Introduction: Assault on the Pinochle

Welcome. We are two brothers, aggregate age 122 years, of which roughly 106 have been spent as stat geeks and baseball fans, probably in descending order of intensity. One of us, Michael, resides in Manhattan and is a former academic economist, self-described as an idiot savant in econometrics. He’s why you’ll keep reading, if you do. The other, Dan, resides in Albany, New York, the hub of civic virtue, and knows how to type. He also knows just enough about economics and statistics to translate for the multitudes when his brother is speaking in tongues.

Astonishingly, Michael was a Fantasy Baseball virgin until last year, when his brother tarnished his theretofore-unsullied innocence by recruiting him to replace an owner who went AWOL at the last moment in a $50 buy-in league. It might as well have been an introduction to freebase, and overnight, homemade multiple regression analyses started popping up like toadstools. We’ll share the results of one recent study with you next time: an attempt to identify hitters who were pitched to differently, and reacted to the pitches they saw differently, in the second half of the 2014 season, betokening (we surmise) a newfound respect among their opponents. You don’t need our help to figure out that you might want to draft Nolan Arenado or perhaps Jedd Gyorko. But how about Ender Inciarte, Ike Davis, and Delmon Young, all of whom we recommend?

Anyway: having finished third and fourth, in an order we won’t disclose, in last year’s $50 league, we took the obvious next step. We are officially registered for the NFBC Main Event, live in New York City on Thursday, April 2nd, $1600 buy-in, $100,000 grand prize, and note this, James McManus and Colson Whitehead: we’re using our own money. We’d like you, FanGraphs readers, to join us in our assault on what Norm Crosby would have called the pinochle of success in Fantasy Baseball. (Yes, we know that the buy-in for the World Series of Poker Main Event is 10k, and yes, we know that there are NFBC events with buy-ins of 10k and more, and yes, we could no doubt find evefn pricier leagues if we knew where to look. Maybe next year.)

Step 1 in our quest for immortality: Prepare for, and then engage in, an NFBC “slow draft,” in which 15 (or 16, assuming none of the other teams involves a folie a deux) lunatics have nothing better to do in January than draft—hell, know the names of—50 players apiece, with whom they will be stuck for the entire season. This of course requires exhaustive research and meticulous strategizing. Our draft position: 8th in the first round, and every round thereafter. Our preparation: encyclopedic. Our draft strategy: impeccable. First violation of our draft strategy: 8th position in the first round. Outcome of draft: troublesome. Details coming in our next post or two.





The Birchwood Brothers are two guys with the improbable surname of Smirlock. Michael, the younger brother, brings his skills as a former Professor of Economics to bear on baseball statistics. Dan, the older brother, brings his skills as a former college English professor and recently-retired lawyer to bear on his brother's delphic mutterings. They seek to delight and instruct. They tweet when the spirit moves them @birchwoodbroth2.

15 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
OtherSideoftheCoin
9 years ago

Good Luck. My friend has been trying to get me to play this for years and I keep passing. As one versed in economics and statistics, I have a hard time looking at the NFBC and not seeing the bad (aside from I most definitely would not win).

As we’re still in the offseason, it would be interesting to see a write-up on the economics of the NFBC from the reporting segment of FanGraphs. What are their revenues? What are their expenses? Is the 20% “vig” steep? How hard would it be for someone else to offer the same thing taking less of a cut?

For all leagues, from a fantasy perspective and winning the grand prize- it would be interesting to know if there’s an observed advantage to earlier or later (sharks? variance of information? etc)

johnnycuff
9 years ago

can’t remember who did it but saw somewhere in the NFBC forums that draft timing didn’t have much effect on the finish NFBC leagues.

anecdotally, i’ve played (and am playing) in a bunch of slow drafts and there are advantages to both early and late drafts. i prefer the early ones because the lack of concrete information (final rosters, trades, position battles, etc) can be offset by drafting over owners who aren’t fully prepared. spring training injuries are the big downside though.

i would like to know why the birchwood brothers are assaulting a card game (pinochle) and not a high pointed piece of rock (pinnacle)