Konerko’s Not Dead Yet

Remember when Paul Konerko was an elite hitter? It wasn’t that long ago that the White Sox first baseman hit .313/.381/.551 with 35 homers. In fact, Konerko posted that line in 2006, after eclipsing the 40 homer mark in both 2004 and 2005.

Of course, one the tenets of baseball analysis is that hitters – especially one dimensional sluggers, tend to age rather rapidly. However, Konerko is only going to be 33 years old, and has shown signs that he may not have run out of steam entirely.

Last season, Konerko had a rather mediocre line of .240/.344/.438 with 22 homers in 122 games. However, as we will see, Konerko was struck with a bout of bad luck, and also showed significant signs of life towards the end of the season.

The first thing to note about Konerko’s 2008 was his poor luck with balls in play. His BABIP was a mere .247, much lower than his career average of .285. His line drive percentage remained high, at 21.5%, right in line with his career LD% of 21.4%. Furthermore, he struck out at the same rate as he has over the last five seasons (he struck out in 18.3% of his at bats in 2008 – his K rate has remained between 18% and 19% every year dating back to 2004), and he actually had the highest walk rate of his career as well.

According to the BABIP model I introduced with Chris Dutton, Konerko’s expected BABIP was .280 this year (incidentally, Konerko is a good example of a player for whom the “old” model of predicting BABIP – namely, adding .120 to line drive percentage – is a poor indicator of true BABIP, as our “new” model has consistently predicted Konerko’s BABIP to be far lower than the “old” model). The 15% difference between Konerko’s actual BABIP and his expected BABIP was the 14th biggest difference among all full-time players in 2008 – in other words, Konerko was extremely unlucky on balls in play.

Furthermore, Konerko’s 2008 was plagued with injury woes. Konerko strained his oblique and was put on the disabled list in June – he was hitting a paltry .215/.325/.368 with 8 homers at the time, so it’s very possible that Konerko tried to play through the injury before finally being placed on the DL (in fact, in the 30 games prior to the DL, Konerko hit only .202/.281/.330).

After coming back from the injury on July 8, Konerko hit like himself again. In the final 60 games of the season, Konerko posted a line of .267/.366/.514 with 14 homers – while striking out 37 times and drawing 30 walks. He suffered a sprained knee in September but managed to play well despite it; both the knee and oblique should be fully healthy in 2009.

At age 33, Konerko will remain an injury risk, and likely will not be able to perform at the same level that he did in his peak. However, rumors of his demise are greatly exaggerated. Konerko suffered from a tremendous amount of bad luck on balls in play that should regress next season, thus raising hit batting average.

Furthermore, although he may not hit 40 homers, he still has enough power to hit 30-35 bombs, and will be helped (as always) by the fly-ball-friendly confines of US Cellular Field. As Konerko demonstrated in the last three months of 2009, when healthy he can still be an offensive force. And he can probably be had relatively late in most drafts, as less-astute owners will assume that he’s washed up.

Paul Konerko is an excellent sleeper for fantasy baseball in 2009.

We hoped you liked reading Konerko’s Not Dead Yet by Peter Bendix!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

newest oldest most voted

the hand/finger injury he suffered in april and continued to struggle with for a couple months probably had far more to do with his poor start than the oblique.

Larry Yocum


Can you be more specific as to why you think that injury was a larger problem than the one that eventually shut him down?

Either way, it was just another injury to add to the list from last year. He looked good down the stretch and I agree with the author that he should be a nice late round sleeper provided that he isn’t dealt to a less friendly ballpark. They are currently shopping him, but he has a no trade clause. Just speculating here, but if he ended up someplace like say SF, then while he would likely be an upgrade for them, it would still be a huge hit on his fantasy value. He is being linked to Anaheim currently.


Answering a question that was never answered this winter for you. As a White Sox fan, I can tell you that the thumb injury in question had a definite effect on Konerko for much of last season. He took a few games off early on because of swelling and pain in his thumb, but the injury continued to bother him all the way until he sat out in June. They felt it was better to have him play through it, despite the fact that it wasn’t getting better. It was regularly discussed in the Chicago media. Konerko said that making solid contact once was enough to make his hand hurt for a few days. He appeared to be adjusting his swing and releasing the bat from his hand as soon as possible, which was detrimental to his swing. It was very clear to us in Chicago that the thumb issue was significantly affecting his performance for the entire first half of the season.

The thumb has apparently been a minor issue throughout his career, acting up once in a while, but last year it was a significant issue over an extended period. Only when he spent significant time out later in the season did it subside.

From what I’ve heard, he has taken precautions, including cortisone shots, to prevent a repeat of those troubles this year. 2008 data on Konerko is clearly injury-related, and 2007 was also a down year, but so far he really looks good in 2009. He looks like 2006 Konerko, and though it’s early in the season, a lot of his batted ball data is very similar to his 2006 data (GB/FB/LD, and while his BABIP is high at .333, that was his 2006 total, so it’s not out of the question). I expect his BABIP to fall but for his GB/FB/LD rates to continue, leading to a good year (maybe .285/.365/.520).