NL Outfield Rankings: March (Preseason)

You can’t please everyone. Not that being a fantasy baseball analyst is like being the president, but being a fantasy baseball analyst is like being the president. You can never make everyone happy, and Eno Sarris occasionally asks you for foreign policy recommendations. Worse, the people who are happy don’t vocalize their contentment while the people who are pissed are more than happy to let you know. Such is the nature of the beast.

It’s all good, though. This is my second year ranking National League outfielders, and you know what? I’m ready. My skin is a little thicker, my stomach a little rounder. It’s a new year, new me. Put it on a shirt!

I run my own projections and calculate values accordingly. These are essentially my predictions for how end-of-season rankings will look. I account for injury history, which is why, if ADP (average draft position) is any indication, I can tell you right now that you’ll be upset with where I ranked Bryce Harper and Giancarlo Stanton.

I will also move some guys around at my discretion, but, for the most part, this will be a fairly straightforward, marginally objective ranking of NL outfielders. Moreover, please remember that the nominal ordering of players is not completely sticky or fixed. There is some fluidity to this endeavor; a little less so at the top, but profoundly so at the bottom. Lastly, and perhaps most importantly, I will inevitably forget someone, especially some top prospect, so let’s not freak out too much, yeah? Just leave a comment and I’ll get back to you.

Tier 1

A.J. Pollock
Bryce Harper
Andrew McCutchen
Charlie Blackmon
Giancarlo Stanton

(Edit, 1:38 pm EDT: I hadn’t seen the news about Pollock maybe needing a DL stint for his elbow until a reader pointed it out. Adjust those expectations accordingly, but that stint would likely cost him two or three spots. Should he avoid the DL, though, I stand by this ordering.)

That’s a good enough start. I admit my power projection for Harper is conservative; I expect regression in both fly ball rate (FB%) and home runs per fly ball (HR/FB). But the bigger culprit is playing time — I know Harper played the entirety of last year, but that’s the first time he can say that. Dude plays so hard, he’s a walking (sprinting?) liability. No doubt his talent is incommensurable, so sleep well knowing that’s the case.

The same can be said about Stanton, who swung so hard, he broke his wrist. Hamate fractures are relatively common and, from my limited understanding, easily treated, but the injury goes to show that, like Harper, the only thing stopping Stanton is himself. And fastballs to the jaw.

Tier 2

Ryan Braun
Yoenis Cespedes
Jason Heyward
Hunter Pence
Yasiel Puig

I’m bullish on Pence, who typically produces in admirable ways when healthy. It’s anyone’s guess how much his rocky 2015 will affect him contemporaneously. I don’t think there’s anything too outrageous here, although I can already hear a few of you muttering about certain omissions. (Thank goodness I no longer have to rank Carlos Gomez.)

Tier 3

Matt Kemp
Starling Marte
Billy Hamilton
Ben Revere
David Peralta
Matt Holliday
Kyle Schwarber
Stephen Piscotty

Yeah, Marte is pretty low. (So is Schwarber, but his eligibility as a catcher kind of skews everything. As an outfielder, I think this isn’t too absurd. I think he should be ranked among catchers only, because if you’re using him in the outfield, you better own Buster Posey. However, I know there will be complaints every month, so I concede.)

I have been vocal about my pessimism concerning Marte, and I’m in the minority. I also have no problem being wrong on this one. I’m simply heeding the multitude of red flags that I see concerning the sustainability of his 2015 performance. Perhaps I’m the only one who sees them — little ghost flags, fluttering in the wind.

I have Holliday probably a dozen spots higher than ADP. People underrate a good batting average, even if it’s somewhat empty. But it doesn’t have to be empty — despite injuries, Holliday’s hard-hit rate (Hard%) still ranked in the top third of hitters, and he swapped fly balls for line drives, a not-terrible development. Even if he only hits 15 home runs, it should pay dividends from the heart of the St. Louis batting order.

Piscotty was once sort of lauded for his hit tool — Kiley McDaniel ranked is a 55 FV (future value) prior to last season — but the batted ball skills Piscotty demonstrated in 2015 seem almost supernatural. He appears proficient spraying the ball to all fields and not popping up — two good ways to sustain a high BABIP. But with such a small sample size, it’s wise not to get too excited too soon. (Don’t tell anyone, but I am.)

Tier 4

Carlos Gonzalez
Jay Bruce
Gregory Polanco
Denard Span
Curtis Granderson
[some space]
Gerardo Parra
Randal Grichuk
Dexter Fowler
Jayson Werth
Christian Yelich

Like Marte, I could not be more out on CarGo. He couldn’t have picked a worse time to (1) be healthy for an entire season for once in his life, and (2) go on a home run rampage despite one of the worst starts to a season in his career. In the last 10 years, nobody has hit 40-plus home runs and recorded a wRC+ as low as his (114). Aaron Hill posted a 114 wRC+ in 2009 on 36 home runs, and it took Hill an extra 126 PAs to get there. He’s a platoon waiting to happen, but it’ll probably take until at least 2017 for it to take form.

