George Springer: Power and Speed Outfielder
Houston Astros outfield prospect George Springer has some of the loudest tools in the minor leagues. He’s a fantastic athlete with a combination of power and speed that’s rarely found in a player drafted out of college – and a cold weather college at that. Springer has put up some exciting numbers as a professional and offers hope for both fantasy owners and an Astros franchise that really could use some good news.
The Breakdown
The New Britain, Connecticut native attended Avon Old Farms School. Avon has been one of the better high school baseball programs in the state in recent years and has sent many players on to Division 1 programs. The Minnesota Twins were intrigued by the raw tools and gave the outfielder a look in the 48th round. Springer didn’t sign and ended up going to UConn as expected. He hit well as a freshman (.358/.454/.679 with 16 home runs) and never stopped hitting for the Huskies. Scouts flocked to the Storrs campus to see Springer along with teammates Mike Olt, Matt Barnes and Nick Ahmed. Springer didn’t disappoint and then also wowed scouting directors on the Cape. He had worked his way into consideration for the top half of the 1st round as a Junior, and the Astros ended up nabbing him with the 11th overall pick. Springer destroyed the California League last season to the tune of .316/.398/.557. He’s off to one of the best starts of any minor leaguer this year with 13 home runs already for Double-A Corpus Christi. The flip side of the coin here is that both those leagues are hitter-friendly and strikeouts have been frequent.
Springer immediately stands out on a baseball field with his athletic ability. He’s built like a major leaguer and he moves like one. too. He’s easily a plus runner and those wheels make him a constant threat to steal bases. In the outfield he glides from gap to gap and covers lots of ground. Runners won’t be testing his strong and accurate arm. At the plate Springer has a lightning quick bat and takes a big cut at the ball. His quick hands and wrists give him good plate coverage but he will expand his zone. He’s largely a patient hitter, but when he gets ahead in the count he can be fooled by both fastballs up and breaking balls low. Springer still needs to improve his two strike approach. He had made significant progress shortening up his swing his Junior year of college, but more work is needed. He still swings out of his heels a lot. Balance is a big issue. Springer sometimes falls down out of the box after a swing. He shows much better balance and weight shift in batting practice, but he still can’t seem to fully translate that to games. The bat speed and leverage in this swing equate to plus raw power. That’s really Springer’s game – hard contact all over the field. Strikeouts are always going to be a problem for Springer, but I don’t believe the K’s will stop him from being a good major leaguer. If things ever really click for him he has tools and ability that compare favorably with some of the best players in baseball. If they don’t, he’s still a five tool center fielder that’s a constant speed and power threat while providing value with his glove.
The Path to Playing Time
As I look at the Houston active roster… well, I don’t see many names that I’d count among the franchise’s long term core assets. There’s a whole lot of opportunity for a player like George Springer to stake a claim to a starting job. Justin Maxwell is perhaps the most interesting outfield piece the Astros have on their 40 man right now. Even so, we’re talking about a 29 year old with a .219 career batting average. Robbie Grossman, J.D. Martinez, Jimmy Paredes and Brandon Barnes all have some qualities that recommend them… but I’m not sure any of them are ideal fits as 1st division starters. Certainly none of these players can hold a candle to the potential that George Springer possesses. The organization clearly has a lot invested in this player. 11th overall picks with tools this loud are likely to get plenty of chances. Even with the dynamite start at Double-A, Astros GM Jeff Luhnow said he doesn’t plan on promoting Springer soon. There’s no need to accelerate the clock on Springer too quickly, of course. Still, the organization is trying to foster a culture of winning and Springer can begin the transition of this roster to a team that contends.
- On 40 Man Roster: No
- Options Remaining: 3
What to Expect
Home runs and stolen bases. Springer should be good for plenty of both. At his peak we could even see a 30/30 center fielder. Don’t count on batting average, though. Strikeout totals will be high and he may K 25-30% of the time.
- Mixed League Value: Strong. Plenty of homers, stolen bases and counting stats if you can suffer a lower AVG. In years where he gets lucky on balls in play he could be extremely valuable.
- AL Only League Value: Excellent. This kind of power and speed makes for an OF1.
- Ottoneu Value: Excellent. Fangraphs Points settings rewards this skill set and won’t punish you for the strikeouts.
- OBP League Value: Springer will take a walk, but the low AVG will drag down his OBP some. He is likely to be one of the only threats in Houston’s lineup once he arrives so he may get pitched around fairly often.
Here’s some video of Springer I took from his college days followed by some swings from Spring Training:
Jason Catania recently discussed George Springer perhaps being more valuable in fantasy baseball than reality.
Thanks for reading -AS
Al Skorupa writes about baseball & baseball prospects for Bullpen Banter and Fangraphs/Rotographs. He lives in Rhode Island. He watches & videotapes a good amount of amateur and minor league baseball. You can follow him on twitter @alskor.
The next Brett Jackson?
I understand where this comp comes from – these players have a lot in common. College centerfielders who play hard, have bat speed and have swing and miss issues. Let me say (and in response to the other Jackson responses below, too) that not all 30% K rates are made the same. In fact, not all 4/5 tool centerfielders are the same. George Springer’s tools eclipse those of Brett Jackson. Jackson had a well rounded set of tools for a college player. Springer had a pretty damn near generational set of tools for a college player. Springer has got a lot more power, among other things. Further, people always had questions about Jackson that had to do with poor pitch identification, yes, but ALSO *swing mechanics*. Jackson had a hitch in his swing that people always thought would become an issue at higher levels. Shockingly, it turned out to be a big issue. Jackson recently had his swing reworked again. Jackson also strikes out more than Springer despite coming along a bit more slowly (though to be fair Springer played in some offensive friendly environments that mitigate that).
