Fantasy Waiver Wire & FAAB Chat
With the questions, we may look at extending this chat another hour. -Jeff
7:31 |
: Welcome everyone |
7:31 |
: Here are the results from Tout Wars’ two 15-team FAAB bidding |
7:32 |
|
7:32 |
|
7:32 |
: $1000 FAAB budget so owners may need to drop 1/5 of their FAAB to get Middleton |
7:33 |
: Barnes or Albers? |
7:33 |
: Barnes or Albers? (% of FAAB?) |
7:33 |
: Barnes and about 10%, 5% on Albers |
7:33 |
: Thinking of picking up a SP, either Kennedy or Triggs – would have to drop either Buxton or McMahon. Your thoughts? Who would you pick up/drop? |
7:34 |
: Trade Buxton. Some owner still believes. Maybe Kennedy for McMahon if you really need pitching. |
7:34 |
: DeShields hit the waiver wire…how high a bid in a 14-team mixed league roto? 5 man bench. |
7:35 |
: Depending on how much an owner needs Saves, 20% |
7:37 |
: BTW, I’m an early, high FAAB bidder, especially in 15-team or deeper leagues. If I want someone, I’ll spend at least 10% on them. Not many players are difference makers, so I bid to get them. |
7:37 |
: I may be high on FAAB recommendations. |
7:37 |
: J. Peraza better upside than Lowrie or N. Walker in a 14 team mixed roto?? |
7:38 |
: Agree but I’d not be surprised if the other two out earn Peraza |
7:38 |
Kevin Kiermaier to try and snag a potential breakout like Panik? He’s my 5th OF in a 14-team league, and his “new approach” is yielding a 40% K rate. Can’t steal if you don’t get on base… : Time to give up on |
7:39 |
: I’d stick with KK but he may need to ride the pine. I remember I thought the same about Hosmer’s start last year but he ended up being a top-20 hitter. |
7:40 |
Tyson Ross higher upside than Newcomb, Rye, Pivetta? Or more than MRs like Betances, Devenski, or Hader? (12 team roto 5×5 mixer). : |
7:40 |
Tyson Ross looks done. Not sure who Rye is but I’d own the rest over him. : |
7:41 |
: Faab % you’d spend on Lucchesi in a 15 team Mixed? |
7:42 |
: Took 2% and 7% in the two leagues I posted. Maybe 5% |
7:42 |
: What do you think we see from him during this stint? Worth a pickup in any size league? |
7:43 |
: Tough call with him. I considered him but passed this week. He might be worth an add if there is room on a team’s bench |
7:43 |
Adam Engel and a break out, but that seems wrong now. Would you wait on him at all? Obv. a deep league. (Naquin, D. Robinson, Pearce, Rajai types on the wire.) Thanks! : Was curious about |
7:44 |
: He could still breakout. Of the guys you listed, I think Naquin has the most talent |
7:44 |
: I have to imagine Cinci leaves Senzel in minors Right? They aren’t trying to win now and don’t want to mess with his service time. |
7:45 |
: The will at least hold him down until the Super Two date has passed |
7:45 |
: Hey Jeff thanks again for doing these chats…which 3B do you prefer, Villanueva or Moran? |
7:46 |
: Moran, Vill. hasn’t done enough yet to change my mind. |
7:46 |
Yoan Moncada? 20/20 season? : Thoughts on |
7:47 |
: I think it’s in him but the AVG/OBP is going to be low. I’m a little worried he won’t get on-base enough for 20 steals |
7:47 |
: Obviously early, but Harvey seems healthy. What to you expect from him going forward? |
7:48 |
: May maxing out around
|
7:48 |
: Big fan of this idea for a FAABchat, btw. Thanks for the time! |
7:48 |
: You’re welcome |
7:48 |
: Thoughts on Yelich’s oblique injury? What does it mean as in future production? |
7:49 |
: He needs to get it healed right and not rush back. I’d be happy if it’s more than a 10-day layoff |
7:49 |
: Your colleague brad johnson has an interesting pitcher based strategy. Basically, target pitching early in drafts if your league focuses on bats. Thoughts on this? |
7:51 |
: In a draft, I try to just find value and treat it like an auction. Going with this approach, I aim for a $$$ mix between hitting and pitching. Sometimes the pitching comes early. Sometimes later |
7:51 |
: E-Rod or T. Ross ROS?? 5×5 14-team mixer. |
7:51 |
: E-Rod |
7:51 |
: In weekly leagues, do you start Ohtani the pitcher or Ohtani the batter? |
7:52 |
: Pitcher by a long ways |
7:53 |
: It really depends on who you replacing in the OF. Look at the trade like Seager & Your OF for Stanton & Marte |
7:53 |
: Was it you that made me avoid Ohtani in all my drafts or did someone else write about his first ST start? Come on! |
7:54 |
: I did not like what I saw early on. He was inconsistent. He quickly pulled it together. Oops |
7:55 |
Austin Barnes ever get the playing time he deserves? : Will |
