A Classic Example of My Favorite Ottoneu Strategy
Last night, the Screw Cancer ottoneu league held their auction draft. Twelve owners (and a co-owner) came together to submit competing bids for around 200 players. Well, mostly. I entered the draft with $31 and 18 open roster spots. I vowed to draft only $1 players, reserving a $3-bid or two for the troublesome position of catcher. The result, I’m proud to say, is a pretty shiny roster.
In chats on FanGraphs and Discord throughout the early winter months, I advised countless ottoneu players to trade for expensive, elite players. “Don’t worry about running out of money,” I said. “Draft a bunch of $1 players,” I said. Yesterday’s draft is a perfect example of how to execute this approach.
The league is Screw Cancer. My team is Haliax Chandrian Explosion.
The Preexisting Roster
I entered the draft with very few needs. A couple catchers, a few depth starters, and three relievers. I like to cop my relievers as they break out so I’ll build depth at that position throughout March and April. Here’s what I started with:
| Position | Player | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| C | n/a | n/a |
| 1B | Joey Votto | $48 |
| 2B | Jose Altuve | $41 |
| SS | Francisco Lindor | $35 |
| 3B | Vladimir Guerrero | $15 |
| MI | Manny Machado | $49 |
| OF | Joey Gallo | $15 |
| OF | Chris Taylor | $9 |
| OF | Ramon Laureano | $8 |
| OF | Ronald Acuna | $19 |
| OF | Brian Anderson | $3 |
| UTIL | Tyler White | $10 |
| $252 |
Like I said, I need catchers. A little depth wouldn’t hurt to cover for off days, Lindor, and Vladito.
| Position | Player | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| SP | Max Scherzer | $51 |
| SP | Gerrit Cole | $23 |
| SP | Anibal Sanchez | $3 |
| SP | Marco Gonzales | $3 |
| SP | Brad Keller | $4 |
| SP | Trevor Williams | $3 |
| SP | Mike Soroka | $6 |
| SP/RP | Ross Stripling | $6 |
| RP | Roberto Osuna | $14 |
| $113 |
Again, I needed some relievers. A few starters for depth and upside would be swell.
I also spent $2 apiece on Carter Kieboom and Keibert Ruiz. It’s good to keep a couple cheap, well-regarded prospects for trade currency. You never know if any will be available in the draft (spoiler, they were).
The Draft Picks
First, a word of warning. Unless you manage to keep a $3 Francisco Cervelli or similar, you’re always going to suffer at catcher. It’s a luxury position. To fit a $20 catcher into your initial $400 budget is usually inefficient. Better to roster $1 players you can later trade for a good catcher and a loan.
You know what I wanted. Here’s what I got.
| Position | Player | Cost |
|---|---|---|
| C | Russell Martin | $1 |
| C | Austin Barnes | $3 |
| OF | Jackie Bradley Jr. | $1 |
| 1B | Ryan Zimmerman | $1 |
| 2B/OF | Jason Kipnis | $1 |
| SP | Michael Pineda | $1 |
| SP | Carlos Rodon | $1 |
| SP | Johnny Cueto | $1 |
| RP | Nate Jones | $1 |
| RP | Pat Neshek | $1 |
| RP | Tommy Hunter | $1 |
| RP | Reyes Moronta | $1 |
| Prospect | Nick Madrigal | $1 |
| Prospect | Jesus Sanchez | $1 |
| Prospect | Ke’Bryan Hayes | $1 |
| Prospect | Yordan Alvarez | $1 |
| Prospect | Triston McKenzie | $1 |
| $19 |
Spending $4 of my $31 on Martin and Barnes hurts. The hope is that one or both rebound. You can squint and see potentially 4.0 pts/g from this tandem. Or 1.8 pts/g. I’m probably going to need to fix this sooner rather than later.
Bradley, Zimmerman, and Kipnis allow me to take advantage of the multi-eligibilities offered by Taylor, Anderson, and White. Those six players will fill three spots when the roster is at full strength. While I await Lindor and Vladito, I’ll need five of them. I’ll aim to add a couple more position players over the course of the spring.
Zimmerman in particular was a steal. He plays most days and posted 5.06 pts/g during a terrible season. A second dead cat bounce is possible. Bradley’s also an undervalued accumulator in ottoneu FGpts. His daily average is below replacement level, but it’s better to get 4 pts/g 25 times (100 points) than fall short on the outfield games played cap by 25 (0 points).
Cueto is already on the 60-day injured* list which means I immediately get a 41st roster spot. Later in the season, he might have modest trade value as a rebound play. Or maybe I’ll just keep him for $3 and see what I get.
*my first reference to the new assignation for disabled players.
Rodon and Pineda are both post-post hype arms with talent who have never delivered results. Honestly, when I nominated them, I thought somebody else would bid. The pitchers I actually wanted to spend $1 on are still available. Still, I’m happy enough with these gambles.
Replacement level for relievers is about 6.5 pts/g. Neshek and Hunter very consistently deliver those results and sometimes more. I usually also roster Pedro Strop and Steve Cishek, but they’ve had their values slightly boosted by the ottoneu robo-ranker. You might have a pay a few bucks for them. Just wait for these Phillies instead. Moronta flashed some swagger last season, and Jones has had the occasional moment of health and prosperity.
