There’s little that Ramírez is yet to accomplish in MLB, though winning MVP might forever be his white whale. (He’d also love to go 40/40 at least once, I’m sure.) His counting stats at the plate took a little bit of a step back as he had even more wear and tear than usual in 2025, but he’s showing no long-term signs of slowing down and continues to command the zone while not striking out as well as anyone.

At the onset of the 2025 season it looked like Caminero would be missing some valuable plate appearances as he was frequently replaced for defense, but he improved enough at third to actually play full games with the Rays leading as the season went on. The massive homer power is Caminero’s calling card and considering his precocious youth combined with a lack of big swing-and-miss, the sky is the limit. He was weirdly average away from Steinbrenner Field but I don’t have much concern there since his BABIP was a ridiculously low .197 on the road.

Enjoy the 3B eligibility while you can! Jazz won’t be sniffing the hot corner any time soon after couping DJ LeMahieu out of a roster spot so he could move back to second base, and he responded with a career year despite missing time with an oblique strain. Coming off back-to-back almost-fully-healthy seasons in which he proved he’s got star output to go with his star-level skills, here’s hoping we can finally see what 150 games of Jazz looks like.

Are Garcia’s gains at the plate legit? The Royals sure think so, rewarding his breakout with a five-year, $57.5 million extension. He’s got almost three years of service time but is still just 25 years old, so it’s entirely possible we haven’t seen the best of him yet. He’s more of a “jack of all trades, master of none” than a guy who will give you insane production in a particular category, but there’s .300/20/40 potential in there.

The very definition of borderline between the top tier and second tier, Machado continues to perform like a metronome. The only thing that concerns me is Father Time’s undefeated record, and Machado is entering his age-33 season. His bat speed is still excellent but it has been going down each year for the three years it’s been tracked by Statcast, so it’s not as if he’s completely ageless.

I want Riley to go back to being great, and I’ll concede that it’s entirely possible if not likely that injuries are part of the explanation for his wRC+ declining each year since his career-high in 2022. But we can’t just ignore that in 2025 he walked less and whiffed and struck out more. This is about as high as I’m comfortable putting him.

Suárez could not have signed with a better team. He’s familiar with the Reds, he’ll need fewer days off as a DH, and most importantly for fantasy, he’ll absolutely mash at GABP. He couldn’t figure out the Park Formerly Known As Safeco across his two stints in Seattle, and there was a worry in the back of my mind that he’d end up back there anyway. He’ll feature prominently in a Reds lineup that was starved for power all last year with Elly De La Cruz battling a quad injury throughout the second half.

Paredes would be higher on this list if I was fully confident that he’s (a) fully healthy after rushing back from a horrible hamstring strain and (b) definitely an Astro in 2026. So much of Paredes’ value comes from his elite ability to pull the ball in the air, and there’s nowhere better to do that than Daikin Park. But with the Astros probably needing to offload an infielder to open up DH for Yordan Alvarez and Paredes’ name being the most-often mentioned, I’m just wary enough to ding him a bit.

Muncy has been as good as ever on a rate basis in the last two seasons, but I’m conscious of his age (35) and the fact that he’s only played 173 games in the last two seasons. Plus, he had his worst showing ever against lefties, albeit in only 80 plate appearances, and he could continue to be shielded from them by Miguel Rojas and Alex Call.

I moved Bregman down just a tad because Wrigley isn’t an amazing ballpark fit for him. He’s not as dead-pull as Paredes (nobody is) but he still relies on pulling the ball in the air. Wrigley’s dimensions themselves aren’t a huge needle-mover for me; yes, left field is deep, but Bregman has the pop to hit homers there. The bigger concern is the wind, which will knock down would-be homers for even the most prolific of power hitters — something Bregman isn’t.

With Kazuma Okamoto in the fold, Barger’s going to be spending more time in right field than at third base, so enjoy that 3B eligibility while you can in 2026! The power has always been real, but getting to it in MLB games was a problem in 2024. No longer was that the case in 2025: Barger mashed 21 homers in 135 games followed by another three in 17 postseason games. With a fantastic hard-hit rate above 50%, I’m taking the over on 24 homers if he can get into 152 games this year. The biggest impediment to that will be solving lefties, against whom he had a wRC+ of 69 in 89 plate appearances.

Montgomery burst onto the scene in his rookie half-season last year, with 21 homers and 55 RBI in just 71 games. If you’re a fan of extrapolating stats out to 162 games and dreaming from there, that’s 48 homers and 125 RBI. No, I don’t think he’ll reach those heights in 2026, as his HR/FB was a ridiculous 26% and his hard-hit rate was a very good but not elite 44%. But he’ll be playing every single day at short (again, enjoy that 3B eligibility while it’s there!), and unimpeded playing time is important.

He’s streaky within seasons, but you ultimately know what you’re gonna get at the end of the year from Chapman: solidly above-average output and 20+ homers. His hand injury led to a career-low in games but he still got into 128 of them, and it didn’t seem to impact his hitting ability upon his return, unlike many hand injuries. In his age-33 season, we’ve got to be careful when considering the aging curve for Chapman, but he actually cut down the strikeouts in 2025 while continuing to walk a ton. I don’t see big concern here yet, the guy’s a grinder.

