American League Outfield Tiered Rankings Update

Today we have the latest batch of American League outfield rankings. There are some prospects climbing in the ranks rapidly as well as some injured veterans plummeting in value.

Tier One
Mike Trout
Chris Davis

No change here, and no real surprise either. An argument could be made that Davis deserves the number one spot, but the steals tip the scale in Trout’s favor. At this point, no one would whine about having either of these guys on their fantasy team.

Tier Two
Jacoby Ellsbury
Adam Jones
Jose Bautista

We’re letting the cream rise to the top a bit here by trimming down Tier Two. Jacoby Ellsbury leads baseball with 33 steals — which is more than seven teams have tallied. His ZiPS rest-of-season is .289/.344/.430 and is great in standard 5×5 formats and is nothing to scoff at in on-base percentage leagues. Health remains the ultimate question, but if he can stay on the field, no doubt Ellsbury cam be a top five AL outfielder.

Tier Three
Yoenis Cespedes
Ben Zobrist
Mark Trumbo
Nelson Cruz
Michael Bourn
Austin Jackson
Alex Gordon

Ideally Yoenis Cespedes will rein in the strikeouts to last year’s sub 20% rate. There isn’t an appreciable difference between last year’s and this year’s SwStr%, Contact%, or Zone%. We’ve even seen a decrease in his O-Swing%. Cespedes is also swinging more at pitches in the zone, the issue is just making contact within the zone at a lower rate. He is projected to hit 12 dingers with over 40 runs and RBIs the rest of the way as well as a getting his strikeout rate below 20% again. He should be a buy candidate for anyone looking to make a run.

Tier Four
Alex Rios
Josh Hamilton
Coco Crisp
Desmond Jennings
Torii Hunter
Leonys Martin
Nick Markakis

Alex Rios could go to any number of places as the trade deadline approaches, though where he lands will have a strong effect on his fantasy value. Few places will be so home run friendly as U.S. Cellular, though the brilliant work of guys at MLBTR have Rios being scouted by the Texas Rangers and the Arizona Diamondbacks, both of which he can block a trade to. Both of those clubs offer great home parks for any hitter as well as a solid lineup for Rios to slot into. If Rios stays in Chicago, he doesn’t have the lineup around him to obtain as many counting stats.

On the other end of tier four we have a bit of a surprise in Leonys Martin, who if Rios accepts a trade to the Rangers may be losing some playing time (though David Murphy seems most likely to lose his job). Martin has posted back-to-back months of 120 wRC+ and for the year he is almost hitting .300 with a near .350 OBP. He had a perfect nine steals and zero times caught stealing in June and is up to 17 bags on the year versus being caught just twice. His ownership has skyrocketed (up 66% in ESPN leagues over the past week) and for good reason.

Tier Five
Shane Victorino
Nick Swisher
Daniel Nava
Wil Myers
Matt Joyce
Brandon Moss
Nate McLouth
Brett Gardner

Nate McLouth’s rate stats may have fallen — back-to-back months of sub 90 wRC+ will do that — but he has kept running. He posted eight steals in April, nine in May, and seven in June. Penciling him in for eight steals per month gives us another 24 bags from now until the season is over. If he can maintain that pace while not crushing your rate stats, he’ll prove to be a very valuable player.

Tier Six
Mike Carp
Oswaldo Arcia
David Murphy
Josh Reddick
Alejandro De Aza
Michael Morse
Michael Brantley
Adam Dunn
Aaron Hicks
Colby Rasmus
Chris Carter
Kelly Johnson
Chris Young

Colby Rasmus is having a nice bounce-back season, as long as no one looks at his strikeout rate or swing rates. His counting stats are hard to argue with but he and Chris Carter having nearly identical seasons. Power, RBI’s, and poor rate stats outside of Carter’s walk rate. Ramsus’ power plays nicely in his home park and he projects for almost 40 runs and RBIs for the rest of the season. Counting numbers are valuable, but if they begin to torpedo your rate stats, are they worst? Call it the Adam Dunn Dilema.

Tier Seven
Raul Ibanez
Rajai Davis
Jarrod Dyson
Curtis Granderson
Dayan Viciedo
Trevor Plouffe
Melky Cabrera
Seth Smith
Vernon Wells
Chris Parmelee
Jonny Gomes
Michael Saunders
Nolan Reimold

Jarrod Dyson would make for a nice deep league add if he could get some playing time. He’s been getting time in center field but is still second on the depth chart behind Lorenzo Cain. Seth Smith continues to to be a worthy option in deep leagues as he is now hitting .278/.351/.427 overall. Curtis Granderson is playing catch, but still can’t grip a bat, let alone is he ready for a rehab assignment. Is it crazy that Raul Ibanez could end the season with 30 home runs?

Tier Eight
Ryan Doumit
Peter Bourjos
Drew Stubbs
Lorenzo Cain
Emilio Bonifacio
Ichiro Suzuki
J.B. Shuck
Jason Bay
J.D. Martinez
Josh Willingham

With Josh Willingham out for at least a month, he is droppable in standard 12-team mixed leagues. At this point there are few redeeming qualities about the players listed, other than availability.

We hoped you liked reading American League Outfield Tiered Rankings Update by David Wiers!

Please support FanGraphs by becoming a member. We publish thousands of articles a year, host multiple podcasts, and have an ever growing database of baseball stats.

FanGraphs does not have a paywall. With your membership, we can continue to offer the content you've come to rely on and add to our unique baseball coverage.

Support FanGraphs

You can catch David spouting off about baseball, soccer, esports and other things by following him on twitter, @davidwiers.

newest oldest most voted
Danny Rohde
Danny Rohde

Is there an Austin Jackson sighting? Wouldn’t want to forget a player averaging close to a run a game