2026 Ottoneu Arbitration Allocation Results

Chicago Cubs center fielder Pete Crow-Armstrong (4) waves to fans after the team clinched a playoff spot after the game against the Miami Marlins at Wrigley Field.
Credit: Matt Marton-Imagn Images

Ottoneu arbitration ended Saturday night and we now have a big ol’ pile of data to look at. Even if you don’t play Ottoneu, this information is pretty fascinating. It’s a look into what players have gained the most in value over the course of the year, as well as how different positions are viewed at this moment in time.

There are also some interesting insights about Ottoneu league dynamics, and we’ll get into those, as well.

But we’ll start with the most fun data point: what players got hit with the most allocations.

As a reminder, Ottoneu arbitration comes in two flavors (vote off and allocations) and we are looking at allocation data today. In every allocation league, each team is given $25 they can allocate to the other teams in their league (at least $1 per team, no more than $3 to any team) to increase the salary of underpriced players. As a result, each year this data is a window into what players Ottoneu managers covet most.

One data note before diving in – rather than using all leagues, I limited myself to a subset of 154 leagues that had 12 teams and had all 12 teams complete arbitration.

So who is the most undervalued at their current salary? To be honest, the names at the top of the list are not a huge surprise.

Top 22 Most Allocated To
# Player Dollars Allocated Allocations
1 Pete Crow-Armstrong 2633 1313
2 Jacob Misiorowski 2418 1216
3 Cam Schlittler 1832 1066
4 Junior Caminero 1615 965
5 Ben Rice 1432 887
6 James Wood 1419 888
7 Kevin McGonigle 1318 822
8 Sal Stewart 1050 702
9 Miguel Vargas 918 642
10 Nick Kurtz 866 561
11 Jordan Walker 864 614
12 Cristopher Sánchez 852 603
13 Parker Messick 821 594
14 Elly De La Cruz 797 560
15 CJ Abrams 783 571
16 Jackson Chourio 777 557
17 Brice Turang 771 578
18 Yordan Alvarez 697 464
19 Konnor Griffin 676 471
20 Gavin Williams 675 527
21 Payton Tolle 613 464
22 Drew Rasmussen 607 483

Why the top 22, you ask? Because that includes the 20 players to receive the most dollars AND the 20 to receive the most allocations. Tolle is actually an outlier here – he is 21st in dollars received and T-21st in allocations received, but he sneaks in anyway.

I don’t think we need to say a ton about most of these names. PCA blew up in a major way. So did The Miz. And Schlittler. These are guys you expect to be hit in arbitration – they were relatively cheap due to valid questions, now they look like elite stars.

A few names that are worth discussing, briefly:

  • Sanchez, De La Cruz, and Alvarez stand out as guys who were already not cheap, but still got heavily targetted in arbitration. They have been good, we have know they are good, but they put up seasons that demanded attention anyway. They were expensive in 2026 auctions; they will be even pricier in 2027.
  • Caminero and Wood are almost in that same camp; maybe Kurtz, as well. They were not Yordan-level bats coming into 2026, but they weren’t prospects we didn’t trust, either. Kurtz is particularly interesting because he only played 99 games. Managers are continuing to put big bets on a guy with a limited track record and a 32% k-rate.
  • Rice pops up in the top 10 despite losing catcher-eligibility. A year ago, I think the risk that he would be 1B-only after 2026 helped keep his price down. He felt like a rental. Well, I guess that isn’t a concern any more.
  • Ottoneu managers trust the breakouts from Walker and Vargas, as well as the debuts of Stewart and McGonigle. Griffin, too, but that one feels different. The first four played 158, 159, 162, and 156 games, respectively. Griffin played 80. The first four were all well above average with the bat (119, 134, 112, 129 wRC+’s, respectively). Griffin (98 wRC+) was not. Griffin being top 20 in arbitration matches what we are seeing with Griffin’s ADP in early drafts on other platforms, but it feels very aggressive to me. Only 11 players had a wRC+ under 100 and got at least 20 allocations assigned to them. The other ten were allocated $441 total vs. the $676 to Griffin. That is a ton of risk that you allocated money to a guy who isn’t worth it. And if he is worth it, you could have just allocated to him next year.

