Bullpen Report: May 13, 2015
• Well, we suspected that A.J. Ramos was the odds on favorite for saves in Miami, and he got the first crack at the ninth inning in the post-Steve Cishek era. It went swimmingly, with Ramos fanning two of the three batters he faced in a perfect final frame. Ben covered these guys in depth last night, but Ramos’ 2.78 2015 xFIP paints the picture of a guy who can certainly take the ninth inning and run with it. The one possible chink his armor has always been control, but so far, in his small sample size 2015, the righty has cut his BB% from 16% (2014) to 9% (2015). I’d start to worry if the free passes came back, but as long as he’s pounding the strike zone, he’s as good an option as the Marlins have. He’ll stay red for another few outings, but he has the potential to go green fairly quickly in this pen. Further helping matters (at least for savvy owners who snagged Ramos) are reports that Miami is apparently out on the Rafael Soriano bidding (is it bidding if no one will pay for your services?).
• As far as blown saves go, it’s really, really tough to imagine a worse one than Addison Reed‘s this afternoon versus the Nationals. The righty was tasked with polishing off an easy three-run a one-run lead, but it was anything other than a walk in the park (what do you call a walk in Chase Field?). Reed got a quick out to open the ninth, but gave up single, single, walk, which set the stage for Michael Taylor’s go-ahead grand slam. His peripherals were better than his actual stats last year, but 2015 hasn’t gone nearly as well. The former White Sox stopper has seen his strikeout rate plummet, in large part due to the fact that he can’t induce swings and misses right now (7% SwStr% compared to 13% last year). His velocity is off only a hair, so it’s tough to pin his issues on that. Interestingly, both his fastball and slider have seen nearly equal ~5% SwStr% decreases; his slider has lost some horizontal bite, but his fastball is moving more than ever. So one has to wonder if command could be an issue.
While Reed is not out of the role, his iffy start to the season has him on the hot seat. If Evan Marshall could pitch like he did last year, he’d be a great sleeper for the ninth gig, but he’s trying to get his K% straightened out in Triple-A. Good news for him, his stuff still looks good, so hopefully he’ll be back up soon. The obvious backup plan is Brad Ziegler, the sidearming righty who racked up a few saves in 2013. While his ERA is shiny, the 35-year-old’s strikeout mark is at a career low, and platoon splits will always be a concern given his arm slot. While Ziegler’s first in line, I wouldn’t sleep on the forgotten Daniel Hudson. While Hudson’s xFIP is a middling 4.14, his velocity is up 3 mph from when he started (pre-Tommy John days) and his SwStr% is an above-average 11%. To add a little more fuel to Hudson being used in high-leverage situations, Chip Hale was quoted as saying “We don’t know where we’re going to be with our roster next year. We’ve talked about Daniel being the starter, a setup guy, a closer…” He’s not first up in this pen, but Hudson could be a worthwhile flier in NL-onlies and dynasty leagues.
• Rehab trail: Jake McGee has now thrown in six rehab games (after tonight) and, assuming he feels OK tomorrow, seems like a lock to be activated this weekend. Brad Boxberger picked up another save this evening and has been lights out for the Rays, so don’t expect McGee to ride in and re-steal the job anytime soon. That said, Boxy owners might want to ‘cuff with McGee just in case — Joe Maddon might be gone, but the Rays still have some of the more novel bullpen usage in baseball. Sean Doolittle is a few weeks behind McGee, but will start a rehab assignment tomorrow. The lefty is coming off a somewhat troubling shoulder injury, but should he regain the form that allowed him to post a ridiculous 1.53 SIERA in 2014, he’ll jump right back into owner’s good graces. Shallow leaguers probably have the luxury of waiting for reports from down on the farm, but if he’s available in your deep league, now is the time to stash and hope for the best. Owning the least worrisome injury of the trio here is Kenley Jansen, who will be activated from the disabled list Saturday. Jansen’s foot has healed enough for him to rejoin the big club, and while Don Mattingly has hinted he won’t get his closer job back right away, it is only a matter of time before he reassumes the gig. He’s likely been stashed in the vast majority of fantasy leagues, but doesn’t help to double check the wire, just in case.
