AL Tiered Outfielder Ranks: April 2016
Here we go again! It is time for the monthly update to the AL Outfield tiers. These tiers reflect my rest of season rankings. Just a warning: I am not extremely reactionary in the first month of the season. So, if you think I should have Colby Rasmus in the first or second tier, don’t be offended if I don’t respond to your comment with much more than a “come on bro!” Of course you can see my preseason tiers here:
AL Tiered Outfielder Rankings: Preseason
I have named my tiers based on the best characters on the greatest TV show of all time: The West Wing. Neither the rank of the characters or the greatness of The West Wing is up for debate. I am currently watching it for the 35th time and it still holds up. Plus, my grandfather is mentioned multiple times which adds to the lore. *Bonus points to the person who can figure out who my grandfather is.
Tier 1: Josh Lyman
He is still the best player in the AL.
Tier 2: Charlie Young
This tier doesn’t change very much except that J.D. Martinez jumps up. Even with the Tigers starting slow, Martinez is still hitting .294/.364/.426. I have notoriously been a J.D. detractor, but obviously I cannot be any longer.
I was tempted to move Mookie and Springer into their own small tier, but I will keep them with the rest due to their individual injury histories. Betts has looked fantastic since starting the year 3-for-23.
Tier 3: Toby Ziegler
Is it time to start freaking out about Justin Upton? Nah. He is walking just under 4% of the time and striking out almost 40% of the time. There is no way that any of that will sustain itself. I am banking that this is most likely an adjustment period to a new team/league and I am trying to buy low.
Miguel Sano makes his first appearance on the outfielder ranks now that he officially qualifies. There is so much to like, yet so much that is extremely frightening. He is walking almost 17% of the time, but striking out over twice that. The power is coming and when it does, all will feel right, but if he can’t make enough contact, then he will struggle to take the next step into the elite tiers.
I am tempted to move Dickerson up even higher, but am being a bit cautious. He is showing that there won’t be much of a power drop off leaving Coors and the .238 average will come up in short order. Hate to say I told you so, but I did.
Tier 4: Sam Seaborn
You can make the argument that Carlos Gomez should drop into the tier below this one or even father, but I am not going to panic quite yet. The average won’t be good, but the power/speed combination upside is still there…. I hope.
Michael Brantley is back finally. It is hard to place him in these tiers because I do worry about his ability to stay healthy. The Indians took their time working him back, so I am less worried about a reoccurrence of this injury and more worried that he appears to be made of glass. Still, the upside is immense and I may be way too low on him still.
Ian Desmond started off slow, but he has hit three home runs and stole three bases over the last six games. In that time, he is hitting .444/.565/.1000 while walking 21.7% and only striking out 13% of the time. It is a small sample of a small sample, but it is also encouraging that he is starting to pick it up.
Tier 5: President Josiah Bartlett
Khris Davis has struggled since coming to Oakland, but we are starting to see him get more comfortable and it has translated that into a .333/.379/.566 with two home runs and six RBIs over the course of the last week. There are going to be streaky moments with Davis, but the power is undeniable and he seems to be getting his feet under him.
Mark Trumbo and Colby Rasmus have looked like world beaters to start the year. Neither will keep it up over the course of the full season.
Shin-Soo Choo is progressing towards the early side of the 4-6 week timetable. He is another guy that is hard to rank, but his return will force the Rangers into making a roster decision with Mazara. Either way, it shouldn’t affect Choo’s playing time or role.
Melky Cabrera is looking as rejuvenated as the rest of the White Sox roster. If he starts to steal bases again, he could easily jump two tiers. He is a guy to watch and might be worth an add in shallower formats.
Tier 6: Leo McGarry
Steven Souza is hitting .295/.358/.574 with five home runs to start the season. Those numbers are obviously going to come down, but the power speed combination that Souza that led him to being everyone’s favorite “sleeper” last season is still there and so far the 30+% strikeout rate hasn’t yet caused his rates to drop. If you can get a top 25 outfielder in the AL for him, I would definitely consider it, but as long as he hits, he should see plenty of time in a Tampa lineup that needs the spark he provides.
