2 Early Mock ADP vs Early NFBC ADP

For the last four years, I have run the 2 Early Mock Drafts with industry analysts. They were a way of getting the initial thoughts on where they would take players for the next season. This year I decided to compare those results versus the first ADP from Draft Champions drafts on NFBC. A few things to consider:

  1. We run the 2 Early Mocks in Early September and they take about 2-3 weeks. So, some players late-season numbers and playoff numbers or late-season injuries or suspensions aren’t considered into those drafts (i.e. Keone Kela, Daniel Hudson, Domingo German, Jon Berti, etc.)
  2. The 2 Early Mocks were 1-catcher formats. So, the catcher ADPs aren’t very useful. I will change that in the future.
  3. If a player was auto-drafted in one of the 2 Early Mocks, that isn’t factored into the ADP. There were a couple of cases of players being auto-drafted in all six of the drafts, which means his ADP is not registered (i.e. Joey Votto.) These players and players not drafted at all in the 2 Early Mocks have been given an ADP of 544 for this table.
  4. The player pool’s ranks for the 2 Early Mocks on the site drafted was put in order of 2019 preseason ranks. So, sometimes players get forgotten about and rookie players or 2019 breakouts can have their values depressed in the 2 Early Mocks as opposed to NFBC.

Here are the results for the top 450 players according to NFBC ADP:

2 Early Mock ADP vs Early NFBC ADP
Position(s) Player Team 2 Early Mock ADP NFBC ADP Change
1 OF Ronald Acuna Jr. ATL 2.2 1.25 0.95
2 OF Mike Trout LAA 1.6 2.38 -0.78
3 OF Christian Yelich MLW 2.7 2.38 0.32
4 OF Mookie Betts BOS 4.3 5 -0.7
5 1B, OF Cody Bellinger LAD 5.3 5.75 -0.45
6 P Gerrit Cole HOU 11 6.25 4.75
7 3B, SS Alex Bregman HOU 11.3 7.5 3.8
8 SS Francisco Lindor CLE 7.2 8.38 -1.18
9 P Jacob deGrom NYM 19 9.5 9.5
10 SS Trea Turner WAS 12.7 10.5 2.2
11 OF Juan Soto WAS 10.3 10.63 -0.33
12 3B Nolan Arenado COL 9.2 10.75 -1.55
13 SS Trevor Story COL 10.8 11.25 -0.45
14 P Justin Verlander HOU 17.8 15.13 2.67
15 SS Fernando Tatis Jr. SD 22.7 17.88 4.82
16 1B Freddie Freeman ATL 11.6 18.5 -6.9
17 P Max Scherzer WAS 10.6 18.5 -7.9
18 P Walker Buehler LAD 23.7 19.5 4.2
19 3B Jose Ramirez CLE 16.5 20.5 -4
20 3B Anthony Rendon WAS 20.5 22.75 -2.25
21 2B, SS Gleyber Torres NYY 41 23.38 17.62
22 3B Rafael Devers BOS 19.5 25 -5.5
23 OF J.D. Martinez BOS 18.6 25.38 -6.78
24 OF Aaron Judge NYY 24.3 25.5 -1.2
25 P Mike Clevinger CLE 36.2 26.13 10.07
26 P Jack Flaherty STL 42.8 26.5 16.3
27 1B Pete Alonso NYM 44.3 27.38 16.92
28 P Shane Bieber CLE 29.3 27.5 1.8
29 SS, 2B Jonathan Villar BAL 39.2 27.63 11.57
30 P Stephen Strasburg WAS 43.6 29.25 14.35