• Quick hits: Jonathan Papelbon is now the all-time leading saves man for Philadelphia and Boston. The righty’s velocity continues to drop, but a high SwStr% is keeping his peripherals from totally going in the tank. His owners wouldn’t mind a mid-season trade to a contender. Neftali Feliz only needed five pitches for his save tonight. His 4.10 xFIP is “meh” but his pedigree and the lack of a real standout option in Texas (although Shawn Tolleson is a nice pickup in holds leagues) keeps his leash somewhat long. Cody Allen looked crisp in pitching a ninth inning that most fans had hoped belonged to Corey Kluber instead. His stuff hasn’t gone away, but his walk rate has been shoddy this year. His owners are opening today portends better things ahead.
Closer Grid:
[Green light, yellow light, red light: the colors represent the volatility of the bullpen order.]
There are few things Colin loves more in life than a pitcher with a single-digit BB%. Find him on Twitter @soxczar.
Reed entered the ninth with a 1 run lead, not a 3 run cushion. Which becomes more obvious when you see the final score after Taylor’s grand slam (9-6).
Obviously you’ve never heard of the elusive 6-run homer.
Cricket scoring. Hit the ball out of the yard on a bounce, it’s 4 runs. On a fly, it’s 6.
My boy Chris Gayle mashes Sixes.
I sort of think Delgado gets the first shot if Reed “needs a breather” … Hudson just logged a 52 pitch performance the other day, and isn’t really trusted to go back-to-back yet … seems more like the new long man than anything else (not that I didn’t pick him up tonight!) … meanwhile Marshall is lost …
I agree with you about Delgado. Outside of the Upton GW Homer he gave up a couple days ago, he has looked pretty good out of the pen.
What do you do with betances in a h2h league? Are non-closer relievers worth hanging onto?
Betances is amazing in head to head leagues. K totals like another starter with zero ERA & WHIP. What’s not to like? Just few wins or saves. Like an ace starter on a bad team.
Are Reed’s struggle due to the supposed mechanical changes he made in the off-season? I remember in spring training reading about how he was concerned about injuries and tried to change his mechanics to prevent a shoulder or elbow injury from happening. I think I remember him saying he was trying to be more “over the top” with his arm angle. That might be a big reason his stuff doesnt have the same movement on it and he isnt getting the swings and misses he once did.
I’ll say it again, it is nonsense to suggest that Melancon is in any danger of losing his job. Hurdle just used him for 3 straight games, pretty telling how much they value him right now.
I think Melancon at this point is yellow on the scale, but if I owned him I would be looking to sell him to any taker I could find. His velocity remains down quite a bit from last year and the Pirates have three guys behind him in Watson, Hughes and Camerino that could legitimately step into his role.
Is Melancon safer today than he was at the start of May? Sure, but I would still feel a bit uneasy trusting him to hold onto the job the rest of the year if his velocity doesnt tick up closer to what it was last year.
I came to suggest that Melancon should be scaled back from red to yellow also. I concur.
How much should we trust the public declarations from Miami that they are out on Soriano? Could it just be posturing?
Is Shaw in Cleveland a better bet to get future saves than Soriano?
I don’t even think Soriano to MIA was a real rumor, just something a writer speculated on and it snowballed.
I think they could be out legitimately. It’s always tough to tell with Boras clients, but I think any interest they had in Soriano was with the assumption they could get him super cheap. If one of the few concerns about Ramos holding the job with the Fish the rest of the year is the arbitration numbers, I doubt Miami would be willing to give legit dollars to an over-the-hill pitcher whose only real value anymore is “closing experience”.
If given a choice, I dump both and take a speculative play on either Rafael Betancourt or Randall Delgado since I think Axford and Reed are DOA in terms of job security at this point.