Are 2021’s Busts This Season’s Rebounds? A Review

Yesterday, I discussed six 2021 fantasy breakouts and reviewed how they followed up in 2022. Naturally, half (3) of them earned within $10 of their 2021 values, while the other half failed to. Let’s now turn our attention to five of 2021’s busts. Did any of them rebound in 2022?

2021 Busts
Name 2020 EOS $$* 2021 EOS $$* Diff Within $7 of 2020 2022 EOS $$* Verdict
Mookie Betts $37.40 $12.32 -$25.07 $30.40 $28.90 STILL A BUST
Michael Conforto $22.33 $0.00 -$22.33 $15.33 DNP
DJ LeMahieu $24.38 $3.53 -$20.85 $17.38 $4.20 STILL A BUST
José Abreu $38.07 $17.50 -$20.57 $31.07 $14.20 STILL A BUST
Wil Myers $23.98 $3.49 -$20.49 $16.98 -$4.90 STILL A BUST
*Using the FanGraphs auction calculator with default settings

It’s a clean sweep! The four players who played in 2022 that were busts in 2021 after a big 2020 season failed to earn within $7 of their 2020 value. Of course, that doesn’t necessarily make them “still a bust” in your league, as that’s dependent on your leaguemates’ valuations and each player’s cost, which is something I can’t possibly know.

Mookie Betts

Betts endured injury in 2021 which cut into his value, but his HR/FB rate also fell significantly from his 2020 career high over a small sample during the short season. He also swiped a career low number of bases. So 2021 wasn’t what his owners paid for.

With still strong skills and better health, you figure Betts would undoubtedly rebound in 2022, but would he get back to his 2020 level or finish in between? He mostly did rebound though fell a tad short of the arbitrary “within $7 of 2020” value, which technically made him STILL A BUST. That said, he likely still earned back his cost, or at least very close to it, in the majority of leagues, so he probably wasn’t really a bust.

The most important part of his 2022 season was that he stole just 12 bases, so after swiping just 10 in 2021, it looks like a low teens total might now become the new norm.

You Aren't a FanGraphs Member
It looks like you aren't yet a FanGraphs Member (or aren't logged in). We aren't mad, just disappointed. We get it. You want to read this article. But before we let you get back to it, we'd like to point out a few of the good reasons why you should become a Member. 1. Ad Free viewing! We won't bug you with this ad, or any other. 2. Unlimited articles! Non-Members only get to read 10 free articles a month. Members never get cut off. 3. Dark mode and Classic mode! 4. Custom player page dashboards! Choose the player cards you want, in the order you want them. 5. One-click data exports! Export our projections and leaderboards for your personal projects. 6. Remove the photos on the home page! (Honestly, this doesn't sound so great to us, but some people wanted it, and we like to give our Members what they want.) 7. Even more Steamer projections! We have handedness, percentile, and context neutral projections available for Members only. 8. Get FanGraphs Walk-Off, a customized year end review! Find out exactly how you used FanGraphs this year, and how that compares to other Members. Don't be a victim of FOMO. 9. A weekly mailbag column, exclusively for Members. 10. Help support FanGraphs and our entire staff! Our Members provide us with critical resources to improve the site and deliver new features! We hope you'll consider a Membership today, for yourself or as a gift! And we realize this has been an awfully long sales pitch, so we've also removed all the other ads in this article. We didn't want to overdo it. In case you didn't read all that, here's the short version. Membership includes:
✓Ad-free browsing
✓Unlimited FanGraphs & RotoGraphs articles
✓Historical & platoon projections
✓Leaderboard & player-page stat heatmaps
✓One-click data exports
✓Customizable player-page dashboards
✓Dark & Classic site modes
✓Weekly Members-only mailbag
✓FanGraphs Walk-Off, your year in review
✓Optional homepage photo removal
✓Gift articles to non-members

Original Verdict: REBOUND | Actual Verdict: STILL A BUST

Michael Conforto

After a disappointing 2021 season, Conforto failed to sign with a team during spring training, and then word spread he had injured his shoulder, which he ultimately decided to undergo surgery on in late April, ending his chances of playing this year.