31 OF Bryce Harper PHI 25.2 30.38 -5.18
32 2B Jose Altuve HOU 34.2 31.75 2.45
33 OF Starling Marte PIT 29.5 34.25 -4.75
34 SS Xander Bogaerts BOS 27.5 34.38 -6.88
35 SS Javier Baez CHC 26.5 35.75 -9.25
36 P Blake Snell TB 41.5 35.88 5.62
37 UT Yordan Alvarez HOU 33 36 -3
38 OF Austin Meadows TB 70.8 39.63 31.17
39 OF George Springer HOU 52.3 40.25 12.05
40 SS Adalberto Mondesi KC 21 40.38 -19.38
41 2B, OF Ketel Marte ARZ 38.5 40.5 -2
42 2B Keston Hiura MLW 60.5 45.75 14.75
43 P Chris Sale BOS 44 45.88 -1.88
44 OF Charlie Blackmon COL 43 46.5 -3.5
45 P Patrick Corbin WAS 51.8 47.25 4.55
46 2B Ozzie Albies ATL 63 47.5 15.5
47 P Aaron Nola PHI 36.2 50.13 -13.93
48 OF Giancarlo Stanton NYY 55.2 51.88 3.32
49 2B, OF Whit Merrifield KC 36.4 52.13 -15.73
50 P Lucas Giolito CWS 53 52.75 0.25
51 P Chris Paddack SD 82.3 53.13 29.17
52 P Luis Castillo CIN 46.7 54.13 -7.43
53 P Clayton Kershaw LAD 39.2 55.5 -16.3
54 3B Vladimir Guerrero Jr. TOR 33.5 55.63 -22.13
55 P Luis Severino NYY 92.8 56.25 36.55
56 P Charlie Morton TB 65.8 58.5 7.3
57 1B Anthony Rizzo CHC 51.6 58.75 -7.15
58 OF Victor Robles WAS 68.3 59.13 9.17
59 3B, OF Kris Bryant CHC 46.7 59.63 -12.93
60 OF Eloy Jimenez CWS 91.3 61 30.3
61 1B, 3B, 2B DJ LeMahieu NYY 90 61 29
62 3B Eugenio Suarez CIN 60.3 61.63 -1.33
63 3B, SS Manny Machado SD 37 63.13 -26.13
64 C J.T. Realmuto PHI 83.3 64 19.3
65 3B Yoan Moncada CWS 87.2 64.75 22.45
66 1B Paul Goldschmidt STL 66 65 1
67 P Yu Darvish CHC 100.2 67.38 32.82
68 P Tyler Glasnow TB 90.8 68.5 22.3
69 P Zack Greinke HOU 65.8 68.75 -2.95
70 OF Tommy Pham TB 60.5 71.75 -11.25
71 OF Jorge Soler KC 97.3 74 23.3
72 1B Matt Olson OAK 99.5 74.38 25.12
73 P Shohei Ohtani LAA 54 74.75 -20.75
74 P Noah Syndergaard NYM 55.8 75.5 -19.7
75 2B, 1B, 3B Max Muncy LAD 78.8 77.75 1.05
76 SS Marcus Semien OAK 122.5 77.75 44.75
77 P Josh Hader MLW 88.3 79 9.3
78 OF Joey Gallo TEX 61.8 79.88 -18.08
79 1B Jose Abreu CWS 105.7 82.25 23.45
80 P Hyun-Jin Ryu LAD 114.8 82.75 32.05
81 SS Bo Bichette TOR 68.7 83.25 -14.55
82 P Trevor Bauer CIN 78.8 85.88 -7.08
83 OF, 3B, 2B Jeff McNeil NYM 115.5 86 29.5
84 OF Eddie Rosario MIN 75.8 86.88 -11.08
85 C Gary Sanchez NYY 68.3 88.13 -19.83
86 OF Ramon Laureano OAK 103.3 88.88 14.42
87 SS Carlos Correa HOU 71.3 89.75 -18.45
88 3B Matt Chapman OAK 67.5 89.88 -22.38
89 P James Paxton NYY 79.4 90.13 -10.73
90 1B Josh Bell PIT 65 91.38 -26.38
91 SS Tim Anderson CWS 99 91.88 7.12
92 P Corey Kluber CLE 87.3 92.75 -5.45
93 P Aroldis Chapman NYY 105.5 93.88 11.62
94 P Kirby Yates SD 108.8 94.38 14.42
95 P Sonny Gray CIN 111.3 95.13 16.17
96 1B, 3B Yuli Gurriel HOU 146.5 95.63 50.87
97 P Jose Berrios MIN 81.2 95.75 -14.55
