Anthony Rizzo’s Answered Your (My) Questions

It’s probably safe to say Anthony Rizzo has silenced skeptics this season. After showing tremendous amounts of promise upon receiving a call up in 2012, he struggled in 2013, but the sky didn’t fall; his peripherals were still good, even improving a little. Still, questions remained, and they were fair. The two largest questions, to me, were: could he hit fastballs? and can he perform versus lefties?

The fastball thing might seem weird, considering the ratings on his profile, but it’s more to do with scouting reports than anything. During Rizzo’s prospect days, “slider bat speed” was mentioned more than a few times. And its presence in was only amplified after his dreadful 2011 stint in San Diego. Don’t worry about his bat-speed any longer, it’s fine. Eno Sarris addressed it here, though, upon his arrival in 2012, noting the changes Rizzo made in order to be quicker to the plate.

If you’re still wondering, though, Rizzo’s performed just fine versus fastballs this year, slugging .511 versus pitches qualified as hard by Brooks Baseball, more than a .70 point improvement over 2013. That’s huge, because the majority of the pitches any batter sees are likely going to be some variation of a fastball. So, while it’s important he’s proven he can, in fact, catch up to heaters, it’s maybe more important that he’s seemingly taken a step or sixteen forward versus breaking stuff.

Most major league players get to the majors based on their ability to hit fastballs. They then face an adjustment period. Rizzo’s gone through that period, and the preliminary results are promising.

Rizzo - BIP

He’s hitting more flyballs this year versus breaking pitches. And considering he’s a power hitter, that’s a fantastic thing. Rizzo’s seen his slugging percentage versus breaking pitches climb from .368 in 2012 to .541 this season. Flyballs are a huge reason. In fact, the only reason Rizzo’s overall flyball rate has increased this season is due to his improvement lifting breaking pitches, although it isn’t near the extreme of 2011’s small sample. (He’s also popping up (IFFB%) less frequently, very key.) Pitchers have taken notice, though, lowering his dosage of breaking pitches again. Good thing he’s proven he can fastballs, anyways, I guess.

So, one box – well, two if you include his increased production versus breaking pitches – has been checked. The other – his production versus lefties – has been checked as well.

Rizzo’s struggles with left handed pitching were pretty pronounced in 2012 and 2013, when he posted wRC+ marks of 57 and 73, respectively; he’s currently at 161 this year. And he’s gotten there, mostly, by just refusing to swing. After swinging at over 50% of the pitches thrown by lefties in 2012, he offered at roughly 42% last season. He’s only doing so at 38% of their pitches this season.

Thanks to his new improving approach, Rizzo’s walk rate has improved every season versus left handed pitching: going from 4.7%, to 10.2%, and finally to 12%. And those gains have also been further buoyed by a declining strikeout rate versus lefties. He’s being more selective and walking more, and swinging and missing less when he offers, all while using the entire field, upping his percentage of balls in play to left field for the third consecutive year. He was due for a little positive babip regression anyways, but he’s only helped his cause by using the entire diamond.

Rizzo was a fun bet this off-season, but no one nailed it quite like our fearless leader, Eno Sarris. I give you Eno’s Fangraphs’ Plus player preview. (If you don’t see it when you go to his page, it means you should throw a little coin in our general direction and get Fangraphs+. The profiles and extra articles are fun, concise, and, in this case, dead on.)

 Profile: There’s a lot of bellyaching in certain circles about the season Anthony Rizzo put up in 2013. Yes, he only hit .233. And yeah, he only hit 23 homers. But he did something very important, too. He maintained strikeout and isolated slugging numbers that were better than league — for the second year in a row. Guess what the average batting average was for a qualified batter that did those things last season? .285. Coincidentally, that’s the exact batting average Rizzo had in 2012. The point is that Rizzo has power, and he makes contact better than the league rate, and that combo is rare. Let’s say you don’t want to pencil him for a .285 batting average next year — maybe you think he’s just not a line drive hitter — .233 is absurdly low for a player with his skillset, and his .258 batting average on balls in play is mostly to blame. Consider he’s only 24, so he’s pre-peak with regards to his power, too. Just a little boost, and Rizzo’s within a chip shot and a ducksnort of .280 and 30 homers. Two players hit those benchmarks last year — Chris Davis and Paul Goldschmidt. If you can’t afford the first two, consider the bargain bin version in this year’s drafts. (Eno Sarris)

The Quick Opinion: For a guy that struck out less than league average and showed good power, Rizzo got a lot of grief for his 2013 season. Make others’ pain your gain by buying low on the Cubbie slugger.

Not too shabby, Eno. To update: according to Steamer, only Rizzo, Jose Abreu, Mike Trout, and Giancarlo Stanton are projected to clear thirty-five homers, while also batting over .275.

As for next season, Rizzo’s likely going to be a top five option at first base. Add in the fact that the Cubs lineup should improve – in theory, anyways – given Kris Bryant’s expected arrival, and the expected improvement of other young players, and you’re left with a power/average combo that should have a good chance to sniff 90 runs scored and batted in, while having an outside chance at leaving the yard forty times. It sure is fun to watch potential turn into bonafide studliness.

We hoped you liked reading Anthony Rizzo’s Answered Your (My) Questions by Landon Jones!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs




Landon is a senior writer at The Fantasy Fix. You can follow and interact with him on Twitter (@joneslandon).

newest oldest most voted
Him
Member
Him

Soler is on his way to join the Cubs as we speak. He probably won’t play today but should be picked up.

Alcantara
Baez
Rizzo
Castro
Soler
Valbuena (Russell by September next year)
Castillo (Schwarber in 2 years?)
Couglan (Bryant in May)
Pitcher

Matt
Member
Matt

It’s nice when your team’s top prospects stay healthy and are on the cusp of contributing in MLB. As a Twins fan I can say that we haven’t quite has as much luck as Cubs fans this year in this regard.

Fatbot
Guest
Fatbot

Wow, “luck as Cubs fans” is usually not the thing of envy.