Lineup Analysis (4/20/25)

American League
Angels
• Tim Anderson (.422 OPS) and Kevin Newman (.273 OPS) split time at shortstop.
Astros
• Mauricio Dubón doesn’t start against lefties.
Athletics
• Brent Rooker with three games in the outfield.
• There is no regular third baseman with Max Schuemann, Luis Urías, and Gio Urshela starting last week.
Blue Jays
• The outfield is already crowded (Straw, Barger, Roden, Santander) with Springer and Varsho getting healthy. There likely won’t be enough playing to go around for the lesser bats.
• Will Wagner and Ernie Clement split time at third base.
Guardians
• With Lane Thomas off the IL, Angel Martínez and Nolan Jones each started one game in right field.
• Daniel Schneemann (.200/.273/.433, 2 HR) started in three of the last four games at second base.
Mariners
• With Dylan Moore moving to second base, Miles Mastrobuoni and Ben Williamson split time at third base.
• Jorge Polanco is the DH and bats second but only against righties.
Orioles
• Ramón Urías (.772 OPS) started the last two games at third base instead of Jordan Westburg (.591 OPS).
Rangers
• Dustin Harris with three starts in left field over the last four games.
Rays
• Normal mess. The only regulars are Yandy Díaz and Junior Caminero. It won’t clear up with Chandler Simpson on the way.
Red Sox
• Carlos Narvaez catches most games.
Royals
• Drew Waters (vs RHP) and MJ Melendez (vs LHP) might be in a left field platoon.
Tigers
• It’s tough to determine if there are any patterns.
• Zach McKinstry started in seven of the last eight games.
Twins
• Edouard Julien hit leadoff for four straight games.
• While batting the bottom of the order, Brooks Lee has started in three of the last four games.
White Sox
• Lenyn Sosa started nine straight games.
• Chase Meidroth hit leadoff last game.
• The outfield playing time might clear up with Andrew Benintendi off the IL.
Yankees
• No changes from last week.
National League
Braves
• Check in on this lineup over the weekend with Marcell Ozuna (hip) sitting, Alex Verdugo promoted, and Bryan De La Cruz demoted.
• Eli White (.571 OPS in 468 career PA) started four straight in the outfield.
Brewers
• Garrett Mitchell (.655 OPS, 0 HR, 1 SB) started in centerfield against the last lefty.
• Speedster Caleb Durbin has been promoted. In AAA, he’s mainly played third base, so the Oliver Dunn/Vinny Capra platoon might be done.
Cardinals
• Brendan Donovan started four games at shortstop.
• I’m not sure how much Thomas Saggese and Nolan Gorman will play going forward with Masyn Winn about to come off the IL.
Cubs
• Jon Berti (.598 OPS) and Gage Workman (.697 OPS) split the first two games at third base after the demotion of Matt Shaw to AAA.
Diamondbacks
• Garrett Hampson (.593 OPS) and Tim Tawa (.754 OPS) continue to split time at second base.
• Over the last 10 games, Alek Thomas (.766 OPS) started seven times and Jake McCarthy (.305 OPS) four times.
Dodgers
• Michael Conforto moved up to batting fifth with Max Muncy moving down to seventh.
Giants
• No changes
Marlins
• Jesús Sánchez sat against the first lefty starter since coming off the IL.
• Griffin Conine (.831 OPS) started in 12 of the last 13 games.
• Matt Mervis (vs RHP) and Eric Wagaman (vs LHP) form a first base platoon.
Mets
• Bretty Baty got two starts at third base in the last four games while hitting .375/.375/.563 this past week. The second base playing time situation is muddled with Baty, Luisangel Acuña, and Jeff McNeil (on a rehab assignment).
• Tyrone Taylor started four straight in center field with Jose Siri on the IL.
Nationals
• With Paul DeJong on the IL, Amed Rosario starts at third base.
• With CJ Abrams on the IL, Nasim Nuñez (.801 OPS) started four straight at shortstop.
• Jacob Young (.677 OPS) is losing centerfield reps to Dylan Crews (.324 OPS). I’m not sure why.
• Because all the middle infielders are banged up, Luis García Jr. starts every game. He normally sits against lefties.
Padres
• Oscar Gonzalez (vs LHP) is now on the short side of the left field platoon with Jason Heyward (vs RHP) on the strong side.
• With Jake Cronenworth on the IL, Jose Iglesias started seven straight games at second base.
• The regular center fielder is unknown with Jackson Merrill and Brandon Lockridge on the IL. Jason Heyward (1 G) and Tyler Wade (2 G) have both played there so far.
Phillies
• Bryson Stott (vs RHP) and Edmundo Sosa (vs LHP) platoon at second base.
• With Brandon Marsh (knee) banged up, Johan Rojas (.648 OPS) started in centerfield in four of the last five games.
Pirates
• Enmanuel Valdez (.205/.295/.333) started the four games at first base.
Reds
• Since returning from the IL, Austin Hays has played every game and hits third or fourth.
• Several guys are or have been banged up, so it’s tough to get a read on the exact situation.
Rockies
• Nick Martini (vs RHP) and Sean Bouchard (vs LHP) are in a right field platoon.
• Adael Amador (6 K in 14 PA) started four straight games at second base while batting ninth.
• Mickey Moniak (.225/.295/.475) started seven straight games.
Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won four FSWA Awards including on for his Mining the News series. He's won Tout Wars three times, LABR twice, and got his first NFBC Main Event win in 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.