It’s Probably Time to Give Up on Maikel Franco
In a general and simplified sense, some players take longer to develop (and subsequently break out) than others. But there’s obviously no shortage of examples throughout the sporting world where that breakout never occurred. Is that something that the Philadelphia Phillies should be concerned about in relation to one of their (still) young position players? In a number of different respects, Maikel Franco was the worst third baseman in baseball among qualifiers in 2017. The Phillies third sacker finished with the worst Off rating among the group that features 22 qualifiers, with a -22.4 mark. The second worst figure on the list of qualifiers came from Yolmer Sanchez, at -5.1, and at least he had the defensive game to at least help things balance out a little bit. Within that group, there was only one third baseman that finished with a negative WAR for the season; it was Franco’s -0.5.
There was a lot of hope that Franco would break through in 2017 for a Phillies team that folks see as the next up-and-coming product of a total rebuild. While they didn’t take too large a step forward, some of their young players did, and more are on the way. Which certainly murks up the picture for Franco somewhat moving forward. With the production and some of the trends that we’ve seen from the last two years in regard to Franco, though, it’s probably time for current and prospective owners to call it quits on the Phillies’ third baseman.
In addition to his paltry Off and WAR figures, Franco ranked at or near the bottom in a number of other respects. His .230 average ranked third-to-last. His .281 OBP ranked at the bottom by about 30 points. His park-adjusted offense came in at 76, which was the worst by about 20. His hard contact rate, at 30.9%, was the third lowest, which was combined with a soft contact rate that was the third highest, at 20.8%. That latter portion did him no favors in regard to his .234 batting average on balls in play, especially when he put the ball on the ground at the second-highest rate among the group (45.4%).
From a park-adjusted offense perspective, here’s a visual of Maikel Franco throughout 2017:
That’s a lot of time spent beneath that threshold of 100. The Phillies came into the season talking about adjustments that they had expected Franco to make. Approach was one. Some semblance of consistency on the power side was another. Looking back, it’s extremely difficult to see where those adjustments may have even made an attempt to exist. His Swing% was up at 50.8% and the fourth highest, while he hacked at over 31% of pitches outside of the strike zone (the eighth highest among the group). The only apparent adjustment that was made, in terms of pitch selection, came on breaking pitches. There was a small change in terms of zone coverage, to swinging more at pitches on the outer part of the zone than those on the inside, though even that change is a relatively minuscule one.
So, a breakout candidate, coming off of a year in which he failed to meet expectations, and then performed worse in the following campaign. Is there really any reason for optimism at this point? I mean, he did hit .271 and post a wRC+ of 110 in September. The most consistent stretch in the above visual did come toward the end of the season, at least as far as wRC+ is concerned. But until the adjustments or the consistency is displayed, it’s tough to garner any sort of legitimate excitement or intrigue around Franco on a Phillies team that is going to have a lot of it elsewhere.
The Phillies still have a little bit of time to let the Franco thing play out before their window officially opens up. Is there a chance that an improving Phillies team could motivate Franco and turn him loose next season? Sure. Is there a chance that a change in leadership (especially on the hitting side, with Matt Stairs’ departure) could lead to a change in vision and approach toward fixing him? Also, sure. But given the output that we’ve seen from him in each of the last two years, it’s extremely difficult to maintain any sort of optimism surrounding Maikel Franco.


Maikel Franco? Heck, I’ve got friends still waiting for Pat Burrell to break out.
For most of the members of my fantasy league, Wieters Watch never ended.
Tying the two together – It was my experience of staying on the Weiters train too long that taught me a lesson. I sold on Franco early in 2017.
Has anyone actually analyzed his swing? Can we hire JD Martinez to do it?
He hits almost half his balls straight into the ground. It just feels like there’s gotta be a fix there somewhere. But maybe he can’t be taught…. I just hope he can. His power is unreal.
Eh, he’ll be basically free in drafts/auctions. No risk so why not. If he loses the 3B job then cut him, simple as that. Exit velocity is good, K’s are good. Struggles mainly due to ridiculous .234 BABIP. Those are legitimate reasons for optimism, but of course the more important point is that he will cost nothing.
He’s young, I’d give him one and a half more seasons before calling him a total bust.
Among 144 qualified hitters in 2017, Franco’s ranks in various batted ball and plate discipline stats:
LD% 125th
GB% 46th
FB% 74th
IFFB% 9th
Hard% 107th
Soft% 27th
BB% 108th
K% 109th
It’s like an instructional book on how not to hit – no line drives, lots of grounders, hit nothing hard, don’t walk much and when you do hit it in the air, pop it up a bunch. Literally the only thing he does well is not strike out. He’s like the hitting version of Josh Tomlin whose lone positive trait is not walking guys.
I meant to include it with my post but forgot – his xwOBA supports his poor numbers. Even is xwOBA was .302 so he pretty much got exactly what was expected out of his batted ball profile.
Yeah he needs a total rebuild to his approach. If he’s not out there starting completely over with his approach/swing this will be his last season in professional baseball.
Franco was a star at age 22 and held his own as an MLB regular at age 23. He shouldn’t be drafted in 12-team or smaller leagues, but I certainly wouldn’t give up on him just because of a bad age 24 season.