Bullpen Report: May 13, 2014

A few quick updates from Monday:

Addison Reed blew his second save on the year and now holds a 1-3 record and is 11/13 on save chances. Kirk Gibson squashed any closer controversy rumors but the fact remains that Reed has not pitched well this year. The Diamondbacks gave up some value in a trade for Reed so he should have a long leash but a 5.03 ERA and 5.49 FIP certainly isn’t pretty. Reed is actually striking out more guys (26.7%)  and walking fewer batters  (4.7%) than last year but the long ball has killed him. A 21.4% HR/FB ratio isn’t sustainable but Reed allows many balls fly through the air with a mere 32% career ground ball rate. I’ll take Gibson at his word and not sound the alarm on Reed but Brad Ziegler is someone to take a look at.

Kyle Farnsworth recorded his third save of the season last night against the Yankees but according to Adam Rubin “there is no longer a set closer” for the Mets.  That doesn’t mean Farnsworth’s owners should let go of his services but Jeurys Familia, Daisuke Matsuzaka and even Papa Grande could see a save opportunity in the future.

Jim Johnson was on the road back to closer but he struggled in the ninth inning last night and Sean Doolittle picked up his second save of the year. It’s a fantasy owner’s nightmare but Oakland might be back to a closer by committee. I wouldn’t put much weight on the order in the grid below as Johnson, Doolittle and Luke Gregerson should all receive save opportunities in the near future. Johnson nearly worked his way back into the full-time role and that could be the case again but it’s a committee for now.

• It wasn’t a save but Casey Janssen pitched a scoreless ninth inning last night to finish a 7-3 win for the Blue Jays. So long as he remains healthy, it’s safe to assume Janssen will receive all the save opportunities in Toronto.

And now for Tuesday:

• Well look at that, Casey Janssen pitched tonight and recorded his first save of the season. As we know, health has been a big concern for Janssen so it’s a relief (pun intended) to see him pitch well on back-to-back days. Janssen was also hitting 91-92 mph on his fastball, which is right in line with last year. The Blue Jays finally have a closer.

Aroldis Chapman entered the ninth inning tonight in a 1-1 game and although he recorded two strikeouts he also gave up the go-ahead run on a Chase Headley home run. Chapman figures to have a few hiccups as he works himself into form and so this certainly isn’t a concern but he did have a little case of gopheritis last season. Chapman’s swing and miss stuff will always make him elite but a lot of his balls in play are fly balls and a night or two like this is to be expected. Still, the important thing is Chapman is healthy and throwing his usual 100 mph gas, his owners should throw him out there with confidence. Huston Street recorded the save on the other end of the game and is now a perfect 12/12 on the season.

Joe Smith pitched a clearn eighth inning tonight, and that looks to be his role in the near future with Frieri continuing to get save opportunities, which played itself out with Fieri nailing down his fifth save of the season. Frieri will likely always be a bit of a roller coaster ride so I wouldn’t cut bait with Joe Smith just yet but the role is clearly in Frieri’s hands.

Tommy Hunter blew his second save in a row tonight, allowing a three run homer to Miguel Cabrera followed by a solo shot by Victor Martinez. After tonight’s outing Hunter now supports a ghastly 6.60/5.04/3.74 ERA/FIP/xFIP line. Darren O’Day pitched a perfect eighth with two strikeouts, lowering his ERA to 0.60. O’Day’s been a bit lucky this year and won’t keep a 100% LOB% all season and is actually getting fewer whiffs than last year which has corresponded with a decreased strikeout rate. He’s still likely first in line for saves if Hunter’s struggles continue or if Baltimore decides to make a change. Also of note is Zach Britton who didn’t pitch tonight but also has a shiny ERA (0.84) with better peripherals than O’Day along with the velocity (93.8 mph on his fastball) that were accustomed to seeing from closers. Both should be owned/monitored in any league counting holds and teams in need of saves should look their way as Hunter has been ineffective of late.