Michael Saunders has replaced Kevin Pillar as the Blue Jays leadoff man. There is no reason to think that Saunders won’t be successful there as long as he is healthy. He is going to bat in front of Josh Donaldson, Jose Bautista, Edwin Encarnacion and Troy Tulowitzki. We could see him take the largest jump up in the ranks by the time the May edition of this list comes out. Pillar loses a ton of value moving to the eighth spot. His defense should keep him in the lineup, but batting so low limits the amount of plate appearances he will get and runs he’ll score. We have also yet to see the power that emerged last season and he has walked only once this season.
What will happened to Nomar Mazara when Choo comes back?–That is the question:
Whether ‘tis nobler in the mind to suffer
The bats and balls of the Major Leagues
Or to take arms against the service clock.
Tier 7: CJ Gregg
Jarrod Dyson has stolen two bases since returning from the DL, not to mention stealing four in Triple-A Omaha during his rehab assignment. He should get the lion share of the at bats in right field. In spite of the fact he is hitting ninth, he could easily swipe 40 bags with his speed and the way the Royals push it on the base paths. #Yosted
Tier 8: Danny Concannon
Byron Buxton got sent down to the minors, which is the reason he has dropped so far. I would think he would return pretty quickly, but I don’t think the Twins have any clue what they are doing. At least Jose Berrios is up.
Not only is Joey Rickard holding his own at the Major League level, but he is extremely popular within the organization and with the fan base. As sad as it is for me to say, I don’t really know if there is any format in which Hyun-soo Kim is worth rostering. It would be nice to see Rickard steal a few more bases, but the Orioles don’t push it on the base paths very often.
Tier 9: Mrs. Landingham
Hyun-Soo Kim
Rusney Castillo is in the minors learning how to hit a breaking ball. There is no reason to think at this point that he will ever be what many of us thought he would be after what appeared to be his mini breakout at the end in 2014.
Max Kepler is joining Buxton in the Minors because the Twins have no idea what they are doing. Kepler does have some things to work on, but I would expect him to be back somewhat quickly.
I have a feeling that Joey Gallo will not be up with the Rangers this season, or ever again. They are playing him at third in the minors in an apparent attempt to market him as a third baseman to prospective trade partners. He has looked good in Triple-A so far though.
Tier 10: Ainsley Hayes
Bradley Zimmer and Lewis Brinson are still worth stashing in deeper formats, but I moved Brinson above of Zimmer because I could see him handling center in Texas if DeShields’ defense and struggles vs righties continue.
Why do the Blue Jays hate Dalton Pompey? Chris Colabello joins the Jenrry Mejia foundation for lost big leaguers and Pompey still can’t get a call up. He might just need a change of scenery.
Justin is the co-host on The Sleeper and The Bust Podcast and writes for Rotographs covering the Roto Riteup as well as other periodic articles. In addition to his work at Rotographs, Justin is the lead fantasy writer/analyst and co-owner for FriendswithFantasyBenefits.com, and the owner of The Great Fantasy Baseball Invitational. He is also a certified addiction treatment counselor. Follow Justin on Twitter @JustinMasonFWFB.
Would Jason Heyward would fall into the low tier two OR high tier three?
High three for me
Why is George Springer so high? What slash line does this author expect from him ROS?
he’s good at baseball
.255/.345/.465. I tend to devalue average though. I was pretty high on Springer to start the year,
Josh Reddick should be near the top of the tier above the one he is currently in. I’d rather have him than all of those players and even some in the tier before that!
Agreed. He and Mazara are a tier too low in my opinion
Regarding Mazara, does anyone know if he is believed to have a difficult time against lefties in the minors?
In his small sample size of MLB PAs, he has a 40% K% against lefties and a minuscule 2.4% K% against righties.
At this point, I’m prepared to platoon Mazara in my daily league. I love what I’m seeing from him against righties, though.
He was the hardest one to rank. I was the highest on Mazara in the preseason, but until we know he is staying up for sure, I will remain a bit conservative.
There is risk reward with Reddick. Can he stay healthy for 500 PAs again? He hadn’t done it since 2012 until last season.
You should have just made a bad Indians OF tier. I can’t believe our entire OF is basically in the the last 2 tiers. Thankfully Brantley is back, meaning one less of those players is seeing regular playing time.
I am hoping they move up the timeline for Zimmer and Frazier.