Well, Bohm is certainly a Steady Vet, just steady at a lower output than you’d like. But the ballpark he plays in and the lineup around him means he’ll rack up RBI in all likelihood, and his 2025 hard hit rate was his best since 2021. Does that portend better power output or just more frustration?

He’s in this tier because I wanted to rank him right about here, not because he’s actually particularly steady. Correa hasn’t been both healthy and very good at the plate since 2022. 2023 was healthy but below-average, 2024 was excellent over 86 games, and 2025 was 144 games of a 106 wRC+. Maybe a full season at third will keep him a little healthier, and Houston is certainly a better place to hit than Minnesota, but you just don’t know what you’re going to get from him. His mere presence on the roster also means Isaac Paredes may be playing elsewhere this year.

Murakami could hit 40 homers; he could hit 15. He could strike out a manageable 30% of the time; he could strike out an untenable 40%. There’s no player in the league, at any position, with as much boom-or-bust potential, and I think I’ve ranked him accordingly. Whatever you get from him — good or bad — don’t be surprised.

Okamoto doesn’t posess the upside that Murakami has (almost nobody on the planet does!) but he’s a much safer bet to produce for the Jays than Murakami is for the White Sox. That’s why he signed for $60 million with a contender and Murakami got just $34 million from the White Sox. Okamoto may have to earn time against tough righties but is widely expected to mash lefties, and his versaility — he should get some time at first base and maybe left field, too — will keep him in the lineup along with the bat.

I had Westburg pretty aggressively ranked for the first several iterations of the rankings, but I of course had to rerank after learning that his partial UCL tear would lead to a PRP injection and keep him out all of April, at minimum. If there’s more clarity on exactly how long he’ll miss I may move him down even further, but I can’t see him going up at this point.

Lewis’ career has been perplexing, to say the least. Much like the recent vintage of Carlos Correa, Lewis has struggled to be simultaneously healthy and good. 2025 was by far his healthiest season as a big-leaguer, but also by far his worst. Despite being around seemingly forever, though, he’s still just in his age-27 season and he’s got all the talent in the world.

We don’t know where exactly Durbin will be playing with the Red Sox between second and third, but what we do know is that he’s playing every day, and he may well maintain eligibility at both positions. He’s great at nothing but good at everything and if you’re in an OBP league, you have to love how much he gets drilled by pitches.

I’ll admit it: I love Ernie Clement, and it’s not just because he went nuclear in the playoffs. A solidly average hitter with the potential for more who doesn’t really walk or strike out? That’s the good stuff. He’ll play mostly second base this year but I’d expect cameos at third and short, at least, to continue.

The Mets did a lot this offseason, but they did nothing to displace Baty’s status as a starter. He’s ostensibly the “starting DH,” but what that really means is that he’ll be playing every day against righties, whether it’s at DH or spelling the starters at third, second, first, left, right, and perhaps even shortstop. The gains he made on offense look legit, too.

McKinstry broke out with an All-Star campaign in 2025 as the Tigers’ Swiss Army Knife. Something like the lefty version of Clement, he got way more playing time than was expected and ran with it, hitting 11 triples and 12 homers while playing all over. I’ve got him below Clement because his path to playing time in 2026 is a little murkier with Kevin McGonigle fast approaching.

The same playing time concerns I have with McKinstry apply to Keith, except that Keith is coming off a worse season. He did improve as a sophomore from his down-and-then-up rookie year, and his extension keeping him under contract through at least 2029 and as late as 2032 makes the Tigers committed to him. Here’s hoping he can tap into that pop he showed in the minors.

I moved Edman down because it’s now set in stone that he’ll miss Opening Day. I don’t want to react too much to that because it’s a long season, but I also expect the Dodgers to do plenty of load management with him as they try to have him fully unleashed for a threepeat in the playoffs.

Smith is the odds-on favorite to replace Marcus Semien as the Rangers’ starting second baseman, so it’s unclear how much positional eligibility he’ll maintain beyond that if Josh Jung stays healthy (a massive if). Something of a McKinstry Lite, Smith was bang average with the bat while playing all over last year.

Lux’s one season in Cincinnati didn’t go well, and the Reds gave up Mike Sirota for him, to boot. A 102 wRC+ doesn’t cut it when you’re as rough defensively as he was, especially in left field at third base. Now with the Rays, he’ll be the starting second baseman (at least against righties) and I wouldn’t expect him to get much time anywhere else, though it’s still possible.

Caballero will begin the season filling in for Anthony Volpe while the latter recovers from offseason shoulder surgery and end it as a superutility sparkplug who can play all over. Caballero runs with reckless abandon and if you’re in need of steals, there are few better options across the league.

Andujar picked a good team for playing time. His lefty-mashing ways will guarantee his presence in the lineup against all southpaws, and the Padres haven’t done much of anything to take away playing time from him against righties, either. He could still maintain eligibility at third with Manny Machado likely to get plenty of DH days sprinkled in.

