reports say that “structurally” the elbow is fine (meaning they think the ligament is intact, although until they do an MRI it’s not clear). Saying “forearm soreness” or even “elbow soreness” gives them the flexibility to be cautious without panicking. I know this sounds condescending and not trying to be but remember the forearm muscles attach to the elbow joint, so technically both can be correct at the same time. Appreciate the comment
Really hope Matz doesn’t miss much time with this “minor shoulder strain”. Thoughts?
This is another one that I missed the deadline on…..thanks. So, given his injury past, and his heavy workload this year (heavy for him, mind you), I would not hold out high hopes. “Headed to the DL” equals a 15 day minimum (depends on when they retroactive this one).
Any word on Kershaw’s recovery? I heard he declared himself “100 percent” after Saturdays bullpen, and they’re aiming to activate him end of the month.
Also curious as to your take on Paxton. He was looking great before the DL trip, and I’m hearing Thursday for an activation.
And with Lackey, when do we expect him back and will he pitch deep enough for QSs?
Sadly I have all three on the same team, and the playoffs started today.
Paxton should be fine this week, assuming no setbacks. I am hearing nothing saying otherwise.
Kershaw isn’t eligible until the 27th, and his last bullpen session showed no ill signs. I think he will be limited in his return, but he should return nonetheless.
Lackey will be back first day he is eligible (Aug 30) or shortly thereafter. I don’t see this as anything other than “-itis” meaning no real structural damage.
Thanks for the questions. Hoping you can survive this round of your playoffs, because if you can, you should be better off next week.
Thanks!
Can I safely cut Shin Soo Choo? 14 team mixed, playoffs underway.
If he is taking up a roster spot you can use to help you now, then Choo needs to go. He won’t be back for at least 4 weeks, and you need to be playing this week-by-week, I would assume.
Ah, right. Forgot to mention no DL slots in my format, and yes I could use all the help I can get. Appreciate the response.
Anytime.