Looking by position, there is a pretty meaningful hitter-pitcher split:

Hitter vs. Pitcher Allocations
Position Allocated To Dollars Allocated Total Allocations
Hitter 262 30116 21746
Pitcher 195 15842 11443

That table excludes Shohei Ohtani because he would have to count in both and it is cleaner to leave him out. But hitters make up 57% of the players targeted and received 65.5% of the dollars and allocations. That 57% feels fairly proportional — 57% of a 40-man rosters is 22.8 hitters (vs. 17.2 pitchers) which doesn’t seem too wild. But 65.5% of the dollars represents allocations being over-indexed on hitters. This isn’t a surprise, given hitters are more stable and less injury-prone.

Across positions, a couple of things stand out:

Position Allocations
Position Players Median Dollars Mean Dollars
1B 55 19.0 134.9
SS 48 19.0 124.8
OF 109 18.0 114.2
Util 11 13.0 44.5
SP 142 12.5 103.8
C 30 11.0 68.9
2B 37 9.0 105.7
3B 43 8.0 128.4
RP 78 3.0 21.8

First, I was surprised to see 1B had the highest mean and median dollars. The chart above “double counts” players (so a 1B/OF eligible player counts in both spots), but the effect was persistent even if I did things like proportionally split allocations across a player’s positions or prioritize players into their most valuable position. Rice, Kurtz, Munetaka Murakami, Kyle Schwarber, Alec Burleson, Bryce Eldridge, Pete Alonso, Matt Olson, Jonathan Aranda, Willson Contreras, and TJ Rumfield all received more than $100 in allocations.

Second, the low rankings for 2B and 3B are pretty notable, especially given was saw Sal Stewart (who qualifies at both spots), Junior Caminero (3B), and Miguel Vargas (1B/3B) in the top nine targets. But those positions fall off fast (the fourth highest allocation total for a 3B was Kazuma Okamoto with $79) and include a number of multi-eligible players (Stewart, CJ Abrams, JJ Wetherholt, Fernando Tatis Jr., McGonigle, Vargas, Okamoto).

Third base was particularly stark – Caminero is carrying almost all the weight. He and Vargas are the only two players who will be primarily used as 3B in 2027 to get over $100 in arbitration allocations. There were eight such players at 2B, 12 at 1B, 11 at SS, 26 at OF, and even seven at C.

Does that mean 3B is going to be thin this year? No, but it does suggest there is not much value being held at 3B. There is Vargas, there is Caminero, and then there are a bunch of players who are already fairly-priced or over-priced.

Looking at how managers distributed dollars, that table of players at the top of the article stands out for another reason: the 22 players on that table account for more than half of all dollars allocated across all leagues. In fact, you cross over 50% at the 20th player – Gavin Williams. The top 52 players account for 75% of all allocations and the top 107 players account for 90%. There were 458 players who received allocations, but 95% of the money went to about 1/3rd of them – 157 players.

 

You can see that graphically here, as well. For all the time and energy and thought poured into arbitration, the vast majority of the impact is on a relatively limited number of the targets.

Interestingly, this is not a result of teams allocating to a limited number of players. Teams allocated to 18 different players, on average and gave out $3 to a single player just 15% of the time. The concentration is heavily driven by large numbers of managers – across leagues – allocating to the same set of players.

The average manager put $3 on 5.3 teams and $1 on just 2.3 teams. For context, if a manager’s goal was to spread dollars across teams as evenly as possible, they would give $2 to eight teams ($16 total) and $3 to three teams ($9 total) to account for $25 across 11 teams. Instead, they are aggressively going after more than two extra teams, on average.

There is a lot more to look at in this data, but we’ll stop there for today. What other questions do you have about arbitration data? What hypotheses do you want to test?





A long-time fantasy baseball veteran and one of the creators of ottoneu, Chad Young's is the Managing Editor for RotoGraphs, and can be heard on the Keep or Kut Podcast. You can follow him on Bluesky @chadyoung.bsky.social.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted