Kyle Blanks, Trayvon Robinson, Brad Brach: Mining the Minors
This week, we’ll cover two Padres and a Dodger. In other words, those of you in NL West-only leagues are in luck.
Similar to the other version of this column, which hits on Thursdays, the Friday edition offers a take on elite prospects, lesser-known farmhands and veteran minor leaguers — all with a nod to their fantasy relevance and impact, specifically for this season. To help owners, I’ll include a player’s Talent Rating; but just as important is the Opportunity Rating, which points out the likelihood that a player will make his way to the majors during the year.
Kyle Blanks, 1B/OF
Organization: Padres
Current Level: Triple-A
Statistics: .315 BA; .985 OPS; 15 HRs; 59 RBIs; 71:31 K:BB over 292 ABs
40-man roster: Yes
Opportunity Rating: 9 (out of 10)
Talent Rating: 8 (out of 10)
Obstacle(s): Position questions; alarming strikeout rate
Just 16 months ago, Blanks was one of fantasy’s top sleepers. The 2004 draftee (a 42nd- round steal) was rated as the Padres’ top prospect after 2008 and coming off a rookie campaign in which he’d mashed 10 HRs and posted an impressive .868 OPS in 148 ABs. Sure, there were warning signs — he K’d in 34% of his ABs — but the the first baseman-turned-outfielder’s power was hard to ignore. Then the righty-hitting Blanks went out and batted just .157 — with an even worse 45% K rate — in his first 102 ABs in 2010, earning him a ticket back to Triple-A. Soon thereafter he had TJ surgery, and his 2010 went from promising to disappointing to over.
Besides the injury, questions about his place in the organization began to arise during the offseason after the Padres acquired first base prospect Anthony Rizzo from the Red Sox in the Adrian Gonzalez trade. Plus, Blanks not only got a late start to 2011 at the end of April, he also was sent to Double-A to begin his recovery. Despite a so-so 200 plate appearances at San Antonio, Blanks got bumped to Triple-A in June, just as Rizzo got the call to the majors, and the numbers have followed: .365/.435/.791. Even better, he’s smacked 5 HRs and 16 RBIs in his past 10 games. He’s now nearing the one-year anniversary of his major surgery, and Blanks seems to finally be getting back to full health.
There are still some caution flags here. Blanks is still whiffing at 24% this year, which will translate to a higher number in the majors, and his position — his 6’6″, 270-pound frame is a better fit at first than in left field — is still up in the air. But Rizzo could be on his way back to the minors after really disappointing so far (.161 BA, .597 OPS) in his first go-round, and there could also be an opening in the outfield if trade candidate Ryan Ludwick gets moved. That’s two possible paths to playing time for Blanks, whose potent bat deserves another shot — and would make for a strong addition in 14-team mixed leagues and all NL-onlies. This is exactly the type of player that shouldn’t be forgotten simply because of some setbacks. Given his age (still just 24) and power potential, Blanks may wind up being the prototypical post-hype sleeper.
ETA: Expect to see Blanks back in the bigs before this month is out.
Trayvon Robinson, OF
Organization: Dodgers
Current Level: Triple-A
Statistics: .300 BA; .935 OPS; 21 HRs; 56 RBIs; 8 SBs; 104:38 K:BB over 317 ABs
40-man roster: Yes
Opportunity Rating: 7
Talent Rating: 8
Obstacle(s): Dodgers recently acquired Juan Rivera; needs to adjust his approach
The biggest contribution Juan Rivera makes to the 2011 fantasy season may just be roster-blocking one of the Dodgers’ top position prospects. Robinson is a 23-year-old switch hitting outfielder who ranks in the top 5 in Triple-A with 21 homers, and before LA traded for Rivera earlier this week, the 2005 10th-rounder was next in line for the team’s rotating left field job.