98 P Mike Soroka ATL 109.5 98.38 11.12
99 P Roberto Osuna HOU 124.3 99.25 25.05
100 P Brandon Woodruff MLW 124.3 99.5 24.8
101 OF Marcell Ozuna STL 91.3 100.88 -9.58
102 OF Andrew Benintendi BOS 75.2 102.25 -27.05
103 OF, 1B Trey Mancini BAL 136.3 104 32.3
104 C Mitch Garver MIN 187 109.5 77.5
105 OF Nicholas Castellanos CHC 100.2 109.63 -9.43
106 1B, C Yasmani Grandal CWS 141.8 111.38 30.42
107 P Carlos Carrasco CLE 112 111.63 0.37
108 OF Yasiel Puig CLE 74.3 111.63 -37.33
109 P Jesus Luzardo OAK 179.3 111.75 67.55
110 UT Nelson Cruz MIN 82.7 112.5 -29.8
111 OF Michael Conforto NYM 93.2 112.88 -19.68
112 P Madison Bumgarner SF 105.3 113.25 -7.95
113 3B Josh Donaldson ATL 89.8 114.25 -24.45
114 1B Rhys Hoskins PHI 78.7 115.13 -36.43
115 OF Luis Robert CWS 157.8 116.75 41.05
116 P Zack Wheeler NYM 139.3 117.13 22.17
117 1B, OF Danny Santana TEX 210.5 117.63 92.87
118 2B, 3B Eduardo Escobar ARZ 81.3 117.88 -36.58
119 OF Kyle Tucker HOU 138.8 118.63 20.17
120 SS Elvis Andrus TEX 129.8 118.75 11.05
121 P Eduardo Rodriguez BOS 146.4 119.38 27.02
122 P Frankie Montas OAK 165 120 45
123 OF Michael Brantley HOU 95.7 121.13 -25.43
124 C Willson Contreras CHC 140 122.63 17.37
125 P Zac Gallen ARZ 145.2 123 22.2
126 P Dinelson Lamet SD 213.7 123.88 89.82
127 OF Oscar Mercado CLE 141.5 125.38 16.12
128 2B, 3B Tommy Edman STL 389.2 128.38 260.82
129 2B, 3B Mike Moustakas MLW 129.8 130.38 -0.58
130 P Liam Hendriks OAK 183 132.88 50.12
131 P Brad Hand CLE 143.3 134.38 8.92
132 OF Max Kepler MIN 99.7 135.13 -35.43
133 P Lance Lynn TEX 160.8 135.88 24.92
134 P Will Smith SF ATL 185.3 136.13 49.17
135 SS Amed Rosario NYM 140 136.25 3.75
136 3B Miguel Sano MIN 166.7 137 29.7
137 OF Aristides Aquino CIN 118.2 137.13 -18.93
138 2B Cavan Biggio TOR 229 137.75 91.25
139 P Robbie Ray ARZ 116 138.75 -22.75
140 P Craig Kimbrel CHC 163.7 139.5 24.2
141 SS Jorge Polanco MIN 105.7 141.88 -36.18
142 P Taylor Rogers MIN 196.8 142 54.8
143 1B Carlos Santana CLE 118.5 142.25 -23.75
144 OF Franmil Reyes CLE 153.3 143.5 9.8
145 P Max Fried ATL 142.6 144.75 -2.15
146 P Kenley Jansen LAD 137 145.63 -8.63
147 OF David Dahl COL 121.8 146.38 -24.58
148 OF Willie Calhoun TEX 151.3 146.63 4.67
149 OF Mallex Smith SEA 151 148.88 2.12
150 P Edwin Diaz NYM 150 149.38 0.62
151 P Ken Giles TOR 189 152.88 36.12
152 P Kyle Hendricks CHC 143.5 153.88 -10.38
153 C Will Smith LAD LAD 217.7 154 63.7
154 SS Corey Seager LAD 136.8 154.13 -17.33
155 P Sean Manaea OAK 231.3 155.25 76.05
156 P Jake Odorizzi MIN 196.3 159.63 36.67
157 P Matthew Boyd DET 163.8 159.88 3.92
158 2B, OF Garrett Hampson COL 270.2 160.63 109.57
159 P Mike Minor TEX 125.2 161.75 -36.55
160 P Hector Neris PHI 232 162.25 69.75