DJ LeMahieu

After an unbelievable short 2020 season with a career best 27% HR/FB rate to go alone with a .364 batting average, LeMahieu was a massive disappointment in 2021 when regression brought him back to Earth. His HR/FB rate slid back into single digits, while his BABIP fell to just over .300. With an uncertain playing time outlook this year, would he even record enough PAs to give his fantasy value a chance to rebound?

The answer was no. He finished with just 541 PAs, which could have maaaaaaaybe been enough to come close to $17+, but he wasn’t much better in those ABs than he was in 2021. His HR/FB rate rebounded slightly and back into double digits to finish just above his career average, but his BABIP fell to a career low, and just the second time below .300. I’m actually surprised his stat line generated positive value at all, as it seems pretty replacement level in a 12-team mixed league to me! Heading into his age 34 season, odds are his 2019 and 2020 season end up being the big blip and not a level he’ll come close to again.

Original Verdict: STILL A BUST | Actual Verdict: STILL A BUST

José Abreu

Abreu was incredible over the short 2020 season as his HR/FB rate and ISO marks skyrocketed to career best out of nowhere. Predictably, he regressed back to his historical averages in 2021, but that represented a massive decline in fantasy value.

In 2022, he posted a career low strikeout rate, but his power disappeared! His HR/FB rate slipped into single digits for the first time, and the first time it fell below his previous low of 14.8%. His ISO finished at just .141, only the second time it fell below .200. What happened?! His maxEV was fine, and while his Barrel% declined back into single digits after three straight low-mid-teen marks, it was still higher than his 2015-2018 seasons when he posted mid-to-high teen HR/FB rates.

He’ll be entering his age 36 season next year, but I’m still betting on his power rebounding. The rest of the skills remain stable, so he might actually be a profitable buy next year.

Original Verdict: STILL A BUST | Actual Verdict: STILL A BUST

Wil Myers

Myers also took the short 2020 season opportunity to showcase career best power skills with his first HR/FB rate over 20% and an ISO over .300. In 2021, his power reverted right back to where it had been previously, as if 2020 never happened.

What did 2022 have in store? Lots of time missed due to injury, limiting him to just 286 PAs, along with the second highest strikeout rate of his career, and his second lowest HR/FB rate and ISO as well. So he only played half a season and when he did take the field, he wasn’t any good.

Original Verdict: STILL A BUST | Actual Verdict: STILL A BUST

Overall, I guess I did pretty well here, as I called everyone except Betts “still a bust”, and all did remain a bust according to my arbitrary rules. Betts was probably a spirit win like those bold predictions that were technically wrong, but directionally correct.





Mike Podhorzer is the founder of ProjectingX IQ, an advanced fantasy baseball analytics platform that transforms projection data and in-season performance signals into actionable intelligence. He is the 2015 Fantasy Sports Writers Association Baseball Writer of the Year and three-time Tout Wars champion. He is the author of the eBook Projecting X 2.0: How to Forecast Baseball Player Performance, which teaches you how to project players yourself. Follow Mike on X@MikePodhorzer and contact him via email.

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
wschampionredsox04Member since 2021
4 years ago

Mookie 8th ranked player per Razzball in 2022. “Still a bust”.

equistMember since 2017
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Probably one of those “Be Sure Your Brain Is In Gear Before Engaging Your Mouth” moments.

wschampionredsox04Member since 2021
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

I did read the article. Thanks.

and you lost me when you had Mookie —-Actual Verdict: STILL A BUST

David McCann
4 years ago

Back than to reading comprehension

Josh
4 years ago

“Still a bust according to my arbitrary rules.” Well ok, as long as this is clearly labeled as fan fiction. About as valuable.

philbradberryMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

I think the argument is that most people who bought Mookie Betts were thrilled with what they returned. He had a 14 ADP but finished 8th on the player. He also had a 147 wrc+ in 2020 and a 144 wrc+ in 2022, indicating that comparing raw dollars between the two years is difficult given the very different run environments.