While this may have bummed out some owners, I’m not sure it’s a bad thing for Robinson’s career in the long-term. A fast and athletic player, Robinson seems to have drastically altered his approach this season. A guy who totaled 52 doubles and 85 steals over the past two seasons has managed just 9 two-baggers and only 8 swipes so far in 2011. And after posting a career-high 17 bombs in 2009 — his only double-digit homer year prior to this season — Robinson may be falling in love with the long ball rather than relying more on his speed and athleticism. Further evidence? His already high 28% K rate from 2005-10 has reached new (read: not good) heights at 33% this year. Could be that Robinson is taking advantage of the hitter haven that is the PCL, but perhaps he should be reminded that power won’t play as well at pitcher-friendly Dodger Stadium.
There’s something intriguing here, and if Robinson gets a shot before the season is out, he could be of help in NL leagues. But the dramatic shift in his approach — not to mention, the swing-and-miss tendencies — would make me worry about Robinson getting exposed in his first taste. Now that he’s proven he can hit balls out of the park, here’s hoping he concentrates more on making contact and getting on base.
ETA: He almost definitely would have gotten a shot by the end of July, but the trade for Rivera likely puts Robinson in a holding pattern. Expect him to get the call this year, but it may not come before September now.
Brad Brach, RP
Organization: Padres
Current Level: Triple-A
Statistics: 2.15 ERA; 0.83 WHIP; 25 SVs; 66:6 K:BB over 46 IPs
40-man roster: No
Opportunity Rating: 8
Talent Rating: 7
Obstacle(s): Trade deadline timeframe; not on 40-man roster
To be totally honest, I’d never heard of Brach — who clocked in at No. 30 in the Padres org this year, according to Baseball America — prior to this June, but he caught my eye while I was perusing the minor league saves leaderboard. Granted, he was closing games in Double-A, but the peripherals made me take notice. A 25-year-old right-hander who was drafted in the 42nd round in 2008, Brach may just be the next out-of-nowhere reliever for the Padres.
After absolutely owning hitters in Double-A — 44 IPs, 32 hits, 64:5 K:BB — Brach was promoted to within one step of the majors on July 4. (Apparently, hitters in the Texas League had more than one reason to celebrate that day.) And while he’s not a scout’s darling because his main (only?) above-average pitch is a mid-90s fastball, he’s put up similarly gaudy stats at every stop in his career: 1.96 ERA, 0.87 WHIP and 11.6 K/9 (compared to just 1.5 BB/9), all to go with 99 saves the past three seasons.
With Heath Bell a highly-sought after trade candidate, Brach would be a worthy add to the bullpen for the big league club once any deal is done. Closer-in-waiting Mike Adams would obviously get the first opp at saves, but Brach could work his way into a setup role. And his low-ERA, low-WHIP and high-strikeout potential would make him a very nice staff filler in NL play.
ETA: He’s only pitched two innings at Triple-A, but as long as he holds his own there until Bell gets dealt, Brach should make his way to San Diego soon thereafter.
***
If you have any suggestions for minor leaguers that you would like to see tracked, discussed and evaluated in Mining the Minors, feel free to post suggestions in the comments section. I’ll do my best to get to as many as I can.
Jason Catania is an MLB Lead Writer for Bleacher Report who also contributes to ESPN The Magazine, ESPN Insider and MLB Rumor Central, focusing on baseball and fantasy content. When he was first introduced to fantasy baseball, Derek Jeter had 195 career hits, Jamie Moyer had 72 wins and Matt Stairs was on team No. 3. You can follow him on Twitter: @JayCat11
Under the hitter’s stats, I think you have the K:BB ratios swapped. Unless Kyle Blanks is walking twice as much as he strikes out.
Indeed, I did. Fixed now. Thanks, James!
Hey, thanks for the info on Brad brach. He got on to my radar last year and then I forgot about him until I too looked at the saves leaders in the minors. But I have 2 prospects I would love your take on. One is also a potential closer for florida named Jose Ceda, especially with the nunez trade to come. And the second is James Paxton in seattles farm system. Paxton reminds me of andy pettite like crazy, and im thinking this guy is for real for real. Thanks alot, always appreciate your take.