What is Mookie’s injury history? Aside from 1 concussion last year which only cost him 8games and barely impacted his performance. I’m not saying he’s the top OF over Trout, but don’t be afraid to hold back on him as he likely is #2!
Concussions scare me. And while he hasn’t hit the DL much, he plays with a sort of recklessness in the outfield that scares me. Maybe you’re right though. I could be overblowing it.
No Granderson? He was ranked #39 in the OF March Update
And no Jay Bruce? He’s had a hot start and projects pretty decently for this year, I thought
These are only AL outfielders. I’m sure the NL list is coming soon.
Reading Comprehension! Completely missed the AL part. Thanks for pointing that out…
The thing I find amusing about your comment is that you skip over NL guys like Stanton, McCutch and Harper and jump right to Grandy and Bruce.
I know this is a cross-league comparison, but would you prefer Khris Davis to Ozuna?
Yes.
Extremely close. Davis over Ozuna, but I do believe in the latter.
“he should see plenty of time in a Tampa lineup that needs the spark he provides”.
Tampa doesn’t have a baseball team.
yawn
trooollllllllololol
Why the love for Saunders? A career .234 hitter who only topped 12 HR once. He has been dealing with lower body injuries for a couple of years and won’t run in front of the big bats behind him. What are the expectations other than runs? I ask because he is available in my 12 team league – I don’t think he has been on a roster in several years. The .422 BABIP looks nice….
He has talent. If he can stay healthy, then he is a 20-15 upside. I would pick him up in a 12-teamer.
Pompey had a foot injury, probably plays into him not being called up.
Completely missed that. Thanks
Why do you hate Mrs. Landingham?!?!
Great article, btw.
Hard to rank someone higher that isn’t in half of the series.
I know Rasmus is gonna cool off, but his plate discipline stats are insane. A little reminiscent of Bautistas breakout. Is he capable of a .360 OBP 35 HR season? Hitting 4th in that lineup would make that pretty valuable.
Come on bro. I would say that 30 .340 is possible if EVERYTHING broke right.
Charlie Young needs to cut his walk rate and find a way to miss significantly more bats to belong in tier 2.
Charlie provides humor, heart-wrenching moments, loyalty. What more do you want from a character!
Where the heck is the Sam Seaborn tier?!?!
Tier 4. A bit high on the list for my tastes, but then again it ain’t my list.
For that matter, where the heck is the Donna Moss tier?!?!
Agreed. Personally I’d be tempted to see Tier 1 changed to “Josh Lyman/DONNA!!”, but really she deserves her own tier IMHO.
Holy Crap! I totally left her off. I will add her!
This isn’t going on because of the hot-streak, as I would have paid more for him than I had to in any draft, but I don’t get how cool everyone is and was on Trumbo. He’s a rightie now hitting in the middle of the order in Baltimore. He has pop. Added together, I think it is definitely good to assume pre-season that he was a likely top-20 and more AL OFer.
“Is it time to start freaking out about Justin Upton?” Answer = Always
At this point, you can quibble about who has more value between Brett Gardner and Jacoby Ellsbury, but I don’t see how you can put them in separate tiers.
I stand by it
How does Brantley appear to be made of glass? Before last year, he had three straight seasons of 149+ games, his shoulder prevented him from crossing that threshold last year. In 2011, he went on the 60 day DL for a fractured hamate bone. So really, in four years, he’s had two injuries, both completely unrelated.
Also, you have Zimmer, but not Frazier? They’re at the same level, and Zimmer is two years older and has a startling K%, they’re both posting 130+ wRC+
I think Zimmer is up first. I could add Frazier, I do like him a lot.
I have a serious problem with Leo not being closer to the top. Should have been Barlett, Leo, cj, lyman, sam, charlie
Josh is the centerpiece of the show. Love Leo, but moving him higher was hard.
Charlie Young ranked above Toby is just insanity.
Also, I know he was just a guest star, but Oliver Platt’s character was always one of my favorites. Maybe a “pinch-hitter” tier for him.
Really curious who your grandpa is. Might have to go through my 6th viewing to figure it out.
Here is a clue. He was shown in the Press Secretary show and the talked about in one of the last seasons by President Bartlett.