161 OF Lourdes Gurriel Jr. TOR 155.8 163 -7.2
162 2B Gavin Lux LAD 162.7 163.13 -0.43
163 3B Justin Turner LAD 117 163.13 -46.13
164 OF Kyle Schwarber CHC 172 163.25 8.75
165 P Raisel Iglesias CIN 200.4 164.63 35.77
166 P Julio Urias LAD 208 167.13 40.87
167 3B, OF Hunter Dozier KC 128.5 169 -40.5
168 3B, OF Scott Kingery PHI 163 170.75 -7.75
169 P Alex Colome CWS 251.2 171.88 79.32
170 OF Nick Senzel CIN 113.2 172.13 -58.93
171 OF Byron Buxton MIN 136.5 173.75 -37.25
172 OF, 3B J.D. Davis NYM 205.8 175.75 30.05
173 P Luke Weaver ARZ 209.7 177.25 32.45
174 OF Jo Adell LAA 164.5 178.38 -13.88
175 P Hansel Robles LAA 255 179 76
176 P German Marquez COL 163.8 179.38 -15.58
177 P Carlos Martinez STL 182.5 180.63 1.87
178 P Emilio Pagan TB 199.8 180.75 19.05
179 SS Jean Segura PHI 147.2 181.75 -34.55
180 P David Price BOS 151.4 183.38 -31.98
181 P Mike Foltynewicz ATL 237.2 184.25 52.95
182 P Jose Leclerc TEX 218.5 184.88 33.62
183 OF Mitch Haniger SEA 165.2 185.38 -20.18
184 C Wilson Ramos NYM 223.2 188.75 34.45
185 1B, OF Joc Pederson LAD 177 189 -12
186 P Andrew Heaney LAA 193.3 190 3.3
187 OF Lorenzo Cain MLW 158.8 190.5 -31.7
188 SS Paul DeJong STL 152.8 190.88 -38.08
189 2B, OF Luis Arraez MIN 306.5 191 115.5
190 C Christian Vazquez BOS 359.3 192 167.3
191 2B, 3B Ryan McMahon COL 180.8 192.13 -11.33
192 P Lance McCullers Jr. HOU 253.7 192.5 61.2
193 UT Khris Davis OAK 121.8 193 -71.2
194 1B Luke Voit NYY 168.5 195.38 -26.88
195 P Brandon Workman BOS 309.7 195.5 114.2
196 C Salvador Perez KC 401.3 196.88 204.42
197 2B Brandon Lowe TB 234 200.63 33.37
198 P Archie Bradley ARZ 218.2 200.88 17.32
199 P Joe Musgrove PIT 268.7 200.88 67.82
200 P Joey Lucchesi SD 194 203.5 -9.5
201 OF Bryan Reynolds PIT 159.7 203.63 -43.93
202 2B Kolten Wong STL 242.7 203.88 38.82
203 OF Andrew McCutchen PHI 189.8 205.63 -15.83
204 2B, SS Kevin Newman PIT 243.2 207.88 35.32
205 1B Eric Hosmer SD 209.8 208 1.8
206 1B Christian Walker ARZ 212.8 208.25 4.55
207 3B, SS, OF Jon Berti MIA 474.2 209.13 265.07
208 OF Adam Eaton WAS 249.3 209.5 39.8
209 1B, 3B Yandy Diaz TB 267.2 210 57.2
210 1B Daniel Murphy COL 183.2 212.25 -29.05
211 1B Edwin Encarnacion NYY 145.2 213.88 -68.68
212 P Ian Kennedy KC 273.2 214.63 58.57
213 P Kenta Maeda LAD 221.8 216.5 5.3
214 OF Alex Verdugo LAD 248 218 30
215 UT Miguel Andujar NYY 171 218.88 -47.88
216 P Nick Anderson TB 330.2 220 110.2
217 OF A.J. Pollock LAD 175.8 220.88 -45.08
218 P Marcus Stroman NYM 233 221.25 11.75
219 SS Didi Gregorius NYY 192.3 222 -29.7
220 P Jose Urquidy HOU 402.8 224.63 178.17
221 P Caleb Smith MIA 162 225.5 -63.5
222 P Mitch Keller PIT 312.5 226 86.5
223 1B, 2B Michael Chavis BOS 248.7 226.75 21.95