Jake
Jake: Glad to refresh your memory. That’s just the sort of thing I try to do with this — make owners aware of these guys and how they might help their fantasy team.
As for Ceda, here’s my post from a couple months ago: http://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/index.php/jose-ceda-and-alexander-torres-mining-the-minors/.
And Paxton looks to be the real deal again — his path getting to where he is had a few up and downs to say the least. I want to see the walk rate come down some, or at least not get any worse as he shows what he’s got at Double-A now. But he could be ready to help the M’s this time next year.
I think Trayvon has 100+Ks not BBs. I think they got swapped some how. Also I’m think it is interesting that Blanks has an “alarming strikeout rate” when that seems to be the big problem with Robinson. Striking out a third of the time is a big deal. How do you think he will fair when he gets called up? Also Blanks must have some issues for SD to trade for Rizzo (far better prospect) and basically leave Blanks to try and figure out RF. Has his fielding improved?
Charles: You’re right, I swapped the K:BB ratio by accident. But the point still holds — both Blanks and Robinson have scary strikeout rates. In Robinson’s case, it’s been an issue in the past, but it’s become a full-blown concern this year. I think he’ll have some problems adjusting to big-league pitching initially, so I wouldn’t be surprised if he comes up and gets limited ABs just to get some introduction to the majors. I doubt he helps even NL-only owners much this year. And as I indicated, I think he’s more interesting as a 12-15 HR/25-30 SB guy if he can cut down his Ks and hit for a .275 average. Otherwise, if he sells out for power, I’m not sure it’ll translate — and the average could be a killer.
Kyle Blanks, striking out 30% of the time and being a power hitter in vortex known as PETCO, hitting with no one on base. I’d rather have Billy Blanks.
The problem with Kyle Blanks’ rise back up the ranks and increase in offensive productivity is it coincides (obviously) with his promotion back up to AAA. As has been well documented in articles across baseball, the PCL is a hitter-friendly league. The parks cater to high averages and inflated home run totals.
Case in point: Anthony Rizzo. While I do think Rizzo will adjust and contribute quite well for the Padres in the future, his numbers were likely inflated by playing in Tucson and the PCL in general. There are 22 players who currently have 15 or home home runs in the PCL (some of whom have actually been promoted already), while there are only 10 players in the International League with 15 or more home runs.
A fair evaluation of Kyle Blanks probably requires more time at AA-San Antonio in order to counter-act the inflated offense of the PCL.
Justin: You make very legitimate points. I usually point out how hitter-friendly the PCL is (see some of my previous posts). In Blanks’ case, I’m sure that it’s helped his numbers. But I don’t think the Padres would send him back to Double-A to get a better idea of whether he’s for real or not. If Rizzo gets sent down and the Padres don’t call up Blanks, I figure they would just shift Blanks to LF at Triple-A rather than send him to Double-A to stick at first. And even though the numbers are inflated, we do have an idea (even if it’s a SSS) that Blanks’ power does translate to the majors, even at Petco.
Blanks is a RHB, and Petco is fairly neutral on RHB; Rizzo is a LHB, and Petco kills LHB. That’s a major factor that should be considered in any comparisons between the two.
Any chance Rizzo or Blanks could get traded this summer?
There’s no way San Diego will trade Rizzo, who was the jewel of the Adrian Gonzalez deal and definitely their 1B of the future. Blanks would make an interesting chip, since he’s better off at 1B (or DH) than LF, and teams are searching for raw power, which is his calling card. I would think any trade of Blanks would make him even more interesting b/c he’d likely get a shot at regular PT, and he’d unquestionably be going to a better park for hitters.
I was kind of hoping Blanks would find himself included as a prospect along with one of the Pad’s RP’s in a contender trade. Unfortunately, I don’t see him getting many AB’s on a contender, but you never know! Like you said, any environment he finds himself in that’s different than where he is at now would be an upgrade.
No one likes my Billy Blanks comment 🙁
Bill Blanks > Kyle Blanks
Maybe if you try it just one more time…