Bullpen Report: July 23, 2017
With the trade deadline fast approaching, there was plenty of relevant bullpen activity on a busy Sunday afternoon…
Sean Doolittle pitched a scoreless ninth with the Nationals up by four against the Diamondbacks. He now has two saves and the completion of a four-run win under his belt with his new team, and Ryan Madson has yet to see a save opportunity in Washington. It bears repeating, however, that Dusty Baker has indicated that he may mix and match with those two in the ninth, and that he will be cautious with Doolittle given his history of arm issues. Even if Doolittle is the main closer in Washington, which appears to be the case for now, Madson is probably still worth stashing in holds leagues, and to those desperate for saves, in case Doolittle falters or sustains another injury.
Zach Britton struck out two and walked one en route to his first save since April 14. Orioles ownership has reportedly given management the green light to trade Britton, so his status is worth monitoring closely in the coming days. His successful save conversion on Sunday was a good start, but Britton has missed a lot of time with a forearm injury this season and teams might not be willing to give up what the Orioles would want in return for their ace reliever. If Britton remains with the Orioles, he will likely reclaim the closer’s role in full capacity assuming he can remain healthy. If he’s traded, however, it’s possible that he could be used in an Andrew Miller-type role on a new team.
On Saturday, Hector Neris allowed a run on three hits in what had been a tie game in the ninth, and was saddled with the loss. On Sunday, with a three-run ninth-inning lead, the Phillies went to Luis Garcia for the save chance. He struck out one in a perfect frame. It was his first save of the season and just the third of his career. Despite the rare save opportunity, Garcia’s peripherals don’t suggest he’s a closer in the making, so the grid remains unchanged for now. Neris’ grip on the ninth, however, remains relatively shaky.
Jose Leclerc was brought into a left-heavy section of the Rays’ lineup in the ninth with the Rangers up by one. He struck out two and walked two to secure the save. Leclerc has an exceptional 35.5 percent strikeout rate this season, but he’s also walked 16.1 percent of batters. Along Alex Claudio and Keone Kela, Leclerc is in the Rangers’ ninth-inning mix. Despite picking up the majority of saves for the Rangers recently, Jeff Banister wouldn’t commit to Alex Claudio as his closer, and Sunday’s converted save chance by Leclerc seemed to back that up. Matt Bush, who held the closer’s role for the Rangers earlier this season, pitched a scoreless seventh with the Rangers trailing by a run on Sunday.
Kenley Jansen blew a three-run ninth-inning lead against the Braves. Jansen allowed the first two batters to reach but settled down and got two outs before finally allowing a three-run homer to Matt Adams that tied the game. It was Jansen’s first blown save of the season.
Staying in the National League West, Brad Hand picked up a save against the Giants on Sunday. Brandon Maurer is San Diego’s usual closer, and he blew a save on Friday when he surrendered two two-out baserunners and a game-tying, three-run blast to Conor Gillaspie. If Hand wasn’t likely to be traded, it might be a bigger deal that he got the save chance over Maurer on Sunday. As it is, Maurer will remain in the closer’s spot on the grid for now, and Hand’s future is completely unknown at this time. If he isn’t traded, he could conceivably take over the closer’s role in San Diego. If he is traded, there’s no telling what his role will be. He’s probably worth owning in all holds leagues, as he’s quietly one of the best relievers in baseball.
With the Yankees leading by two runs in Seatlle, Dellin Betances pitched the seventh and David Robertson pitched the eighth. Betances has struggled mightily with command this season to the tune of a 17.8 percent walk rate, and it appears that Robertson may snag the eighth inning role and be next in line for saves behind closer Aroldis Chapman. For now, Betances will remain in his usual spot behind Chapman on the grid, but that could change if he continues to see the seventh and Robertson continues to see the eighth.
There were a few fresh faces in the eighth inning on Sunday: Blake Parker of the Angels, Bruce Rondon of the Tigers, and Jason Grilli of the Rangers all pitched in close eighth innings despite occupying lesser roles recently. Parker and Grilli pitched spotless frames, and Rondon allowed two runs on three hits before giving way to Justin Wilson for a four-out save opportunity. Wilson allowed a home run and a walk in the ninth but struck out three in the outing to secure his 12th save.
Other closer activity: Raisel Iglesias notched a two-inning save against the Marlins. Santiago Casilla allowed a hit but notched his 16th save against the Mets. Kelvin Herrera struck out two in a perfect ninth in a tie game at home. Bud Norris secured a one-run save against the Red Sox. Tyler Clippard was brought into a two-on, no out situation in a tie game in the ninth inning on the road, and he allowed a game-ending single to the first batter he faced, Brandon Moss. Brandon Kintzler entered in the top of the ninth with the Twins trailing by a run, and he allowed three runs on two hits and two walks. Jim Johnson entered in the bottom of the 10th in a tie game against the Dodgers, and allowed the winning run to score. Aroldis Chapman allowed two hits but struck out one and notched his 11th save of the season against the Mariners.
Closer Grid:
[Green light, yellow light, red light: the colors represent the volatility of the bullpen order.]
Ben Kaspick is the host Locked On Giants, a daily San Francisco Giants podcast on the Locked On Podcast Network. Follow him on Twitter/X @BenKaspick.
Need saves, desperate for better ERA/WHIP…rank Clippard, Phelps and Treinen
Of the three, Clippard will likely get the most save opportunities. I wouldn’t feel great about running him out there in that role, but if you’re desperate for saves…
I think Treinen is next because he already looks like next in line behind Casilla, and Casilla is not very good. Phelps may be the best reliever of the bunch, but the furthest from save opps because Edwin Diaz is good.
Vanilla American Name Bullpen Update:
Nate Jones is out for the season and Joe Smith is off the DL.
Was Claudio available tonight? Threw 3.1 innings the past two days.
I doubt he was. And the Rangers aren’t pitching Kela in back-to-back days yet apparently (https://twitter.com/evan_p_grant/status/889220277904736256). So that’s probably why Leclerc, who’s most likely the 7th inning guy, got the save opportunity.
Will Harris has been on DL since July 15th.
Really hard to trust this grid with such oversight.
Keep an eye on Ryan Dull, who is expected to be activated by Oakland as soon as Thursday. Casilla is closing games now by default after the trade of Madson and Doolittle, but Casilla has not pitched well, with an ERA and more advanced pitching metrics at about 4.00, not as well as Dull pitched in 2016. As well, Dull’s velocity and k-rate were up in 2017 before he was sidelined with a knee injury.
I need to cut a reliever, either Oh or David Robertson. I’m 2nd overall, and every point will count. I’m four saves behind the category leader: Her three closers are Kimbrel, Rodney, and Jim Johnson (68 saves between the three); Even with the cut, I’ll still also have Knebel, Felipe Rivero, and Justin Wilson (47 saves, but none of the three began ’17 as a closer). Maybe those three can close my 4-save deficit, but ideally, whichever reliever I keep–Oh or Roberston–will also help. Oh is now in a closer-by-committee role, with every chance of completely losing the job, while Robertson is pitching far better and stepping into a suddenly volatile Yankees bullpen mix in which he may get save opportunities. I’m also in tight races in WHIP, K, and ERA, and like I said, every point counts. Robertson will probably put up better numbers, but Oh, if he throws even a couple good outings, stands a decent chance of retaking the closer role for himself. Given that scenario, do I keep Oh, or Roberston?
Oh. He has a much clearer path to an every-day closer role. It would take something dramatic or an injury for Robertson to unseat Chapman, but it would just take pitching well for Oh to get it back.
Good point. Oh just has to pitch well and he’ll get save opportunities, which is not the case with Robertson.