224 OF Austin Riley ATL 191.2 227.63 -36.43
225 2B Dee Gordon SEA 195 227.75 -32.75
226 C Jorge Alfaro MIA 385.7 228.38 157.32
227 P Mark Melancon ATL 359.7 229.13 130.57
228 P Brendan McKay TB 179.3 233 -53.7
229 P Sean Doolittle WAS 191 233.38 -42.38
230 P Giovanny Gallegos STL 399.8 237.5 162.3
231 OF Nomar Mazara TEX 201 238 -37
232 P Domingo German NYY 127.8 238.88 -111.08
233 P Miles Mikolas STL 211.7 238.88 -27.18
234 OF Ryan Braun MLW 306.5 239.25 67.25
235 P Griffin Canning LAA 272.8 239.88 32.92
236 OF Kevin Pillar SF 245.3 239.88 5.42
237 OF Justin Upton LAA 193.5 241 -47.5
238 C Carson Kelly ARZ 292.2 241.13 51.07
239 C Omar Narvaez SEA 357.7 241.5 116.2
240 2B Rougned Odor TEX 261.3 241.88 19.42
241 P A.J. Puk OAK 277 242.75 34.25
242 P Masahiro Tanaka NYY 204.4 243.88 -39.48
243 P Joe Jimenez DET 300 244.38 55.62
244 SS Dansby Swanson ATL 268.2 245.88 22.32
245 OF Wil Myers SD 188.8 246.75 -57.95
246 P Sandy Alcantara MIA 255.5 247.5 8
247 P Dustin May LAD 298.7 248.5 50.2
248 1B Nate Lowe TB 205.5 249.13 -43.63
249 P Jon Gray COL 202.2 251.25 -49.05
250 C Sean Murphy OAK 441.7 251.75 189.95
251 OF Shin-soo Choo TEX 260.8 252.88 7.92
252 C Francisco Mejia SD 409.6 253.25 156.35
253 P Chris Archer PIT 305.7 253.63 52.07
254 P Michael Kopech CWS 358 255 103
255 P Ryan Yarbrough TB 192.3 256.25 -63.95
256 3B Gio Urshela NYY 252.3 257.25 -4.95
257 P Dakota Hudson STL 285 260.5 24.5
258 OF Austin Hays BAL 469 261.38 207.62
259 P Forrest Whitley HOU 263.7 261.88 1.82
260 OF Domingo Santana SEA 214.2 264.25 -50.05
261 1B C.J. Cron MIN 247 267 -20
262 P Keone Kela PIT 493.7 268.13 225.57
263 1B Renato Nunez BAL 236.7 269.25 -32.55
264 OF Hunter Renfroe SD 273.2 269.5 3.7
265 2B Cesar Hernandez PHI 277.5 269.75 7.75
266 P Anthony DeSclafani CIN 301.3 270.25 31.05
267 C James McCann CWS 463 270.25 192.75
268 SS Willy Adames TB 346.8 270.75 76.05
269 3B, 2B Starlin Castro MIA 306.8 272.13 34.67
270 P Rich Hill LAD 286.5 272.38 14.12
271 OF, 3B Brian Anderson MIA 310 275.5 34.5
272 OF David Peralta ARZ 179 276.13 -97.13
273 1B, C Travis d’Arnaud ATL 439.8 276.75 163.05
274 OF Avisail Garcia TB 241.7 277.88 -36.18
275 P John Means BAL 303.2 278.88 24.32
276 P Adrian Houser MLW 351.3 279.5 71.8
277 P Dylan Cease CWS 316.7 281 35.7
278 2B, 3B Tommy La Stella LAA 333.5 281.88 51.62
279 2B Nick Madrigal CWS 516.8 283.5 233.3
280 OF Mark Canha OAK 301 283.75 17.25
281 C Yadier Molina STL 435 283.75 151.25
282 P Aaron Civale CLE 308.7 285.25 23.45
283 P Daniel Hudson WAS 544 285.25 258.75
284 P Dallas Keuchel ATL 232.3 285.25 -52.95
285 P Yonny Chirinos TB 233.7 286.5 -52.8
286 C Buster Posey SF 544 286.88 257.12
287 OF Trent Grisham MLW 268.3 287.63 -19.33