Said another way, if Aaron judge finishes next year as the top fantasy player, but his raw dollars earned is $8 less, is he a bust? Certainly not.

wschampionredsox04Member since 2021
4 years ago
Reply to  philbradberry

that’s exactly how I felt. I drafted him 14th and he finished 8th. Silly to have him in the piece. Yet the author got very upset with a few comments and he’ll downvote this one

dl80Member since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

Does dollar value not account for the changed offensive environment then? If he does, I don’t see how that’s possible. If it doesn’t, that is a huge shortcoming of that system.

philbradberryMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

I guess I would just recommend using a relative comparison. Wrc+, top 5 at any given position, etc. Mookie Betts was not even close to a bust this season and it makes this article seem irrelevant. He was not a bust and that should be pretty easy to admit.

treebeardedMember since 2019
4 years ago
Reply to  Mike Podhorzer

I think Red Sox guy is having a hard time separating feelings from math. Yes, Mookie Betts is an incredible player and put up a ton of great stats this year. The math still says he earned less than you bought him for. Don’t get hung up on the semantics of the term “bust.” I think that that word, plus the red highlighting above, is triggering some people’s emotional response. If the article was more boringly-titled, like, “Negative Return On Investment Value of Outstanding 2022 Hitters” then it wouldn’t trigger these same reactions, though the math and conclusions would remain the same. (I am a language guy.)

Naked Mole Gaetti
4 years ago
Reply to  treebearded

This is a valid point, but I think there might be a difference, beyond the psychological, in overpaying for Betts and overpaying the same for an OF at the $13 price point. If I bought a guy at $13 in a 12-team mixed league and he produced $5 in value, there’s a very good chance, based on my skill on the waiver wire, that I essentially wasted all $13. That is, historically speaking, I can expect to get at least $5 in value from an empty OF roster spot that I’m planning to fill as the season unfolds. So, the math might say I overpaid by the same amount, but buying the $13 player would’ve done more harm to my chances to win the league.

tedMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  treebearded

Yes, agree. It is perhaps difficult to accept any definition by which a player like Betts is considered a bust.

My question, and I assume that the answer is “yes”, is whether the Fangraphs auction calculator has updated for the current offensive environment.

As philbradberry notes, Betts ran a 144 wRC+ this season, similar to both his 147 in 2020 and his 137 in 2019.

In Ottoneu’s fangraphs points leagues, Betts was the third best outfielder this year, and 10th best position player. In 2019 (which was similar to his 2020), he was also the 10th best position player.

The difference being that in 2019 and 2020, Betts was a 7.5 P/G player, whereas in 2022, he was a 6.75 P/G player. But of course offense was down across MLB this season relative to 2019: there were nearly 30 players who posted point totals over 1,000 in 2019 (fangraphs points in Ottoneu). This year there were 8.

So, I guess the short hand to this stupidly long post: are we judging Betts a bust based on league-normalized valuations? Again, I assume the answer is “yes”. And, again, I am perfectly happy to acknowledge that Betts can simultaneously be among the very best producers in both real-life and fantasy baseball, while also being a guy who did not return on his investment.

philbradberryMember since 2020
4 years ago
Reply to  treebearded

But where does is state that people paid the $37 he earned in 2020? People could have paid $25 for him, then he wouldn’t have been a bust. This is just a silly argument to say Betts was a bust.

Bless You BoysMember since 2020
4 years ago

I honestly forgot about Michael Conforto.

Another Old GuyMember since 2020
4 years ago

I definitely have to wade into this. I use a combination of projections in the spring from folks that are smarter than I am with rate stats, such as Mike and Ariel Cohen, as well as FG depth charts to do an SGP valuation. Bett’s actual numbers were very close to the expert projections as overall a rebound was predicted, but not to 2020’s earnings. Mike’s point for an auction league should be well taken. If one bid $37 in response to the 2020 valuation of Betts, they bid about $8 more than he earned this year. If that error gets repeated many times in constructing an auction team, the path to winning becomes impossible. Bust depends on one’s definition of it. I am glad the folks in my CBS league are more understanding as opposed to what I am seeing here, because I do a similar article each year for my local auction league mates. I indeed use the same criteria Mike is using with a slight variation. I refer to the biggest bust (which is my exact terminology) as the one that loses the most money from his auction price. What Mike is saying might not be relevant for non-auction leagues (although I still use valuations to rank players), but it is definitely something to ponder in an auction league. One additional comment is that Betts was really banged up in 2021 with the hip bone spur and shoulder amongst other issues. Both of those likely led to the relative power outage in 2021. The other factor was 2020 provided a really small sample size, which of course skews everything. The changes in the ball also create some “apple to oranges” comparisons. On another note, I await folks smarter than to predict how the rule changes for 2023 will play out with player projections.