Arenado’s downturn continued in 2025, as he had his worst full-season wRC+ since his rookie year of 2013 with the Rockies. He slugged under .400 for the second straight year, and while I could see an uptick in power assuming he’s fully healthy thanks to Chase Field and a less balky shoulder, I’m not going to count on it for the soon-to-be 35-year-old. This is about as highly as I could justify ranking him.

Norby only got into 88 games last year thanks to a couple IL stints, and while he wasn’t awful, he obviously didn’t take the leap forward the Marlins were expecting him to. That said, he’s still got the leg up for the 3B job and is getting reps at 1B as well, so he shouldn’t have a big problem staying in the lineup if his health allows.

We’ve reached the point in Jung’s career where it’s plausible to say that the idea of Jung is far better than the player. He was at least healthy last year after just 46 games in 2024, but his wRC+ dipped to below-average, and he’s pretty allergic to walks. The Rangers didn’t do much to buttress last year’s struggling offense so they’re hoping for internal gains from players like Jung; he’ll get plenty of runway once again.

The trade of Arenado (and Brendan Donovan) was good news for Gorman, who should get a chance to play every day even if the exact positioning is somewhat up in the air. He’ll make you want to pull your hair out for large chunks of the season but it’s hard to not dream on the raw power even if he continually struggled to get to it in games.

It’s easy to forget how good Vientos was in 2024, though many Mets fans would tell you that Vientos certainly “helped” expedite the memoryholing process by performing poorly outside of a really good August last year. He’s got an uphill battle for playing time but at minimum should play against every lefty.

Rengifo signing with the Brewers got him ranked higher than I expected he would be, as he’s got unimpeded playing time at third base. But it can’t be ignored just how bad he was last year, nor can we brush aside how badly he’s graded out at third base.

Vargas had a solid first full big-league season bouncing between third and first and will now return to his customary third base with Murakami set to take over at first. But he’s a slump away from losing time to Lenyn Sosa.

The thing that gives me pause with Moncada isn’t how he’s performed on the field, but his laundry list of injuries for basically his entire big-league career. He hasn’t gotten into 100+ games since 2022 or 125+ since 2021, and he’s limited to being a strong-side platoon bat who’s almost entirely hidden away from lefty pitching.

McMahon hit worse as a Yankee than as a Rockie but I actually hypothetically like the idea of him at Yankee Stadium more than at Coors. There’s no Coors Effect to make him worse on the road, anymore, and the short porch in YS3 is plenty inviting for a lefty pull hitter like McMahon. It’s just unfortunate that your league probably doesn’t care how great of a fielder he is.

Marte probably loses 3B eligibility this year, as he’s expected to continue to start in right field, a position he took to very well in his first action last year. He was essentially average at the plate and there’s certainly room for growth for Marte, who’s still just 24.

Castro nosedived after a trade to the Cubs, putting a sour pall over his free agency. Still, he was able to secure a multi-year deal with the Rockies and ought to continue to play all over just about every day. His value is in his versatility and availability.

If your league doesn’t care how well McMahon fields, it really doesn’t care how well Hayes fields. But, the elite glove will keep him in the lineup on a daily basis, and he went from 43% below-average as a Pirate last year to 18% below-average as a Red. Progress!

Báez making the All-Star team as the starting center fielder was a great story, to be sure, but it hid how mediocre his season turned out to be overall. The versatility will help him play pretty often but with Kevin McGonigle fast approaching, it’s unclear how long even semi-regular playing time will last.

India was awful in 2025. He took horribly to both third base and left field, and he’ll be back at his customary second base and DH this season. That he was tendered a contract at all qualified as a surprise to me, but the strong strikeout and walk ratios are at least very Royals-y.

Mayer looks likely to get significant playing time, at least against righties, even with Durbin, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, and Andruw Monasterio in the fold. The pop is legit, the question is how much the hit tool will be able to keep up.

Alexander was set to be a super-utilityman for the Orioles until Westburg and Jackson Holliday’s injuries, and now should get significant regular time on the infield while still getting some run in the outfield, too. He’s got a good power/speed combo at an affordable price.

Arias swings way, way too often; his hit tool might be the worst of any non-catching regular in the sport. But he’s still a regular at least until Travis Bazzana is ready, and will run into some homers.

Schmitt has been quietly solid when he’s gotten into games the last couple years, and although the signing of Luis Arraez complicates his playing time, he’s just an injury away from significant plate appearance totals.

Shaw had an extremely streaky rookie year that ultimately mathed out to being slightly below-average at the plate. With Bregman in the fold, he’ll take on a superutility role and seems likeliest to gain eligibility in the outfield

Lawlar’s star has faded dramatically, but perhaps a position change to the outfield will do him some good. He lines up to be the Snakes’ starting CF and has been hitting well thus far in Spring Training.

House has been excellent in Spring Training so he moves up two tiers with the third base job unquestionably his.

Muncy shoots up the list thanks to a great spring training that has him running away with the starting 3B job, but I’ll need more than this small sample to think he’s legit.

Lee will be the starting shortstop this year despite being bad on both sides of the ball in 2025, so his 3B eligibility is waning. There’s not much to like about his profile, either.