288 C Roberto Perez CLE 544 289 255
289 P Jeff Samardzija SF 289.5 289.13 0.37
290 OF Randal Grichuk TOR 361.5 289.5 72
291 SS Carter Kieboom WAS 295.2 289.5 5.7
292 P Garrett Richards SD 382.3 289.63 92.67
293 OF Dylan Carlson STL 325.8 290.38 35.42
294 1B Joey Votto CIN 544 290.38 253.62
295 UT Nick Solak TEX 279.2 291.25 -12.05
296 3B Kyle Seager SEA 246.3 292.38 -46.08
297 P Reynaldo Lopez CWS 232.2 293 -60.8
298 P Steven Matz NYM 239.5 293.5 -54
299 OF Kevin Kiermaier TB 299.3 296.75 2.55
300 OF Brett Gardner NYY 460.7 298.5 162.2
301 P Johnny Cueto SF 363.7 299 64.7
302 C Kurt Suzuki WAS 544 301.13 242.87
303 C Danny Jansen TOR 324 304 20
304 OF Gregory Polanco PIT 346.7 305.88 40.82
305 P Cole Hamels CHC 240.6 306.5 -65.9
306 P Jose Quintana CHC 209.2 308.13 -98.93
307 P Seth Lugo NYM 372.5 310.38 62.12
308 SS, OF, 2B, 3B David Fletcher LAA 369.5 310.75 58.75
309 P Scott Oberg COL 544 310.75 233.25
310 2B, SS, OF Niko Goodrum DET 361.2 312.13 49.07
311 C Tom Murphy SEA 513.5 313.88 199.62
312 OF Jesse Winker CIN 255.7 313.88 -58.18
313 OF Corey Dickerson PHI 318 317.13 0.87
314 P Chris Bassitt OAK 405 318.75 86.25
315 OF Kole Calhoun LAA 328.2 320.5 7.7
316 2B Mauricio Dubon SF 503.3 320.63 182.67
317 OF Sam Hillard COL 544 320.88 223.12
318 1B, OF Garrett Cooper MIA 310.7 321.5 -10.8
319 P Michael Pineda MIN 324.7 321.5 3.2
320 OF Manuel Margot SD 279 321.88 -42.88
321 OF Teoscar Hernandez TOR 451.7 322 129.7
322 P Ross Stripling LAD 287.8 322.25 -34.45
323 OF Mike Yastrzemski SF 302.5 322.63 -20.13
324 2B Robinson Cano NYM 293.5 323 -29.5
325 C Willians Astudillo MIN 393.5 326.25 67.25
326 OF Anthony Santander BAL 305.7 327.13 -21.43
327 P Jordan Lyles MLW 412.7 327.75 84.95
328 P Julio Teheran ATL 260.5 328.63 -68.13
329 C Robinson Chirinos HOU 498.2 331.38 166.82
330 1B, 2B Howie Kendrick WAS 434.8 332.38 102.42
331 OF Josh Rojas ARZ 322.2 333.13 -10.93
332 P Anibal Sanchez WAS 363.8 334.13 29.67
333 OF Stephen Piscotty OAK 354 335.25 18.75
334 P Zach Plesac CLE 347.5 336.88 10.62
335 P MacKenzie Gore SD 356.3 337 19.3
336 SS Nico Hoerner CHC 283.8 339.5 -55.7
337 C Tucker Barnhart CIN 544 340 204
338 SS Andrelton Simmons LAA 297 341.75 -44.75
339 P Pablo Lopez MIA 264.3 342.5 -78.2
340 1B, 3B, OF Marwin Gonzalez MIN 467.3 343.25 124.05
341 P Tony Gonsolin LAD 431.7 343.63 88.07
342 P Nate Pearson TOR 440.2 344.13 96.07
343 OF Victor Reyes DET 521.5 344.63 176.87
344 P Nathan Eovaldi BOS 319 345.75 -26.75
345 3B Matt Carpenter STL 202 347 -145
346 OF Jackie Bradley Jr. BOS 421.3 347.25 74.05
347 2B, SS Freddy Galvis CIN 489.5 347.38 142.12
348 P Merrill Kelly ARZ 419.7 347.75 71.95
349 P Marco Gonzales SEA 334 353.13 -19.13