7:55 |
: He’s dealing with an injury so more rest for now. |
7:55 |
Wilson Ramos has been terrible. How early to I pull the plug for a Lucroy, Brian McCann or Russ Martin (OBP league)? : I purposely waited on catcher (one C league) knowing that I would probably just drop the guy I ended up with at some point for a FA was producing better. I didn’t plan to do so this early, but |
7:56 |
: Russ Martin. Set and ignore. Maybe not much power but nice OBP. You can drop later for a power if other needs come up. |
7:56 |
: Quintana’s velo was up a mile today from his last start. Promising enough to continue top 20 consideration? |
7:57 |
: Yes |
7:57 |
: AL-Only league with starts limit. Want to target TB middle men to vulture wins with the starters only going 3 or 4, but Cash keeps switching the orders around. Is this a dumb move for me? |
7:58 |
: You just have to pick a guy and go with it. It’s so tough to target Wins, especially from MR. Just play the best value for ERA, WHIP, and Ks and hope the Wins come. |
7:58 |
Eduardo Rodriguez or gohara for Nick Pivetta? Are you playing schebler in a weekly league or benching? : Would you drop either |
7:59 |
: Maybe on Gohara to if I need a starter. |
7:59 |
: I’d probably bench Schebler. He might give you nothing. |
8:00 |
Joey Lucchesi, Yonny Chirinos, Bryan Mitchell, Dillon Peters : Rank them ROS: |
8:00 |
: In that order but swap Peters and Mitchell |
8:01 |
Chad Green? Have 3 closers already and nobody else seems droppable. He seems valuable like Devenski last year but that Yankees bullpen is stacked so I’m a little more skeptical he gets saves or holds? Or should I just keep him and drop Strickland : Jeff, in a 12 team save + hold league, do I hold onto |
8:01 |
: Drop him over Strickland. You might be able to pick him up later if the need arises. |
8:01 |
: After one week of baseball: breakout pitcher and breakout hitter? |
8:02 |
: Ohtani and it’s way too early to make a call on any hitter. |
8:02 |
Cody Reed, Liriano, Domingo German or Sal Romano? : I’m looking for a SP with RP eligibility. Who should I pickup between |
8:02 |
: Reed, two-start week if you are brave. |
8:03 |
: In a 12 team keeper, how do you see the stash value of Robles v. Gleyber? Does Robles just have too many roadblocks to an early call up? |
8:03 |
: Robles was my #1 prospect target. Being an OF, he just needs one of three to go on the DL to get time, |
8:04 |
Matt Kemp to pick up Renfroe? : Drop |
8:04 |
: Not right now. Kemp’s playing Renfroe is a AVG/OBP sink |
8:04 |
: I want to pick up Franco but I already have Seager, Olson, and Swanson in my 1B — 1B/3B — and Utility spots (respectively) |
8:05 |
: OK … not much you can do. |
8:05 |
: Is there anything more pleasurable than seeing a pitch crushed like the one Gallo smashed today? |
8:06 |
: Triples … I love triples |
8:07 |
: Link to article on stabilization points for stats? |
8:07 |
Jed Lowrie is on the wire. Should I cut Soler and his upside (finally got a hit today!) for Lowrie? : 8 team AL only. Boring and steady |
8:07 |
: yes |
8:07 |
: Who do you trust more going forward- Alonso or Davidson? In a small sample Davidson is showing more discipline with 6 walks in 34 PA |
8:08 |
: Alonso but if my team really needed power, they could take a chance on Davidson |
8:08 |
: $1000 budget…how high a bid on a bench stashes DeShields, or Sal Perez? |
8:08 |
: 10% each |
8:09 |
Dansby Swanson on the wire. Drop Altherr for him? : |
8:09 |
: I would. Take a chance that Swanson has put his skills together |
8:09 |
: Drop Beltre for Franco or Andujar in a dynasty? |
8:09 |
: Dynasty, Franco. |
8:09 |
Randal Grichuk ever hit the ball again? : Will |
8:10 |
: If he does, it will be hard. |
8:10 |
: Sorry – sent without a name before so re-sending – Glasnow dropped this week in dynasty. Any value? |
8:10 |
: Yes, take a flier |
8:10 |
: Is Ryu droppable for Newcomb, T. Ross, Kennedy, or Pivetta? |
8:10 |
: Maybe for Newcomb but I wouldn’t |
8:11 |
: Which SP to start this week? Manaea @LAD or Quintana vATL? |
8:11 |
: Quintana |
8:11 |
: Are a believer in Swanson’s hot start? Drop simmons for him? |
8:11 |
: No, but if you wait to verify the hot start, he won’t be on the wire. Simmons isn’t going anywhere. |
8:12 |
: Better stash, Calhoun or Senzel? When do you think Calhoun gets the call? |
8:12 |
: Calhoun for ’18. It’s when the Rangers get an extra year of control. IIRC, early May. |
8:13 |
: Rank, E-Rod, Pivetta, Junis, Kennedy, Luchessi, Newcomb |