Span is the less-hyped, but still-possibly-overly-hyped, version of Holliday: an aging veteran coming off an season hampered by injuries. He could still be good for 20 stolen bases and a .300 average as the lead-off man for what projects to be the 4th-best offense in baseball by WAR.

Polanco has some breakout upside. Granderson, Parra and Fowler generally provide the same kind of production. Even I’m not totally sold on Werth, but he flexed muscle in limited time last year and has serious batting average upside given he posted a BABIP north of .350 from 2012 through 2014. And there’s also a non-zero chance he could run again. Man, maybe I am sold on him.

Grichuk, Piscotty’s right field counterpart, is difficult to peg. He hits the ball hard, but his plate discipline is borderline pitiful (albeit in a small sample size as well). He also does not do anything spectacular in regard to batted ball skills to justify such a high BABIP; alas, I’m inclined to be very bearish in this instance.

Tier 5

Michael Conforto
Ender Inciarte
Joc Pederson
Marcell Ozuna
Nick Markakis
Odubel Herrera
Jorge Soler
Domingo Santana
Brandon Moss
Carl Crawford

The volatility increases as the playing time becomes less reliable. I like Conforto more than Grichuk — I think he has a higher floor, and maybe even a higher ceiling, too — but he doesn’t run, which is enough to knock him down a peg or two, and Juan Lagares‘ existence could crowd him out of much-needed (and, perhaps, much-deserved) playing time.

Pederson’s spring training stat line is ugly, dude: a 40% strikeout rate versus what amounts to Triple-A-quality pitching. Yeah, small samples. But his contact rate seems to continually digress. But cheap power is cheap power — just ask Ozuna, Santana and Moss. Herrera makes for cheap power-speed combo in the vein of his predecessors from the previous tier.

Markakis here kills me. It’s OK if you throw this one out. But consider that no man really deserves a 2.1% HR/FB, and he still has the chops to hit for a high batting average. It’s so empty, but it is what it is. Speaking of old dogs with old tricks, Crawford deserves more love with Andre Ethier hitting the shelf, but not too much more. He’s still Carl Crawford, after all.

Tier 6

Hector Olivera
Yasmany Tomas
Wil Myers
Michael Taylor
Scott Schebler
Marlon Byrd
Darin Ruf
Socrates Brito
Angel Pagan
Alex Rios
Adam Duvall
Jabari Blash
Rymer Liriano
Mallex Smith
Keon Broxton
Ramon Flores
Jose Peraza
Jesse Winker

Here lies scattered fragments of various prospects with even the remotest hint of value and, uh, some old-timers as well. There is literally no order to this tier — just names of young hitters to keep in mind and old hitters I’m contractually obligated to mention.

One-liners: Despite being a rookie, Olivera is already 31 years old; temper expectations accordingly. Taylor and Schebler are power-speed threats with contact issues; think 2015 Steven Souza. / Smith and Peraza are burners on the base paths and could make for cheap, nifty sources of stolen bases. / Broxton has some wheels, too, but he fits more a slugger’s profile but, uh, comes up a bit short on power. / Goeddel and Brito represent a happy medium, with double-digit power and speed, although the latter is averse to free passes. / Blash is the poweriest of them all, with a triple-slash line that would make Kyle Blanks blush. / Duvall mimics Blash with a slightly better minor league strikeout rates — don’t know how much that means, but the power is certainly intriguing. / Flores probably has the highest floor but the lowest ceiling, the kind of hitter whose on-base percentage (OBP) matches his slugging (SLG) — in this case, that’s a good thing. / Winker should debut at some point in 2016 and demonstrates excellent plate discipline and enough power (and first round draft pick credentials) as a 22-year-old to warrant him being a touted prospect.

* * *

I omitted Ben Zobrist because he will likely play most of his time at second base. Can’t think of any other notable players eligible at multiple positions whom I omitted.

* * *

What do you think? Where did I go horribly wrong? Also, Happy Last Non-Baseball Week Before November!





Two-time FSWA award winner, including 2018 Baseball Writer of the Year, and 8-time award finalist. Featured in the print edition of Baseball Prospectus since 2022 (2026 edition out now). Biased toward a nicely rolled baseball pant.

51 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
isanz33
10 years ago

I was just surprised not to see Dickerson anywhere in here.

isanz33
10 years ago

Just traded him for Huston Street 🙂

brittle.fuzMember since 2016
10 years ago

Tier One looks more like a Bold Predictions column. Oft injured A.J already hurt too.