350 OF Kyle Lewis SEA 407.5 353.38 54.12
351 P Mike Fiers OAK 413.8 353.75 60.05
352 P Tyler Mahle CIN 392.3 355 37.3
353 SS Nick Ahmed ARZ 343.8 356.5 -12.7
354 2B Jurickson Profar OAK 286 357.63 -71.63
355 P Blake Treinen OAK 544 366.13 177.87
356 SS, 2B Luis Urias SD 242.2 367.38 -125.18
357 OF, 1B Dominic Smith NYM 447 368.5 78.5
358 P Jordan Yamamoto MIA 544 368.88 175.12
359 P Mychal Givens BAL 468.3 369.75 98.55
360 OF Brandon Nimmo NYM 277.2 371 -93.8
361 1B Miguel Cabrera DET 544 373 171
362 P Kyle Gibson MIN 362 375 -13
363 2B, 3B Hanser Alberto BAL 353.7 377.38 -23.68
364 1B Daniel Vogelbach SEA 300.8 377.88 -77.08
365 P Tyler Beede SF 462.2 380.63 81.57
366 2B, 3B Asdrubal Cabrera WAS 475.4 380.75 94.65
367 P Casey Mize DET 387.2 382.75 4.45
368 P Walker, Taijuan ARZ 544 383 161
369 OF Ian Happ CHC 477.2 383.38 93.82
370 OF Ender Inciarte ATL 385.7 384.5 1.2
371 P Austin Voth WAS 544 384.5 159.5
372 C Welington Castillo TEX 544 384.75 159.25
373 P Sixto Sanchez MIA 493.5 386.25 107.25
374 2B Brendan Rodgers COL 448.8 387.25 61.55
375 P Josh James HOU 305.8 387.75 -81.95
376 OF Josh VanMeter CIN 402.8 387.75 15.05
377 1B Rowdy Tellez TOR 496 388.25 107.75
378 P Trevor Richards TB 331.8 388.63 -56.83
379 P Dylan Bundy BAL 428.5 388.88 39.62
380 P Jairo Diaz COL 483 388.88 94.12
381 P Jon Lester CHC 338.3 389 -50.7
382 C, 1B Caratini, Victor CHC 544 389.5 154.5
383 OF Mike Tauchman NYY 402.2 390.13 12.07
384 OF Clint Frazier NYY 428.8 390.63 38.17
385 P Michael Lorenzen CIN 393.8 391.5 2.3
386 2B, SS, OF Chris Taylor LAD 339.5 391.63 -52.13
387 OF Delino DeShields TEX 469.5 391.88 77.62
388 C Severino, Pedro BAL 544 392.38 151.62
389 OF Tsutsugo, Yoshitomo FA 544 392.5 151.5
390 P Alex Reyes STL 313 393.88 -80.88
391 2B Jonathan Schoop MIN 315.5 394.5 -79
392 OF Jason Heyward CHC 438.5 395.5 43
393 OF Leury Garcia CWS 508.3 396.25 112.05
394 P Jordan Montgomery NYY 495.5 400.75 94.75
395 2B Adam Frazier PIT 432.8 401.63 31.17
396 P Alex Young ARZ 462.2 402.88 59.32
397 OF Ian Desmond COL 302 403.38 -101.38
398 1B Eric Thames MLW 442.2 407.38 34.82
399 P Wade Miley HOU 356.4 407.63 -51.23
400 P James Karinchak CLE 521.3 407.75 113.55
401 P Corey Knebel MLW 447.3 411 36.3
402 OF Harrison Bader STL 352 411.5 -59.5
403 P Dobnak, Randy MIN 544 412.13 131.87
404 P Matt Manning DET 441.3 412.25 29.05
405 C Chance Sisco BAL 544 412.75 131.25
406 P Shane Greene ATL 334.2 413.38 -79.18
407 C Tyler Flowers ATL 544 414.75 129.25
408 P Brad Keller KC 489.2 417.75 71.45
409 P Jake Arrieta PHI 544 417.88 126.12
410 OF, 1B Matt Beaty LAD 474.5 417.88 56.62
411 OF Raimel Tapia COL 465.2 419.75 45.45
412 P Freddy Peralta MLW 450 421.13 28.87