There’s no reason Springer can’t hit. He tracks pitches well and his swing is a thing of beaty. If he doesn’t settle down, learn to stay back and temper his approach I think he can still be what we hoped Brett Jackson would become. IF Springer does make further progress (and this article is me saying I think he will) then he can be a monster.
EDIT: Fixed typo, wording
30% strikeout rate in the minors?? YIKES
Yeah, its kind of funny how prospecters will ignore an obvious giant red flag like high K rate in a player who will turn 24 this season. The Brett Jackson comp is all too appropriate. Its easy to fall in love with speed/power tools but if a guy can’t hit it just won’t matter.
Even all or nothing MLB guys like Pedro Alvarez and Mark Reynolds were only K’ing in the sub 25% range in the minors.
Totally agree. It’s silly how anyone could gloss over such a glaring flaw. If I owned Springer in any league, I’d be dealing him to anyone who thought he was worth a damn. That contact rate screams bust.
In fact, I’ll go so far as to suggest this article is awful and is hurting fantasy players more than helping them. Strong mixed league value? Outfield 1 value in AL leagues? Dude, the author needs to read up on contact rate translations and look up a few comps before making such outlandish predictions. I love Fangraphs, but this particular article has a blind spot in it a mile wide.
I completely get where you’re coming from… just disagree. Comps and minor league rate translations only go so far. I tried to explain the “why” above, but I feel George Springer is a pretty unique player and I’d encourage anyone with a chance to acquire the guy to do so.
This isn’t just a random minor league player with a 26% k rate. This is a guy with a great work ethic, exceptional athleticism, an extremely quick bat and tons of power who takes a walk. There’s a lot of risk here, sure, but the potential payoff is really high. I’ve seen a lot of the player personally and I’m very high on the guy.
a .250 hitter with 30/30 potential hitting in the 3rd or 4th spot in a lineup can be extremely valuable to a fantasy team. As I said, he makes a lot of hard contact so if he gets lucky on BIP in any given year he’s going to look fantastic. Some bad luck and he’ll hurt your average but the counting stats make it more than worth the gamble for me.
Upside is BJ Upton perhaps?
How soon will the Astros ‘spring’ for George?
HEY-O
Not any time soon. Perhaps we see him second half of 2014, but he may get a full year at AAA next season, too. I wouldn’t be entirely shocked to see them delay his arb by waiting until June 2015… but the front office is going to want to show some progress to fans and ownership before then, and Springer (along with Jon Singleton) are perhaps the nearest big ticket guys to helping.
George Springer..doesn’t pass the name test.
I doubt he gets promoted to the majors annytime this year. For an astros team clearly punting this year entirely, they don’t benefit from promoting him this year.
They also don’t benefit from promoting a guy who couldn’t hit water if he was thrown out of a boat. As mentioned in most above posts, Springer is pretty awful at that whole making contact thing. He won’t see any success at all in the majors unless he improves by quite a bit in that area.
“As mentioned in most above posts, Springer is pretty awful at that whole making contact thing.”
Is he? Clearly the strikeouts are a big issue – and I’m sure he would have trouble making contact if you put him in the bigs right now. BUT… I don’t think your statement is accurately, strictly speaking. Yes, the vagaries of minor league scoring, parks and defenses come into play… but the guy has hit .298 as a pro and .375 on balls in play. He has good plate coverage and goes deep in to counts despite an aggressive approach and some holes in his swing. So fair to speculate he can’t hit major league pitching well right now, but I don’t think we can say that he’s shown that he’s “pretty awful at that whole making contact thing.”
Again, a lot of people just look at stats and don’t get the entire picture. Being a Cubs fan I have seen plenty of Brett Jackson to know there is ZERO comparison between the two. Springer actually seems to have a clue at the plate. And this isn’t the first article to mention how nice of a swing he has.
Time will tell which makes for a fun debate on guys like this. But put me on the side of believing Springer is going to be a productive major league player……and potentially a lot more!
You guys crack me up! You act as if no player has ever had success with a high k rate. Just this season alone Justin Upton is making a case for MVP with over a 25% k rate. Mike Stanton has already had success with a high k rate. Braun is close to 25% this season. I agree it may hamper his ability to succeed right away, but he’s already shown he can hit for a nice average while still k’ing a lot at AA. He also draws walks at over a 10% clip. And he has speed which will help his average.
All in all I think Springer doesn’t get enough attention as a top prospect. I have a bigger issue with guys like Starling Marte who k a lot and don’t walk. I think they are more likely to struggle, yet just look at how well Marte is doing. Watch out for Springer, I have a feeling he will succeed at the next level!
“I agree it may hamper his ability to succeed right away, but he’s already shown he can hit for a nice average while still k’ing a lot at AA. He also draws walks at over a 10% clip. And he has speed which will help his average.”
Agree strongly with this (with caveat of playing in hitter friendly leagues). He also hits the ball HARD – which should equate to a high LD% and help his ability to hit for AVG as well. This is not your typical minor league player striking out a lot. This is a talented ballplayer who rushes things but is working on his flaws. Upton probably isn’t a fair comparison… he’s pretty special. Although they’re not similar players, the first name I thought of succeeding recently with higher K rates was Chris Davis. Prospects are works in progress.
It seems like there’s some negative reaction to Springer’s hot start. My piece was inspired by that and the interest generated by it, but my opinion of Springer hasn’t changed much over the past couple years. I have a lot of faith in his ability to make adjustments… though Ks will always be an issue.
Should also remember he’s a late bloomer from a cold weather state.
I’m with you on this one Al! Nice article.
This kid is making some of you look like complete retards. The ugly truth will always come through. Stat guys can be very valuable in evaluations.. but they are wrong most of the time. When Springer is one of the best CF in the game, you can all look back and said you projected bust. Once again, this website is full of idiots.