8:13 |
: These guys are so close. ERod, Newcomb, and then flip a coin |
8:14 |
: ROS:
|
8:14 |
: You mentioned Naquin earlier. Where might he play, especially with Brantley back? |
8:15 |
: Has Brantley ever stayed healthy? |
8:15 |
Kyle Hendricks? Im worried : What you think of |
8:15 |
: He may be done. He’s a two-pitcher guy with a fastball maxing out under 90 mph |
8:15 |
: Gibson or Stratton? |
8:15 |
: Gibson |
8:16 |
Keston Hiura for my Gregory Polanco, Reddick and Robles in a 14 team dynasty points league. I’m in win now mode. Take it? Thank you! : Got offered Donaldson, Boxberger, and |
8:16 |
: Yes but Robles may come back to bite you in years to come. You have to live with the loss. |
8:17 |
Dustin Fowler get the call soon? : With Boog out, does |
8:17 |
: I think so. Seems like the A’s demoted him to work on something. Not sure |
8:17 |
: Kepler has had a nice start to the season. Pretty good minor league career. Think this might be a breakout year? |
8:18 |
: I think he’ll be a good but not great player. |
8:18 |
: No major breakout IMO |
8:18 |
: Any Hope for Hanley after his 30/30 claim? |
8:18 |
: No way on the SB |
8:18 |
Colin Moran, but he needs a few more starts to be 3B eligible. Thank you! : Have Lamb and Suarez on the DL now. Any 3B recommendations in a 12 team roto? Have |
8:20 |
Cory Spangenberg for the week. Three games at CO. Duffy has been leading off in Tampa : |
8:20 |
Jordan Montgomery in a 12-team mixed? He’s looked awful so far. : Are you okay dropping |
8:20 |
: Yes, Curn for a good pitcher |
8:21 |
: Hinch said Giles was unavailable tonight, hence the Peacock save. Peacock worth a look? |
8:21 |
: Depending on league depth, he may be a must own. I’m starting him every week in my TGFBI team |
8:22 |
: Taijuan worth waiver 1 in a 12 team roto with a 180 start limit? Thanks! |
8:22 |
: Yes, I never save the #1. Just get players when you can. |
8:22 |
: How into Mahle are you? |
8:23 |
https://www.fangraphs.com/fantasy/quick-looks-mahle-mikolas-lucchesi/ : He’s OK, I did a Quick Look this past week. |
8:24 |
: Hey who do you like more for my dh Moran, Thames, Choo? Thanks |
8:24 |
: Choo for now |
8:24 |
: Should I mostly ignore Teheran’s next start in COL when evaluating what to do with him? |
8:24 |
: Ignore |
8:24 |
: Who do you think gets the next save opp in MIL? |
8:25 |
: Barnes |
8:25 |
Trevor Bauer, can he reach top 20? : what do you think of |
8:25 |
: I like him and he could easily be top-20. It will depend on how many Win’s he gets. |
8:25 |
Jim Johnson be on a team? : 14 team. Should |
8:26 |
: No |
8:26 |
: What’re your thoughts on using SP eligible relievers in head to head leagues? I’ve got Hicks, Gsellman and Peacock for 4 SP spots. Should I continue to target these players or take fliers on SPs. |
8:27 |
: I love this strategy for off days. Get enough to fill open slots and then begin working on the rest of your team |
8:27 |
: Am I already injured? Be patient with cold start or cut in a 10 team league? |
8:27 |
: Cut in a 10-teamer |
8:27 |
8:28 |
: Tucker and evaluate closely once his stats start to stabilize |
8:28 |
: It’s only a week. You change your tune on matthew chapman? |
8:28 |
: No, I will never change an opinion based on a one week sample size for hitters. |
8:28 |
: In an OPS league, prefer to keep Buxton or Conforto as a 5th OF? Kinda potential vs power… |
8:29 |
: Conforto if you need production this season. |
8:29 |
Jose Martinez, Sean Manaea, Miles Mikolas and Ryan Flaherty in 12 team H2H 12×12. Thanks! : Please rank for ROS? |
8:29 |
: Martinez, Mikolas, Flaherty, Manaea |
8:30 |
A.J. Minter’s strikeouts go? : Where did |
8:30 |
: A.J. Minter fastball velocity cliff:
![]() |
8:30 |
: Is Ottavino’s new slider for real or just an early season mirage? |
8:31 |
: It looks nasty. I like him as speculative bid for Saves. |
8:34 |
: Sorry, but I’m done for the week. With the high question count, we are potentially looking to have someone answer questions before or me. It won’t be together but would extend for two hours instead of one. |
Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won four FSWA Awards including on for his Mining the News series. He's won Tout Wars three times, LABR twice, and got his first NFBC Main Event win in 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.
BOOG POWELL is on the DL, btw — he wasn’t shipped to AAA as you had posted
Jeff was referencing Fowler having been sent to AAA out of ST, apparently to work on something.