Moranall
10 years ago
Reply to  brittle.fuz

Oft injured AJ? His only injury was when he took a Cueto pitch off the hand.

brittle.fuzMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  Moranall

He’s awesome but he’s had one full season of AB’s in majors and one in minors, every other season has been plagued w nagging injuries, shoulder, groin, hamstring and now second year w elbow problem. I’v had him for 4 years and love him but he doesn’t belong above Harper with that fragility.

Moranall
10 years ago
Reply to  Moranall

His 2012 and 2013 weren’t shortened because of injuries. Every player is going to have their usual dings and nicks, but there’s really been nothing unusual with Pollock, especially compared to Harper or Stanton.

Moltar
10 years ago

Is there gonna be a March (April?) Ranks update for 3B? RP? Or are you just skipping them altogether?

OutOfTheBox
10 years ago

I am not saying Cargo is ranked wrong but it is ironic that he hits 40 HR and plays in 150 games and is ranked lower this year than last.

Ryan BrockMember since 2016
10 years ago
Reply to  OutOfTheBox

He’s one year older and one year closer to being traded out of COL

Baller McCheeseMember since 2016
10 years ago

Hmmm… I see you dodged explaining your Billy Hamilton ranking. Well played, Alex Chamberlain. Well played.

NoHayBanda
10 years ago

He had a .274 obp in an injury shortened season. And stole 57 bags….

rayguMember since 2024
10 years ago

should Hamilton be ranked higher? I think there is a better case for him to be ranked lower. He’s a zero in every other category.

Ryan BrockMember since 2016
10 years ago

Piscotty up in the 3rd tier but Grichuk/Conforto down in the 4th and 5th surprises me – I’ve been viewing these three as sort of the 1a, 1b, and 1c of NL OF breakout candidates.

Spudchukar
10 years ago

Grichuk posted an .877 OPS, in 323 ABs in 2015. That isn’t exactly a small sample size. Yes, he strikes out a lot, but now that he has secured the starting CF position for the Cards, he should only blossom. He has hit 4th or 5th in the line-up, meaning he should hit with more runners on base, which should elevate his production. Not only am I bullish on him, I am expecting him to be an All-Star come July. His defense has been even better than I ever imagined this Spring, elevating him to near Heyward WAR numbers.

Mike PodhorzerFanGraphs Staff
10 years ago

Love. I had Pollock as my most valuable NL outfielder before the elbow issue too, but would never share such a ranking publicly!

Wil Myers will prove you way wrong. In fact, he may be a good bold prediction to add to my currently blank list. I guess injury history is the cause of the pessimism?

OnSight
10 years ago

Marte above Pence? Even though Pence is entering his age 33 season and needed 160, 162, and 162 games played to have HR totals of 24, 27(career high), and 20? Seems like a good bet for <20 HR and <15 SB this year especially if he plays around <155 games.

OnSight
10 years ago
Reply to  OnSight

*Marte below pence

Moranall
10 years ago

What are the chances that David Peralta moves up to at least the second tier this season? He’s going to play every day, even against lefties, and is an XBH machine with very good average and OBP. Might hit double digit steals, too.

MDLMember since 2021
10 years ago

Charlie Blackmon?

Alice Cooper
10 years ago
Reply to  MDL

Is ranked in the first tier?

Jason BMember since 2017
10 years ago
Reply to  Alice Cooper

He wasn’t asking where he was at in the rankings; he just saw some guy down at the Golden Corral who looked a LOT like Charlie Blackmon, so he tapped him on the shoulder and said “Charlie Blackmon?”

p.s. It was not Charlie Blackmon.

p.p.s. However the lunch buffet was decent enough, and the price was reasonable. They ran out of crab legs however.

MDLMember since 2021
10 years ago
Reply to  Alice Cooper

Sorry I wasn’t clear… my issue is that he is ranked in the first tier, not the third or fourth.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago

i think it’s a little bit wild not to even rank melvin upton on a list where you’re raking ramon flores. i know everyone hates him, but he has a starting job for the padres as far as anyone knows, and he quietly put up almost exactly the same OPS last year that he used to put up every year for the rays. he’s not that old yet. been decent in the spring. and the contract probably buys him a little extra leash. i really feel like atlanta just messed him up somehow.

i’m not saying full rebound to old bossman junior levels here, i’m just saying… you ranked alex rios, he isn’t even on a team. rymer liriano got his face broken and whenever he comes back he’s considered a corner outfielder by a team that already has ryan braun and domingo santana. and ramon flores.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

actually jon jay’s not here either… the padres are still in the NL right. nope, blash is here. ok. yeah i don’t get this at all

MattabattacolaMember since 2020
10 years ago

I am having a hard time deciding between Harper and Stanton. They both have endless ceilings with scary injury floors… Any insight to separate them?

brittle.fuzMember since 2016
10 years ago

“A.J. Pollock (elbow) had three hits in five at-bats in an intrasquad game on Tuesday.”