The prospect haul was generous. Combined with Kieboom and Ruiz, I now own seven top prospects for a total cost of $9. These will supply me with all the in-season reinforcements I could possibly desire. I just have to wait for a couple teams to decide they’re rebuilding. Any leftovers can fill the role of Kieboom and Ruiz in the next draft.
I have two open roster spots and $12 to spend.
You can follow me on twitter @BaseballATeam


Your infield is an embarrassment of riches!
but the depth is pretty thin
I have at least 3 players eligible at every position (excluding C). I do need a couple more bats for thin days, but they’ll make their way onto my roster soon enough.
In my opinion, your bullpen doesn’t look that good but I guess considering what you spent on it you did ok. Bullpens seems to be the easiest piece to correct mid-season from my experience. Overall, seems like a very good roster.
Exactly, it’s meant to be serviceable until it’s fixed. Simplistically, the difference between an elite $100 bullpen and a rep level $5 bullpen is a little over 800 points. Scherzer+Altuve ($92) are about the same over rep level alternatives. However, the cost to upgrade a rep level bullpen is much lower than acquiring the top SP or 2B during the season. And those elite players are considerably more bankable than their $20 RP counterparts.
what kind of outputs do you consider as replacement level for various positions?
thanks.
Varies by position and year-to-year. Roughly the following:
C: 2.8 pts/g
Other positions: 4.3 pts/g
SP: 4.1 pts/IP
RP: 6.5 pts/IP
pearls of wiz. thanks again.
I just took over my first Otto roster in a H2H FGPts format, and kept 11 players for $308, leaving me $92 for the remaining 29 roster spots. I have the 3rd least amount of draft dollars in the league. I’d love to draft another stud (Judge, Stanton, Freeman, Blackmon, Rizzo, Votto), but not sure if I have too many roster spots to fill to spend $50-$60 on one player. I’ve seen that you typically go into the draft with around 10-13 roster spots to fill with mostly $1 players. Do you think I should grab one of those studs, and then cobble together a roster that’s mostly filled with $1 players, or should I wait and try and draft a bunch of $5 players and hope to generate value that way? Any help would be appreciated!
Share your league link and team name. I’ll take a quick peek.
Thank you!
https://ottoneu.fangraphs.com/880/home
Team: Forgot About Trea
Here’s what I see – droves of players who should not have been cut. This tells me your leaguemates might be very timid in auction. It’s too bad you can’t get the $41 back for Thor.
That branches to two possible strategies – spreading the wealth around the decent, non-elite players or grabbing whatever early bargains are available. You might be able to nab Votto in the $30s for example. I tend to prefer locking in what’s available (i.e. early bargains) and regretting the choice later. Better to regret missed value in mid-tier guys than to miss both elite AND mid-tier types.
If your league doesn’t have a weekly GS cap, I recommend rostering 14-15 SP. Only spend $1 per SP. You can go a very long way by simply making 14 starts per week. You’ll also want to entirely eschew prospects as there just isn’t room to run a deep lineup and all the SP you need.
If you do have a GS cap, then SP quality matters more than quantity.
PS – if you’d like this sort of analysis on the regular, I recommend becoming a patron and joining our Discord community. There’s an ottoneu-specific channel and dozens of active participants who like to share strategies.
https://www.patreon.com/BaseballATeam
Yeah, I was surprised at how many studs were cut at reasonable prices… But yeah, that advice makes sense. I think I’ll try and grab the best available value early on, and figure the rest of the roster out as we go along.
There is a 10 start weekly limit for SP, so I guess I should focus on grabbing a couple of the top arms if possible (Kershaw, Greinke, Mikolas, Hendricks) – though there is much less SP available than offensive studs. Do you think I can get by with Thor, Buehler, and Kershaw at the top, with a bunch of value SP’s thrown in to round out the rotation?
Thank you very much for the help, I really appreciate it. I started to look into your Patreon yesterday during the chat, and I’ll give it another look today. How much is the Patreon per month?
Never mind, I see the tiers on the side now.
Just became a Patron!
Awesome. I sent you a note through their messaging system.
Interesting, but does this work as well in an -only league auction? My suspicion is no, because the $1 players are real, real bad
That is correct. You should not plan to do this in Only unless it happens to be quite shallow.
Ha. I actually tossed back my $3 Francisco Cervelli since I don’t plan to spend more than $2 to fill all my C games played. There’s a reason he’s been a $1 catcher his entire career.
As someone who has $35 to fill 17 roster spots in Ottoneu, I’m really happy to hear this worked out for you.
I never leave the draft room with 2 catchers. Since you can make up games missed at double speed, I wait until mid-summer to find some cheap breakout. And by then you’ll probably have more $$ if you cut some guys
i guess the real question is, how do you convince other teams to give up premium talent, especially in the offseason, when more owners are deluding themselves into thinking they’ll compete that year?
In ottoneu, it’s incredibly easy. Just find any expensive guy coming off a bad season but reasonably likely to rebound. Joey Votto was a favorite target of mine this winter.
The real question is, when will he finally publish that damn third book!