Closer Grid:

Closer First Second DL/Minors
Arizona Addison Reed Brad Ziegler Oliver Perez J.J. Putz
Atlanta Craig Kimbrel David Carpenter Luis Avilan Jordan Walden
Baltimore Tommy Hunter Darren O’Day Zach Britton
Boston Koji Uehara Junichi Tazawa Andrew Miller
CHI (NL) Hector Rondon Justin Grimm James Russell Pedro Strop
CHI (AL) Matt Lindstrom Ronald Belisario Daniel Webb Nate Jones
Cincy Aroldis Chapman Jonathan Broxton Sam LeCure
Cleveland Bryan Shaw Cody Allen Scott Atchison
Colorado LaTroy Hawkins Adam Ottavino Rex Brothers
Detroit Joe Nathan Joba Chamberlain Al Alburquerque Joel Hanrahan
Houston Chad Qualls Anthony Bass Josh Zeid Jesse Crain
KC Greg Holland Wade Davis Aaron Crow
LAA Ernesto Frieri Joe Smith Michael Kohn Dane de la Rosa
LAD Kenley Jansen Chris Perez Brian Wilson
Miami Steve Cishek A.J. Ramos Mike Dunn
Milwaukee Francisco Rodriguez Will Smith Brandon Kintzler Jim Henderson
Minnesota Glen Perkins Jared Burton Casey Fien
NY (NL) Kyle Farnsworth Jeurys Familia Daisuke Matsuzaka Bobby Parnell
NY (AL) David Robertson Shawn Kelley Adam Warren
Oakland Jim Johnson Luke Gregerson Sean Doolittle
Philly Jonathan Papelbon Mike Adams Antonio Bastardo
Pittsburgh Mark Melancon Tony Watson Justin Wilson Jason Grilli
St. Louis Trevor Rosenthal Carlos Martinez Kevin Siegrist Jason Motte
SD Huston Street Joaquin Benoit Alex Torres
SF Sergio Romo Santiago Casilla Jeremy Affeldt
Seattle Fernando Rodney Danny Farquhar Tom Wilhelmsen
TB Grant Balfour Joel Peralta Jake McGee
Texas Joakim Soria Alexi Ogando Jason Frasor Neftali Feliz
Toronto Casey Janssen Brett Cecil Steve Delabar Sergio Santos
Wash. Rafael Soriano Tyler Clippard Drew Storen

[Green light, yellow light, red light: the colors represent the volatility of the bullpen order.]

We hoped you liked reading Bullpen Report: May 13, 2014 by Benjamin Pasinkoff!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

When he's not focusing on every team's bullpen situation, Ben can be found blogging at Ben's Baseball Bias and on Twitter @BensBias

newest oldest most voted
Mike Wimmer
Mike Wimmer

As a Mark Melancon owner, should I just ride him as far as I can with Grilli likely back before the end of the month or should I see if I can get someone like Shaw off my waiver wire?


I would ride him. I think he’s the better pitcher going forward, and I think the Pirates know that. Grilli is too old, last season was kind of a fluke for him, and he’s had some real problems staying healthy going back to the second half of last season. Melancon definitely seems like the better play rather than trying to guess what will happen with the other closer committees.

I just wish the Pirates would give him more save opps.


Hurdle indicated that the job will be Grilli’s when he returns. Before his injury, Grilli had converted four of seven saves.”I hate to take a guy’s job away because of an injury,” Hurdle said. “Grilli is feeling fine again. He is starting to feel aggressive.”


Hurdle indicated that the job will be Grilli’s when he returns. Before his injury, Grilli had converted four of seven saves.”I hate to take a guy’s job away because of an injury,” Hurdle said. “Grilli is feeling fine again. He is starting to feel aggressive.”


keep him. I bet he holds off Grilli.. Melancon is a very good reliever and Grilli is old/injury-prone and no need to make a change when it’s working…