Actionable Platoons (6/12/21)
Normally, I’m the fantasy manager who fades anyone in a platoon. I find that most weeks these hitters are unstartable and just take up roster spots. After two months of trying to find starting outfielders in 15-team leagues, I’m looking into platoons to help me find some weekly rentals. For that reason, I wanted to add set platoons to my weekly lineups article. Here is my first stab at the format and let me know what should be improved.
The main lineup article is being pushed back starting this week to run on Tuesday or Wednesday. Real-life (i.e. my kids are home for the summer) has limited the amount of time I have near the end of the week and my waiver wire article will take precedence.
When I’m looking into the platoons, I’m going to try to only include ones that two players in a distinct lefty-versus-righty platoon. If there is any vagueness or a third player involved, the guesswork needed on who plays when is not an advantage. In the instances where one side is set in stone but the other is iffy, I did include the set player. Also, I’m just going to avoid any catcher platoons for the simple reason I just don’t care. Finally, I going to point out some potential targets for the upcoming week. I know rotations will change, but at least some of the better options will be known.
So with the above guidelines, here is the current actionable platoon grid (I don’t like the table’s look and will try to improve it).
| Team | Position | vs LHP | vs RHP | Notes/others involved |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Angels | none | |||
| Astros | none | |||
| Athletics | 2B/LF | Chad Pinder | Tony Kemp | |
| Athletics | RF | Stephen Piscotty | Seth Brown | |
| Athletics | DH | – | Mitch Moreland | Random player slots into DH |
| Blue Jays | DH/OF | Jonathan Davis | Rowdy Tellez | Random regular DH’s when Tellez sits |
| Cleveland | 1B | Yu Chang | Bobby Bradley | Josh Naylor plays some 1B also. |
| Mariners | none | |||
| Orioles | 2B | Pat Valaika | Stevie Wilkerson | |
| Rangers | 1B/3B | Nate Lowe | Brock Holt | Lowe is hitting .165/.277/.215 over the last month. |
| Rangers | LF | Eli White | Jason Martin | |
| Rays | INF/OF | Mike Brosseau | Brett Phillips | A lot of moving parts. This was Choi-Brosseau and Phillips-Kiermaier |
| Red Sox | none | |||
| Royals | SS | Hanser Alberto | Nicky Lopez | |
| Tigers | OF | – | Nomar Mazara | Baddoo and Castro on the other side. |
| Twins | OF | Kyle Garlick | Trevor Larnach | |
| Twins | CF | Rob Refsnyder | Gilberto Celestino | |
| White Sox | LF | – | Jake Lamb | Lamb and Eaton don’t have set subs right now. Injuries have added to the confusion, but the platoons might clear up in a week. |
| White Sox | RF | – | Adam Eaton | |
| Yankees | 1B/2B | Chris Gittens | Rougned Odor | |
| Yankees | OF | Clint Frazier | Brett Gardner | |
| Braves | LF | Ehire Adrianza | Abraham Almonte | |
| Brewers | CF | Tyrone Taylor | Jackie Bradley Jr. | Might be more, but tough to know with the Hiura demotion and the Shaw injury. |
| Cardinals | None | |||
| Cubs | OF/IF | Eric Sogard | Jason Heyward | |
| D-backs | OF | Tim Locastro | David Peralta | |
| Dodgers | 1B | Albert Pujols | Max Muncy | |
| Giants | OF | Mauricio Dubón | Steven Duggar | Might be more but injuries are masking them. |
| Giants | OF | Austin Slater | LaMonte Wade Jr | |
| Marlins | none | |||
| Mets | none | |||
| Nationals | 1B | Ryan Zimmerman | Josh Bell | |
| Padres | none | |||
| Phillies | none | |||
| Pirates | none | |||
| Reds | CF | Scott Heineman | Naquin and Akiyama both start vs RHP | |
| Rockies | none |
So using the above list and the projected starters at Rotowire, here are the hitters who could see the most at-bats this upcoming week.
Full week adds (min five games)
- Brock Holt and Jason Martin: Rangers with five games, all against righties.
- Nomar Mazara: Detroit with seven games, five against righties.
- Jackie Bradley Jr.: Milwaukee with seven games, six against righties
- Jason Heyward: Chicago Cubs with seven games, five against righties.
- David Peralta: Arizona with seven games, five against righties. Last three verses righties but the Dodgers.
- Max Muncy: Los Angeles Dodgers with six games, all against righties.
- Steven Duggar and LaMonte Wade Jr.: San Francisco with seven games, six against righties.
First half (Monday to Thursday, min three games)
- Stevie Wilkerson and DJ Stewart: Baltimore with four games, all against righties.
- Scott Heineman: Cincinnati with four games, three against lefties.
Second half (Fri to Sunday, min three games)
- Ryan Zimmerman: Washington with three games, three versus lefties, one game is a doubleheader.
Jeff, one of the authors of the fantasy baseball guide,The Process, writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won four FSWA Awards including on for his Mining the News series. He's won Tout Wars three times, LABR twice, and got his first NFBC Main Event win in 2021. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.
And there are guys who Should be platooned vs LHP who are must starters vs Righties if you’re in a league with ample bench slots. But that’s grist for another article.
Good idea, useful stuff. One update: Austin Hays was activated by the Orioles for Friday’s game, so McKenna is back to AAA and Stewart is back to the bench.
Good point
Full hand high five on this….thank u
I’ve been winning with platoons for years, although you don’t necessarily need a platooned player, just a lhb who is useless against lefties. Shoo Shin Choo, when he had that season at the Reds was a very good example. Neil Walker a few years ago vs RHP was another. I got several good years out of Walker.
Most people suggest having two players for one spot, THIS IS BAD ADVICE. The trick is to have three players for two spots. For example, a 1B, an OF and a 1B/OF. It works beautifully.
Nice addition to the tool box. Thanks, Jeff.
Tyrone Taylor just went on the IL, so he won’t be platooning any time soon.
Muncy too.
This is an awesome new series Jeff. Thanks again for the constant deep dives for us players. Cheers!
Where are you getting Nate Lowe in the short side of a 1B/3B platoon? Last week was a bit of a weird week where he was off Monday and Thursday (the team was off); they started him on Tuesday (against left handed Alex Wood though demoted from where he usually hits), and then gave him an extra rest day on Wednesday against the right hander (probably to clear his head since he hasn’t been hitting). He played against lefty Kershaw and then Bauer and Buehler this weekend (hitting higher against the righties than the lefties).
It would be pretty odd for him to be on the short side of a platoon given he’s a lefty bat
Yep. Made no sense. And since the article, Lowe has hit .313/.421/.563 while walking out nearly as much as striking out.