413 P Anderson, Chase TOR 544 421.38 122.62
414 2B, 3B Joey Wendle TB 438 423.75 14.25
415 1B Kevin Cron ARZ 521 426 95
416 1B Ryan Mountcastle BAL 463 426.75 36.25
417 P Justus Sheffield SEA 362.2 427.13 -64.93
418 P Ryan Pressly HOU 429.8 428 1.8
419 P J.A. Happ NYY 394 428.38 -34.38
420 P Zach Eflin PHI 445 430 15
421 OF Jake Fraley SEA 482.5 432.25 50.25
422 C Joey Bart SF 544 436.13 107.87
423 P Drew Pomeranz MLW 544 437 107
424 P Patrick Sandoval LAA 492.2 437.75 54.45
425 2B Scooter Gennett SF 544 438 106
426 1B Ji-Man Choi TB 544 438.5 105.5
427 OF Jose Martinez STL 453.2 438.63 14.57
428 P Rick Porcello BOS 544 438.88 105.12
429 3B Evan Longoria SF 477.5 440.63 36.87
430 P Spencer Turnbull DET 438.2 440.88 -2.68
431 SS Orlando Arcia MLW 544 441.25 102.75
432 P Diego Castillo TB 544 442.5 101.5
433 1B Brandon Belt SF 490.7 444.13 46.57
434 2B Shed Long SEA 507.2 444.5 62.7
435 OF Shogo Akiyama FA 544 446.13 97.87
436 OF, 2B, SS Jose Peraza CIN 544 447.75 96.25
437 3B Travis Shaw MLW 544 448.88 95.12
438 P Jose Urena MIA 519.2 451.13 68.07
439 OF Tyler O’Neill STL 368.6 454.38 -85.78
440 1B Albert Pujols LAA 544 455 89
441 OF Alex Kirilloff MIN 426.3 455.13 -28.83
442 C Elias Diaz PIT 544 455.38 88.62
443 C Reese McGuire TOR 544 455.63 88.37
444 OF Nick Markakis ATL 422.5 456.5 -34
445 P Matt Shoemaker TOR 438.3 456.5 -18.2
446 P Danny Salazar CLE 544 456.63 87.37
447 1B, 3B Jake Lamb ARZ 544 457.13 86.87
448 SS Miguel Rojas MIA 544 457.13 86.87
449 P Shaun Anderson SF 544 457.88 86.12
450 P Brusdar Graterol MIN 544 457.88 86.12

We hoped you liked reading 2 Early Mock ADP vs Early NFBC ADP by Justin Mason!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs




Justin is the co-host on The Sleeper and The Bust Podcast and writes for Rotographs covering the Roto Riteup as well as random topics that float into his juvenile brain. In addition to his work at Rotographs, Justin is the lead fantasy writer/analyst and co-owner for FriendswithFantasyBenefits.com, owner of The Great Fantasy Baseball Invitational, and a fantasy football and baseball writer for Fantasy Alarm. He is also a certified addiction treatment counselor. Follow Justin on Twitter @JustinMasonFWFB.

newest oldest most voted
NL Rules
Member
NL Rules

Thanks for putting this together Justin! I am surprised at the NFBC ADP difference between Tatis and Baez. Love both players but I think Baez needs to be ranked over Tatis, if only for injury risk reasons. Length of proven track record plays a part too but I am always willing to rank based on my instincts for future performance vs past stats. I’m guessing the main reason is that – based on 2019 – projections will show more SBs for Tatis.