*slides quietly out of comment section*

Moranall
10 years ago
Reply to  brittle.fuz

Yes, he might start the year on the DL, but it would only be for a couple of days. It would be retroactive to March 8 since he hasn’t played in an official Cactus League game since then. That means he could be on the DL for literally as long as one day before being activated. The Dbacks are trying to get him to 35 PA before he gets back into the starting lineup.

I don’t think 3 games is going to have a huge impact on Pollock’s overall value.

MikeInNJ
10 years ago

Why are Marlon Byrd and Alex Rios in this list?

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago

you’re also missing the tommy pham boat, but that’s a personal hobby horse of mine

Lanidrac
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

That’s because Pham isn’t in line for regular playing time. Short of an outfield injury, he’ll only get some occasional starts against tough lefties when either Piscotty or Holliday shift over to first base or a day off for one of the starters.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

yes, i’m aware.

(A), i don’t think it’ll be tough lefties, i think it’ll be pretty much every lefty.
(B), i think pham will play his way into more time than that. relatively quickly if the cards are smart and fair, more gradually if they’re stubborn. or, worst-case, when someone gets hurt, he’ll get rolling and they won’t be able to get rid of him. i think he’s every bit as good a player as piscotty and grichuk are, possibly better, and just needs a chance.
(C) is ramon flores in line for regular playing time? jesse winker? the list has alex rios on it, he’s not on a team. so it goes pretty deep.

Lanidrac
10 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

Even if he is good enough to start on most teams, he’s certainly not as good as any of the current starters on the Cardinals at this point. He hit well in a very small sample size, but Piscotty hit better in a somewhat larger small sample size while also having a much better minor league track record, while Grichuk proved he already has a monster Major League bat with a lot more power over the course of last year.

Lanidrac
10 years ago

The thing about Grichuk (who is Piscotty’s CF counterpart, not RF, by the way) is that he doesn’t just hit the ball hard, he hits it extremely hard. His average exit velocity is right up there among the league leaders with guys like Stanton. Despite his poor plate discipline, he’s the kind of guy who can still post a decent batting average (due to a very high BABIP) and monster power numbers from all the hard hit balls he hits when he does manage to make contact.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  Lanidrac

ah, yes, funny you should mention. regarding the previous comment – here’s a fun one

1) go here http://baseballsavant.com/apps/hit_leader.php

2) set minimum ABs to 70

3) click AVG-MPH (6th column) twice to get top-down results

4) look at who is ranked 8 and 10

5) then start to consider strikeout rates, defense, speed, etc

Lanidrac
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

Pham posted that number in a very small sample size, while Grichuk’s much better power (and the fact that he’s a plus defender himself) more than makes up for his disadvantages in plate patience and speed. Grichuk could very well hit 30 HRs (along with a lot of doubles) this year, a number that Pham has no chance of getting anywhere near even if he had regular playing time.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

how big of a sample do you need to determine that a guy hits the ball hard?

like, if a pitcher throws 95, he throws 95. it can move up or down a bit on a given day, sure, but you have a pitcher throw in front of the radar machines, you get an idea of whether he’s a hard thrower or not pretty quickly. don’t you? hitting the ball hard i think is pretty similar. i mean – do you see anybody else who looks fluky up there on the list? out of everybody with 70 recorded hits, pham was the only guy who got up there.

heck, grichuk only had 137 ABs with data, which is less than twice as many as pham had (75). are you sure that’s a large enough sample to be name dropping him with stanton like you just did? how big is big enough?

(stanton is a huge outlier, anyway, if you actually look at the numbers on that thing. the distance between stanton and grichuk at #10 on that list is the same as the distance between grichuk and CJ cron at #196.)

at one point last year – this is true – pham actually *looked at his own fangraphs page*, saw that he was hitting the ball on the ground too much, and tweaked his swing to get more lift. in september his GB/FB dropped from 2+ to 1.33, and he hit 4 homers (and one more in the playoffs) after having 1 in more PA earlier in the year. his ISO in september was .303. that *is* a bit of a small sample, of course, sure. but i find the overall collection of information suggestive.

i guess there’s no point arguing about this though. i know what i think is gonna happen, and these are the reasons why. that’s all i’m saying. we’ll all find out together.

Spudchukar
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

Grichuk posted 323 ABs in 2015, so his sample size isn’t that small. He hit .276, which is pretty remarkable for a guy with contact issues. A .900 OPS is certainly likely.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  wily mo

ok but we were talking about the exit velocity measuring thing, which doesn’t use every plate appearance (i don’t know exactly how it works)

youngone
10 years ago

When considering all of the platoon/part-time players listed in tier 5 (e.g. Soler) and tier 6, not including Tommy Pham in this list as a deep sleeper with massive upside is a glaring omission.

wily moMember since 2020
10 years ago
Reply to  youngone

that’s what i’m saying!